Law covered in these questions
- Landlord and Tenant (Covenants) Act 1995 ss 3, 5, 16
- Landlord and Tenant Act 1927, s19(1)(a)
- International Drilling Fluids Ltd v Louisville Investments (Uxbridge) Ltd [1986] Ch 513
- Landlord and Tenant Act 1988, ss 1 and 4
- Landlord and Tenant Act 1988, s1
- Landlord and Tenant (Covenants) Act 1995, ss 5 and 16
- Landlord and Tenant (Covenants) Act 1995, s16
- Landlord and Tenant Act 1927, s19(1A)
- Landlord and Tenant (Covenants) Act 1995, ss 5 and 16(4)
- Landlord and Tenant (Covenants) Act 1995, s17
- Landlord and Tenant (Covenants) Act 1995, ss 1 and 17
- Landlord and Tenant (Covenants) Act 1995, s19
- Allied Dunbar Assurance plc v Homebase Ltd [2002] EWCA Civ 666
- Old Grovebury Manor Farm Ltd v W Seymour Plant Sales and Hire Ltd (No 2) [1979] 1 WLR 1397
All 15 questions with answers
Try them above first, then read the worked answers below.
Question 1 · Assignment and underlettingDraft, pending solicitor review
A tenant assigns a lease that was granted in 2010 to a new tenant. The assignee does not pay the rent. Who is liable to the original landlord under the Landlord and Tenant (Covenants) Act 1995?
- Nobody is liable, because covenants cannot pass on assignment.
- The original tenant remains liable for the whole term in every case.
- Only the guarantor of the new tenant is liable, if any.
- The assignee is liable, because the tenant covenants pass to the assignee, and the original tenant is released on assignment unless an authorised guarantee agreement applies.Correct answer
- The original landlord must pay the rent to the new tenant.
Question 2 · Assignment and underlettingDraft, pending solicitor review
Dune Ltd's lease of offices contains a covenant 'not to assign the whole of the premises without the landlord's consent'. Dune has found an assignee with strong accounts. The landlord refuses consent because it wants to recover the premises to let them to another of its tenants at a higher rent. Which of the following best describes the position?
- The refusal is lawful, because the covenant does not state that consent will not be unreasonably withheld.
- The refusal is lawful, because a landlord may always refuse consent if it wishes to re-let at a higher rent.
- The refusal is likely to be unreasonable, as consent to assign cannot be unreasonably withheld and this reason is collateral.Correct answer
- The refusal is unreasonable only if Dune can show it will suffer loss by remaining in the premises.
- The refusal is lawful, because a landlord may refuse consent to assign for any reason which benefits it.
Under s19(1)(a) of the Landlord and Tenant Act 1927, a qualified covenant against assignment without consent is subject to a proviso that consent is not to be unreasonably withheld. Following International Drilling Fluids Ltd v Louisville Investments (Uxbridge) Ltd [1986] Ch 513, a landlord may not refuse on grounds that have nothing to do with the relationship of landlord and tenant regarding the subject matter of the lease, such as a wish to recover the premises for its own purposes. A financially strong assignee makes refusal on covenant grounds unlikely to be reasonable.
Law basis: Landlord and Tenant Act 1927, s19(1)(a); International Drilling Fluids Ltd v Louisville Investments (Uxbridge) Ltd [1986] Ch 513Question 3 · Assignment and underlettingDraft, pending solicitor review
Elder Ltd applied in writing for its landlord's consent to assign its lease, which contains a qualified covenant. Three months later, despite reminders and full information being provided, the landlord has neither consented nor given reasons. Elder's assignee is threatening to withdraw. Which of the following best describes Elder's position?
- Elder may forfeit the lease and claim back the rent it paid, because the landlord breached the lease.
- Elder may assign without consent, because the landlord's silence for 28 days is treated as consent.
- Elder must serve a notice under s146 on the landlord before it can claim any remedy for the delay.
- Elder has no remedy, because a landlord may take as long as it wishes to decide on consent to assign.
- The landlord has a statutory duty to decide within a reasonable time with reasons, so Elder may claim damages.Correct answer
Under s1 of the Landlord and Tenant Act 1988, where a lease contains a qualified covenant and the tenant serves a written application, the landlord must within a reasonable time give consent (unless it is reasonable not to) and serve written notice of its decision, stating any conditions or reasons for refusal. The burden of proving reasonableness is on the landlord. Breach is actionable in tort for damages under s4. Three months with full information is likely unreasonable. Silence is not deemed consent, so assigning without consent is risky.
Law basis: Landlord and Tenant Act 1988, ss 1 and 4 ↗Question 4 · Assignment and underlettingDraft, pending solicitor review
Fennel Ltd's lease contains an absolute covenant 'not to assign, underlet or part with possession of the whole or any part of the premises'. Fennel wants to assign to a well-funded company. The landlord refuses without giving reasons. Which of the following best describes the position?
- The landlord must give reasons within a reasonable time, because the Landlord and Tenant Act 1988 applies.
- The landlord may refuse for any reason, as no reasonableness proviso is implied into an absolute covenant.Correct answer
- The landlord must consent, because a covenant that prevents all dealings is void as a restraint of trade.
- The landlord may refuse only if it offers to accept a surrender of the lease from Fennel Ltd instead.
- The landlord must consent if the assignee is financially stronger than the current tenant, Fennel Ltd.
Section 19(1)(a) of the Landlord and Tenant Act 1927 applies only to covenants against assignment without consent (qualified covenants). Where the covenant is absolute, the landlord can refuse for any reason, and the duties under the Landlord and Tenant Act 1988 do not apply, since they arise only where the lease requires consent that is not to be unreasonably withheld. Absolute covenants against assignment are unusual in long commercial leases because they reduce value at rent review, but they are lawful.
Law basis: Landlord and Tenant Act 1927, s19(1)(a); Landlord and Tenant Act 1988, s1 ↗Question 5 · Assignment and underlettingDraft, pending solicitor review
Gale Ltd took a 15-year lease of a shop in 2018. In 2022, with the landlord's consent, it assigned the lease to Heron Ltd, without giving any guarantee. Heron has now stopped paying rent. The landlord sues Gale for the arrears. Which of the following best describes Gale's liability?
- Gale is liable, because the landlord's consent to assign was conditional on Gale remaining liable.
- Gale is liable for six months' rent only, which is the maximum recoverable from a former tenant.
- Gale is not liable, because it was released from the tenant covenants on a lawful assignment of a new lease.Correct answer
- Gale is liable, provided the landlord serves notice on it within three months of the arrears arising.
- Gale is liable, because an original tenant remains liable for the rent for the whole of the lease term.
The lease was granted after 1 January 1996, so it is a 'new lease' under the Landlord and Tenant (Covenants) Act 1995. Under s5, on a lawful assignment of the whole, the tenant is released from the tenant covenants and ceases to be entitled to the landlord's covenants. Gale could have remained liable only if it had given an authorised guarantee agreement under s16, which it did not. Continuing liability for the whole term is the old privity rule for pre-1996 leases. The s17 notice procedure applies only where a former tenant remains liable.
Law basis: Landlord and Tenant (Covenants) Act 1995, ss 5 and 16 ↗Question 6 · Assignment and underlettingDraft, pending solicitor review
Ivy Ltd's 2019 lease contains a qualified covenant against assignment and states that the landlord may require, as a condition of consent, that the assigning tenant enters into an authorised guarantee agreement. Ivy wants to assign to Juno Ltd and objects to giving any guarantee. Which of the following best describes the position?
- The landlord may require a guarantee only if it is given by Ivy's directors rather than the company.
- The landlord may require Ivy to guarantee Juno and all later assignees for the rest of the lease term.
- The landlord may require an authorised guarantee only if Juno has weaker accounts than Ivy has.
- The landlord may never require a guarantee, because the 1995 Act always releases tenants on assignment.
- The landlord may lawfully require an authorised guarantee agreement, as the lease specifies it as a condition of consent.Correct answer
Under s16 of the Landlord and Tenant (Covenants) Act 1995, an outgoing tenant may enter into an authorised guarantee agreement guaranteeing performance by its immediate assignee, where consent to assign is required and is given subject to that condition. Section 19(1A) of the Landlord and Tenant Act 1927 allows the parties to a non-residential lease granted after 1995 to specify conditions for consent, and a landlord withholding consent unless such a condition is met is not unreasonable. An AGA cannot extend to later assignees beyond the immediate assignee.
Law basis: Landlord and Tenant (Covenants) Act 1995, s16; Landlord and Tenant Act 1927, s19(1A) ↗Question 7 · Assignment and underlettingDraft, pending solicitor review
In 2020, Kite Ltd assigned its 2015 lease to Lynx Ltd and gave an authorised guarantee agreement. In 2023, Lynx assigned the lease to Moth Ltd with the landlord's consent. Moth has now defaulted on the rent. Which of the following best describes Kite's liability?
- Kite is liable, because an authorised guarantee agreement covers every later tenant for the rest of the term.
- Kite is liable, because Moth has failed to pay and Kite was a party to the original lease in 2015.
- Kite is liable for half the arrears, with Lynx responsible for the other half under its own guarantee.
- Kite is not liable, because its guarantee ended when Lynx, its immediate assignee, was released on assigning.Correct answer
- Kite is liable only if the landlord serves notice on it within six months of the rent falling due.
An authorised guarantee agreement can only guarantee performance by the outgoing tenant's immediate assignee. Under s16(4) of the Landlord and Tenant (Covenants) Act 1995, any provision making the guarantor liable beyond the period during which the assignee is bound by the covenants is ineffective. When Lynx lawfully assigned to Moth, Lynx was released (s5) and Kite's guarantee ended. Moth's default is a matter for the landlord against Moth and any AGA Lynx gave. The s17 notice is relevant only if Kite were otherwise liable.
Law basis: Landlord and Tenant (Covenants) Act 1995, ss 5 and 16(4) ↗Question 8 · Assignment and underlettingDraft, pending solicitor review
Nest Ltd assigned its lease to Orb Ltd and gave an authorised guarantee agreement. Orb failed to pay the March quarter's rent. The landlord first wrote to Nest about it in November, eight months later, demanding payment of that rent. Which of the following best describes Nest's liability for the March rent?
- Nest is liable, but only for interest on the March rent rather than for the rent itself.
- Nest is liable, because the six-month notice rule applies only to former tenants and not to guarantors.
- Nest is not liable for it, because the landlord failed to serve the statutory notice within six months.Correct answer
- Nest is not liable, because a landlord must sue the current tenant to judgment before claiming from Nest.
- Nest is liable, because a guarantee of rent may be enforced at any time within the six-year limitation period.
Under s17 of the Landlord and Tenant (Covenants) Act 1995, a former tenant (including one liable under an authorised guarantee agreement) is not liable for a 'fixed charge' such as rent or service charge unless, within six months of the charge becoming due, the landlord serves a notice in the prescribed form informing it that the charge is due and that the landlord intends to recover it. The landlord's November demand was outside the six-month period, so Nest is not liable for the March rent. Section 17 applies to guarantors of former tenants too.
Law basis: Landlord and Tenant (Covenants) Act 1995, s17 ↗Question 9 · Assignment and underlettingDraft, pending solicitor review
Pyre Ltd took a 25-year lease in 1990. It assigned the lease in 2005, and the lease has since been assigned twice more. The current tenant has stopped paying rent, and the landlord has served a valid s17 notice on Pyre within the time limit. Which of the following best describes Pyre's position?
- Pyre is not liable, because only the tenant immediately before the current tenant can be pursued.
- Pyre is liable only if it gave an authorised guarantee agreement when it assigned the lease in 2005.
- Pyre is liable for the arrears, because as original tenant of a pre-1996 lease it remains liable by privity of contract.Correct answer
- Pyre is not liable, because every tenant is released from liability when it assigns a lease with consent.
- Pyre is not liable, because liability of an original tenant ends after 15 years from assignment.
For leases granted before 1 January 1996 ('old leases'), the original tenant remains liable on the tenant covenants for the whole term by privity of contract, even after assignment, unless the lease provides otherwise. The automatic release in s5 of the Landlord and Tenant (Covenants) Act 1995 applies only to new leases, and authorised guarantee agreements are a new-lease concept. However, s17 of the 1995 Act applies to old leases too, so the landlord must serve notice within six months, which it has done. Pyre may claim indemnity from later tenants.
Law basis: Landlord and Tenant (Covenants) Act 1995, ss 1 and 17 ↗Question 10 · Assignment and underlettingDraft, pending solicitor review
Quay Ltd, a former tenant, has just paid three quarters of arrears of rent in full after receiving a valid notice under s17 of the Landlord and Tenant (Covenants) Act 1995. The current tenant is insolvent and still in occupation. Quay wants to regain some control over the premises. Which of the following best describes Quay's statutory right?
- It may take possession of the premises, as the landlord's rights pass to it on payment.
- It may call for an overriding lease, making it the current tenant's immediate landlord.Correct answer
- It may forfeit the current tenant's lease, as it has paid the rent the current tenant owed.
- It may require the landlord to grant it a fresh lease of the premises with vacant possession.
- It may require the landlord to transfer the freehold reversion to it at market value.
Under s19 of the Landlord and Tenant (Covenants) Act 1995, a former tenant or guarantor who has made full payment of a sum demanded under a s17 notice may, within 12 months of payment, require the landlord to grant it an overriding lease. This is a lease of the reversion, interposed between the landlord and the defaulting tenant, so that the former tenant becomes the current tenant's landlord and can enforce the covenants or forfeit. Payment does not itself give it possession or the landlord's existing rights.
Law basis: Landlord and Tenant (Covenants) Act 1995, s19 ↗Question 11 · Assignment and underlettingDraft, pending solicitor review
Rook Ltd's lease permits underletting of the whole with consent, but only at a rent not less than the rent currently payable under the lease. Market rents have fallen. Rook proposes to grant an underlease at the passing rent but to pay the undertenant a large reverse premium and a rent-free period, so that the effective rent is far lower. Which of the following best describes the position?
- The condition is unenforceable, because it is unreasonable to require an above-market underlease rent.
- The condition is satisfied, because the rent stated in the underlease is equal to the passing rent.
- The landlord may enforce the condition, and arrangements designed to undermine it may put Rook in breach.Correct answer
- The condition applies only if the landlord can show that it will suffer a loss from the underletting.
- The condition is void, because a landlord cannot control the rent payable under an underlease at all.
Conditions in a lease restricting the terms of underleases, such as a minimum rent, are generally enforceable and are not subject to the s19(1)(a) reasonableness proviso, which governs refusals of consent rather than express lease conditions (Allied Dunbar Assurance plc v Homebase Ltd [2002] EWCA Civ 666). Side arrangements, such as reverse premiums, designed to circumvent the requirement may be treated as breaching it, as in Allied Dunbar. Rook should therefore not rely on matching the headline rent while undermining the condition.
Law basis: Allied Dunbar Assurance plc v Homebase Ltd [2002] EWCA Civ 666Question 12 · Assignment and underlettingDraft, pending solicitor review
Sage Ltd assigned its lease of a shop to Thorn Ltd without asking for the landlord's consent, which the lease required under a qualified covenant. Thorn has taken possession. The landlord asks who now holds the lease and what it can do. Which of the following best describes the position?
- The assignment is void unless the landlord accepts rent from Thorn within three months of completion.
- The assignment is void, so Sage remains the tenant and Thorn is merely a trespasser on the premises.
- The assignment is effective, but the landlord's only remedy is to claim damages from Sage for breach.
- The assignment is effective to pass the lease to Thorn, but it is a breach which may entitle the landlord to forfeit.Correct answer
- The assignment is valid and not a breach, because consent could not reasonably have been refused.
An assignment made in breach of a covenant against assignment is nevertheless effective to vest the lease in the assignee (Old Grovebury Manor Farm Ltd v W Seymour Plant Sales and Hire Ltd (No 2) [1979] 1 WLR 1397), but it is a breach of covenant. If the lease contains a forfeiture clause, the landlord may forfeit, against Thorn as current tenant, subject to waiver and relief. Under the 1995 Act, an assignment in breach is an 'excluded assignment', so Sage is not released (s11 of the 1995 Act). It does not matter that consent could not reasonably have been refused if it was never sought.
Law basis: Old Grovebury Manor Farm Ltd v W Seymour Plant Sales and Hire Ltd (No 2) [1979] 1 WLR 1397; Landlord and Tenant (Covenants) Act 1995, s11Question 13 · Assignment and underlettingDraft, pending solicitor review
Umber Ltd's lease is guaranteed by its director, Val. Umber wants to assign the lease to Wisp Ltd, and the landlord proposes, as a condition of consent, that Val should give a fresh guarantee directly guaranteeing Wisp's performance of the tenant covenants for the rest of the term. Which of the following best describes the effect of such a guarantee?
- It would be void under the anti-avoidance rule, although Val could guarantee Umber's obligations under an AGA.Correct answer
- It would be valid, provided Val receives independent legal advice before signing the new guarantee.
- It would be valid, because a guarantor is free to guarantee any later tenant if it agrees to do so.
- It would be void, and Umber's own authorised guarantee agreement would also be void for the same reason.
- It would be valid for six months only, after which Val would be released automatically by statute.
The 1995 Act's anti-avoidance provision (s25) makes void any agreement which would frustrate the release of a tenant or its guarantor on assignment. In Good Harvest Partnership LLP v Centaur Services Ltd [2010] EWHC 330 (Ch), a guarantee by the outgoing tenant's guarantor directly of the assignee was held void. In K/S Victoria Street v House of Fraser (Stores Management) Ltd [2011] EWCA Civ 904, the Court of Appeal confirmed that the guarantor may, however, guarantee the outgoing tenant's obligations under its AGA. Umber's own AGA is permitted by s16.
Law basis: Landlord and Tenant (Covenants) Act 1995, ss 16, 24 and 25; K/S Victoria Street v House of Fraser [2011] EWCA Civ 904 ↗Question 14 · Assignment and underlettingDraft, pending solicitor review
Xylo Ltd's lease of offices was granted in 2017. It contains a qualified covenant against assignment and a clause stating that the landlord may withhold consent if the proposed assignee does not have pre-tax profits of at least three times the annual rent in each of its last three years. Xylo's proposed assignee has profits of twice the rent. Which of the following best describes the landlord's position?
- The landlord must consent, because pre-agreed conditions are void under the Landlord and Tenant Act 1988.
- The landlord may refuse, and this is not unreasonable because the lease specifies this circumstance.Correct answer
- The landlord may refuse only if it can also show that the assignee is likely to default on the rent.
- The landlord may refuse, but must pay Xylo compensation for loss of its proposed assignment.
- The landlord must consent, because a refusal based on financial tests is always unreasonable in law.
Section 19(1A) of the Landlord and Tenant Act 1927, added by the 1995 Act, applies to qualified covenants in non-residential leases granted on or after 1 January 1996. It allows the parties to agree in advance circumstances in which the landlord may withhold consent, or conditions subject to which it may grant consent. If the landlord withholds consent because such a circumstance exists, it is not unreasonably withholding consent. The assignee fails the agreed profits test, so the landlord may refuse without further justification. No compensation is payable.
Law basis: Landlord and Tenant Act 1927, s19(1A)Question 15 · Assignment and underlettingDraft, pending solicitor review
Yew Ltd holds a head lease which requires that any underlease must exclude the security of tenure provisions of the Landlord and Tenant Act 1954. Yew has agreed to underlet to Zed Ltd. Yew's draft underlease omits any contracting-out procedure, and completion is in two days. Which of the following is the best advice to Yew?
- Proceed, and contract out by agreement with Zed in a side letter at any time after completion.
- Complete the contracting-out procedure before Zed becomes bound, or Yew will breach the head lease.Correct answer
- Proceed, because the 1954 Act never applies to underleases of business premises, only to head leases.
- Proceed, because underleases are automatically excluded from the 1954 Act when the head lease says so.
- Proceed, because the head landlord cannot enforce conditions relating to the terms of an underlease.
Contracting out of ss 24 to 28 of the Landlord and Tenant Act 1954 requires compliance with s38A and the Regulatory Reform (Business Tenancies) (England and Wales) Order 2003: a warning notice served before the tenant becomes contractually bound and a simple or statutory declaration by the tenant, with a reference in the lease. It cannot be done after the tenancy is granted. If Yew grants an underlease that is not contracted out, it will breach the head lease condition, which the head landlord can enforce. The head lease cannot itself exclude the Act from the underlease.
Law basis: Landlord and Tenant Act 1954, s38A; Regulatory Reform (Business Tenancies) (England and Wales) Order 2003More Property Practice topics
Back to all Property Practice questions, or sit a timed mock.