Law covered in these questions
- Legal Services Act 2007 ss 12, 14, Sch 2
- Legal Services Act 2007, ss12, 14 and Sch 2
- Legal Services Act 2007, s12 and Sch 2
- Legal Services Act 2007, s12 and Sch 2 para 6
- Legal Services Act 2007, s12 and Sch 3
- McKenzie v McKenzie [1971] P 33
- Practice Guidance (McKenzie Friends: Civil and Family Courts) [2010] 1 WLR 1881
- LSA 2007, Sch 3
- Employment Tribunals Act 1996, s6
- Legal Services Act 2007, s12 and Sch 4
- Legal Services Act 2007, Sch 2 para 8
- Solicitors Act 1974, s81
- Legal Services Act 2007, ss12, 14 and Sch 2 para 4
- Legal Services Act 2007, s12
All 15 questions with answers
Try them above first, then read the worked answers below.
Question 1 · Reserved legal activitiesDraft, pending solicitor review
Chloe is not authorised or exempt. She charges a fee to represent a client at a county court trial, saying she has a law degree. Which statement best describes her position?
- She commits no offence, because county court trials are open to any person.
- She commits an offence only if she holds herself out as a solicitor.
- She is likely to commit an offence, because exercising a right of audience is a reserved legal activity and she is not authorised.Correct answer
- She commits an offence only if the client suffers loss.
- She commits no offence, because a law degree is enough to act.
Exercising a right of audience, conduct of litigation, reserved instrument activities, probate activities, notarial activities and administration of oaths are reserved. Carrying out one without authorisation or exemption is an offence.
Law basis: Legal Services Act 2007 ss 12, 14, Sch 2 ↗Question 2 · Reserved legal activitiesDraft, pending solicitor review
Callum is not a lawyer. He runs a property services business and, for a fee of £400, prepares a TR1 transfer of registered land for a client and submits it to HM Land Registry. Which of the following best describes Callum's position?
- He has carried on a reserved instrument activity without entitlement, which is an offence.Correct answer
- He has acted lawfully, because preparing a transfer of land is unreserved work that anyone may carry out for payment.
- He has acted lawfully, provided the transfer was signed by the client rather than by Callum himself as the preparer.
- He has committed a disciplinary offence only, for which the SRA may fine him but which carries no criminal consequence.
- He has acted lawfully, because only the conduct of litigation and rights of audience are restricted to authorised persons.
Reserved instrument activities are one of the six reserved legal activities in s12 of the Legal Services Act 2007. Schedule 2 defines them to include preparing an instrument of transfer or charge for the purposes of the Land Registration Act 2002, and making an application or lodging a document for registration. Callum prepared a TR1 for reward and is neither authorised nor exempt. Under s14 it is an offence for a person to carry on a reserved legal activity unless entitled to do so. The client's signature does not alter who prepared the instrument. The SRA has no disciplinary jurisdiction over an unregulated individual such as Callum.
Law basis: Legal Services Act 2007, ss12, 14 and Sch 2 ↗Question 3 · Reserved legal activitiesDraft, pending solicitor review
WillsDirect Ltd is not regulated by any approved regulator. It charges clients £150 to draft wills and lasting powers of attorney. A competitor alleges that WillsDirect is acting unlawfully. Which of the following best describes WillsDirect's position?
- It is acting lawfully, because neither wills nor powers of attorney are reserved activities.Correct answer
- It is acting unlawfully, because probate activities include all work concerning the estates of people who are still alive.
- It may draft wills but not lasting powers of attorney, because powers of attorney are a reserved legal activity.
- It may lawfully draft wills only if each will is checked and signed off by a solicitor with a current practising certificate.
- It is acting unlawfully, because preparing a will for a fee is a reserved instrument activity restricted to authorised persons.
Will writing is not a reserved legal activity under the Legal Services Act 2007. The definition of reserved instrument activities in Schedule 2 expressly excludes wills and other testamentary instruments, and also excludes powers of attorney. Probate activities concern preparing papers on which to found or oppose a grant of probate or letters of administration after death, so they do not cover drafting a will for a living person. WillsDirect may therefore lawfully offer these services without authorisation, although its clients will not have the protections that come with regulated providers, such as access to the Legal Ombudsman. No solicitor sign-off is required by law.
Law basis: Legal Services Act 2007, s12 and Sch 2 ↗Question 4 · Reserved legal activitiesDraft, pending solicitor review
Emeka is an executor of his late aunt's estate. He engages an unregulated estate administration company for a fee. The company proposes to prepare and submit the application for the grant of probate, and then to collect in the assets and distribute the estate. Which of the following best describes the company's position?
- Neither activity is reserved, because probate work only becomes reserved if the will is contested in the Chancery Division.
- Only preparing the probate application is reserved; administering the estate after the grant is not.Correct answer
- Both activities are lawful, provided the company holds the estate money in a separate bank account in the executor's name.
- The probate application is not reserved, but distributing the estate is reserved because it involves handling money for beneficiaries.
- Both the probate application and the later administration of the estate are reserved, so the company may not carry out either for a fee.
Probate activities are reserved under s12 of and Schedule 2 to the Legal Services Act 2007. They cover preparing any probate papers on which to found or oppose a grant of probate or letters of administration, where done for a fee, gain or reward. An unregulated company that prepares Emeka's application for payment would therefore be carrying on a reserved activity without entitlement. By contrast, the general administration of an estate after the grant, such as collecting in assets, paying debts and distributing to beneficiaries, is not reserved. Holding money in a separate account does not affect whether the application work is reserved.
Law basis: Legal Services Act 2007, s12 and Sch 2 para 6 ↗Question 5 · Reserved legal activitiesDraft, pending solicitor review
Oliver is being sued in the county court by a former business partner for breach of contract. He cannot afford a lawyer, so he plans to fill in and file his own defence and present his own case at the trial. Which of the following best describes Oliver's position?
- As a party to the proceedings, he is exempt and may conduct the litigation and exercise rights of audience on his own behalf.Correct answer
- He may file his own defence, but he must instruct an authorised person to exercise rights of audience at the trial itself.
- He may represent himself only on the small claims track, because litigants in person are not permitted on the fast or multi-track.
- He may represent himself only if the court first grants him permission, because rights of audience are reserved to authorised persons.
- He commits an offence if he conducts the litigation, but the court may later decide not to punish him if he acted in good faith.
The conduct of litigation and the exercise of rights of audience are reserved legal activities under s12 of the Legal Services Act 2007. However, Schedule 3 makes exempt a party to proceedings who conducts litigation or exercises rights of audience on his own behalf. Oliver therefore needs no permission and commits no offence in issuing documents, filing his defence and presenting his case at trial on any track. The restriction is on doing these things for other people without entitlement. Courts may control how a litigant in person behaves, but the basic right to act in person exists regardless of the track.
Law basis: Legal Services Act 2007, s12 and Sch 3 ↗Question 6 · Reserved legal activitiesDraft, pending solicitor review
At a family court hearing, Priti, a litigant in person, attends with her friend Zoe, who is not a lawyer. Zoe wishes to sit beside Priti, take notes and quietly suggest questions. Zoe also asks whether she can address the judge on Priti's behalf. Which of the following best describes the position?
- Zoe may address the court only if Priti signs a written authority, which gives Zoe the status of an exempt person.
- Zoe may address the court as of right, because a McKenzie friend automatically acquires the same rights of audience as the party.
- Zoe may address the court provided she charges no fee, because unpaid representation is not a reserved legal activity.
- Zoe may assist as a McKenzie friend, but she has no right to address the court unless the court grants her a right of audience.Correct answer
- Zoe may not attend at all, because only authorised persons may sit with a party in family proceedings to give assistance.
A litigant in person may normally be assisted by a McKenzie friend (McKenzie v McKenzie [1971] P 33). The Practice Guidance (McKenzie Friends: Civil and Family Courts) [2010] 1 WLR 1881 confirms that a McKenzie friend may provide moral support, take notes, help with papers and quietly give advice. A McKenzie friend has no right to act as an advocate or conduct litigation. The court has a discretion under Schedule 3 to the Legal Services Act 2007 to grant a lay person a right of audience in particular proceedings, but this is exceptional. Neither a written authority nor the absence of a fee gives Zoe that right.
Law basis: McKenzie v McKenzie [1971] P 33; Practice Guidance (McKenzie Friends: Civil and Family Courts) [2010] 1 WLR 1881; LSA 2007, Sch 3Question 7 · Reserved legal activitiesDraft, pending solicitor review
Joseph, a self-employed HR consultant with no legal qualification, charges a fee to represent a dismissed employee at a full hearing in the employment tribunal. A solicitor suggests that Joseph is committing an offence. Which of the following best describes Joseph's position?
- He is committing an offence, because representing anyone at a contested hearing for a fee is always a reserved legal activity.
- He is acting lawfully only if the claimant's claim is worth less than £10,000, which is the limit for lay representation.
- He is acting lawfully only at preliminary hearings, because full hearings require the representative to be an authorised person.
- He is committing an offence unless he is supervised throughout the hearing by a solicitor with higher rights of audience.
- He is acting lawfully, because a party to employment tribunal proceedings may be represented by any person they choose.Correct answer
Section 6 of the Employment Tribunals Act 1996 provides that a person may appear before an employment tribunal in person or be represented by a barrister, a solicitor, a representative of a trade union or employers' association, or any other person whom they desire to represent them. Joseph may therefore represent the claimant at a full hearing and charge for it without committing an offence under the Legal Services Act 2007. Lay representatives in the tribunal are not regulated as such, although paid claims management activity may be regulated separately. There is no value limit or supervision requirement.
Law basis: Employment Tribunals Act 1996, s6 ↗Question 8 · Reserved legal activitiesDraft, pending solicitor review
Hannah, a solicitor with a current practising certificate, is asked by a client to authenticate and certify documents for use in Brazil, which requires a notarial act. Hannah is not a notary. Which of the following best describes the position?
- Hannah may carry out the notarial act, because notarial work is unreserved and may be done by any qualified lawyer.
- A notary must be instructed, because a practising certificate does not authorise notarial activities.Correct answer
- Hannah may carry out the notarial act, provided she certifies the documents in her capacity as a commissioner for oaths.
- Hannah may carry out the notarial act, because solicitors are authorised for all six reserved legal activities on admission.
- Hannah may carry out the notarial act only if she holds higher rights of audience, which include notarial powers.
Notarial activities are one of the six reserved legal activities in s12 of the Legal Services Act 2007. The approved regulator for notarial activities is the Master of the Faculties, and only notaries are authorised to carry them on. The Law Society is an approved regulator for the other reserved activities, but not for notarial activities, so a practising certificate does not entitle Hannah to perform a notarial act. The power to administer oaths is a different reserved activity and does not include notarial authentication. Higher rights of audience concern advocacy in the higher courts, not notarial work.
Law basis: Legal Services Act 2007, s12 and Sch 4 ↗Question 9 · Reserved legal activitiesDraft, pending solicitor review
A client attends a firm to swear a statutory declaration. The supervising solicitor is out, so Lewis, a trainee who has passed SQE1 but has not been admitted, offers to administer the declaration. Which of the following best describes the position?
- Lewis may administer it, because trainees undertaking qualifying work experience have the same powers as solicitors.
- Lewis may administer it, provided the declaration is not to be used in court proceedings or filed with HM Land Registry.
- Lewis cannot administer it, because he is not yet a solicitor holding a practising certificate.Correct answer
- Lewis may administer it, because the administration of oaths is not a reserved activity and may be done by any adult.
- Lewis may administer it, provided that a solicitor at the firm later countersigns the declaration on the same day.
The administration of oaths is a reserved legal activity under s12 of and Schedule 2 to the Legal Services Act 2007. Section 81 of the Solicitors Act 1974 gives every solicitor who holds a practising certificate the powers of a commissioner for oaths. Lewis has not been admitted and has no practising certificate, so he is not entitled to administer the declaration. Supervision or later countersignature does not make the original act lawful, and trainees do not have the powers of solicitors. The restriction applies regardless of how the declaration will later be used.
Law basis: Legal Services Act 2007, Sch 2 para 8; Solicitors Act 1974, s81 ↗Question 10 · Reserved legal activitiesDraft, pending solicitor review
Ivy is a chartered accountant with no legal authorisation. A client owes £8,000 to one of her business clients. For a fee, Ivy completes, signs and issues a county court claim form in her business client's name and serves it. Which of the following best describes Ivy's position?
- Ivy risks an offence, because issuing proceedings for another is the conduct of litigation.Correct answer
- Ivy acted lawfully, because only exercising rights of audience at a hearing is reserved, and issuing a claim is administrative work.
- Ivy acted lawfully, provided the claim form names the business client as claimant and Ivy only as its representative.
- Ivy acted lawfully, because debt claims under £10,000 are allocated to the small claims track where no activities are reserved.
- Ivy acted lawfully, because chartered accountants are authorised by their professional body for all civil debt litigation.
The conduct of litigation is a reserved legal activity under s12 of the Legal Services Act 2007. Schedule 2 para 4 defines it as issuing proceedings before any court, commencing, prosecuting and defending such proceedings, and performing ancillary functions such as entering appearances. Ivy, who is neither authorised nor exempt, issued and served proceedings for a fee on behalf of another person, so she risks an offence under s14. The small claims track does not remove the reservation on the conduct of litigation, although lay representatives may sometimes appear at small claims hearings. Naming herself as representative does not help, because that is the very activity that is reserved.
Law basis: Legal Services Act 2007, ss12, 14 and Sch 2 para 4 ↗Question 11 · Reserved legal activitiesDraft, pending solicitor review
Ruth was admitted as a solicitor three months ago and has a practising certificate. A client asks her to act as advocate in his jury trial for burglary in the Crown Court. Ruth has no further advocacy qualification. Which of the following best describes Ruth's position?
- She may conduct the jury trial only if the client consents in writing after being told she has no higher rights qualification.
- She may conduct the jury trial, because all solicitors acquire full rights of audience in every court on admission without restriction.
- She may never conduct a Crown Court trial, because only barristers have rights of audience in the Crown Court.
- She may not conduct the jury trial until she has obtained a higher courts advocacy qualification through the SRA's assessment.Correct answer
- She may conduct the jury trial if her supervising partner, who has higher rights, sits behind her throughout the hearing.
Solicitors have rights of audience in all courts on admission, but the SRA's regulatory arrangements require a solicitor to obtain a higher courts advocacy qualification before exercising rights of audience in the higher courts, such as conducting a Crown Court jury trial. Newly qualified solicitors may appear in the magistrates' and county courts, and in the Crown Court in limited circumstances, such as appeals from the magistrates' court. Client consent or supervision by another advocate does not remove the requirement. It is wrong to say only barristers may appear in the Crown Court, because solicitor-advocates with higher rights regularly do so.
Law basis: Legal Services Act 2007, s12; SRA Authorisation of Individuals Regulations (higher rights of audience)Question 12 · Reserved legal activitiesDraft, pending solicitor review
Martin was struck off the roll of solicitors two years ago. He now runs an unregulated business advising on employment disputes. His website and letterhead describe him as 'Martin Hale, Solicitor (non-practising)'. Which of the following best describes Martin's position?
- He is acting lawfully, provided his clients sign an acknowledgment that he is not covered by professional indemnity insurance.
- He risks an offence by using a description implying that he is still a solicitor.Correct answer
- He is acting lawfully, because once struck off he is no longer regulated by the SRA and may describe himself as he wishes.
- He commits an offence only if he also holds himself out as having a practising certificate for reserved legal work.
- He is acting lawfully, because employment advice is unreserved and the description makes clear he is not practising.
Section 21 of the Solicitors Act 1974 makes it an offence for a person who is not qualified to act as a solicitor wilfully to pretend to be, or take or use any name, title or description implying that he is, qualified or recognised by law as a solicitor. Martin has been struck off, so he is no longer a solicitor at all, not even a non-practising one. Describing himself as 'Solicitor (non-practising)' implies that he remains on the roll. Although the employment advice itself is unreserved, the misleading description creates the risk of an offence. A client acknowledgment does not prevent the public being misled.
Law basis: Solicitors Act 1974, s21 ↗Question 13 · Reserved legal activitiesDraft, pending solicitor review
Tasha is an in-house solicitor employed by Bramley Retail Ltd, which is not authorised by the SRA. She conducts county court debt claims on behalf of Bramley. Bramley now proposes that Tasha should also conduct litigation for Bramley's customers for a fee. Which of the following best describes the position?
- Acting for customers is permitted, but acting for Bramley itself is not, because an employer cannot be represented by its own employee.
- Acting for Bramley is permitted, but acting for customers would require Bramley itself to be authorised.Correct answer
- Both arrangements are permitted, provided Bramley holds professional indemnity insurance covering Tasha's litigation work.
- Neither arrangement is permitted, because an in-house solicitor cannot conduct litigation unless her employer is an authorised body.
- Both arrangements are permitted, because Tasha is a solicitor and may conduct litigation for anyone while employed by Bramley.
Under s15 of the Legal Services Act 2007, where an employee carries on a reserved legal activity in that capacity, the employer is also treated as carrying it on. However, this does not apply where the activity is provided to the employer itself, which is why an in-house solicitor can conduct litigation for her employer without the employer being authorised. If Bramley offers litigation services to its customers through Tasha for a fee, Bramley would itself be carrying on a reserved legal activity for the public and would need to be authorised, for example as an alternative business structure. Insurance does not cure the lack of authorisation.
Law basis: Legal Services Act 2007, s15 ↗Question 14 · Reserved legal activitiesDraft, pending solicitor review
Brendan, a retired engineer who is not a lawyer, agrees to help his nephew by preparing a transfer of registered land when the nephew buys a flat from his mother. Brendan charges nothing and expects no reward. Which of the following best describes Brendan's position?
- He does not commit an offence, because the reservation applies only to unregistered land and not to registered land.
- He commits an offence unless the transaction is between members of the same family living at the same address.
- He commits an offence only if HM Land Registry rejects the transfer because of an error in Brendan's drafting.
- He does not commit an offence, because a person who prepares such an instrument without any fee, gain or reward is exempt.Correct answer
- He commits an offence, because preparing a land transfer is reserved and the absence of a fee is irrelevant to entitlement.
Reserved instrument activities include preparing a transfer of registered land under the Land Registration Act 2002 (Legal Services Act 2007, Sch 2 para 5). However, Schedule 3 exempts a person carrying on reserved instrument activities otherwise than for, or in expectation of, any fee, gain or reward. Brendan acts unpaid and expects no reward, so he is an exempt person and commits no offence under s14. The exemption does not depend on family relationship or residence. The reservation applies to registered land transfers, so the suggested distinction is wrong, and whether the Land Registry accepts the transfer has no bearing on entitlement.
Law basis: Legal Services Act 2007, Sch 2 para 5 and Sch 3 ↗Question 15 · Reserved legal activitiesDraft, pending solicitor review
Abdul is a party to a small claims track claim in the county court. He attends the final hearing with his brother-in-law, Samir, who is not a lawyer and who will speak for him. Samir is not paid. Which of the following best describes Samir's position?
- Samir may present the case only if Abdul does not attend, because lay representatives replace a party who cannot be present.
- As a lay representative, Samir may present Abdul's case at the small claims hearing because Abdul is attending it.Correct answer
- Samir may speak only if he is paid, because unpaid lay representation is not recognised by the court rules.
- Samir may present the case only after the court grants him a right of audience on a formal application with a fee.
- Samir may not speak at all, because only solicitors, barristers and chartered legal executives have rights of audience at small claims hearings.
The Lay Representatives (Rights of Audience) Order 1999, together with the small claims provisions of the Civil Procedure Rules, permits a lay representative to exercise a right of audience at a small claims hearing. The general position is that a lay representative may not do so if the party they represent does not attend the hearing, unless the court permits. Because Abdul is present, Samir may present his case. No formal application or fee is required, and the right does not depend on whether the lay representative is paid. The small claims regime is an important exception to the general reservation of rights of audience.
Law basis: Lay Representatives (Rights of Audience) Order 1999; CPR Part 27More Legal Services topics
Back to all Legal Services questions, or sit a timed mock.