Topics covered
- Actus reus and omissions
- Murder: intention
- Theft
- Burglary
- Self-defence
- Police powers: arrest
- Detention without charge
- Disclosure and bail
- Hearsay in criminal proceedings
- Sentencing and guilty pleas
All 10 questions with answers and the law behind them
Read them here, or use the practice mode above to test yourself first.
Question 1 · Actus reus and omissionsDraft, pending solicitor review
Nell finds her elderly mother unconscious on the sofa after taking pills. Nell, who lives with her and cares for her, decides not to call anyone, and her mother dies. Which statement best describes whether Nell can be liable for the death?
- She can be liable only if she took active steps to hasten death.
- She is liable for murder, because she intended her mother to die.
- She cannot be liable, because her mother took the pills herself.
- She can be liable, because a person who has assumed responsibility for a vulnerable relative may owe a duty to act and be liable for gross negligence manslaughter.Correct answer
- She cannot be liable, because there is no liability for omissions.
Omissions can found liability where there is a duty to act, for example by assumption of responsibility. Gross negligence manslaughter needs a duty, breach, causation, risk of death and gross negligence.
Law basis: R v Stone and Dobinson [1977] QB 354; R v Adomako [1995] 1 AC 171Question 2 · Murder: intentionDraft, pending solicitor review
Omar sets fire to a house at night to scare his enemy, not intending to kill anyone. He knows that there are people sleeping inside, and that death is virtually certain. A person dies. Which statement best describes his mens rea?
- The jury may find intention to kill or cause serious harm, because death or serious injury was a virtual certainty and he appreciated that.Correct answer
- He cannot have the mens rea for murder, because he did not desire death.
- He has no mens rea, because he was reckless.
- He has the mens rea for murder only if he desired death.
- He has the mens rea for manslaughter only.
Under the virtual certainty test, the jury may find intention if death or serious injury was a virtual certainty and the defendant appreciated this. Murder needs intent to kill or to cause grievous bodily harm.
Law basis: R v Woollin [1999] 1 AC 82Question 3 · TheftDraft, pending solicitor review
Pat picks up another customer's umbrella from a café stand by mistake, believing it is hers. She realises the mistake later but keeps it, intending never to return it. Which statement best describes the position?
- She is guilty of burglary, because she took it from the café.
- She is not guilty, because she acquired it innocently.
- She can be guilty of theft from the time she knows it is not hers and decides to keep it as an appropriation with dishonesty, although she had innocently come by it.Correct answer
- She is not guilty, because umbrellas cannot be stolen.
- She is guilty of robbery, because she used force.
Theft is the dishonest appropriation of property belonging to another with the intention to permanently deprive. A later assumption of rights by keeping or dealing with property that was innocently acquired is an appropriation.
Law basis: Theft Act 1968 ss 1, 3(1) ↗Question 4 · BurglaryDraft, pending solicitor review
Quinn enters a shop during opening hours with the intention of stealing goods. Which statement best describes whether Quinn commits burglary?
- No, because the shop was open to the public.
- No, because burglary applies only to dwellings.
- No, because burglary needs force.
- Yes, because he entered a building as a trespasser, which he becomes by entering with an intention beyond the permission given, with intent to steal.Correct answer
- No, because he has not yet taken anything.
Question 5 · Self-defenceDraft, pending solicitor review
Rob is threatened with a punch by a drunk stranger, and Rob stabs him in the chest with a knife he carries. He says that he believed he was in danger of serious violence. Which statement best describes how the law approaches self-defence?
- The jury considers whether the force was reasonable in the circumstances as the defendant believed them to be, and a genuine mistake can count even if unreasonable, but excessive force is not reasonable.Correct answer
- Self-defence is a complete defence to any force, whatever the threat.
- Self-defence is available only to police officers.
- Self-defence applies only if the defendant retreated first.
- Self-defence applies only if the belief was reasonable.
Question 6 · Police powers: arrestDraft, pending solicitor review
A constable has reasonable grounds to suspect that Sid has committed an indictable offence of theft. Which statement best describes the power of arrest under PACE 1984 s 24?
- The constable must obtain a warrant first in all cases.
- The constable may arrest only if the offence is murder.
- The constable may arrest only at the suspect's home.
- The constable may arrest without a warrant if arrest is necessary for one of the reasons in s 24(5), such as to allow the prompt and effective investigation of the offence.Correct answer
- The constable may arrest only if the suspect admits it.
Section 24 allows arrest without a warrant if the officer has reasonable grounds to suspect the person is guilty of an offence and has reasonable grounds to believe that arrest is necessary for one of the reasons listed in s 24(5).
Law basis: Police and Criminal Evidence Act 1984 s 24 ↗Question 7 · Detention without chargeDraft, pending solicitor review
A suspect is arrested for burglary and brought to a police station. Which statement best describes the maximum period the police can detain him without charge before an extension is needed under PACE?
- Six hours in all cases.
- 24 hours from the relevant time, extendable to 36 hours by a superintendent for an indictable offence, and then to 96 hours with magistrates' warrants.Correct answer
- 48 hours as of right for any offence.
- Seven days with no further authority.
- 72 hours as of right, with no review.
Question 8 · Disclosure and bailDraft, pending solicitor review
A defendant charged with an either-way offence is refused bail by the magistrates. Which statement best describes his position?
- He can apply only to the police.
- He can apply to the Crown Court for bail, because the Crown Court can hear a bail application if the magistrates refuse bail.Correct answer
- He can apply only after trial.
- He cannot apply again, because a refusal of bail is final.
- He can apply only to the Court of Appeal.
Question 9 · Hearsay in criminal proceedingsDraft, pending solicitor review
At a criminal trial the prosecution wants to read out a statement of a witness who has died, which describes the defendant's actions. Which statement best describes the admissibility of the statement?
- It can be admitted only if it was sworn before a judge.
- It can be admitted only if the defendant agrees.
- It cannot be admitted, because hearsay is never admissible.
- It can be admitted only after a retrial.
- It may be admitted as hearsay under the Criminal Justice Act 2003, because the maker is dead and the statement was made in a document and relevant.Correct answer
Hearsay is generally inadmissible, but section 116 of the Criminal Justice Act 2003 admits a statement if the maker is dead, subject to the conditions, and the court can exclude it where it is unfair.
Law basis: Criminal Justice Act 2003 s 116 ↗Question 10 · Sentencing and guilty pleasDraft, pending solicitor review
A defendant pleads guilty at the first stage of proceedings in the Crown Court. Which statement best describes the effect on the sentence?
- The court gives no reduction for a plea to an indictable offence.
- The court must take the plea into account and normally gives a reduction of up to one third, which reduces as the proceedings progress.Correct answer
- The court must halve the sentence in every case.
- The court cannot reduce the sentence, whatever the stage.
- The court must reduce the sentence to the statutory minimum.
Next: sit a timed mock, or return to the FLK2 practice questions.