Law covered in these questions
- Legal Services Act 2007 Part 6
- Legal Ombudsman scheme rules
- Legal Services Act 2007, ss1 and 28
- Legal Services Act 2007, s1(3)
- SRA Principles 4 and 5
- SRA Code of Conduct for Solicitors, para 1.4
- Legal Services Act 2007, s2 and Sch 4
- Legal Services Act 2007, s30
- Legal Services Act 2007, ss12, 13 and 18
- Legal Services Act 2007, s114 and Part 6
- Legal Services Act 2007, s72 and Part 5
- Legal Services Act 2007, Sch 13
- Legal Services Act 2007, Part 6
- Legal Services Act 2007, s1(3)(d)
All 12 questions with answers
Try them above first, then read the worked answers below.
Question 1 · Regulatory framework and objectivesDraft, pending solicitor review
A client complains that a solicitor failed to give proper service. The client wants an independent body to investigate the complaint about the service, not the conduct. Which body deals with service complaints about regulated legal providers, once the firm's own complaints procedure has been used?
- The Solicitors Regulation Authority, which handles all service complaints.
- The Law Society, which can award compensation for poor service.
- The Legal Ombudsman, which is the independent body for complaints about service.Correct answer
- The High Court, through a direct complaint to the Lord Chief Justice.
- The Solicitors Disciplinary Tribunal, which investigates service complaints first.
Question 2 · Regulatory framework and objectivesDraft, pending solicitor review
A trade association for high street firms writes to the SRA. It argues that when the SRA reviews its rules, its first priority should be protecting the income of existing solicitors from cheaper unregulated competitors. Which of the following best describes how the SRA must approach this argument?
- The SRA may adopt the argument, because the regulatory objectives apply only to the Legal Services Board and not to front-line regulators.
- The SRA must follow the argument, because the Law Society as approved regulator can direct the SRA on matters of professional income.
- The SRA must give priority to the argument, because encouraging a strong legal profession is the primary regulatory objective above all others.
- It must act compatibly with the regulatory objectives, which include promoting competition and consumer interests.Correct answer
- The SRA may only consider the argument if the Legal Services Board first directs it to treat the economic interests of solicitors as an objective.
Section 1 of the Legal Services Act 2007 sets out eight regulatory objectives, including protecting and promoting the interests of consumers, promoting competition in the provision of legal services and improving access to justice. Under s28 an approved regulator, and so the SRA acting for the Law Society, must so far as reasonably practicable act compatibly with those objectives. Protecting the income of existing practitioners is not an objective. The objective of encouraging an independent, strong, diverse and effective profession is real, but it does not rank above the others and cannot justify shielding solicitors from competition at consumers' expense.
Law basis: Legal Services Act 2007, ss1 and 28 ↗Question 3 · Regulatory framework and objectivesDraft, pending solicitor review
Imran is an in-house solicitor employed by a property developer. The managing director tells him to send a letter to a tenant stating that the company has already obtained a possession order, which is untrue, because 'you work for us, not the regulator'. Which of the following best describes Imran's position?
- He must refuse only if the tenant is a consumer, because the duty not to mislead is owed solely to individuals and not to businesses.
- He is only bound by the professional principles when acting for members of the public, so his position is governed by his employment contract.
- He may send the letter, because in-house solicitors owe their professional duties primarily to their employer rather than to third parties.
- As an authorised person he remains bound by the professional principles, including acting with independence and integrity, whoever employs him.Correct answer
- He may send the letter if the managing director confirms the instruction in writing, which transfers responsibility for its accuracy to the company.
Section 1(3) of the Legal Services Act 2007 lists the professional principles, which include that authorised persons should act with independence and integrity and maintain proper standards of work. The SRA Principles and the Code of Conduct for Solicitors apply to solicitors wherever they work, including in-house. Sending a letter he knows to be untrue would breach the duties of honesty and integrity and the duty not to mislead (Code para 1.4). Employment does not dilute these duties, and a written instruction from the employer cannot transfer his personal regulatory responsibility. The duty not to mislead is owed to anyone, not just consumers.
Law basis: Legal Services Act 2007, s1(3); SRA Principles 4 and 5; SRA Code of Conduct for Solicitors, para 1.4 ↗Question 4 · Regulatory framework and objectivesDraft, pending solicitor review
The SRA wishes to amend its rules so that firms must publish more information about their prices. A solicitor asks whether the SRA can simply bring the new rule into force once its board has approved it. Which of the following best describes the position?
- The change needs the approval of Parliament by affirmative resolution, because all professional rules are statutory instruments.
- The change needs the approval of the Law Society Council, because the Law Society is the representative body of solicitors.
- The change needs the approval of the Lord Chancellor alone, because the Legal Services Board has no role in approving rule changes.
- The SRA board's approval is sufficient, because the SRA is an independent statutory body with unlimited power to make its own rules.
- Changes to the SRA's regulatory arrangements generally need the approval of the Legal Services Board before they take effect.Correct answer
The Legal Services Board is the oversight regulator created by the Legal Services Act 2007. Approved regulators, including the Law Society which delegates its regulatory functions to the SRA, must apply to the LSB for approval of alterations to their regulatory arrangements under Schedule 4 to the Act, subject to limited exemptions. The SRA cannot bring material rule changes into force on its own board's say-so. The Law Society's representative arm must not control regulatory decisions, so its Council's approval is not the test. Rules of approved regulators are not statutory instruments, and the Lord Chancellor does not approve routine rule changes.
Law basis: Legal Services Act 2007, s2 and Sch 4 ↗Question 5 · Regulatory framework and objectivesDraft, pending solicitor review
A solicitor complains that the Law Society publicly campaigned against a proposed change and that this must mean the SRA will reject the change. Which of the following best describes the relationship between the Law Society and the SRA?
- The SRA is a department of the Ministry of Justice, so the Law Society's campaign has no legal connection with the SRA at all.
- The Law Society must approve SRA decisions on rule changes, but it may not campaign publicly on matters the SRA is considering.
- The Law Society and SRA are both approved regulators with equal powers, so either may make the final decision on any rule change.
- The SRA is a committee of the Law Society Council, so the Council's campaign position binds the SRA when it makes regulatory decisions.
- The Law Society is the approved regulator but its regulatory functions are exercised independently by the SRA.Correct answer
The Law Society is the approved regulator for solicitors under Schedule 4 to the Legal Services Act 2007. Section 30 requires the LSB to make rules ensuring that approved regulators separate their regulatory functions from their representative functions, and that regulatory decisions are not prejudiced by representative interests. The Law Society therefore delegates regulation to the SRA, which acts independently. The Law Society may lobby and campaign for its members as their representative body, but its campaign cannot bind or control the SRA. The SRA is not a government department, and there is only one approved regulator for solicitors.
Law basis: Legal Services Act 2007, s30 ↗Question 6 · Regulatory framework and objectivesDraft, pending solicitor review
Molly is a licensed conveyancer working at a firm authorised by the Council for Licensed Conveyancers. A client asks whether Molly can represent her at a contested county court hearing about a boundary dispute arising from the purchase. Which of the following best describes the position?
- Molly may appear, because rights of audience are not a reserved legal activity when the dispute arises from a conveyancing transaction.
- Molly may appear only if a solicitor at another firm supervises her, because supervision allows any lawyer to exercise rights of audience.
- Molly may appear, because every person authorised by any approved regulator is entitled to carry on all six reserved legal activities.
- Molly may appear, because the Council for Licensed Conveyancers is the approved regulator for all property-related litigation.
- Her CLC authorisation covers reserved instrument activities but gives her no right of audience at the hearing.Correct answer
Under the Legal Services Act 2007 a person is entitled to carry on a reserved legal activity only if authorised to carry on that particular activity by a relevant approved regulator, or exempt (s13 and s18). Authorisation is activity-specific. Licensed conveyancers are authorised by the CLC for reserved instrument activities (and, with further authorisation, probate activities), but not for general rights of audience in contested civil hearings. A boundary dispute hearing involves the exercise of a right of audience, which is reserved regardless of the subject matter. Supervision by an authorised person does not of itself confer rights of audience on someone who is not entitled.
Law basis: Legal Services Act 2007, ss12, 13 and 18 ↗Question 7 · Regulatory framework and objectivesDraft, pending solicitor review
Gareth was unhappy with the service he received from his solicitor's firm. He has been told that complaints about the Legal Ombudsman's service standards and scheme rules are ultimately the responsibility of a particular body. Which body is responsible for administering the ombudsman scheme?
- The Legal Services Consumer Panel, which is the body that decides complaints referred to the Legal Ombudsman scheme.
- The Law Society, which administers the Legal Ombudsman as part of its representative role for the solicitors' profession.
- The Office for Legal Complaints, established under the Legal Services Act 2007 to administer the Legal Ombudsman scheme.Correct answer
- The Solicitors Regulation Authority, which runs the Legal Ombudsman as part of its role in investigating misconduct by solicitors.
- The Solicitors Disciplinary Tribunal, which hears appeals from Legal Ombudsman decisions about solicitors' service.
Part 6 of the Legal Services Act 2007 created the Office for Legal Complaints (s114), a body independent of the approved regulators, which administers the ombudsman scheme operating as the Legal Ombudsman. The OLC makes the scheme rules and appoints the Chief Ombudsman. The SRA deals with professional misconduct, not service complaints, and does not run the Legal Ombudsman. The SDT hears disciplinary prosecutions and is not an appeal route from ombudsman decisions. The Law Society's representative role is separate. The Legal Services Consumer Panel advises the LSB on consumer interests but does not decide complaints.
Law basis: Legal Services Act 2007, s114 and Part 6 ↗Question 8 · Regulatory framework and objectivesDraft, pending solicitor review
Two solicitors, Asha and Daniel, run a partnership. They want to admit Kevin, an accountant with no legal qualification, as a partner who will own 30% of the firm and help manage it. Which of the following best describes the regulatory consequence?
- The firm would become a licensable body and must be licensed as an alternative business structure before Kevin becomes a partner.Correct answer
- The firm need only notify the SRA within 28 days after Kevin joins, because non-lawyer partners are permitted in recognised bodies.
- The firm may admit Kevin without any change, provided he does not personally carry out any reserved legal activities for clients.
- The firm cannot admit Kevin, because non-lawyers may hold management roles in law firms but are prohibited from owning any share.
- The firm may admit Kevin only if he becomes a registered foreign lawyer, because non-lawyers are prohibited from owning law firms.
Under Part 5 of the Legal Services Act 2007, a body is a licensable body if a non-authorised person is a manager of it or has an interest in it (s72). Kevin, as a non-lawyer partner with a 30% share, would be both. A firm that carries on reserved legal activities with non-lawyer managers or owners must be licensed by a licensing authority, such as the SRA, as an alternative business structure. It cannot remain a recognised body, which is limited to bodies whose managers and owners are lawyers. Non-lawyer ownership is lawful through the ABS regime, so an outright prohibition is wrong, and mere notification after the event is not enough.
Law basis: Legal Services Act 2007, s72 and Part 5 ↗Question 9 · Regulatory framework and objectivesDraft, pending solicitor review
Lumen Ltd, a licensed alternative business structure, is approached by an investor, Freya, who wishes to buy 15% of its shares. She has no legal qualifications. Which of the following best describes what must happen?
- Lumen Ltd need only update its register of members, because share transfers are a matter of company law, not legal regulation.
- Freya may buy the shares only if she first qualifies as a lawyer, because ABS shareholders must be authorised persons.
- No approval is needed because Freya's holding is below 25%, which is the threshold at which beneficial ownership is assessed.
- Freya may buy the shares without approval, provided she takes no part in the day-to-day management of the legal work.
- Freya's acquisition of a material interest must first be approved by the licensing authority.Correct answer
Schedule 13 to the Legal Services Act 2007 regulates ownership of licensed bodies. A person holding a material interest, which broadly means 10% or more of the shares or voting rights in the licensed body or its parent, must be approved by the licensing authority. The authority considers whether the person's holding would compromise the regulatory objectives or the duties of the body, and whether the person is fit and proper. Freya's 15% stake exceeds the 10% threshold. The 25% figure is the beneficial ownership threshold under the Money Laundering Regulations, not the ABS ownership test. Non-lawyer investors are permitted, so qualification as a lawyer is not required.
Law basis: Legal Services Act 2007, Sch 13 ↗Question 10 · Regulatory framework and objectivesDraft, pending solicitor review
Siobhan used an unregulated online will-writing company, which is not authorised by any approved regulator, to prepare her will. The will contains a serious error. She asks whether she can complain to the Legal Ombudsman. Which of the following best describes the position?
- The SRA must deal with the complaint, because the SRA regulates all providers of legal services in England and Wales.
- The Legal Ombudsman can deal with the complaint once the company has had eight weeks to resolve it, whether or not it is regulated.
- The Legal Ombudsman cannot deal with it, because its jurisdiction covers complaints about authorised persons.Correct answer
- The Legal Ombudsman can deal with the complaint only if the error caused a financial loss of more than £50,000.
- The Legal Ombudsman can deal with the complaint, because will writing is a reserved legal activity and all providers fall within its jurisdiction.
The Legal Ombudsman scheme under Part 6 of the Legal Services Act 2007 deals with complaints about acts or omissions of authorised persons, such as solicitors, barristers and licensed conveyancers, and their firms. Will writing is not a reserved legal activity, so it may lawfully be offered by unregulated providers, who are outside the ombudsman's jurisdiction. Siobhan's remedies lie in contract or negligence, and possibly consumer law, through the courts or any voluntary redress scheme. The SRA regulates only those it authorises. The £50,000 figure is the limit on ombudsman awards, not a jurisdictional trigger.
Law basis: Legal Services Act 2007, Part 6Question 11 · Regulatory framework and objectivesDraft, pending solicitor review
Rafael is a solicitor-advocate acting for a defendant at trial. He discovers a recent Court of Appeal decision directly against his client's case, which his opponent has not cited. His client tells him to say nothing about it. Which of the following best describes Rafael's duty?
- He may stay silent, because it is the responsibility of the opposing advocate alone to identify authorities that help their side.
- He need only mention the decision if the judge asks him directly whether there are any adverse authorities on the point.
- He must draw the decision to the court's attention, despite the client's instruction.Correct answer
- He must withdraw from the case immediately, because he cannot continue once his client has given an improper instruction.
- He must say nothing, because his duty to act in the best interests of his client takes precedence over his duties to the court.
One of the professional principles in s1(3) of the Legal Services Act 2007 is that authorised persons who exercise rights of audience or conduct litigation should comply with their duty to the court to act with independence in the interests of justice. Paragraph 2.7 of the SRA Code of Conduct for Solicitors requires a solicitor to draw the court's attention to relevant cases and statutory provisions, including adverse ones. Where principles conflict, those safeguarding the wider public interest, such as the proper administration of justice, take precedence over the client's interests. Rafael need not withdraw, because he can comply with his duty by citing the case.
Law basis: Legal Services Act 2007, s1(3)(d); SRA Code of Conduct for Solicitors, para 2.7 ↗Question 12 · Regulatory framework and objectivesDraft, pending solicitor review
Nadia runs an unregulated advice business offering advice on visa applications for a fee. She is not a solicitor and is not registered with any body. A client asks whether her business is lawful. Which of the following best describes the position?
- Her business is lawful, provided she does not appear before the First-tier Tribunal, which is the only regulated part of immigration work.
- Her business is lawful, provided she charges a fixed fee, because only hourly-rate immigration advice requires registration.
- She risks an offence, because immigration advice in business requires qualification under a statutory scheme.Correct answer
- Her business is lawful, provided she tells each client in writing that she is not a solicitor before giving any advice.
- Her business is lawful, because immigration advice is not a reserved legal activity and is therefore wholly unregulated.
Immigration advice is not one of the six reserved legal activities under the Legal Services Act 2007, but it is separately regulated by Part 5 of the Immigration and Asylum Act 1999. Under s84 a person must not provide immigration advice or services unless qualified, for example by being registered with the Immigration Advice Authority (formerly OISC) or authorised by a designated qualifying regulator such as the SRA. Breach is an offence under s91. A written disclaimer does not cure the lack of qualification, and the restriction is not limited to tribunal appearances or to particular fee structures.
Law basis: Immigration and Asylum Act 1999, ss84 and 91 ↗More Legal Services topics
Back to all Legal Services questions, or sit a timed mock.