SQE1 Tort Law practice questions

Tort Law covers negligence, occupiers' liability, nuisance, vicarious liability and defamation. The questions ask you to apply the rule to a short client scenario.

Each answer shows the case or section behind it, with links to legislation.gov.uk where a statute applies.

These questions are marked Draft until a qualified solicitor has reviewed them. See how we write questions.

Practice mode

10 questions. Choose an answer, check it, and read the law behind it. Your place is saved in this browser.

Keyboard: press 1 to 5 (or A to E) to choose, Enter to check or continue.

Topics covered

  • Standard of care
  • Causation: but for
  • Remoteness and the thin skull rule
  • Occupiers' liability to visitors
  • Occupiers' liability to trespassers
  • Vicarious liability
  • Private nuisance: coming to the nuisance
  • Rylands v Fletcher
  • Defamation: serious harm
  • Contributory negligence

All 10 questions with answers and the law behind them

Read them here, or use the practice mode above to test yourself first.

Question 1 · Standard of careDraft, pending solicitor review

Lena, a learner driver with two lessons behind her, drives into a parked car because she brakes too late. The parked car's owner sues. Lena says she was doing her best for a beginner. Which statement best describes the standard of care applied?

  1. No standard of care, because a learner driver owes no duty to parked cars.
  2. A subjective standard, so she is not liable if she did her best.
  3. A standard that is lower because she was being supervised.
  4. The standard of a reasonable learner driver of her experience.
  5. The standard of a reasonably competent driver, so her inexperience is not a defence.Correct answer
Question 2 · Causation: but forDraft, pending solicitor review

Patient Ali attends A&E after drinking poisoned tea, and the doctor negligently sends him home without examining him. It is later shown that Ali would have died from the poison even if treated properly. Which statement best describes the hospital's liability for his death?

  1. The hospital is liable, because the poison was a foreseeable cause of death.
  2. The hospital is liable, because the doctor breached a duty of care.
  3. The hospital is liable, because the negligence increased the risk of death.
  4. The hospital is liable for half of the loss, because causation is uncertain.
  5. The hospital is not liable for the death, because the negligence did not cause it on a but-for basis.Correct answer
Question 3 · Remoteness and the thin skull ruleDraft, pending solicitor review

Sam negligently spills a hot drink on Kit, causing a minor burn. Because of a rare pre-existing condition, the burn develops into a serious illness. Burns were foreseeable, but the illness was not. Which statement best describes Sam's liability?

  1. Sam is liable only for the minor burn, because the illness was not foreseeable.
  2. Sam is liable for the illness only if Kit warned him about the condition.
  3. Sam is not liable at all, because the full extent of the harm was unforeseeable.
  4. Sam is liable for the whole illness, because the type of harm was foreseeable and he takes his victim as he finds him.Correct answer
  5. Sam is liable only if he knew about the condition.
Question 4 · Occupiers' liability to visitorsDraft, pending solicitor review

A hotel hires an electrician, Eli, to repair a fault in its wiring. While working, he is shocked by a live wire in the ceiling, a risk ordinarily associated with his work. He sues the hotel under the Occupiers' Liability Act 1957. Which statement best describes the position?

  1. The hotel is not liable, because occupiers owe no duty to visitors who are contractors.
  2. The hotel is liable, because it has no defence to a claim by a lawful visitor.
  3. The hotel is unlikely to be liable, because an occupier may expect a person in the exercise of his calling to guard against the special risks ordinarily incident to it.Correct answer
  4. The hotel is liable, because it owes every visitor the same duty whatever their trade.
  5. The hotel is not liable, because an electrician is a trespasser when working on site.
Question 5 · Occupiers' liability to trespassersDraft, pending solicitor review

A quarry company knows that its disused quarry has unstable edges and that local children regularly climb the fence to play there. A 12-year-old trespasser is injured when an edge collapses. Which statement best describes the company's duty?

  1. It owed a duty only if the child could prove the company intended harm.
  2. It owed a duty under the 1984 Act, because it knew of the danger and that trespassers were likely to be near it, and the risk was one against which it was reasonable to offer protection.Correct answer
  3. It owed the full common duty of care under the 1957 Act, as for any visitor.
  4. It owed no duty, because trespassers are owed none.
  5. It owed a duty only if it had invited the child onto the land.
Question 6 · Vicarious liabilityDraft, pending solicitor review

A petrol station worker, Joe, is asked by a customer to leave the premises, and he follows the customer to his car, swearing and attacking him. The customer sues Joe's employer. Which statement best describes the employer's position?

  1. The employer is not liable, because an employer is never liable for an employee's intentional wrong.
  2. The employer is liable only if it had authorised the assault.
  3. The employer is likely to be liable, because there was a close connection between what Joe was employed to do and the wrong, so it was in the course of his employment.Correct answer
  4. The employer is not liable, because Joe was acting on his own initiative.
  5. The employer is liable only if the customer can sue Joe successfully first.
Question 7 · Private nuisance: coming to the nuisanceDraft, pending solicitor review

A confectioner has used noisy machinery on his premises for many years. A neighbour builds a consulting room next door, then finds that the noise prevents her from working, and sues in nuisance. Which statement best describes her claim?

  1. It succeeds only if the noise occurs at night.
  2. It succeeds only if the confectioner intended to annoy her.
  3. It can succeed, because it is no defence that the claimant came to the nuisance.Correct answer
  4. It fails, because the neighbour has no right to use her land in a way that the noise affects.
  5. It fails, because the confectioner was there first.
Question 8 · Rylands v FletcherDraft, pending solicitor review

A householder's ordinary domestic water pipe bursts and floods a neighbour's flat. The neighbour sues under the rule in Rylands v Fletcher. Which statement best describes the position?

  1. The claim succeeds only if the householder knew the pipe was defective.
  2. The claim fails only because the householder was not negligent.
  3. The claim fails, because ordinary domestic water supply is not a non-natural or extraordinary and unusual use of land.Correct answer
  4. The claim succeeds, because the householder is strictly liable for water on his land.
  5. The claim succeeds, because anything that escapes from land is covered by the rule.
Question 9 · Defamation: serious harmDraft, pending solicitor review

A local newspaper wrongly states that a builder cheats customers. The builder sues in libel. Which statement best describes what he must show to bring a claim under the Defamation Act 2013?

  1. That at least one person stopped dealing with him.
  2. That the statement was published with malice.
  3. That publication has caused, or is likely to cause, serious harm to his reputation.Correct answer
  4. That the statement was untrue, and the newspaper must then prove it was true.
  5. That the statement caused him financial loss in a particular month.
Question 10 · Contributory negligenceDraft, pending solicitor review

Priya is injured in a collision caused entirely by another driver's negligence. She was not wearing a seatbelt, and the court finds that a seatbelt would have reduced the severity of her injuries but not prevented them. Her damages before reduction are £40,000. Which statement best describes the likely award?

  1. £30,000, because the usual reduction is 25% in every seatbelt case.
  2. Nothing, because contributory negligence is a complete defence.
  3. £20,000, because both drivers were at fault equally.
  4. Around £34,000, because damages are reduced for contributory negligence, and the usual reduction in this situation is 15%.Correct answer
  5. £40,000, because the other driver caused the collision.

Next: sit a timed mock, or return to the FLK1 practice questions.