Topics covered
- Parliamentary sovereignty
- Human Rights Act: interpretation
- Judicial review: grounds
- Judicial review: time limit
- Court hierarchy and precedent
- Statutory interpretation: golden rule
- Burden and standard of proof
- Rule of law and the separation of powers
- Magistrates' courts and triable-either-way offences
- Sources of law: precedent and ratio
All 10 questions with answers and the law behind them
Read them here, or use the practice mode above to test yourself first.
Question 1 · Parliamentary sovereigntyDraft, pending solicitor review
Parliament passes the Act A in 2024. In 2026 it passes Act B, which contradicts Act A on the same point, without mentioning Act A. Which statement best describes the effect?
- Act A prevails, because only an express repeal can override a statute.
- Neither Act has any effect until the courts decide which is more important.
- Act B prevails, because under the doctrine of implied repeal the later statute overrides the earlier one to the extent they conflict.Correct answer
- Act A prevails, because earlier statutes cannot be overridden by implication.
- Act B prevails only if the House of Lords had approved it by a two-thirds majority.
Under parliamentary sovereignty, a later Act overrides an earlier inconsistent one by implied repeal. Constitutional statutes receive some protection, because they can be repealed only by express words or necessary implication.
Law basis: Ellen Street Estates v Minister of Health [1934] 1 KB 590; Thoburn v Sunderland CC [2002] EWHC 195 (Admin)Question 2 · Human Rights Act: interpretationDraft, pending solicitor review
A court finds that a provision in primary legislation cannot be read compatibly with a Convention right, even applying s 3 of the Human Rights Act 1998. Which statement best describes what the court can do?
- Make a declaration of incompatibility under s 4, which does not affect the validity of the provision.Correct answer
- Disapply the provision in the case before it only.
- Refer the matter to the European Court of Human Rights for a binding decision.
- Strike down the provision, because it is incompatible with the Convention.
- Amend the provision itself so that it complies with the Convention.
Courts must read legislation compatibly with Convention rights where possible. If that is not possible, a higher court may declare it incompatible, but the provision stays valid and Parliament decides whether to change it.
Law basis: Human Rights Act 1998 ss 3, 4 ↗Question 3 · Judicial review: groundsDraft, pending solicitor review
A local authority refuses a taxi licence after deciding the case solely on the basis of a policy that it will never grant licences to anyone over 70, without considering the applicant's circumstances. Which ground of judicial review does this most clearly support?
- Legitimate expectation, because the applicant had been promised a licence.
- Illegality, because the authority acted outside the statute that created it.
- Irrationality, because no reasonable authority could have adopted the policy.
- Illegality, because the authority fettered its discretion by applying a rigid policy.Correct answer
- Procedural impropriety, because the authority breached the rule against bias.
Failing to exercise a statutory discretion by applying a rigid policy without regard to individual circumstances is a way of acting unlawfully, under the heading of illegality, because the decision-maker fetters its discretion.
Law basis: British Oxygen Co Ltd v Board of Trade [1971] AC 610Question 4 · Judicial review: time limitDraft, pending solicitor review
A claimant wishes to challenge a decision of a public body, made on 1 June. Which statement best describes the time limit for bringing a claim for judicial review?
- Within three months, but only if the court extends it by agreement of both parties.
- Within six months of the decision, with no need for promptness.
- The claim must be brought promptly and in any event within three months of the date the grounds first arose.Correct answer
- Within 12 months of the decision, and only if the claimant had no legal advice.
- Within 28 days of the decision, with no extension.
The claim form must be filed promptly and in any event within three months of when the grounds arose. Promptness is required even within the three months, and the court may refuse permission for delay.
Law basis: Civil Procedure Rules r 54.5(1)Question 5 · Court hierarchy and precedentDraft, pending solicitor review
In a civil case, the Court of Appeal is asked to follow its own earlier decision, which the party says was wrongly decided. Which statement best describes the Court's approach?
- It is bound only if the earlier decision was made by the same three judges.
- It is free to depart from its earlier decisions whenever it thinks they were wrong.
- It is bound by its earlier decision only if the Supreme Court has endorsed it.
- It is never bound by its own earlier decisions in any circumstances.
- It is normally bound by its earlier decision, subject to exceptions such as a conflict between two earlier decisions or a decision made per incuriam.Correct answer
The Court of Appeal is generally bound by its own previous decisions, subject to the Young v Bristol Aeroplane exceptions: two conflicting earlier decisions, a decision inconsistent with a higher court, and a decision made per incuriam.
Law basis: Young v Bristol Aeroplane Co Ltd [1944] KB 718Question 6 · Statutory interpretation: golden ruleDraft, pending solicitor review
A statute makes it an offence to 'draw a sword' in a public place. Alex draws a ceremonial sword from its sheath on stage during a licensed play. A court uses a rule of interpretation which modifies the ordinary meaning only to avoid an absurd result. Which rule is that?
- The golden rule.Correct answer
- The mischief rule.
- The literal rule.
- The purposive approach under EU law.
- The rule of ejusdem generis.
The golden rule starts with the ordinary meaning but allows the court to depart from it where it would produce an absurdity or repugnance. The literal rule applies the words regardless of result, and the mischief rule looks to the gap in the old law the Act was meant to fix.
Law basis: Grey v Pearson (1857) 6 HL Cas 61; Adler v George [1964] 2 QB 7Question 7 · Burden and standard of proofDraft, pending solicitor review
In a civil claim in negligence, which statement best describes the burden and standard of proof?
- The claimant must prove the case on the balance of probabilities.Correct answer
- The claimant must prove the case on a standard that is higher than the balance of probabilities but lower than beyond reasonable doubt.
- The defendant must disprove the claim beyond reasonable doubt.
- The defendant must prove the case on the balance of probabilities.
- The claimant must prove the case beyond reasonable doubt.
In civil cases the party who asserts must prove it, to the civil standard of more likely than not. The criminal standard of beyond reasonable doubt applies to the prosecution in criminal cases.
Law basis: Miller v Minister of Pensions [1947] 2 All ER 372Question 8 · Rule of law and the separation of powersDraft, pending solicitor review
A minister uses a power in an Act to make secondary legislation which contradicts the Act itself and removes a person's right of access to a court. Which statement best describes the court's position?
- The court must apply the regulations, because ministers are accountable only to Parliament.
- The court cannot review delegated legislation made by a minister.
- The court can quash the regulations as ultra vires, because a minister cannot use delegated powers to undermine a statutory right unless the Act clearly authorises it.Correct answer
- The court can amend the Act to resolve the conflict.
- The court can strike down the Act itself for failing to respect the rule of law.
Delegated legislation can be challenged on judicial review if it exceeds the powers given by the parent Act. Rights of access to the courts can be removed only by clear and express words in primary legislation.
Law basis: R (UNISON) v Lord Chancellor [2017] UKSC 51Question 9 · Magistrates' courts and triable-either-way offencesDraft, pending solicitor review
A defendant is charged with theft, an offence triable either way. At the plea before venue hearing the defendant pleads not guilty. Which statement best describes what happens next?
- The magistrates decide whether the case is suitable for summary trial, and if so the defendant may elect trial in the Crown Court.Correct answer
- The case must go to the Crown Court, because it is not an indictable-only offence.
- The defendant must be tried by a jury of twelve in the magistrates' court.
- The magistrates must try the case, and the defendant has no right to elect Crown Court trial.
- The prosecution decides which court will try the case, with no input from the defendant.
Question 10 · Sources of law: precedent and ratioDraft, pending solicitor review
A judge in the High Court is considering a decision from a lower court on identical facts. The earlier decision reasoned from a different principle. Which statement best describes the status of the earlier judgment?
- It is binding, because the ratio decidendi of any English court binds all later courts.
- It has no weight at all, because only Supreme Court decisions can be cited.
- It is binding only if the lower court was a Crown Court.
- It is not binding on the High Court, because decisions of a lower court do not bind a higher court, although the judge may treat it as persuasive.Correct answer
- It is binding, because it was decided on identical facts.
A court is bound only by decisions of courts above it in the hierarchy, and sometimes its own. A decision of a lower court may persuade but does not bind.
Law basis: Doctrine of binding precedent (court hierarchy)Next: sit a timed mock, or return to the FLK1 practice questions.