Topics covered
- Three certainties
- Certainty of subject matter
- Formalities for declaring a trust of land
- Constitution of trusts: Milroy v Lord
- Secret trusts
- Resulting trusts: purchase money
- Trustees' duty of care and investment
- Breach of trust: liability and limitation
- Variation of trusts: Saunders v Vautier
- Remedies: tracing and following
All 10 questions with answers and the law behind them
Read them here, or use the practice mode above to test yourself first.
Question 1 · Three certaintiesDraft, pending solicitor review
Oscar's will says, 'I leave £50,000 to my brother Paul in the hope that he will give some of it to my friends.' Which statement best describes the effect on a trust of the money for the friends?
- A trust arises, because Oscar named his friends as intended recipients.
- No trust arises, because the words are precatory and show no certainty of intention to create a trust, so Paul takes the money absolutely.Correct answer
- No trust arises, because wills cannot create trusts.
- A trust arises for the friends, with Paul as trustee for half.
- A trust arises, because a will can create a trust of any sum.
An express trust needs certainty of intention, subject matter and objects. Words of hope or wish are precatory and do not show an intention to bind the recipient as trustee.
Law basis: Re Adams and the Kensington Vestry (1884) 27 Ch D 394; Knight v Knight (1840) 3 Beav 148Question 2 · Certainty of subject matterDraft, pending solicitor review
Rita declares that she holds '500 of the 1,000 bottles of wine in my cellar' on trust for Sam. The bottles are identical, and none are separated from the rest. Which statement best describes whether a trust is created?
- No trust arises, because the trust property is not identified until the bottles are separated.Correct answer
- A trust arises, because the bottles are identical, so any 500 will do.
- A trust arises, but only on Rita's death.
- A trust arises over the whole cellar in equal shares.
- A trust arises, because Rita used the word 'trust'.
There must be certainty of subject matter. Where tangible assets are not ascertained, a purported trust of part of a larger mass fails, unlike the position for shares of the same class.
Law basis: Re London Wine Co (Shippers) Ltd [1986] PCC 121; Hunter v Moss [1994] 1 WLR 452Question 3 · Formalities for declaring a trust of landDraft, pending solicitor review
Tara orally declares that she holds her house on trust for her friend Uma. Nothing is written down. Which statement best describes the effect?
- The trust is valid for personal property only.
- The trust is valid, because oral declarations are always effective.
- The trust is valid, because Uma knows about it.
- The trust is unenforceable, because a declaration of trust of land must be evidenced in writing and signed by the settlor.Correct answer
- The trust is void and Tara holds the house for herself outright, even though the law of resulting trusts could apply.
Question 4 · Constitution of trusts: Milroy v LordDraft, pending solicitor review
Vera intends to give shares to her nephew Will and signs a letter saying 'the shares are yours', but she does not sign a share transfer form or give the certificates. Which statement best describes the position?
- The gift is complete, because Vera's intention is clear.
- Vera is now a trustee of the shares for Will.
- The gift is complete, because the letter is signed.
- Will can compel Vera to complete the transfer as a matter of right.
- The gift is not completely constituted, so Will has no interest, because equity does not perfect an imperfect gift.Correct answer
A gift or trust is effective only if the settlor has done everything within their power to transfer the property, or has declared themselves trustee. Equity will not perfect an imperfect gift.
Law basis: Milroy v Lord (1862) 4 De GF & J 264; Re Rose [1952] Ch 499Question 5 · Secret trustsDraft, pending solicitor review
A testator leaves his house to Xavier in his will and tells Xavier before signing the will that Xavier is to hold it for the testator's partner. Xavier agrees. After the testator dies, Xavier refuses to hold the house for the partner. Which statement best describes the position?
- A fully secret trust arises, and Xavier holds the house on trust for the partner, because of the communication, the acceptance and the reliance, and it operates outside the Wills Act.Correct answer
- A trust arises only if Xavier signs a document after the death.
- A trust arises only if the partner knew about the arrangement.
- No trust arises, because the Wills Act requires all trusts to appear in the will.
- A half-secret trust arises, because the will does not mention the partner.
A fully secret trust needs the testator's intention, communication to the legatee, and acceptance by the legatee, and the legatee then holds on trust outside the will to prevent fraud.
Law basis: Ottaway v Norman [1972] Ch 698; McCormick v Grogan (1869) LR 4 HL 82Question 6 · Resulting trusts: purchase moneyDraft, pending solicitor review
Yasmin pays the whole £200,000 for a house that is put into the name of her friend Zara, who contributes nothing. There is no discussion of the arrangement. Which statement best describes the beneficial ownership?
- Yasmin has no claim, because there was no written agreement.
- Zara owns the house, because she is the legal owner.
- Zara owns it, because the presumption of advancement applies between friends.
- They share it equally, because they are friends.
- A purchase money resulting trust arises in Yasmin's favour, because she provided the whole price and the presumption is that the legal owner holds the property for her.Correct answer
Where a person pays the purchase price of property put into another's name, the law presumes a resulting trust for the payer. The presumption of advancement applies only to certain relationships, such as a husband to wife or a parent to a child, and is of limited force.
Law basis: Dyer v Dyer (1788) 2 Cox 92; Re Vandervell's Trusts (No 2) [1974] Ch 269Question 7 · Trustees' duty of care and investmentDraft, pending solicitor review
A trustee of a family trust invests the whole fund in a single speculative company without taking advice. The fund loses 60% of its value. Which statement best describes the trustee's position?
- The trustee is in breach only if the investment was dishonest.
- The trustee is in breach only if the beneficiaries objected beforehand.
- The trustee is likely to be in breach of the statutory duty of care and the duty to consider standard investment criteria and take advice.Correct answer
- The trustee is not in breach, because the investment might have succeeded.
- The trustee is not in breach, because trustees may invest as they wish.
Trustees must exercise reasonable skill and care. When investing they must have regard to the standard investment criteria, suitability and diversification, and obtain and consider proper advice unless it is unnecessary.
Law basis: Trustee Act 2000 ss 1, 4, 5 ↗Question 8 · Breach of trust: liability and limitationDraft, pending solicitor review
A trustee breaches a trust and the beneficiary, who is an adult with an immediate interest, discovers it 10 years later. Which statement best describes the limitation position under the Limitation Act 1980?
- The period is six years from when the beneficiary discovered the breach in all cases.
- The period is three years from the date of the breach in every case.
- The period is generally six years from the breach, though there is no limit for fraud or for recovery of trust property that the trustee converted to their own use.Correct answer
- There is no limit for any claim against trustees.
- The period is twelve years in all cases.
The period for breach of trust is six years from the breach (and for a future interest, from when it falls into possession). No period applies where the claim concerns fraud or the trustee's conversion of the trust property to their own use.
Law basis: Limitation Act 1980 s 21 ↗Question 9 · Variation of trusts: Saunders v VautierDraft, pending solicitor review
A trust fund is held for Aled, aged 25, absolutely, with the trustees holding it until he is 30. No other person has any interest in the fund. Aled wants the money now. Which statement best describes his position?
- He can only after the Charity Commission approves.
- He can only if the court approves, as for a minor.
- He can only if the trustees agree to it unanimously.
- He can call for the trust property under the rule in Saunders v Vautier, because he is adult, of full capacity and the only beneficiary.Correct answer
- He cannot, because the trust deed fixes the age of 30.
If all beneficiaries are sui juris and together absolutely entitled, they may end the trust and call for the property, even against the settlor's wishes.
Law basis: Saunders v Vautier (1841) Cr & Ph 240Question 10 · Remedies: tracing and followingDraft, pending solicitor review
A trustee wrongfully takes £10,000 of trust money, pays it into his own bank account that already contains £2,000 of his own funds, and spends £9,000 on a holiday. He leaves £3,000 in the account. Which statement best describes the beneficiaries' claim to the money in the account?
- They can claim nothing, because the bank is the owner of the account.
- They can claim the £3,000 by tracing, because the trustee is presumed to spend his own money first, so the balance is treated as trust money.Correct answer
- They can claim £3,000 only if the trustee agrees.
- They cannot claim any of it, because the money has been mixed.
- They can claim only £1,000, because the trustee's own funds are first used up.
When trust money is mixed with the trustee's own, the trustee is presumed to spend his own money first. Beneficiaries can trace into the lowest intermediate balance, so £3,000 is traceable here.
Law basis: Re Hallett's Estate (1880) 13 Ch D 696; Re Oatway [1903] 2 Ch 356Next: sit a timed mock, or return to the FLK2 practice questions.