Topics covered
- Royal prerogative
- Wednesbury unreasonableness
- Legitimate expectation
- Rule against bias
- Standing in judicial review
- Devolution
- Ouster clauses
- Retained EU law
- Ministerial accountability and scrutiny
- Constitutional conventions
- Human Rights Act: public authorities
All 11 questions with answers and the law behind them
Read them here, or use the practice mode above to test yourself first.
Question 1 · Royal prerogativeDraft, pending solicitor review
The Prime Minister advises the Crown to ratify a treaty, using the royal prerogative. Which statement best describes the court's role if someone challenges the decision?
- The court can review the merits of every prerogative decision.
- The court can reverse the policy decision because it disagrees with it.
- The court has no power to consider any prerogative, whatever the circumstances.
- The court can only review prerogative powers that Parliament has abolished.
- The court can decide whether a prerogative power exists and its limits, but it will not review the merits of a treaty-making decision, although a prerogative cannot be used to change domestic law.Correct answer
The courts may rule on the existence and extent of prerogative powers, and a prerogative cannot be used to alter statute law or remove statutory rights. Treaty-making itself is non-justiciable policy.
Law basis: R (Miller) v Secretary of State for Exiting the EU [2017] UKSC 5; R (Miller) v Prime Minister [2019] UKSC 41Question 2 · Wednesbury unreasonablenessDraft, pending solicitor review
A council decides that a cinema may open on Sundays only if no children under 15 are admitted. The cinema challenges the condition as unreasonable. Which statement best describes the test the court applies?
- Whether a majority of local people support the decision.
- Whether the court would have made the same decision itself.
- Whether the condition is the best available policy choice.
- Whether the decision is so unreasonable that no reasonable authority could have come to it.Correct answer
- Whether the cinema owner agrees with the council's reasons.
Wednesbury unreasonableness asks whether the decision is one that no reasonable decision-maker could have reached. The court does not substitute its own view on the merits.
Law basis: Associated Provincial Picture Houses Ltd v Wednesbury Corporation [1948] 1 KB 223Question 3 · Legitimate expectationDraft, pending solicitor review
A regulator publishes a clear promise that existing licence holders will be consulted before any change to licensing rules. It then changes the rules without consulting them. Which ground of review is most apt?
- Irrationality, because the regulator has acted unreasonably in changing policy.
- No ground, because a public body can never be bound by a promise.
- Substantive illegality, because the regulator has no power to make rules.
- Bias, because the regulator has an interest in the outcome.
- Procedural legitimate expectation, based on a clear and unambiguous promise to consult.Correct answer
A clear and unambiguous representation by a public body can give rise to a legitimate expectation that the promised procedure will be followed, and the body must then act fairly in departing from it.
Law basis: Council of Civil Service Unions v Minister for the Civil Service [1985] AC 374Question 4 · Rule against biasDraft, pending solicitor review
A planning committee member votes on an application by a company in which she holds shares. Which statement best describes the effect?
- The decision is quashed only if the applicant proves that she had a grudge.
- The decision stands, because only actual bias counts.
- The decision is likely to be quashed for automatic disqualification, because a decision-maker with a financial interest in the outcome is disqualified from deciding.Correct answer
- The decision is voidable only if the applicant proves that she was influenced.
- The decision stands if the committee voted unanimously.
A decision-maker with a direct pecuniary interest in the outcome is automatically disqualified and no proof of actual bias is needed. For other cases the test is whether a fair-minded and informed observer would see a real possibility of bias.
Law basis: Dimes v Grand Junction Canal (1852) 3 HLC 759; Porter v Magill [2001] UKHL 67Question 5 · Standing in judicial reviewDraft, pending solicitor review
An environmental charity wishes to challenge a licensing decision that affects a protected wetland, though the charity has no property or personal interest there. Which statement best describes the rule on standing?
- Only the Attorney General can bring a claim in the public interest.
- Only a person directly affected in their own property can bring a claim.
- The charity needs a sufficient interest in the matter, which a court may find for a representative public-interest body with a genuine concern.Correct answer
- The charity has standing automatically as a registered charity.
- A claim can be brought only by a person who took part in the original decision.
Question 6 · DevolutionDraft, pending solicitor review
The Scottish Parliament passes an Act in an area reserved to the UK Parliament. Which statement best describes the effect?
- It is valid, because the UK Parliament has no power to legislate for Scotland.
- It is valid for 12 months and then lapses automatically.
- It is valid, because the Scottish Parliament is sovereign within Scotland.
- The provision is outside the Parliament's legislative competence and is not law, as the Scotland Act 1998 reserves certain matters to Westminster.Correct answer
- It is valid but applies only to Scottish courts.
The Scottish Parliament can legislate only within its competence. A provision relating to reserved matters is outside competence and is not law. The UK Parliament remains sovereign and can legislate for Scotland.
Law basis: Scotland Act 1998 s 29(1), (2)(b), Sch 5 ↗Question 7 · Ouster clausesDraft, pending solicitor review
A statute states that a tribunal's decisions 'shall not be called into question in any court'. A claimant argues that the tribunal made a decision outside its jurisdiction. Which statement best describes the courts' approach?
- The courts can review only if the tribunal agrees.
- The courts can review only on the merits and not on jurisdiction.
- The courts interpret ouster clauses narrowly and will generally still review decisions that are void for lack of jurisdiction.Correct answer
- The courts must refuse to hear any claim, whatever the grounds.
- The courts will strike down the statute containing the clause.
Courts read such clauses restrictively. A decision made without jurisdiction is not protected by a clause ousting review, and judicial review remains available unless Parliament uses unmistakably clear words.
Law basis: Anisminic Ltd v Foreign Compensation Commission [1969] 2 AC 147; R (Privacy International) v Investigatory Powers Tribunal [2019] UKSC 22Question 8 · Retained EU lawDraft, pending solicitor review
A client asks about the status of EU-derived rules that were part of UK law before the end of the transition period. Which statement best describes the position now under the Retained EU Law (Revocation and Reform) Act 2023?
- All EU law applies in the UK exactly as before and prevails over later statutes.
- The special status of retained EU law has ended, and such rules are now generally known as assimilated law, which courts interpret and apply under the amended rules.Correct answer
- Only the Court of Justice of the European Union may interpret the rules.
- EU law continues to have direct effect and supremacy over Acts of Parliament.
- All EU-derived law was repealed on 31 December 2023 and no longer has effect.
Question 9 · Ministerial accountability and scrutinyDraft, pending solicitor review
A government minister makes a serious error in a department. Which statement best describes the principle of individual ministerial responsibility?
- The minister must always resign when any error occurs.
- The minister is accountable to Parliament for the department's actions and must answer for them, though resignation is not required in every case.Correct answer
- The minister is accountable only to the Prime Minister.
- The minister is accountable to the courts rather than to Parliament.
- The minister is legally liable personally for every civil servant's error.
Under the constitutional convention of ministerial responsibility, ministers answer to Parliament for the conduct of their departments. Resignation depends on the circumstances and political judgment.
Law basis: Constitutional convention of individual ministerial responsibilityQuestion 10 · Constitutional conventionsDraft, pending solicitor review
A convention says the monarch gives royal assent to bills passed by both Houses. Suppose that the monarch refused assent. Which statement best describes the court's position on conventions?
- Conventions are statutes and can be repealed only by Parliament.
- Conventions are enforceable only through the criminal courts.
- Conventions are legally binding and enforced by injunction.
- Conventions are enforceable only by the House of Lords.
- Conventions are not legally enforceable, though courts may recognise them and use them in deciding the law.Correct answer
Conventions are rules of political practice which are not law and not enforced by the courts, although the courts may recognise their existence. They are not laid down in statute.
Law basis: R (Miller) v Secretary of State for Exiting the EU [2017] UKSC 5, paras 136-151Question 11 · Human Rights Act: public authoritiesDraft, pending solicitor review
A private care home contracted by a council to house vulnerable adults is accused of breaching a resident's Convention rights. Which statement best describes whether the home is a public authority under the Human Rights Act 1998?
- It is always a public authority, because it is paid by the council.
- It is a public authority only if it is a registered charity.
- It depends on whether the body is exercising functions of a public nature, and a private provider is a public authority only for those functions, not for its private acts.Correct answer
- It is never a public authority, because it is a private business.
- It is a public authority only if the resident has complained.
Next: sit a timed mock, or return to the FLK1 practice questions.