Topics covered
- Separate legal personality
- Directors' authority: s 40
- Directors' duties: conflicts
- Substantial property transactions
- Partnership: incoming partner
- Wrongful trading
- Transaction at an undervalue
- Registration of charges
- Unfair prejudice
- Shareholder resolutions
All 10 questions with answers and the law behind them
Read them here, or use the practice mode above to test yourself first.
Question 1 · Separate legal personalityDraft, pending solicitor review
Mia ran a decorating business as a sole trader and then transferred it to Mia Decorators Ltd, of which she is the only director and shareholder. The company later fell into debt to its paint supplier and cannot pay. Mia gave no personal guarantee. Which statement best describes the supplier's position?
- The supplier can claim against Mia personally, because she previously ran the business as a sole trader.
- The supplier can claim against Mia personally for any debt incurred while she was a director.
- The supplier can claim against Mia personally, because a company with one member is a sham.
- The supplier can claim only against the company, because the company is a separate legal person from Mia.Correct answer
- The supplier can claim against Mia personally, because she is the only shareholder and director.
Question 2 · Directors' authority: s 40Draft, pending solicitor review
The articles of Orbit Ltd say its directors may not borrow more than £100,000 without shareholder approval. The directors borrow £150,000 from Brightbank without that approval. Brightbank knew of the limit in the articles but was not told that approval was missing, and it acted honestly. Which statement best describes the position?
- The company is not bound, because Brightbank knew of the limit in the articles.
- The company is bound only if Brightbank asked for and received evidence of shareholder approval.
- The company is bound only if the shareholders later ratify the loan by ordinary resolution.
- The company is bound, because s 40 treats the directors' power to bind the company as free of limits in the constitution in favour of a person dealing in good faith.Correct answer
- The company is not bound, because the articles bind outsiders dealing with the company.
Under s 40 a person dealing in good faith can rely on the directors' power, and knowing of a limit in the constitution does not itself amount to bad faith. The person has no duty to enquire.
Law basis: Companies Act 2006 s 40(1), (2)(b) ↗Question 3 · Directors' duties: conflictsDraft, pending solicitor review
Ravi is a director of Skyline Ltd, which builds loft conversions. Through his work he hears of a chance to buy a derelict warehouse, which Skyline cannot afford. He buys it himself without telling the board and sells it at a large profit. Which statement best describes his position?
- He is not in breach, because Skyline could not have afforded the warehouse.
- He is not in breach, because he used his own money and not the company's.
- He is in breach of the duty to avoid conflicts, because he exploited an opportunity learned as a director without authorisation, and it does not matter that the company could not have taken it.Correct answer
- He is in breach only if he intended to harm Skyline.
- He is in breach only if Skyline would have bought the warehouse had it been told.
Question 4 · Substantial property transactionsDraft, pending solicitor review
A company has net assets of £30,000. Its directors propose to sell a vehicle worth £4,000 to one of the directors. Which statement best describes whether member approval is needed under s 190 of the Companies Act 2006?
- Approval is not needed, because substantial transactions only arise above £100,000.
- Approval is needed, because every sale of an asset to a director requires it.
- Approval is needed unless the director abstains from the board vote.
- Approval is needed, because the value exceeds 10% of the company's net assets.
- Approval is not needed, because the asset is not worth more than £5,000, so the transaction is not substantial even though it exceeds 10% of net assets.Correct answer
An asset is substantial if it exceeds £100,000, or exceeds 10% of net assets and is more than £5,000. Here 10% is £3,000, but the value is not more than £5,000, so the second limb fails.
Law basis: Companies Act 2006 ss 190, 191(2) ↗Question 5 · Partnership: incoming partnerDraft, pending solicitor review
Ben, Cara and Dev run a printing firm as an ordinary partnership. In March the firm bought paper on credit from a supplier. In June Zoe joined the partnership. The firm cannot pay the supplier. Which statement best describes Zoe's position?
- Zoe is liable for it, but only up to the amount of capital she contributed.
- Zoe is not liable for the debt incurred before she became a partner, unless she agrees to be.Correct answer
- Zoe is liable for it jointly with the others, but only if the supplier knew of her when it supplied the paper.
- Zoe is liable for it, because she shares in the firm's profits.
- Zoe is liable for it, because partners are liable for all the firm's debts whenever incurred.
Question 6 · Wrongful tradingDraft, pending solicitor review
Nadia is the sole director of Kestrel Ltd. In January she realises that there is no reasonable prospect of avoiding insolvent liquidation, but she keeps trading and takes on new credit. Kestrel goes into insolvent liquidation in June, and creditors are worse off. Which statement best describes Nadia's exposure?
- She is liable for wrongful trading only if she acted dishonestly.
- She is liable only if the creditors can prove she intended to defraud them.
- The liquidator can seek a contribution from her for wrongful trading, unless she shows she took every step to minimise loss to creditors once she knew.Correct answer
- She is not liable, because a director has no duty to creditors once the company is insolvent.
- She is liable for all the company's debts without any defence, because she was the only director.
Wrongful trading does not need dishonesty. It applies where the director knew or ought to have concluded there was no reasonable prospect of avoiding insolvent liquidation, and the defence is taking every step to minimise potential loss to creditors.
Law basis: Insolvency Act 1986 s 214(2), (3) ↗Question 7 · Transaction at an undervalueDraft, pending solicitor review
Hale Ltd is insolvent. Eighteen months before it went into liquidation, it gave a valuable machine to the director's brother for nothing. Which statement best describes what the liquidator can do?
- Do nothing, because the relevant time for undervalue transactions is six months.
- Apply to the court for an order restoring the position, because the gift was a transaction at an undervalue within the relevant time while the company was insolvent.Correct answer
- Do nothing, because gifts to connected persons are valid if made within three years.
- Apply to the court only if the director personally received the machine.
- Apply to the court only if the brother knew the company was insolvent.
A gift is a transaction at an undervalue. The relevant time is two years before the onset of insolvency, and the company must have been unable to pay its debts then, or have become so because of it. The brother's knowledge goes only to the defence.
Law basis: Insolvency Act 1986 ss 238, 240(1)(a) ↗Question 8 · Registration of chargesDraft, pending solicitor review
Fenwick Ltd grants Northbank a fixed charge over its factory to secure a loan. The charge is not delivered for registration at Companies House within 21 days. Which statement best describes the effect?
- The charge is valid against the company but not against Northbank's own creditors.
- The charge is valid, because registration is only an administrative requirement.
- The charge is void only against creditors who had no notice of it.
- The charge is void against everyone, and the loan can no longer be recovered.
- The charge is void against a liquidator, an administrator and creditors of the company, although the debt itself remains payable.Correct answer
If a charge is not registered in time, it is void against a liquidator, administrator and creditors. The money secured remains payable, so the lender becomes an unsecured creditor.
Law basis: Companies Act 2006 ss 859A, 859H ↗Question 9 · Unfair prejudiceDraft, pending solicitor review
Lila and Omar started a bakery company as equal shareholders and agreed that both would manage it. Omar then removes Lila from the board and stops paying her anything, with no reason given. Which statement best describes Lila's best route?
- A claim for breach of the articles only, because unfair prejudice needs a breach of the articles.
- A petition for unfair prejudice, because exclusion from management in a quasi-partnership can unfairly prejudice a member's interests, and the court can order a buy-out.Correct answer
- A petition to wind up the company, because it is the only remedy available to a minority shareholder.
- No claim, because a shareholder has no right to take part in management.
- A derivative claim, because only the company can sue for wrongs done to it.
Question 10 · Shareholder resolutionsDraft, pending solicitor review
The shareholders of Arden Ltd hold a general meeting to change the company's articles. 60% of the votes cast are in favour. Which statement best describes the result?
- The resolution fails, because the articles can be altered only by special resolution, which needs at least 75% of the votes cast.Correct answer
- The resolution passes, provided the directors also approve it by a board resolution.
- The resolution passes, because it has the support of more than half of the members.
- The resolution fails, because alteration of the articles needs the vote of every shareholder.
- The resolution passes, because a simple majority is enough to alter the articles.
Next: sit a timed mock, or return to the FLK1 practice questions.