Law covered in these questions
- SRA Accounts Rules 2019, rule 8.1
- double-entry bookkeeping principles
- Value Added Tax Act 1994, s 36
- SRA Accounts Rules 2019, rules 5.3, 6.1 and 8.1
- SRA Accounts Rules 2019, rules 5.3 and 8.1
- Value Added Tax Act 1994
All 12 questions with answers
Try them above first, then read the worked answers below.
Question 1 · Abatements, bad debts and dishonoured chequesDraft, pending solicitor review
Mason LLP sent Kira a bill for £2,400 including VAT. Kira complained about the level of costs, and the partner agreed to reduce the bill by £600 including VAT. Which of the following best describes the entries for the reduction?
- Credit Kira's ledger office section £600; debit profit costs £500 and HMRC £100.Correct answer
- Credit Kira's ledger client section £600; debit client cash £600.
- Credit Kira's ledger office section £600; debit bad debts £600.
- Credit office cash £600; debit Kira's ledger office section £600.
- Debit Kira's ledger office section £600; credit profit costs £500 and HMRC £100.
An abatement reduces a bill already delivered and reverses part of the billing entries. Kira's ledger, office section, is credited with the full reduction of £600, reducing what she owes. The profit costs account is debited £500 and the HMRC (VAT) account £100, because the firm earns less and owes less VAT. No money moves, so no cash account is used. Writing the sum off as a bad debt is wrong: a bad debt is used where the client cannot or will not pay, whereas here the firm has agreed to reduce the costs themselves.
Law basis: SRA Accounts Rules 2019, rule 8.1; double-entry bookkeeping principlesQuestion 2 · Abatements, bad debts and dishonoured chequesDraft, pending solicitor review
Orton Solicitors delivered a bill to Priscilla for £1,200 including VAT nine months ago. She has become insolvent and the firm decides to write off the debt and claim VAT bad debt relief. Which of the following best describes the entries?
- Credit her ledger office section £1,200; debit bad debts account £1,200.
- Credit her ledger client section £1,200; debit bad debts £1,200 in full.
- Debit her ledger office section £1,200; credit bad debts £1,000 and HMRC £200.
- Credit her ledger office section £1,200; debit bad debts £1,000 and HMRC £200.Correct answer
- Credit her ledger office section £1,200; debit profit costs £1,000 and HMRC £200.
Writing off a bad debt removes the amount owed from the client's ledger: Priscilla's ledger office section is credited with £1,200. The firm debits the bad debts expense account with the net £1,000 and, because VAT bad debt relief is available (the debt is over six months old and written off), debits the HMRC account with £200 to reclaim the VAT already accounted for. Debiting bad debts with the full £1,200 ignores the relief. Debiting profit costs is the treatment for an abatement, where the firm reduces its fee rather than failing to recover it.
Law basis: Value Added Tax Act 1994, s 36 ↗Question 3 · Abatements, bad debts and dishonoured chequesDraft, pending solicitor review
Wright Solicitors receives a cheque from Ayo for £960 in payment of a bill already delivered and pays it into business account. A week later the bank returns the cheque unpaid. Which of the following best describes the entries for the dishonour?
- Credit office cash £960; debit Ayo's ledger office section £960.Correct answer
- Debit office cash £960; credit Ayo's ledger office section £960.
- Credit client cash £960; debit Ayo's ledger client section £960.
- Credit Ayo's ledger office section £960; debit profit costs £960.
- Credit office cash £960; debit bad debts account £960.
When a cheque is dishonoured, the original receipt entries are reversed. The cheque was office money paid into business account: on receipt the firm debited office cash and credited Ayo's ledger office section. On dishonour, office cash is credited £960, because money has effectively left the account, and Ayo's ledger office section is debited £960, reinstating the debt. Client-side entries are wrong because the cheque was office money. Writing the sum off as a bad debt is premature, since the firm can still pursue Ayo, and debiting profit costs would treat it as an abatement.
Law basis: SRA Accounts Rules 2019, rule 8.1; double-entry bookkeeping principlesQuestion 4 · Abatements, bad debts and dishonoured chequesDraft, pending solicitor review
Pace Solicitors delivered a bill to Hugo for £3,600 including VAT two months ago. Hugo has stopped responding. The firm decides to write off the debt now and claim VAT bad debt relief immediately. Which of the following best describes the VAT position?
- Relief is available at once because the debt has been written off.
- Relief is available at once because Hugo is no longer responding.
- Relief is never available because VAT on legal fees is not recoverable.
- Relief is not yet available, as six months have not yet passed.Correct answer
- Relief is available only once Hugo has been made bankrupt.
Under section 36 of the Value Added Tax Act 1994, a supplier can claim bad debt relief for VAT accounted for on a supply only where, among other conditions, the debt has been written off in its accounts and six months have elapsed from the later of the date of supply and the date payment was due. Two months is too soon, so the firm cannot yet claim relief, though it may write off the net debt in its accounts. Relief does not depend on the debtor's bankruptcy, and VAT on legal fees can be the subject of bad debt relief.
Law basis: Value Added Tax Act 1994, s 36 ↗Question 5 · Abatements, bad debts and dishonoured chequesDraft, pending solicitor review
Vance Solicitors billed Selina £1,200 including VAT, and she paid in full. The firm later agrees to reduce its bill by £240 including VAT because of a delay. Which of the following best describes Selina's ledger after the abatement but before any refund?
- The office section shows a £240 credit balance owed to Selina.Correct answer
- The client section shows a £240 debit balance owed by Selina.
- The client section shows a £240 credit balance held for Selina.
- The office section shows a £240 debit balance owed by Selina.
- The office section shows a nil balance as the bill was paid.
After Selina paid the bill, her office section balance was nil. The abatement is recorded by crediting her ledger office section with £240 and debiting profit costs (£200) and HMRC (£40). Her office section therefore shows a credit balance of £240, meaning the firm owes her that sum. The firm should refund it promptly, recording a credit to office cash and a debit to her office section. The client section is unaffected because no client money is involved; refunding an overpaid fee is an office account matter, not client money held for her.
Law basis: SRA Accounts Rules 2019, rule 8.1; double-entry bookkeeping principlesQuestion 6 · Abatements, bad debts and dishonoured chequesDraft, pending solicitor review
Garvey Solicitors receives a £10,000 cheque from Peter on account of a deposit and pays it into client account. Before it clears, the firm sends £10,000 to the seller's solicitors. Peter's cheque is then dishonoured. Which of the following best describes Peter's ledger after the dishonour is recorded?
- The client section shows a nil balance, as the payment and receipt cancel out.
- The client section shows a £10,000 debit balance to be cleared at once.Correct answer
- The office section shows a £10,000 debit balance owed by Peter to the firm.
- The client section shows a nil balance, as the firm records only cleared funds.
- The client section shows a £10,000 credit balance until the cheque is re-presented.
The receipt was recorded by crediting Peter's client section with £10,000, and the payment to the seller's solicitors by debiting it, leaving nil. When the cheque is dishonoured, the receipt is reversed: credit client cash and debit his client section, creating a £10,000 debit balance. That shows the firm has paid out other clients' money, in breach of rule 5.3. Rule 6.1 requires the firm to replace the £10,000 immediately from business account, after which the debt is shown on the office section. The debit balance cannot remain until the cheque is re-presented.
Law basis: SRA Accounts Rules 2019, rules 5.3, 6.1 and 8.1Question 7 · Abatements, bad debts and dishonoured chequesDraft, pending solicitor review
Jessop Solicitors billed Ms Grant £1,200 including VAT. She paid £600, and nothing more has been received for seven months. The firm writes off the balance and claims VAT bad debt relief. Which of the following best describes the entries?
- Debit her office section £600; credit bad debts £500 and HMRC £100.
- Credit her office section £600; debit profit costs £500 and HMRC £100.
- Credit her office section £600; debit bad debts account £600.
- Credit her office section £1,200; debit bad debts £1,000 and HMRC £200.
- Credit her office section £600; debit bad debts £500 and HMRC £100.Correct answer
Only the unpaid £600 is written off, so Ms Grant's ledger office section is credited £600, clearing the remaining debt. The £600 includes VAT of £100 (one-sixth of a VAT-inclusive sum at 20%). Because the debt is more than six months overdue and written off, the firm can claim bad debt relief under section 36 VATA 1994, so it debits HMRC with £100 and the bad debts account with the net £500. Writing off £1,200 ignores her part payment. Debiting profit costs is the abatement treatment, and debiting bad debts with £600 ignores the VAT relief.
Law basis: Value Added Tax Act 1994, s 36 ↗Question 8 · Abatements, bad debts and dishonoured chequesDraft, pending solicitor review
Kemble Solicitors pays Rafe's £3,000 cheque into client account on account of a future deposit. Before any money is paid out for him, the cheque is dishonoured. Which of the following best describes the position?
- The firm must write off £3,000 as a bad debt on Rafe's office section.
- Rafe's office section shows a £3,000 debit balance owed to the firm.
- The firm has breached the rules and must replace £3,000 from office money.
- Rafe's client section shows a £3,000 debit balance until he pays again.
- The receipt is reversed, leaving nil on his client section.Correct answer
On receipt, the firm debited client cash and credited Rafe's client section with £3,000. When the cheque is dishonoured, those entries are reversed: credit client cash and debit his client section, leaving a nil balance. Because nothing was paid out in reliance on the cheque, no other client's money was used and there is no breach of rule 5.3. A debit balance, and the need to replace money under rule 6.1, would arise only if the firm had made a payment for Rafe before the cheque bounced. No office money or bad debt is involved.
Law basis: SRA Accounts Rules 2019, rules 5.3 and 8.1Question 9 · Abatements, bad debts and dishonoured chequesDraft, pending solicitor review
Harker Solicitors bills Mr Doyle £3,000 plus VAT of £600. It later agrees to reduce the total by £360 including VAT. Which of the following best describes the entries for the reduction?
- Credit his office section £360; debit profit costs £288 and HMRC £72.
- Credit his office section £360; debit profit costs £300 and HMRC £60.Correct answer
- Credit his office section £300; debit profit costs £300 only.
- Debit his office section £360; credit profit costs £300 and HMRC £60.
- Credit his client section £360; debit profit costs £300 and HMRC £60.
An abatement reduces a delivered bill. The reduction of £360 is VAT-inclusive, so its VAT element is one-sixth, £60, and the net reduction in profit costs is £300. The entries are: credit Mr Doyle's ledger office section £360, reducing his debt, and debit profit costs £300 and HMRC £60, reducing the firm's income and output tax. Splitting the £360 as £288 and £72 wrongly applies 20% to the inclusive figure. The client section is not involved because the abatement concerns the bill, not client money held.
Law basis: SRA Accounts Rules 2019, rule 8.1; Value Added Tax Act 1994Question 10 · Abatements, bad debts and dishonoured chequesDraft, pending solicitor review
Last year Cooper Solicitors wrote off Mr Nash's £1,200 bill, including £200 VAT, and claimed VAT bad debt relief. Unexpectedly, Mr Nash now pays the full £1,200. Which of the following best describes the firm's VAT position?
- It must repay the VAT relief claimed, as the debt has been paid.Correct answer
- It must repay only half the relief, as the payment came late.
- It must refund the £1,200 to Mr Nash as the debt no longer exists.
- It may keep the VAT relief because the debt was properly written off.
- It need take no action as the relief claim is now closed.
VAT bad debt relief under section 36 of the Value Added Tax Act 1994 compensates a supplier for output tax accounted for on a supply for which it has not been paid. If the debtor later pays, the relief must be repaid to HMRC to the extent of the payment received, because the firm has now received the VAT it originally accounted for. As Mr Nash has paid in full, the firm must repay the £200 relief. Writing off a debt in the firm's accounts does not extinguish Mr Nash's liability, so the firm need not refund him.
Law basis: Value Added Tax Act 1994, s 36 ↗Question 11 · Abatements, bad debts and dishonoured chequesDraft, pending solicitor review
Abbott Solicitors has a £12 debit balance on Mrs Rye's office section for an unbilled search fee paid more than a year ago. Mrs Rye cannot now be found, and the firm decides to write off the £12, which carried no VAT. Which of the following best describes the entries?
- Credit her office section £12; debit profit costs £12.
- Credit her office section £10; debit bad debts £10 and HMRC £2.
- Debit her office section £12; credit bad debts £12.
- Credit her client section £12; debit client cash £12.
- Credit her office section £12; debit bad debts £12.Correct answer
Writing off a debt owed to the firm removes it from the client's ledger and treats it as an expense. Mrs Rye's office section is credited £12, clearing the debit balance, and the bad debts account is debited £12. No VAT relief arises because the search fee carried no VAT. Debiting profit costs would treat the item as an abatement of the firm's fees, but this was a disbursement, not profit costs. Client-side entries are wrong because the debt relates to office money paid by the firm, not money held for her.
Law basis: SRA Accounts Rules 2019, rule 8.1; double-entry bookkeeping principlesQuestion 12 · Abatements, bad debts and dishonoured chequesDraft, pending solicitor review
Mr Ellis's cheque for £1,440 in payment of a delivered bill is dishonoured. The firm had paid it into business account. Mr Ellis promptly replaces it with a bank transfer for £1,440. Which of the following best describes his office section after both events?
- A £2,880 debit balance, as both payments must be reversed.
- A nil balance, after the dishonour and the replacement.Correct answer
- A £1,440 debit balance, as the original cheque was dishonoured.
- A £1,440 credit balance, as the firm received two payments.
- A nil balance, because a dishonoured cheque is never recorded.
After the original cheque was received, Mr Ellis's office section was cleared to nil. When it is dishonoured, the receipt is reversed: credit office cash and debit his office section £1,440, reinstating the debt. When his replacement bank transfer arrives, office cash is debited and his office section credited £1,440, clearing the debt again and leaving a nil balance. The firm has received the money only once, so there is no credit balance. The dishonour must be recorded, because rule 8.1 requires accurate and complete records.
Law basis: SRA Accounts Rules 2019, rule 8.1; double-entry bookkeeping principlesMore Solicitors Accounts topics
Back to all Solicitors Accounts questions, or sit a timed mock.