Law covered in these questions
- SRA Accounts Rules 2019, rule 5.3
- SRA Accounts Rules 2019, rules 5.1(b), 5.2 and 8.1
- SRA Accounts Rules 2019, rules 5.3 and 6.1
- SRA Accounts Rules 2019, rule 5.2
- SRA Accounts Rules 2019, rule 5.1
- SRA Accounts Rules 2019, rules 2.4 and 5.1
- SRA Code of Conduct for Solicitors, para 1.3
- SRA Accounts Rules 2019, rules 5.1(b) and 5.2
- SRA Accounts Rules 2019, rule 5.1(b)
- Mental Capacity Act 2005, s 9
- SRA Accounts Rules 2019, rules 2.5 and 5.1(b)
- Insolvency Act 1986, Sch B1, para 64
- SRA Accounts Rules 2019, rules 2.1(c), 5.1 and 6.1
- SRA Accounts Rules 2019, rules 3.3 and 5.1(b)
All 18 questions with answers
Try them above first, then read the worked answers below.
Question 1 · Withdrawals from client accountDraft, pending solicitor review
Marta is acting for Ben in a boundary dispute. Ben's client ledger shows £400 held in client account. A surveyor's invoice for £650 arrives, and Marta asks the cashier to pay it in full from client account so the surveyor is paid quickly. Which of the following best describes the proposed payment?
- It would breach the rules because it exceeds the money held for Ben.Correct answer
- It would breach the rules only if the shortfall is not repaid within five weeks.
- It is permitted because the general client account holds enough money overall.
- It is permitted because the payment is for the purpose of Ben's matter.
- It is permitted if Ben agrees in writing to repay the shortfall promptly.
Rule 5.3 provides that you may withdraw client money only where sufficient funds are held on behalf of that specific client or third party to make the payment. Paying £650 when only £400 is held for Ben would use £250 belonging to other clients and create a debit balance on Ben's client ledger. It does not matter that the general client account has enough money overall or that the payment serves Ben's matter. The firm should pay £400 from client account and the balance from office account, or pay the whole amount from office account.
Law basis: SRA Accounts Rules 2019, rule 5.3Question 2 · Withdrawals from client accountDraft, pending solicitor review
Nikos instructs Hart Solicitors to transfer £10,000 from his ledger to the ledger of his daughter, Eleni, also a firm client, to help with her house purchase. Nikos confirms the instruction in a signed letter. Which of the following best describes the proposed inter-client transfer?
- It is prohibited because client money can only be returned to the person who paid it in.
- It is prohibited because it amounts to providing a banking facility.
- It is permitted on Nikos's instructions and must be properly recorded on both ledgers.Correct answer
- It is permitted only if the money is first paid out and then paid back in.
- It is permitted only with the SRA's prior written authorisation.
Rule 5.1(b) allows withdrawal or transfer of client money following receipt of instructions from the client. A transfer between ledgers on Nikos's signed instructions, in connection with Eleni's purchase, is therefore permitted; it must be authorised and supervised (rule 5.2) and recorded as a debit on Nikos's client ledger and a credit on Eleni's (rule 8.1). No physical movement of money is needed. This is not a banking facility, because it is linked to a regulated service, namely Eleni's conveyancing. SRA authorisation is needed only where neither the purpose nor client instructions justify a withdrawal.
Law basis: SRA Accounts Rules 2019, rules 5.1(b), 5.2 and 8.1Question 3 · Withdrawals from client accountDraft, pending solicitor review
Kimberley's client cheque for £30,000 is paid into client account on Monday. On Tuesday, before it has cleared, her solicitor pays £30,000 to the seller's solicitors. On Thursday the cheque is dishonoured. Which of the following best describes the firm's position?
- It has breached the rules and must immediately replace the £30,000.Correct answer
- It has breached the rules and must report to the SRA before replacing the money.
- It has not breached the rules provided Kimberley repays the money within 14 days.
- It has breached the rules only if it knew the cheque was likely to be dishonoured.
- It has not breached the rules because it acted on the client's instructions.
Rule 5.3 permits withdrawals only where sufficient funds are held for that client. A firm may pay out against an uncleared cheque, but it does so at its own risk: once the cheque is dishonoured, the payment has been made using other clients' money, and the rule has been breached. Under rule 6.1 the firm must correct the breach promptly and immediately replace the £30,000 from its own money. Kimberley's instructions and the firm's lack of knowledge do not prevent a breach. Any SRA report does not delay the duty to replace the shortfall.
Law basis: SRA Accounts Rules 2019, rules 5.3 and 6.1Question 4 · Withdrawals from client accountDraft, pending solicitor review
At Yates Solicitors, a newly arrived paralegal with no authority on the firm's systems approves a £12,000 payment from client account because the authorising partner was on holiday. The payment was correct in amount and purpose. Which of the following best describes the firm's position?
- It has breached the rules only because the payment exceeded £10,000.
- It has complied because the partner was away and the payment was urgent.
- It has complied because the payment was made for the correct purpose and amount.
- It has complied provided the partner ratifies the payment on returning.
- It may have breached the rule that withdrawals be authorised and supervised.Correct answer
Rule 5.2 requires that you appropriately authorise and supervise all withdrawals from client account. A payment approved by an unauthorised paralegal, outside the firm's systems of control, is unlikely to meet this requirement, even if the amount and purpose were correct. Rule 5.1 concerns why money may be withdrawn, but rule 5.2 is a separate obligation about how withdrawals are controlled. The rules set no monetary threshold of £10,000, and later ratification cannot retrospectively supply the authorisation and supervision that rule 5.2 requires at the time of the payment.
Law basis: SRA Accounts Rules 2019, rule 5.2Question 5 · Withdrawals from client accountDraft, pending solicitor review
Hilary is the solicitor for Mr Ross, who has £18,000 in client account for a planned purchase. Mr Ross dies suddenly. His son, Callum, who is not named as an executor, asks Hilary to pay him the £18,000 to cover the funeral. Which of the following best describes Hilary's position?
- She should pay the money to charity under the residual balance rules.
- She should not pay Callum because he has no authority over the money.Correct answer
- She may pay Callum because the money is needed for the funeral expenses.
- She may pay Callum if he signs an indemnity in favour of the firm.
- She may pay Callum once he provides a copy of the death certificate.
Rule 5.1 permits withdrawal of client money for the purpose for which it is held, on the instructions of the client or third party for whom it is held, or with SRA authorisation. On Mr Ross's death his instructions lapse and the money forms part of his estate, controlled by his personal representatives. Callum, not being an executor, cannot give valid instructions. Hilary should wait for instructions from the personal representatives, although she might pay the funeral director directly if properly authorised. An indemnity or death certificate does not give Callum authority, and the charity route is irrelevant.
Law basis: SRA Accounts Rules 2019, rule 5.1Question 6 · Withdrawals from client accountDraft, pending solicitor review
Abbott Solicitors holds £10,000 for its client, Petra, which the firm has undertaken to the other side's solicitors to use to discharge a charge on completion. Before completion, Petra instructs the firm to pay £10,000 to her instead. Which of the following best describes the firm's position?
- It must pay Petra because she is the client for whom the money is held.
- It must pay Petra because client money must be available on demand.
- It should not release the money, as that would breach its undertaking.Correct answer
- It may pay Petra provided it tells the other side's solicitors first.
- It may pay Petra if she gives her instructions in writing and signs them.
Although the money is client money held for Petra, the firm has given an undertaking to use it to discharge the charge. Releasing it to Petra would breach that undertaking, which the firm must honour under the SRA Code of Conduct (paragraph 1.3), and would not be a withdrawal for the purpose for which the money is held under rule 5.1(a). The availability-on-demand principle in rule 2.4 does not override the firm's existing commitment regarding the money. Telling the other side does not release the undertaking unless they agree to that release.
Law basis: SRA Accounts Rules 2019, rules 2.4 and 5.1; SRA Code of Conduct for Solicitors, para 1.3Question 7 · Withdrawals from client accountDraft, pending solicitor review
Harriet, a client buying a flat, telephones her solicitor and asks him to pay her estate agent's holding deposit of £500 from the money she has in client account. He verifies her identity on the call, records the instruction on file and makes the payment. Which of the following best describes the withdrawal?
- It breaches the rules unless the payment is authorised by the SRA in advance.
- It complies, as the rules do not require written instructions.Correct answer
- It breaches the rules because instructions to withdraw must always be in writing.
- It breaches the rules because payments must go only to the client personally.
- It complies only if Harriet confirms the instruction in writing within 14 days.
Rule 5.1(b) permits withdrawal of client money following receipt of instructions from the client. The rule does not require those instructions to be written. Harriet's telephone instruction, verified and recorded, is sufficient, and the payment is for her purchase, so it is connected with the regulated service. Good practice, and protection against fraud, means firms should verify and record such instructions, and many firms' policies require written confirmation, but that is not a requirement of the rule itself. SRA authorisation is needed only where neither purpose nor instructions justify the withdrawal.
Law basis: SRA Accounts Rules 2019, rules 5.1(b) and 5.2Question 8 · Withdrawals from client accountDraft, pending solicitor review
Ali and Bea, a couple, jointly instructed Tyler Solicitors on the sale of their jointly owned house. The net proceeds of £150,000 are in client account. Bea emails asking for the whole sum to be paid into her sole bank account. Ali has not been consulted. Which of the following best describes the firm's position?
- It may pay Bea because she is one of the clients for whom it is held.
- It may pay Bea provided she agrees to indemnify the firm against Ali.
- It should obtain instructions from both Ali and Bea before paying.Correct answer
- It must split the proceeds equally and pay half to each of them.
- It may pay Bea if she provides proof that the account is in her name.
The proceeds are client money held for Ali and Bea jointly. Rule 5.1(b) allows withdrawal following instructions from the client, and where money is held for joint clients the firm should obtain instructions from both before releasing it to one of them. Paying the whole sum to Bea on her sole instruction could prejudice Ali and expose the firm to a claim. The firm should not decide the split itself, as their respective entitlements may differ from equal shares. An indemnity from Bea does not supply Ali's missing instructions.
Law basis: SRA Accounts Rules 2019, rule 5.1(b)Question 9 · Withdrawals from client accountDraft, pending solicitor review
Mrs Lowe has £22,000 in client account at Ridley Solicitors for her house sale. She has since lost capacity. Her son, Peter, is her attorney under a registered property and financial affairs lasting power of attorney and instructs the firm to pay the money into her bank account. Which of the following best describes the firm's position?
- It must refuse because only Mrs Lowe herself can give instructions.
- It may act on Peter's instructions only if he is also a client of the firm.
- It must obtain a Court of Protection order before paying out the money.
- It may act on Peter's instructions as her attorney after checking the LPA.Correct answer
- It must pay the money to Peter personally as he now controls her affairs.
Rule 5.1(b) permits withdrawal on instructions from the client. Where a client lacks capacity and has a registered property and financial affairs lasting power of attorney, her attorney can give instructions on her behalf. After checking the LPA and Peter's identity, the firm may pay the money into Mrs Lowe's own account. A Court of Protection order is unnecessary where a valid LPA is in place. Paying the money to Peter personally would be wrong, because the money belongs to Mrs Lowe and the attorney must act in her best interests.
Law basis: SRA Accounts Rules 2019, rule 5.1(b); Mental Capacity Act 2005, s 9Question 10 · Withdrawals from client accountDraft, pending solicitor review
Pryor Solicitors acts for the executors of Joan's estate. One beneficiary, Clive, demands that the firm pay his £20,000 legacy immediately from the estate money held in client account. The executors have not yet authorised any distributions. Which of the following best describes the firm's position?
- It may pay Clive if he signs a receipt for the legacy.
- It should not pay Clive without the executors' instructions.Correct answer
- It must pay Clive because legacies are payable on demand.
- It may pay Clive if the estate is plainly solvent overall.
- It must pay Clive because the money is in the firm's client account.
The firm's clients are the executors, and the estate money is held for them. Rule 5.1 permits withdrawal for the purpose for which money is held or on the instructions of the client or third party for whom it is held. Clive is a beneficiary, not the firm's client, and cannot direct payment. The firm must obtain the executors' instructions before paying any legacy. Legacies are not payable on demand; executors are generally not obliged to distribute before the end of the executor's year, and the firm must not pre-empt their decision, whatever the estate's apparent solvency.
Law basis: SRA Accounts Rules 2019, rule 5.1Question 11 · Withdrawals from client accountDraft, pending solicitor review
Sandford Solicitors acts for Ivan and his lender on a purchase. The lender's £150,000 advance is in client account, but the sale falls through. The lender instructs the firm to return the advance at once. Ivan asks the firm to keep it in case another property is found. Which of the following best describes the firm's position?
- It must pay the money to Ivan because it is recorded on his ledger.
- It must follow the lender's instruction and return the advance.Correct answer
- It may keep the money for up to 28 days in case a new property is found.
- It must keep the money because Ivan is the firm's main client.
- It may keep the money only if the lender charges Ivan interest.
The mortgage advance is client money held for the lender until completion. Rule 5.1(b) permits withdrawal on the instructions of the client or third party for whom the money is held, and rule 2.5 requires money to be returned promptly once there is no proper reason to hold it. With the purchase abandoned, the lender is entitled to its money and has instructed its return. Ivan cannot direct the use of the lender's funds. Recording the advance on his ledger does not make it his money, and there is no 28-day holding period.
Law basis: SRA Accounts Rules 2019, rules 2.5 and 5.1(b)Question 12 · Withdrawals from client accountDraft, pending solicitor review
Lytton Solicitors holds £40,000 for its client, Sparrow Ltd. Administrators have now been appointed over the company. One of its directors instructs the firm to pay the £40,000 to a supplier. Which of the following best describes the firm's position?
- It must act on the director's instructions as an officer.
- It may act if the supplier is a genuine creditor of the company.
- It may act if the board approves the payment by resolution.
- It must pay the money to the company's shareholders.
- It should act only on the administrators' instructions.Correct answer
Rule 5.1(b) permits withdrawal following instructions from the client. Once administrators are appointed, the management powers of the company's directors cease to be exercisable without the administrators' consent, and the administrators control the company's affairs, business and property. Instructions about the company's money must therefore come from the administrators. Acting on the director's instructions, or a board resolution, could result in an improper withdrawal and a breach of insolvency law. The supplier's status as a genuine creditor does not give the director authority, and shareholders are not entitled to the money.
Law basis: SRA Accounts Rules 2019, rule 5.1(b); Insolvency Act 1986, Sch B1, para 64Question 13 · Withdrawals from client accountDraft, pending solicitor review
Sita, a partner at Benson Solicitors, is one of two trustees of a family trust; the other is the settlor's brother, Malcolm. Trust money is held in the firm's client account. Sita authorises a £15,000 distribution to a beneficiary without consulting Malcolm. Which of the following best describes the payment?
- It is proper because a professional trustee may act without lay trustees.
- It is proper provided the firm records the payment on the trust ledger.
- It is proper because the beneficiary is entitled under the trust.
- It is likely improper because trustees must generally act unanimously.Correct answer
- It is proper because Sita is a trustee and the money is in her firm's account.
Trust money held by a solicitor-trustee is client money under rule 2.1(c), and rule 5.1 requires withdrawals to be for the purpose for which the money is held or on proper instructions. Under general trust law, private trustees must act unanimously unless the trust instrument provides otherwise. Sita alone cannot authorise a distribution, so the payment is likely an improper withdrawal that must be corrected under rule 6.1. Being a professional trustee does not allow her to override her co-trustee, and recording the payment does not make it authorised.
Law basis: SRA Accounts Rules 2019, rules 2.1(c), 5.1 and 6.1Question 14 · Withdrawals from client accountDraft, pending solicitor review
In a financial remedy order, Petra is required to pay £8,000 from the proceeds of the family home to clear joint credit card debts. Her solicitors hold the proceeds in client account. She instructs them in writing to pay the card provider. Which of the following best describes the payment?
- It is prohibited because the firm would be acting as Petra's bank.
- It is permitted only if the card provider is also a client of the firm.
- It is permitted only with the SRA's prior written authorisation.
- It is prohibited because the payee is not a party to the proceedings.
- It is permitted, as it is made on her instructions in her matter.Correct answer
Rule 5.1(b) permits a withdrawal following receipt of instructions from the client. The payment implements a court order in the financial remedy proceedings in which the firm acts, so it relates to the firm's regulated services and is not a banking facility under rule 3.3. Petra's written instructions authorise the payment. It does not matter that the card provider is not a party or a client. SRA authorisation under rule 5.1(c) is only needed where neither the purpose for which money is held nor instructions justify a withdrawal.
Law basis: SRA Accounts Rules 2019, rules 3.3 and 5.1(b)Question 15 · Withdrawals from client accountDraft, pending solicitor review
Kerr Solicitors is told by Omar's bank that a £60,000 transfer for his purchase has been sent and will arrive later that day. Before it is credited to client account, the cashier sends £60,000 to the seller's solicitors to avoid delaying completion. Omar holds nothing else with the firm. Which of the following best describes the payment?
- It complies because Omar's bank had confirmed the transfer was sent.
- It breaches the rules because insufficient funds were held for Omar.Correct answer
- It complies because the money arrived in client account the same day.
- It breaches the rules only if the transfer later failed to arrive.
- It complies because completion would otherwise have been delayed.
Rule 5.3 permits a withdrawal only where sufficient funds are held on behalf of that client. Until Omar's transfer is credited to client account, the firm holds nothing for him, so paying £60,000 uses other clients' money, even if only for a few hours. Confirmation that the money has been sent is not receipt, and the later arrival of the funds does not prevent a breach having occurred, though it may correct it. If the firm wished to avoid delay, it could have funded the payment from business account. Commercial pressure is not a defence.
Law basis: SRA Accounts Rules 2019, rules 5.3 and 6.1Question 16 · Withdrawals from client accountDraft, pending solicitor review
Juno instructs Hardy Solicitors to transfer her file, and the £4,000 it holds for her, to her new solicitors. Hardy delivered a bill for £500 last month, which Juno has not paid and does not dispute. Which of the following best describes what Hardy may do with the £4,000?
- Send the whole £4,000 to Juno herself rather than the new solicitors.
- Send the whole £4,000 and pursue Juno separately for the £500.
- Keep the whole £4,000 until Juno pays the bill from other funds.
- Transfer £500 for its costs and send £3,500 to the new solicitors.Correct answer
- Transfer £500 only if Juno signs a further written authority.
Rule 4.3 permits the firm to use client money to pay its costs once it has given a bill or written notification, provided the transfer is for the specific sum identified and covered by money held. Hardy delivered a bill for £500, so it may transfer that sum. The balance of £3,500 should be sent to the new solicitors on Juno's instructions under rule 5.1(b). Retaining the whole £4,000 would exceed what the firm is owed. Further written authority for the £500 is not required, and paying Juno directly would ignore her instructions.
Law basis: SRA Accounts Rules 2019, rules 4.3 and 5.1(b)Question 17 · Withdrawals from client accountDraft, pending solicitor review
Dawson Solicitors holds £75,000 for a client following a cancelled transaction. The client instructs it to send the money to a company in another country with which he has no apparent connection. The fee earner suspects the funds may be the proceeds of crime. Which of the following best describes the firm's position?
- It must pay at once, as client money must be paid out on instructions.
- It may pay if the client confirms in writing that the money is legitimate.
- It should not pay until it has considered a disclosure and consent.Correct answer
- It must pay the money to charity as a balance with no legitimate owner.
- It may pay provided it tells the client of its suspicions beforehand.
Although rule 5.1(b) permits withdrawals on client instructions, the firm must also comply with the money laundering legislation. If it suspects the funds are criminal property, making the payment could amount to entering into an arrangement under section 328 of the Proceeds of Crime Act 2002. It should make an internal report to its MLRO, who may make an authorised disclosure to the National Crime Agency and seek consent before any payment. Telling the client of the suspicion risks tipping off. The client's written assurance does not remove the risk, and the charity route is irrelevant.
Law basis: Proceeds of Crime Act 2002, s 328; SRA Accounts Rules 2019, rules 3.3 and 5.1 ↗Question 18 · Withdrawals from client accountDraft, pending solicitor review
Peel Solicitors holds £14,000 for Mr Grange, whose house sale has just completed. Mr Grange is then made bankrupt, and a trustee in bankruptcy is appointed. Mr Grange instructs the firm to pay the £14,000 to his daughter. Which of the following best describes the firm's position?
- It should not follow them, as his estate vests in the trustee.Correct answer
- It may follow his instructions if his daughter signs an indemnity.
- It must pay the money to the Official Receiver's general fund.
- It may follow his instructions if the sale completed before bankruptcy.
- It must follow his instructions, as he is the client for whom it is held.
Under section 306 of the Insolvency Act 1986, a bankrupt's estate vests in the trustee in bankruptcy on the trustee's appointment. The £14,000 held for Mr Grange forms part of his estate, so he no longer has authority to direct its use. Rule 5.1 permits withdrawals on the instructions of the person for whom money is held, and that is now the trustee. Paying the daughter could expose the firm to liability. An indemnity from her does not cure the lack of authority, and the timing of completion does not keep the money out of the estate.
Law basis: Insolvency Act 1986, s 306; SRA Accounts Rules 2019, rule 5.1 ↗More Solicitors Accounts topics
Back to all Solicitors Accounts questions, or sit a timed mock.