Topics covered
- Offer and invitation to treat
- Counter-offer
- Acceptance: the postal rule
- Consideration: past consideration
- Consideration: practical benefit
- Privity and third-party rights
- Misrepresentation
- Exclusion clauses: UCTA 1977
- Discharge by frustration
- Damages: remoteness
All 10 questions with answers and the law behind them
Read them here, or use the practice mode above to test yourself first.
Question 1 · Offer and invitation to treatDraft, pending solicitor review
A clothing shop displays a coat in its window with a price ticket of £50. A customer enters the shop and offers £50 for the coat. The manager refuses, saying the ticket was a mistake and the real price is £150. Which statement best describes the legal position?
- The shop is bound, because a seller's mistake as to price can never prevent a contract from being formed.
- The shop is not bound, because the window display is an invitation to treat and the customer's tender is the offer, which the shop may refuse.Correct answer
- The shop is not bound, because any offer made by display lapses automatically once a customer enters the shop.
- The shop is bound, because the priced window display is an offer which the customer accepted by tendering the stated price.
- The shop is bound, because the display is a unilateral offer to the world which the customer accepted by entering the shop.
Goods displayed with a price are normally an invitation to treat, not an offer. The customer makes the offer at the till or when tendering payment, and the shop is free to accept or refuse it. The wrong options treat the display as an offer, or invent a rule that mistakes as to price never matter.
Law basis: Fisher v Bell [1961] 1 QB 394; Pharmaceutical Society of GB v Boots Cash Chemists [1953] 1 QB 401Question 2 · Counter-offerDraft, pending solicitor review
On 1 March Anna wrote to Ben offering to sell him her van for £8,000. On 2 March Ben replied offering £7,000. Anna did not respond. On 5 March Ben emailed: 'I accept your offer at £8,000.' Anna refuses to sell. Which statement best describes the position?
- A contract was formed on 2 March at £7,000, because Anna did not reject Ben's reply within a reasonable time.
- No contract was formed, because Ben's reply of 2 March was a request for information which suspended Anna's offer until she responded.
- A contract was formed on 5 March, because Ben accepted the terms of Anna's original offer while it was still open.
- No contract was formed, because Anna's original offer lapsed on 2 March through the passage of time.
- No contract was formed, because Ben's reply of 2 March was a counter-offer which terminated Anna's original offer.Correct answer
A counter-offer rejects and destroys the original offer, so it cannot later be accepted. Ben's email of 5 March is a fresh offer which Anna may refuse. Silence cannot amount to acceptance, and a one-day gap does not make the offer lapse.
Law basis: Hyde v Wrench (1840) 3 Beav 334; Stevenson, Jaques & Co v McLean (1880) 5 QBD 346 (request for information, contrasted); Felthouse v Bindley (1862) 11 CBNS 869Question 3 · Acceptance: the postal ruleDraft, pending solicitor review
On Monday Priya posted a letter offering to sell a painting to Quentin for £2,000. The letter said nothing about how acceptance must be communicated. On Wednesday Quentin posted a letter of acceptance. The letter was lost in the post and never reached Priya. On Thursday Priya, having heard nothing, sold the painting to a third party. Which statement best describes the position?
- No contract was formed, because the postal rule applies only where the offeror has expressly invited acceptance by post.
- A contract was formed on Thursday, when the letter would ordinarily have reached Priya in the post.
- A contract was formed when Quentin posted his letter, so Priya is in breach by selling the painting to the third party.Correct answer
- No contract was formed, because acceptance takes effect only when it is communicated to the offeror.
- A contract was formed on posting, but Priya is excused from performing because she did not know of the acceptance.
Where post is a reasonable means of acceptance, acceptance takes effect when the letter is posted, even if it is lost. The offer was itself made by post, so post was contemplated. Priya's later sale therefore breaches the contract that already existed.
Law basis: Adams v Lindsell (1818) 1 B & Ald 681; Household Fire and Carriage Accident Insurance Co v Grant (1879) 4 Ex D 216Question 4 · Consideration: past considerationDraft, pending solicitor review
Carl, without being asked, cleared the gutters of his neighbour Dee's house while she was on holiday. When she returned, Dee orally promised to pay him £100 for his trouble but later refused to pay. Which statement best describes whether Carl can enforce Dee's promise?
- Carl can enforce it, because Dee received a real benefit from his work.
- Carl can enforce it, because a voluntary promise to pay for services already rendered is always binding.
- Carl cannot enforce it, because his work was done before the promise and was not requested by Dee, so the consideration is past.Correct answer
- Carl cannot enforce it, because contractual promises are enforceable only if made in writing.
- Carl cannot enforce it, because a promise to pay money is enforceable only if made in a deed.
Consideration must move from the promisee in exchange for the promise. Work done earlier and without request is past consideration, and the narrow exception for services requested beforehand does not apply. A deed or writing is not the issue, and benefit to the promisor is not enough.
Law basis: Re McArdle [1951] Ch 669; Roscorla v Thomas (1842) 3 QB 234; Lampleigh v Brailsford (1615) Hob 105 (exception, not met)Question 5 · Consideration: practical benefitDraft, pending solicitor review
Bright Builders Ltd had a main contract to refurbish 20 flats and sub-contracted the carpentry to Tom for £20,000. After finishing 10 flats Tom ran into financial difficulty. Bright, fearing Tom would not finish and that it would face a penalty under its main contract, promised him an extra £4,000 to complete. Tom did not threaten Bright, and there was no duress or fraud. Tom completed the work. Bright refuses to pay the extra £4,000. Which statement best describes the position?
- Bright is not bound, because performing an existing contractual duty can never amount to consideration.
- Bright is not bound, unless Tom did something beyond his existing obligation that gave Bright a legal benefit.
- Bright is bound only if its promise to pay the extra £4,000 was made in a deed.
- Bright is bound, because a promise to pay more in a commercial contract needs no consideration.
- Bright is bound, because it obtained a practical benefit from Tom's performance and there was no duress or fraud, so its promise is supported by consideration.Correct answer
A promise to pay more for performance of an existing duty can be supported by a practical benefit to the promisor, where there is no economic duress or fraud and the promisor had reason to doubt the other party's performance. The rigid rule that existing duty is never consideration no longer governs this situation.
Law basis: Williams v Roffey Bros & Nicholls (Contractors) Ltd [1991] 1 QB 1; Stilk v Myrick (1809) 2 Camp 317; Re Selectmove Ltd [1995] 1 WLR 474 (limit: part payment of debts)Question 6 · Privity and third-party rightsDraft, pending solicitor review
Dina contracted with Eli, a decorator, for Eli to redecorate her house for £3,000. A term of the contract said that on completion Eli would pay £500 to Dina's daughter, Fay, who is named in the contract. Eli completed the work but has not paid Fay. Fay gave nothing in return for Eli's promise, and the contract does not mention the Contracts (Rights of Third Parties) Act 1999. Which statement best describes Fay's position?
- Fay can enforce the term only if Dina assigns her contractual rights to Fay in writing.
- Fay can enforce the term only if the contract expressly states that the 1999 Act applies.
- Fay can enforce the term only if she can show she provided consideration for Eli's promise.
- Fay can enforce the term against Eli, because it purports to confer a benefit on her and she is identified by name, unless the contract shows the parties did not intend her to enforce it.Correct answer
- Fay cannot enforce the term, because she is not a party to the contract and privity of contract bars her claim.
Question 7 · MisrepresentationDraft, pending solicitor review
Gareth bought a used van from Hana after Hana told him it had never been in an accident. Hana had not checked the van's history, but she had no reason to think the statement was untrue. The statement was false, and Gareth had to pay £2,500 for structural repairs. Which statement best describes Gareth's position under the Misrepresentation Act 1967?
- Gareth can only rescind the contract, because damages are unavailable for any non-fraudulent misrepresentation.
- Gareth can recover damages under s 2(1) only if he proves that Hana owed him a duty of care and was careless.
- Gareth has no remedy, because a statement about the history of goods is only an opinion.
- Gareth can recover damages only if he proves that Hana made the statement fraudulently.
- Gareth can claim damages under s 2(1) unless Hana proves she had reasonable grounds to believe, and did believe, the statement was true; he need not prove fraud or negligence.Correct answer
Question 8 · Exclusion clauses: UCTA 1977Draft, pending solicitor review
Zeta Ltd, a manufacturer, engaged Orion Consulting Ltd to advise on a new production system. Orion's standard terms, which Zeta accepted, said: 'Orion accepts no liability for loss arising from negligent advice.' Orion advised negligently and Zeta suffered £80,000 of financial loss. Which statement best describes the effect of the clause?
- The clause is valid and enforceable, because both parties are businesses and are free to allocate risk between them.
- The clause is effective, because the 1977 Act does not apply to clauses excluding liability for pure economic loss.
- The clause is effective only to the extent that Orion shows it satisfies the requirement of reasonableness under the Unfair Contract Terms Act 1977.Correct answer
- The clause is void, because the Consumer Rights Act 2015 makes any exclusion of negligence liability unenforceable.
- The clause is automatically void, because the 1977 Act makes any clause excluding liability for negligence void.
In a business contract, a clause excluding liability for negligence that causes loss other than death or personal injury is subject to the reasonableness test, and the burden is on the party relying on it. Only exclusion for death or personal injury caused by negligence is void outright, and the Consumer Rights Act does not govern business-to-business terms.
Law basis: Unfair Contract Terms Act 1977 ss 1, 2(1), 2(2), 11(1), 11(5) ↗Question 9 · Discharge by frustrationDraft, pending solicitor review
Mina hired a concert hall from Hall Ltd for 1 June at a fee of £5,000 and paid a £2,000 deposit in advance. On 1 May, without fault on either side, the hall was destroyed by fire. Which statement best describes the position?
- The contract was void from the outset, so each party must return everything received under it.
- The contract was frustrated and automatically discharged from the date of the fire, and the deposit is recoverable subject to the court's power to allow Hall Ltd to retain expenses.Correct answer
- Hall Ltd is in breach of contract, and Mina can recover damages for the profit she expected from the concert.
- The contract is voidable at Mina's option, and Hall Ltd must provide an alternative venue.
- The contract remains binding until either party terminates it by notice, and the deposit is forfeited.
Question 10 · Damages: remotenessDraft, pending solicitor review
Vector Ltd, a printing business, contracted to buy a specialised machine from Ruka Ltd for £40,000, to be delivered on 1 June. Ruka delivered six weeks late, in breach. Ruka knew Vector was a printing business but did not know that Vector had won a one-off, unusually lucrative contract that depended on the machine. Vector lost its normal profits from ordinary printing work during the delay, and also the exceptional profit on the one-off contract. Which statement best describes the recoverable loss?
- Vector can recover neither loss, because lost profits are always too remote in contract.
- Vector can recover neither loss unless Ruka expressly agreed in the contract to be liable for lost profits.
- Vector can recover both losses if they were foreseeable at the date of the breach, rather than at the date of the contract.
- Vector can recover both losses, because both were factually caused by the breach.
- Vector can recover its normal lost profits, but can recover the exceptional profit only if the special circumstances were within the parties' contemplation when the contract was made.Correct answer
Under the rule in Hadley v Baxendale, loss recoverable is that arising naturally from the breach or in the reasonable contemplation of both parties at the time of contracting. Normal profits meet that test, but an unusually lucrative contract not made known to the defendant does not.
Law basis: Hadley v Baxendale (1854) 9 Exch 341; Victoria Laundry (Windsor) Ltd v Newman Industries Ltd [1949] 2 KB 528; Transfield Shipping Inc v Mercator Shipping Inc (The Achilleas) [2008] UKHL 48Next: sit a timed mock, or return to the FLK1 practice questions.