Law covered in these questions
- Land Registration Act 2002, s27(1) and (2)(b)
- Law of Property Act 1925, ss 52 and 54(2)
- Walsh v Lonsdale (1882) 21 Ch D 9
- Land Registration Rules 2003, r58A
- RICS Code for Leasing Business Premises (1st edition, 2020)
- Land Registration Act 2002, ss 29 and 32
- Lease drafting practice
- Law of Property Act 1925, s62
- Holme v Brunskill (1878) 3 QBD 495
- RICS Code for Leasing Business Premises (2020)
- Marks and Spencer plc v BNP Paribas [2015] UKSC 72
- United Scientific Holdings Ltd v Burnley BC [1978] AC 904
- Lease rent review disregards
- Landlord and Tenant Act 1954, s34
All 14 questions with answers
Try them above first, then read the worked answers below.
Question 1 · Grant of a commercial leaseDraft, pending solicitor review
Willow Ltd took a new lease of a warehouse for a term of ten years, granted by deed. Completion took place six months ago, but its solicitor forgot to apply to HM Land Registry to register the lease. Which of the following best describes Willow's interest?
- It has only an equitable lease, because a lease for more than seven years does not operate at law until registered.Correct answer
- It has no interest at all, because an unregistered lease of over seven years is void against the landlord.
- It has a legal lease, provided the landlord's freehold title is noted to show the lease within two years.
- It has a legal lease, because the lease was granted by deed and this is all the law requires for a legal lease.
- It has a legal lease, which overrides any registered disposition of the freehold because it is under 21 years.
Under s27(2)(b) of the Land Registration Act 2002, the grant of a lease of registered land for a term of more than seven years is a registrable disposition, and under s27(1) it does not operate at law until the registration requirements are met. Until registration Willow has an equitable lease, binding on the landlord but vulnerable against a buyer of the reversion unless it is protected or overrides through actual occupation. Only leases of seven years or less override as legal leases under Sch 3 para 1. The lease is not void between the parties.
Law basis: Land Registration Act 2002, s27(1) and (2)(b) ↗Question 2 · Grant of a commercial leaseDraft, pending solicitor review
Xenia agreed to take a five-year lease of a shop at a market rent from Yorick. The lease document was signed by both parties but not witnessed and not stated to be a deed. Xenia has gone into occupation. Which of the following best describes her interest?
- She holds an equitable lease, because a lease exceeding three years must be made by deed to be legal.Correct answer
- She holds a legal lease, provided it is registered at HM Land Registry within two months.
- She holds no interest at all, because a lease not made by deed is void for all purposes.
- She holds a legal lease, because she has gone into occupation and is paying the rent required.
- She holds a legal lease, because a lease at a market rent never needs to be made by deed at all.
Under s52 of the Law of Property Act 1925, a legal lease must be made by deed, subject to the exception in s54(2) for leases taking effect in possession for a term not exceeding three years at the best rent reasonably obtainable without a fine. Xenia's lease is for five years, so the exception does not apply. A signed written agreement complying with s2 of the 1989 Act takes effect as an equitable lease (Walsh v Lonsdale (1882) 21 Ch D 9). Her occupation and payment of rent may also give rise to a legal periodic tenancy.
Law basis: Law of Property Act 1925, ss 52 and 54(2); Walsh v Lonsdale (1882) 21 Ch D 9Question 3 · Grant of a commercial leaseDraft, pending solicitor review
Zinnia Ltd's solicitor is drafting a 15-year lease of an office floor in a registered building. The landlord's solicitor reminds her that the lease must contain certain information at the front. Which of the following best describes the requirement?
- The lease must begin with a summary of the rent review provisions, as required by the Code for Leasing.
- A registrable lease must begin with the prescribed clauses LR1 to LR14 under the Land Registration Rules.Correct answer
- Every lease, whatever its length, must contain a schedule of dilapidations at the front of the document.
- No particular information is required, as HM Land Registry accepts any lease of more than seven years.
- The lease must begin with the landlord's warning notice and the tenant's declaration contracting out.
Under rule 58A of the Land Registration Rules 2003, a lease granted on or after 19 June 2006 which is required to be completed by registration must contain the prescribed clauses (LR1 to LR14) at its beginning, covering matters such as the parties, the property, the term, rights granted and reserved, restrictive covenants and any options. This helps HM Land Registry register the lease. A schedule of condition or a summary of rent review is not a statutory requirement, and contracting-out documents are separate from the lease itself.
Law basis: Land Registration Rules 2003, r58AQuestion 4 · Grant of a commercial leaseDraft, pending solicitor review
Abacus Ltd is negotiating a new lease of shop premises. The landlord's letting agent is a member of the Royal Institution of Chartered Surveyors. Abacus's solicitor wants to know what protections the RICS Code for Leasing Business Premises gives at the negotiation stage. Which of the following best describes the position?
- The Code is purely voluntary guidance with no mandatory requirements, so the agent may ignore it entirely.
- The Code requires every landlord to grant leases of at least ten years without any break clause.
- The Code requires the landlord to pay the tenant's legal costs of negotiating the lease in every case.
- The Code gives the tenant a statutory right to rescind the lease if the landlord does not comply with it.
- The agent must follow its mandatory rules, such as heads of terms stating if the lease is contracted out.Correct answer
The RICS Code for Leasing Business Premises (1st edition, 2020) is a professional statement that RICS members must follow. Its mandatory requirements include ensuring that the parties are aware of the Code, and that heads of terms deal with matters such as the length of term, rent and review, whether the lease is to be contracted out of the Landlord and Tenant Act 1954, repairing obligations, alienation, insurance and service charges. It does not prescribe particular lease terms, give the tenant statutory rescission rights or determine who pays costs.
Law basis: RICS Code for Leasing Business Premises (1st edition, 2020)Question 5 · Grant of a commercial leaseDraft, pending solicitor review
Bolt Ltd has signed an agreement for lease under which the landlord will carry out fitting-out works to a new unit, and the lease will be granted once the works are certified complete. The landlord has money troubles and may sell the building. Which of the following best protects Bolt?
- Register a Class C(iv) land charge at the Land Charges Department in Plymouth.
- Rely on the agreement, which binds any buyer of the building automatically.
- Enter a restriction on the title preventing any sale until the works are done.
- Take occupation of the unit at once, which will protect the agreement in all cases.
- Protect the agreement for lease by a notice on the landlord's registered title.Correct answer
An agreement for lease is an estate contract. To bind a buyer of the landlord's registered title, it should be protected by entering a notice under s32 of the Land Registration Act 2002; otherwise a registered disposition for value could take free of it (s29), unless Bolt were in actual occupation within Sch 3 para 2, which is unlikely before the works finish. A restriction is used to control dispositions rather than to protect the priority of an interest like this. A land charge registration applies to unregistered land.
Law basis: Land Registration Act 2002, ss 29 and 32 ↗Question 6 · Grant of a commercial leaseDraft, pending solicitor review
Cobalt Ltd is taking a lease of the second floor of an office block. The draft lease grants Cobalt the right to use the entrance hall, lifts and stairs, but says nothing about the car park, which Cobalt's staff have been told they can use, or about running cables through the building's service ducts. Which of the following is the best advice?
- No change is needed, as the agent's statement about car parking will be binding as part of the lease terms.
- Cobalt should seek a separate licence for the car park after completion, as leases cannot include parking.
- Cobalt should require express rights for the car park and the use of service conduits to be included in the lease.Correct answer
- No change is needed, as a tenant of part automatically acquires every right reasonably useful for its business.
- No change is needed, as rights to use service conduits are implied into all commercial leases by statute.
On a lease of part, the tenant's rights over the landlord's retained parts depend mainly on express grant. Implied rights are limited, uncertain and unlikely to extend to car parking or new service media. Pre-contract statements by an agent are not lease terms, and the lease will usually contain an entire agreement clause. Cobalt's solicitor should ensure the lease expressly grants rights to use specified car parking spaces and to use and connect to service conduits, and that these rights cannot be varied to its detriment without suitable alternatives.
Law basis: Lease drafting practice; Law of Property Act 1925, s62Question 7 · Grant of a commercial leaseDraft, pending solicitor review
Dynamo Ltd's lease is guaranteed by its parent company. Without telling the guarantor, the landlord and Dynamo agree a variation increasing the rent by 20% and extending the tenant's repairing obligations. The lease contains no clause dealing with variations. Dynamo then defaults. Which of the following best describes the guarantor's position?
- The guarantor remains liable for all sums, because a guarantee covers whatever the tenant agrees to pay.
- The guarantor remains liable in full, because the parent company controls the tenant and must have known.
- The guarantor is likely to be released, because a material variation was made without its consent.Correct answer
- The guarantor remains liable only for the original rent, but is bound by the new repairing covenant.
- The guarantor is released only if it can show that it suffered actual financial loss from the variation.
Under the rule in Holme v Brunskill (1878) 3 QBD 495, a guarantor is discharged if the principal contract is varied without its consent, unless the variation is obviously insubstantial or cannot be prejudicial. A 20% rent increase and heavier repairing obligations are material. Many leases include a clause preserving the guarantor's liability despite variations, but this lease does not, and s18 of the Landlord and Tenant (Covenants) Act 1995 also limits a former tenant's and its guarantor's liability for later variations. Corporate relationship does not amount to consent.
Law basis: Holme v Brunskill (1878) 3 QBD 495Question 8 · Grant of a commercial leaseDraft, pending solicitor review
Echo Ltd is negotiating a ten-year lease with a tenant's break at year five. The landlord's draft makes the break conditional on the tenant having 'materially complied with all tenant covenants'. Echo's solicitor wants to reduce the risk that the break fails. Which of the following is the best approach?
- Limit the conditions to payment of the basic rent due and giving up occupation, as the Code for Leasing encourages.Correct answer
- Delete all conditions, so that the tenant can break even if it is still in occupation on the break date.
- Make the break conditional on full compliance, which is the safest wording for the tenant to accept.
- Accept the draft, because the landlord must waive any condition that is not complied with by the break date.
- Accept the draft, because courts will always treat a minor breach as compliance with a break condition.
Break clauses are construed strictly and conditions must be strictly satisfied; a tenant who fails a condition loses the break. Wide conditions requiring compliance with all covenants are dangerous, as almost any breach, such as minor disrepair, may defeat the break. The RICS Code for Leasing Business Premises 2020 recommends that break conditions should be limited to paying the main rent, giving up occupation and leaving behind no continuing subleases. A requirement to give up occupation is reasonable, so deleting all conditions is unlikely to be agreed.
Law basis: RICS Code for Leasing Business Premises (2020); Marks and Spencer plc v BNP Paribas [2015] UKSC 72Question 9 · Grant of a commercial leaseDraft, pending solicitor review
Fable Ltd's 15-year lease provides for upward-only open market rent reviews every five years, to be triggered by the landlord serving notice 'not later than six months before the review date'. The landlord served notice two months late. Fable argues that the review cannot now take place. Which of the following best describes the position?
- The review cannot proceed, because a landlord who misses a deadline is treated as waiving the review.
- The review can proceed, but only if the landlord pays Fable compensation for the late notice.
- The review can proceed, because time is presumed not to be of the essence in rent review provisions.Correct answer
- The review cannot proceed, because a time limit in a lease is always treated as of the essence.
- The review can proceed only if Fable has not yet paid the rent due on the relevant review date.
In United Scientific Holdings Ltd v Burnley BC [1978] AC 904, the House of Lords held that there is a presumption that time is not of the essence in rent review clauses, so a party may operate the review late unless the lease expressly makes time of the essence or there are contra-indications, such as an interrelated tenant's break clause. The wording here is a simple time limit, so the review can proceed. Delay does not by itself amount to waiver, and no compensation is payable for late operation.
Law basis: United Scientific Holdings Ltd v Burnley BC [1978] AC 904Question 10 · Grant of a commercial leaseDraft, pending solicitor review
Garnet Ltd installed a mezzanine floor in its leased warehouse at its own cost, with the landlord's consent and under no obligation to do so. The rent review clause requires a hypothetical letting on the terms of the lease, with the usual disregards. At review, the landlord's surveyor values the unit including the mezzanine. Which of the following best describes the position?
- The mezzanine must be valued, because the landlord gave consent and so shares in the improvement.
- The mezzanine should be disregarded only if Garnet agrees to remove it at the end of the lease.
- The mezzanine should be valued at half its cost, to share the benefit between the two parties.
- The mezzanine should be disregarded, as a tenant's voluntary improvement carried out with consent.Correct answer
- The mezzanine must be valued, because all improvements become part of the landlord's premises.
Commercial leases normally require certain matters to be disregarded at rent review, typically the tenant's occupation, goodwill and voluntary improvements carried out with consent other than under an obligation to the landlord. This prevents the tenant paying rent on its own investment, mirroring s34 of the Landlord and Tenant Act 1954 for statutory renewals. The mezzanine was a voluntary improvement made with consent, so it should be disregarded. The landlord's consent does not make it a landlord's improvement for valuation, and there is no rule of splitting its value.
Law basis: Lease rent review disregards; Landlord and Tenant Act 1954, s34Question 11 · Grant of a commercial leaseDraft, pending solicitor review
Harbour Ltd is taking a lease of a whole building. Under the draft, the landlord insures and recovers the premium from the tenant. Harbour's solicitor wants to protect it if the building is destroyed by fire. Which of the following provisions are most important for Harbour?
- A covenant by Harbour to rebuild the premises at its own cost, so that the landlord's policy is never needed.
- A clause allowing the landlord to keep the insurance money if it decides not to rebuild the premises.
- A clause making Harbour liable for any shortfall in insurance money caused by the landlord's own breach.
- An obligation on Harbour to keep paying full rent while the landlord reinstates, so its lease is preserved.
- Rent suspension while the building is unusable from an insured risk, and a right to end the lease if it is not reinstated in time.Correct answer
Where the landlord insures, the tenant should seek a landlord's covenant to reinstate using the insurance money, suspension of rent (and service charge) while the premises are unfit because of damage by an insured risk (with the landlord insuring loss of rent), and a right for either party, or at least the tenant, to terminate if reinstatement has not occurred within a stated period. The tenant should not take on rebuilding obligations or uninsured shortfalls caused by the landlord. These points are also reflected in the RICS Code for Leasing Business Premises.
Law basis: RICS Code for Leasing Business Premises (2020); lease insurance provisionsQuestion 12 · Grant of a commercial leaseDraft, pending solicitor review
Indigo Ltd is taking a five-year lease and has agreed to provide a rent deposit equal to six months' rent. Its solicitor is reviewing the rent deposit deed. Indigo is worried the landlord might become insolvent. Which of the following provisions best protects Indigo?
- The deposit may be used by the landlord for any purpose, provided it returns an equal sum on expiry.
- The deposit becomes the landlord's property on payment and is credited only at the end of the lease term.
- The deposit is held in a separate designated account, with Indigo's ownership and the landlord's charge clearly recorded.Correct answer
- The deposit is held without any written deed, so that the landlord can repay it informally at any time.
- The deposit is paid into the landlord's general business account, so it is available to pay the landlord's debts.
A tenant's rent deposit is at risk if the landlord becomes insolvent and the money is mixed with its own funds. Indigo should insist that the deed provides that the money remains its property, held in a separate, designated account, with the landlord taking only a charge to secure the tenant's obligations, interest accruing for the tenant and clear provisions for repayment (for example on assignment or expiry). If the money becomes the landlord's property, Indigo would be an unsecured creditor on insolvency.
Law basis: Rent deposit deed practice; Insolvency Act 1986Question 13 · Grant of a commercial leaseDraft, pending solicitor review
Jasper Ltd is taking a lease of offices in a multi-let building. The draft service charge clause allows the landlord to recover the cost of 'any services, works or improvements the landlord in its discretion considers desirable'. Which of the following is the best amendment for Jasper to seek?
- Ask for the service charge to be fixed for the term at the level of the first year's estimate.
- Accept the clause, but require the landlord to obtain three quotes for any works costing under £100.
- Delete the service charge clause, as tenants of multi-let buildings never contribute to the landlord's costs.
- Limit recovery to reasonable costs of maintenance and repair, and exclude improvements and initial construction defects.Correct answer
- Accept the clause, because the landlord's discretion is automatically subject to a duty to act reasonably.
In a multi-let building, the landlord will recover the cost of services through a service charge. The tenant should limit recovery to reasonable and properly incurred costs of specified services, repairs and maintenance, exclude improvements, initial construction defects and costs of letting other units, and seek a cap if appropriate. The RICS professional statement on service charges in commercial property supports such principles. Commercial tenants do not have the statutory protections given to residential tenants under the Landlord and Tenant Act 1985, so drafting matters.
Law basis: RICS Professional Statement, Service charges in commercial property (1st edition, 2018)Question 14 · Grant of a commercial leaseDraft, pending solicitor review
Kestrel Charity is taking a lease of an office building. The landlord has not yet opted to tax the building, and Kestrel's activities are mainly VAT-exempt, so it cannot recover VAT. Which of the following is the most important protection for Kestrel's solicitor to seek?
- Nothing, because charities are always exempt from paying VAT on rent under commercial leases.
- A covenant by the landlord not to opt to tax, or a cap on the VAT the tenant must pay on the rent.Correct answer
- A covenant by the landlord to register Kestrel for VAT so that it can recover VAT on the rent.
- A covenant by Kestrel to pay any VAT on the rent, as that is the usual position for exempt tenants.
- Nothing, because a lease of commercial property can never become subject to VAT once it has been granted.
The grant of a lease of commercial property is exempt from VAT, but the landlord may opt to tax under Schedule 10 to the Value Added Tax Act 1994, making rent standard-rated. Leases usually require the tenant to pay any VAT on the rent. A tenant making exempt supplies, such as many charities, banks and insurers, cannot recover that VAT, so an option to tax effectively increases its rent. It should therefore seek a landlord's covenant not to opt to tax during the term, or a cap. Charitable status does not of itself exempt rent from VAT.
Law basis: Value Added Tax Act 1994, Sch 9 Group 1 and Sch 10 ↗More Property Practice topics
Back to all Property Practice questions, or sit a timed mock.