Law covered in these questions
- SRA Code of Conduct for Solicitors, paras 7.7, 7.8
- SRA Code of Conduct for Solicitors, para 7.7
- SRA Code of Conduct for Firms, para 3.9
- SRA Code of Conduct for Solicitors, para 7.12
- SRA Code of Conduct for Solicitors, para 7.6
- SRA Code of Conduct for Solicitors, para 7.5
- SRA Code of Conduct for Solicitors, para 7.11
- SRA Principles 4 and 5
- SRA Code of Conduct for Solicitors, section 7
- Parry-Jones v Law Society [1969] 1 Ch 1
- Solicitors Act 1974, s44B
- SRA Code of Conduct for Solicitors, paras 7.3 and 7.4
- SRA Code of Conduct for Solicitors, para 7.4
- SRA Accounts Rules, rule 3.3
All 13 questions with answers
Try them above first, then read the worked answers below.
Question 1 · Reporting and cooperation dutiesDraft, pending solicitor review
A solicitor discovers that a partner at the same firm has been taking client money for personal use. Which statement best describes the solicitor's obligation?
- To avoid reporting, because it would breach duties to the firm.
- To report only if the sum taken exceeds £10,000.
- To wait until the partner has repaid the money before deciding what to do.
- To tell only the client and leave it to the client to report it.
- To report promptly to the SRA, because serious misconduct must be reported and the duty is not displaced by loyalty to the firm.Correct answer
Solicitors must report promptly to the SRA any facts or matters they reasonably believe are capable of amounting to a serious breach of its regulatory requirements. That includes misuse of client money.
Law basis: SRA Code of Conduct for Solicitors, paras 7.7, 7.8Question 2 · Reporting and cooperation dutiesDraft, pending solicitor review
Laura, a solicitor, acts for a claimant. She receives a witness statement from the defendant's solicitor, Victor, which bears a date and signature she has good reason to believe were added after the witness had died. She has no proof, but the evidence is strong. Which of the following best describes Laura's obligation?
- She need not report, because the duty to report applies only to misconduct by solicitors within her own firm.
- She must report Victor only if her own client consents, because the information came to her while acting for the client.
- She must report promptly to the SRA if she reasonably believes the facts are capable of amounting to a serious breach.Correct answer
- She must not report Victor until she has proof that would satisfy a court on the balance of probabilities.
- She must raise the matter with Victor first and report only if he fails to give a satisfactory explanation within 14 days.
Paragraph 7.7 of the SRA Code of Conduct for Solicitors requires a solicitor to report promptly to the SRA, or another approved regulator as appropriate, any facts or matters she reasonably believes are capable of amounting to a serious breach of their regulatory arrangements by any person regulated by them, including solicitors at other firms. The test is reasonable belief that the facts are capable of amounting to a serious breach, not proof. Apparent falsification of evidence by another solicitor would be serious and may involve dishonesty. There is no requirement to obtain the client's consent, to warn Victor first, or to limit reporting to colleagues in her own firm.
Law basis: SRA Code of Conduct for Solicitors, para 7.7Question 3 · Reporting and cooperation dutiesDraft, pending solicitor review
Kestrel LLP discovers evidence that one of its senior associates has been forging clients' signatures on probate documents. The managing partner proposes to hold a full internal investigation over the next six months and to decide afterwards whether to tell the SRA. Which of the following best describes the firm's obligation?
- The firm may delay reporting for up to six months, which is the period the SRA allows firms to investigate their own staff.
- The firm need report only if the associate is later charged with a criminal offence by the police or the CPS.
- The firm must report promptly to the SRA and should not delay reporting until its internal investigation is complete.Correct answer
- The firm need not report if it dismisses the associate, because the SRA's concern ends once the person leaves the firm.
- The firm may complete its investigation first, because a report is required only once it has established the facts conclusively.
Paragraph 3.9 of the SRA Code of Conduct for Firms, mirroring para 7.7 of the Code for Solicitors, requires a prompt report of facts or matters the firm reasonably believes are capable of amounting to a serious breach. The SRA expects firms not to delay reporting while they carry out a lengthy investigation; a firm may make initial enquiries, but should report promptly once it has a reasonable belief and can update the SRA later. Forging signatures is plainly capable of being a serious breach involving dishonesty. Dismissal does not end the duty, because the SRA needs to protect the public from the associate working elsewhere, and there is no requirement to await a criminal charge.
Law basis: SRA Code of Conduct for Firms, para 3.9; SRA Code of Conduct for Solicitors, para 7.7Question 4 · Reporting and cooperation dutiesDraft, pending solicitor review
Tomasz, an associate at a large firm, discovers that a partner has misled a client about the progress of her claim. He tells the firm's COLP in detail, expecting the COLP to report it. He then asks whether he must also report it to the SRA himself. Which of the following best describes his position?
- He must report to the SRA himself only if the partner is a member of the firm's management board.
- His obligation is satisfied by informing the COLP, on the understanding that the COLP will make any report required.Correct answer
- He must also report to the SRA directly, because the duty to report is personal and cannot be met by telling anyone else.
- He has no obligation at all, because only the COLP has a duty to report serious breaches to the SRA.
- He must report to the Legal Ombudsman as well, because misleading a client is a service failure within its jurisdiction.
Paragraph 7.12 of the SRA Code of Conduct for Solicitors provides that any obligation to notify or provide information to the SRA is satisfied if the solicitor provides the information to the firm's COLP or COFA, as appropriate, on the understanding that they will do so. Tomasz therefore meets his obligation by reporting fully to the COLP. If he later has reason to believe the COLP has not reported a matter that should be reported, he should consider reporting directly. Every solicitor has the personal duty in para 7.7, but para 7.12 provides the route for meeting it. The Legal Ombudsman deals with complaints from eligible complainants, not with reports from solicitors.
Law basis: SRA Code of Conduct for Solicitors, para 7.12Question 5 · Reporting and cooperation dutiesDraft, pending solicitor review
Martha, a solicitor, is charged with assault occasioning actual bodily harm following an incident outside a restaurant. She intends to plead not guilty and says she will tell the SRA only if she is convicted. Which of the following best describes her obligation?
- She must notify the SRA within 28 days of conviction, and only if she is sentenced to a term of imprisonment.
- She need notify only her firm's COLP, who will decide after the trial whether the SRA needs to be informed.
- She need notify the SRA only if she is convicted, because the presumption of innocence applies to regulatory reporting.
- She must notify the SRA promptly that she has been charged, without waiting for the outcome of the trial.Correct answer
- She need notify the SRA only if the offence was committed in the course of her work as a solicitor.
Paragraph 7.6 of the SRA Code of Conduct for Solicitors requires a solicitor to notify the SRA promptly if she is subject to any criminal charge, conviction or caution, subject to the Rehabilitation of Offenders Act 1974. The duty arises on charge, not just on conviction, and applies regardless of whether the alleged offence relates to her practice. Notification does not mean the SRA assumes guilt; it allows the SRA to assess any risk to the public. There is no 28-day rule linked to sentence, and leaving the decision until after the trial would defeat the purpose of prompt notification.
Law basis: SRA Code of Conduct for Solicitors, para 7.6Question 6 · Reporting and cooperation dutiesDraft, pending solicitor review
A departing employee of Grange Solicitors alleges that a partner sexually harassed her. The firm offers her a settlement agreement including a clause that she must not disclose the allegations to anyone, including the SRA or the police. Which of the following best describes the firm's position?
- The clause is acceptable, because a settlement agreement may lawfully restrict any disclosure the parties agree to restrict.
- The firm must not use a clause that seeks to prevent her reporting to the SRA or other bodies such as the police.Correct answer
- The clause is acceptable, provided the employee has received independent legal advice on the settlement agreement.
- The clause is acceptable, provided the firm itself reports the allegation to the SRA within 28 days of signing the agreement.
- The clause is acceptable as regards the SRA, but it must allow her to report to the police if a crime has been committed.
Paragraph 7.5 of the SRA Code of Conduct for Solicitors provides that a solicitor must not attempt to prevent anyone from providing information to the SRA or any other body exercising regulatory, supervisory, investigatory or prosecutory functions in the public interest. The SRA's warning notice on non-disclosure agreements makes clear that NDAs must not be used to prevent or discourage reports to regulators or law enforcement. Independent legal advice does not make such a clause acceptable, and a contractual agreement cannot override the regulatory obligation. Allowing reports to the police while barring reports to the SRA would still breach the Code. The firm's own reporting duty is separate.
Law basis: SRA Code of Conduct for Solicitors, para 7.5Question 7 · Reporting and cooperation dutiesDraft, pending solicitor review
Ayesha, a solicitor, realises she missed the limitation date for issuing her client's personal injury claim, so the claim is now likely to be time-barred. She is tempted to tell the client that the court rejected the claim on its merits. Which of the following best describes what Ayesha must do?
- She must be honest and open with the client, explaining promptly what has happened and its likely impact.Correct answer
- She may tell the client that the claim failed on its merits, provided the client receives an ex gratia payment.
- She must say nothing until her firm's insurer has decided whether to accept liability for any claim by the client.
- She must issue the claim anyway and hope the defendant does not take the limitation point in its defence.
- She must tell the client only if the client asks directly whether the limitation period has been missed.
Paragraph 7.11 of the SRA Code of Conduct for Solicitors requires a solicitor to be honest and open with clients if things go wrong, and if a client suffers loss or harm as a result, to put matters right where possible and explain fully and promptly what has happened and the likely impact. Ayesha must tell the client about the missed deadline and should advise the client to obtain independent legal advice, because there is now a conflict between her interests and the client's. She should also notify the firm's insurer, but that does not justify withholding the truth from the client. Telling the client the claim failed on its merits would be dishonest.
Law basis: SRA Code of Conduct for Solicitors, para 7.11; SRA Principles 4 and 5Question 8 · Reporting and cooperation dutiesDraft, pending solicitor review
Ella, a junior solicitor, reports to the SRA that her supervising partner has been overcharging vulnerable clients. The partner then removes her from all interesting work and blocks her promotion, saying she has been 'disloyal'. Which of the following best describes the partner's conduct?
- The partner's conduct is acceptable unless the SRA ultimately upholds Ella's report after its investigation concludes.
- The partner's conduct is a matter for the employment tribunal only, because the SRA does not regulate workplace treatment.
- The partner's conduct is acceptable, because Ella should have reported to the COLP rather than directly to the SRA.
- Subjecting Ella to detrimental treatment for making a report based on a reasonably held belief breaches the Code.Correct answer
- The partner's conduct is acceptable, because allocation of work is a management matter outside the SRA's regulation.
Section 7 of the SRA Code of Conduct for Solicitors provides that a solicitor must not subject any person to detrimental treatment for making or proposing to make a report, or providing or proposing to provide information, based on a reasonably held belief, under the Code's reporting provisions, irrespective of whether the SRA or another body subsequently investigates or finds any wrongdoing. Ella had a reasonable belief and reported to the SRA. The partner's retaliation is a breach regardless of the outcome of the SRA's investigation. Ella was entitled to report directly to the SRA rather than through the COLP, and any employment law remedies exist alongside regulatory consequences.
Law basis: SRA Code of Conduct for Solicitors, section 7Question 9 · Reporting and cooperation dutiesDraft, pending solicitor review
The SRA is investigating complaints about Hollis & Partners and asks the firm to produce several client files. The senior partner refuses, saying the files contain confidential and privileged material that the firm cannot disclose without the clients' consent. Which of the following best describes the firm's position?
- The firm must produce the files, because confidentiality and privilege do not bar the regulator's access.Correct answer
- The firm may produce only those parts of the files that are not covered by legal professional privilege.
- The firm may refuse unless each client gives written consent, because client confidentiality overrides regulatory requests.
- The firm may refuse, because the SRA can obtain privileged material only under a warrant issued by a High Court judge.
- The firm may refuse, because the SRA may obtain documents only once it has referred the matter to the SDT.
Paragraphs 7.3 and 7.4 of the SRA Code of Conduct for Solicitors require solicitors to cooperate with the SRA and respond promptly with full and accurate explanations, information and documents. Section 44B of the Solicitors Act 1974 gives the SRA statutory power to require production of documents. In Parry-Jones v Law Society [1969] 1 Ch 1 the Court of Appeal held that a solicitor's duty of confidentiality to clients does not prevent the professional regulator from inspecting documents, because the regulator is itself bound to keep them confidential. Privilege is not waived by such production. No warrant or SDT referral is required, and client consent is unnecessary.
Law basis: Parry-Jones v Law Society [1969] 1 Ch 1; Solicitors Act 1974, s44B; SRA Code of Conduct for Solicitors, paras 7.3 and 7.4 ↗Question 10 · Reporting and cooperation dutiesDraft, pending solicitor review
Gideon, a solicitor, instructs a barrister in a commercial claim. At a hearing he hears the barrister tell the judge that a witness is unavailable when Gideon knows the barrister has simply not contacted the witness. Gideon reasonably believes this is capable of being a serious breach. To whom should he report it?
- He should report it to the judge in writing, which discharges any obligation to report to a regulator.
- He should report it to the SRA, which regulates barristers who are instructed by solicitors.
- He should report it to the Legal Ombudsman, which investigates misconduct by all authorised persons.
- He need not report it, because the reporting duty applies only to conduct by persons regulated by the SRA.
- He should report it to the Bar Standards Board, as the approved regulator responsible for the barrister.Correct answer
Paragraph 7.7 of the SRA Code of Conduct for Solicitors requires a solicitor to report promptly to the SRA, or another approved regulator, as appropriate, any facts or matters that he reasonably believes are capable of amounting to a serious breach of their regulatory arrangements by any person regulated by them. Barristers are regulated by the Bar Standards Board, to which the General Council of the Bar delegates its regulatory functions, so the BSB is the appropriate recipient. The SRA does not regulate barristers merely because they are instructed by solicitors. The Legal Ombudsman handles service complaints rather than misconduct, and telling the judge does not replace a report to the regulator.
Law basis: SRA Code of Conduct for Solicitors, para 7.7Question 11 · Reporting and cooperation dutiesDraft, pending solicitor review
Beatrix, a solicitor and sole practitioner, has serious financial difficulties and enters into an individual voluntary arrangement with her creditors. She does not think the SRA needs to know because her practice continues as normal. Which of the following best describes her obligation?
- She must notify the SRA promptly, because a relevant insolvency event has occurred.Correct answer
- She must notify the SRA within 12 months, when she next renews her practising certificate.
- She need notify the SRA only if any of her creditors are current or former clients of her practice.
- She need not notify the SRA, because only bankruptcy, not a voluntary arrangement, is relevant to her practice.
- She need not notify the SRA, provided her client account remains fully reconciled each month.
Paragraph 7.6 of the SRA Code of Conduct for Solicitors requires a solicitor to notify the SRA promptly if a relevant insolvency event occurs in relation to her. The SRA's definition of a relevant insolvency event includes not only bankruptcy but also entering into an individual voluntary arrangement. Financial difficulty may create risks to client money and to the solicitor's independence and judgement, which is why prompt notification is required. The duty does not depend on whether creditors are clients, does not wait for renewal of the practising certificate, and is not displaced by keeping client account properly reconciled.
Law basis: SRA Code of Conduct for Solicitors, para 7.6Question 12 · Reporting and cooperation dutiesDraft, pending solicitor review
The SRA writes to Cedric, a solicitor, asking for an explanation of an apparent breach. Cedric replies late, gives a partial account and omits a key email that shows he knew about the problem earlier than he claims. Which of the following best describes the position?
- Cedric's response is acceptable, because the SRA bears the burden of proving any allegation before the SDT.
- Cedric has done nothing wrong, because the SRA must obtain documents from the firm's COLP rather than from individuals.
- Cedric's response is acceptable, provided he supplies the missing email if the matter is referred to the SDT.
- Cedric has done nothing wrong, because a solicitor is entitled to withhold documents that may incriminate him.
- Cedric has failed to respond with a full and accurate explanation, which is itself a breach of the Code.Correct answer
Paragraph 7.4 of the SRA Code of Conduct for Solicitors requires a solicitor to respond promptly to the SRA and provide full and accurate explanations, information and documents in response to any request or requirement. Deliberately omitting a key email and giving a misleading account may also breach the requirements of honesty and integrity in Principles 4 and 5, and is likely to be treated as aggravating any underlying breach. Although the SRA bears the burden of proof in disciplinary proceedings, that does not entitle a solicitor to be less than candid with the regulator. There is no privilege against self-incrimination of the kind Cedric suggests in this regulatory context.
Law basis: SRA Code of Conduct for Solicitors, para 7.4Question 13 · Reporting and cooperation dutiesDraft, pending solicitor review
Ashgrove Law Ltd learns that one of its conveyancing partners has been allowing clients to use the firm's client account to move funds where there was no underlying legal transaction. The firm wonders whether, as a firm, it has its own duty to report. Which of the following best describes the position?
- Only the individual partner has a duty to report, because firms are not subject to reporting obligations under the SRA Codes.
- The firm need report only once the SRA's annual reporting accountant inspection has confirmed a breach occurred.
- The firm need report only if the misuse of client account resulted in an actual loss to a client or third party.
- Only the firm's MLRO has a duty, and it is to report to the NCA rather than to the SRA under the money laundering regime.
- The firm itself has a duty to report promptly to the SRA facts it reasonably believes are capable of being a serious breach.Correct answer
Paragraph 3.9 of the SRA Code of Conduct for Firms requires the firm itself to report promptly to the SRA any facts or matters that it reasonably believes are capable of amounting to a serious breach of the SRA's regulatory arrangements by any person regulated by the SRA. Using client account as a banking facility where there is no underlying legal transaction breaches rule 3.3 of the SRA Accounts Rules and raises serious money laundering concerns. A separate report to the NCA may also be needed if there is suspicion of money laundering, but that does not replace the regulatory report. Actual loss is not required, and the firm must not wait for an accountant's report.
Law basis: SRA Code of Conduct for Firms, para 3.9; SRA Accounts Rules, rule 3.3More Legal Services topics
Back to all Legal Services questions, or sit a timed mock.