Law covered in these questions
- Landlord and Tenant Act 1927, s18(1)
- Leasehold Property (Repairs) Act 1938, s1
- Law of Property Act 1925, s146
- Jervis v Harris [1996] Ch 195
- Ravenseft Properties Ltd v Davstone (Holdings) Ltd [1980] QB 12
- Proudfoot v Hart (1890) 25 QBD 42
- Landlord and Tenant Act 1927, s19(2)
- Landlord and Tenant Act 1927, s19(3)
- Rent review valuation principles
- hypothetical letting on the terms of the lease
- Implied covenant for quiet enjoyment
- Southwark LBC v Mills [2001] 1 AC 1
- Port v Griffith [1938] 1 All ER 295
- Co-operative Insurance Society Ltd v Argyll Stores (Holdings) Ltd [1998] AC 1
All 16 questions with answers
Try them above first, then read the worked answers below.
Question 1 · Lease covenantsDraft, pending solicitor review
Lark Ltd's lease of a 1970s office block has expired and the landlord claims £400,000 for breach of the tenant's repairing covenant. The landlord's valuer says the diminution in the value of the reversion caused by the disrepair is only £150,000, because the building is likely to be substantially redeveloped. Which of the following best describes Lark's maximum liability?
- Its damages cannot exceed the diminution in value of the reversion, so £150,000 at most.Correct answer
- Its damages are nil, because a tenant's repairing covenant ends automatically when a lease expires.
- Its damages are the full £400,000, because the cap applies only to claims made during the lease term.
- Its damages are £400,000 less any rent paid in the final year of the lease term as a set-off.
- Its damages are the full £400,000, because it is liable for the cost of putting the building in repair.
Under s18(1) of the Landlord and Tenant Act 1927, damages for breach of a covenant to keep or put premises in repair cannot exceed the amount by which the value of the reversion is diminished by the breach. Further, no damages are recoverable for failure to repair where the premises are to be pulled down or structurally altered so that the repairs would be valueless. Repair cost is usually the starting point, but the cap limits recovery to £150,000 here, and possibly less if demolition is intended. Liability for breaches during the term survives expiry.
Law basis: Landlord and Tenant Act 1927, s18(1)Question 2 · Lease covenantsDraft, pending solicitor review
Merlin Ltd holds a 15-year lease of a warehouse with eight years left. The landlord wants to forfeit for breach of the tenant's repairing covenant and serves a notice under s146 of the Law of Property Act 1925. Which of the following must the notice include?
- A schedule of works certified by the local authority's building control officer as essential.
- A demand for all arrears of rent, because forfeiture for disrepair requires rent to be outstanding.
- A statement that the landlord will re-enter in seven days, with no other information about remedies.
- A statement offering the tenant a new lease on different terms in place of the existing lease.
- A statement of the tenant's right to serve a counter-notice under the Leasehold Property (Repairs) Act 1938.Correct answer
The Leasehold Property (Repairs) Act 1938 applies to leases of seven years or more with at least three years unexpired. A s146 notice relating to repairing covenants must inform the tenant of its right to serve a counter-notice within 28 days claiming the benefit of the Act. If the tenant does so, the landlord cannot proceed to forfeit or claim damages without the court's leave, which requires proof of one of the grounds in s1(5). The notice need not demand rent or include certified schedules, though it must specify the breach and require it to be remedied.
Law basis: Leasehold Property (Repairs) Act 1938, s1; Law of Property Act 1925, s146Question 3 · Lease covenantsDraft, pending solicitor review
Nova Ltd's lease of a shop has 12 years left. It contains a clause allowing the landlord, if the tenant fails to carry out repairs after notice, to enter, do the works and recover the cost 'as a debt'. Nova ignored a notice; the landlord did the works and claims the cost. Nova argues the landlord needs the court's leave under the Leasehold Property (Repairs) Act 1938. Which of the following best describes the position?
- The landlord may recover the cost as a debt without the court's leave, as the 1938 Act applies to damages claims, not debts.Correct answer
- The landlord can recover only the diminution in value of the reversion, under s18 of the 1927 Act.
- The landlord cannot recover anything, because a landlord may never enter to carry out the tenant's repairs.
- The landlord may recover the cost only if it first forfeits the lease and then re-lets the shop.
- The landlord needs leave, because the 1938 Act applies to every claim connected with the tenant's repairs.
In Jervis v Harris [1996] Ch 195, the Court of Appeal held that a landlord's claim under a self-help clause to recover the cost of repairs it carried out after the tenant's default is a claim in debt, not damages for breach of the repairing covenant. It is therefore outside the Leasehold Property (Repairs) Act 1938 and the s18(1) cap in the Landlord and Tenant Act 1927. Such clauses are a common and powerful landlord's remedy. The landlord must follow the clause's procedure carefully, including the notice and the right of entry.
Law basis: Jervis v Harris [1996] Ch 195Question 4 · Lease covenantsDraft, pending solicitor review
Opal Ltd's lease of a 1960s building contains a tenant's covenant to 'keep the premises in good repair'. Stone cladding has begun to come away because no expansion joints were included when the building was constructed. Fixing it safely requires inserting expansion joints, adding about 5% to the cost of the work. Which of the following best describes Opal's liability?
- The work is likely to be repair, as inserting the joints does not give back something wholly different from what was let.Correct answer
- The work is an improvement for which the landlord is liable, as only the landlord may remedy inherent defects.
- The work cannot be repair, because any work which costs more than the original construction is excluded.
- The work cannot be repair, because a tenant is never liable for a defect existing when the building was built.
- The work is repair only if the lease expressly mentions inherent defects in the definition of repair.
Whether work is repair is a question of degree. In Ravenseft Properties Ltd v Davstone (Holdings) Ltd [1980] QB 12, remedying cladding that was dangerous because no expansion joints had been included was held to be repair: the joints were a small part of the work and did not change the character of the building into something wholly different from what was demised. There is no rule that inherent defects are excluded from repair. The tenant's solicitor should consider excluding inherent defects expressly when negotiating the lease.
Law basis: Ravenseft Properties Ltd v Davstone (Holdings) Ltd [1980] QB 12Question 5 · Lease covenantsDraft, pending solicitor review
Pine Ltd is taking a ten-year lease of an old warehouse that is already in poor repair. The draft lease requires the tenant 'to put and keep the premises in good repair'. Pine is not prepared to pay to improve the building's existing condition. Which of the following is the best advice?
- The covenant is unenforceable, because a tenant cannot be required to repair defects existing at the grant.
- The covenant will be read down by the court at the end of the lease to reflect the condition at the grant.
- The covenant requires Pine to repair only the interior, so external disrepair is the landlord's problem.
- It would oblige Pine to put the building into repair first, so liability should be tied to a schedule of condition.Correct answer
- The covenant would only require Pine to keep the building in its current condition, so no change is needed.
A covenant to keep premises in repair obliges the tenant first to put them into repair if they are in disrepair at the start (Proudfoot v Hart (1890) 25 QBD 42), and 'put and keep' makes this explicit. A tenant taking an old building should limit its obligation so it need not put the premises in any better state than shown in a photographic schedule of condition annexed to the lease. Courts will not read such a covenant down later, and a general repairing covenant covers the whole premises demised, not just the interior.
Law basis: Proudfoot v Hart (1890) 25 QBD 42Question 6 · Lease covenantsDraft, pending solicitor review
Quince Ltd's lease of a factory contains a covenant 'not to make any alterations or additions to the premises without the landlord's consent'. Quince wants to install a new loading bay door, which would improve the premises and increase their letting value. The landlord refuses consent without giving reasons. Which of the following best describes the position?
- The landlord may refuse for any reason, because the lease does not say consent will not be unreasonably withheld.
- Quince may carry out the works without consent, because improvements never need the landlord's consent.
- Consent to an improvement under a qualified covenant must not be unreasonably withheld, so Quince may seek a declaration.Correct answer
- The landlord must consent, but may charge Quince a premium of up to one year's rent for granting consent.
- The landlord may refuse, because the statutory reasonableness rule applies only to assignment, not alterations.
Under s19(2) of the Landlord and Tenant Act 1927, a covenant against making improvements without the landlord's consent is deemed to be subject to a proviso that consent is not to be unreasonably withheld. The landlord may require payment of a reasonable sum for any damage or diminution in value of the premises or neighbouring premises, legal and other expenses, and, where reasonable, an undertaking to reinstate. It cannot demand a premium for consent. Quince may apply to court for a declaration that consent is being unreasonably withheld, but should not proceed without consent.
Law basis: Landlord and Tenant Act 1927, s19(2)Question 7 · Lease covenantsDraft, pending solicitor review
Rowan Ltd's lease contains an absolute covenant 'not to make any structural alterations to the premises'. Rowan wants to remove a load-bearing wall to create an open-plan office, which would be an improvement. The landlord refuses permission. Which of the following best describes the position?
- Rowan may carry out the work, provided it pays the landlord compensation for any loss in value of the building.
- The landlord may refuse for any reason, because statute does not imply reasonableness into an absolute covenant.Correct answer
- The landlord must not unreasonably refuse, because all covenants about improvements are subject to reasonableness.
- Rowan may carry out the work, because a covenant against structural alterations is void in a commercial lease.
- The landlord must consent if Rowan provides an undertaking to reinstate the wall at the end of the lease.
Section 19(2) of the Landlord and Tenant Act 1927 applies only to qualified covenants, that is, covenants against making improvements without the landlord's consent. Where the covenant is absolute, the landlord can refuse for any reason or none, and the tenant has no statutory right to insist. The landlord may of course choose to waive the covenant by granting a licence for alterations. That is why a tenant should negotiate qualified rather than absolute alteration covenants, at least for non-structural works.
Law basis: Landlord and Tenant Act 1927, s19(2)Question 8 · Lease covenantsDraft, pending solicitor review
Sable Ltd's lease of a shop contains a covenant not to use the premises other than as a bookshop 'without the landlord's consent'. Sable asks for consent to change the use to a gift shop. The landlord says it will consent only if the rent is increased by 10%. Which of the following best describes the position?
- The landlord may demand the increase, provided it is no more than the open market rent for the new use.
- The landlord may demand the increase, because it is entitled to share in any benefit from a change of use.
- The landlord cannot demand anything, and must consent within 28 days or be treated as having consented.
- The landlord must consent without any conditions, because consent to change of use cannot be unreasonably withheld.
- The landlord cannot demand increased rent for consent, although statute does not require it to act reasonably in refusing.Correct answer
Section 19(3) of the Landlord and Tenant Act 1927 provides that where a lease contains a qualified covenant against change of use, no fine or sum of money in the nature of a fine, whether by increase of rent or otherwise, may be required for consent, unless the change involves structural alteration. The landlord may require reasonable legal and other expenses. Unlike s19(1) and (2), s19(3) does not imply that consent cannot be unreasonably withheld, so the landlord may still refuse, but it cannot sell its consent for extra rent.
Law basis: Landlord and Tenant Act 1927, s19(3)Question 9 · Lease covenantsDraft, pending solicitor review
Tarn Ltd, a landlord, is granting a 15-year lease of a unit in its retail park. It proposes to limit the permitted use to 'the sale of children's shoes only' to protect its tenant mix. Tarn's surveyor warns about the effect on future rent reviews. Which of the following best describes the likely effect?
- A narrow user clause is likely to increase the rent at review, because it reduces competition for the premises.
- A narrow user clause is likely to reduce the open market rent at review, as the hypothetical tenant has few options.Correct answer
- A narrow user clause has no effect at review, because the valuer must assume any lawful use is permitted.
- A narrow user clause will be ignored at review, because user clauses cannot be enforced against tenants.
- A narrow user clause increases the rent, because the landlord must be compensated for limiting the use.
At rent review, the valuer assumes a hypothetical letting on the terms of the actual lease (other than rent), unless the review clause states otherwise. A highly restrictive user clause limits the pool of hypothetical tenants and so tends to depress the open market rent. Landlords therefore balance estate management benefits against reduced rental value; sometimes the review clause assumes a wider use, though such assumptions must be clear. There is no default assumption that any lawful use is permitted.
Law basis: Rent review valuation principles; hypothetical letting on the terms of the leaseQuestion 10 · Lease covenantsDraft, pending solicitor review
Ula Ltd leases the ground floor of an office building from Vortex Ltd, which retains the upper floors. For six months, Vortex's contractors have erected scaffolding blocking the entrance and made constant drilling noise while refurbishing the upper floors, making Ula's offices barely usable. The lease contains no express covenant for quiet enjoyment. Which of the following best describes Ula's position?
- Ula may claim for breach of the implied covenant for quiet enjoyment, as the interference is substantial.Correct answer
- Ula may claim only in nuisance against the contractors, as the landlord cannot be liable for contractors.
- Ula has no claim, because quiet enjoyment protects only against noise and not against physical obstruction.
- Ula may forfeit the lease, because a tenant has a statutory right to end a lease for the landlord's breach.
- Ula has no claim, because a landlord's covenant for quiet enjoyment is never implied into a written lease.
A covenant for quiet enjoyment is implied into every lease unless expressly displaced. It is broken by acts of the landlord, or those claiming under it, which substantially interfere with the tenant's possession and ordinary use of the premises, including physical obstruction of access and serious disturbance from works. Ula may claim damages or an injunction. A landlord can be liable for acts it authorises through contractors. Forfeiture is a landlord's remedy, not a tenant's.
Law basis: Implied covenant for quiet enjoyment; Southwark LBC v Mills [2001] 1 AC 1Question 11 · Lease covenantsDraft, pending solicitor review
Willow Books Ltd leases a shop in a parade owned by Xeno Ltd. The lease contains no covenant by Xeno restricting the use of other units. Xeno now lets the neighbouring unit to a large rival bookseller. Willow claims Xeno has breached its obligation not to derogate from its grant. Which of the following best describes the position?
- There is a breach, because a landlord impliedly promises never to let neighbouring units to a competitor.
- There is a breach, provided Willow can show that its profits have fallen since the rival opened.
- There is no breach, as letting nearby to a competitor does not make Willow's premises unfit for the purpose of the letting.Correct answer
- There is no breach, because non-derogation from grant only applies to leases of residential property.
- There is a breach, because a landlord must always protect a tenant's goodwill against loss of trade.
A landlord must not derogate from its grant by using its retained land in a way that makes the demised premises unfit or materially less fit for the purpose for which they were let. However, letting neighbouring premises to a trade competitor does not, by itself, amount to derogation (Port v Griffith [1938] 1 All ER 295), since the premises remain usable as a bookshop. A tenant wanting protection from competition must negotiate an express covenant restricting the landlord's use of adjoining property. The principle applies to commercial as well as residential leases.
Law basis: Port v Griffith [1938] 1 All ER 295Question 12 · Lease covenantsDraft, pending solicitor review
Yarrow plc is the anchor tenant of a shopping centre under a lease containing a covenant to keep the premises open for retail trade during normal hours. The store is loss-making and Yarrow closes it, while continuing to pay rent. The landlord seeks an order requiring Yarrow to reopen. Which of the following best describes the likely outcome?
- The court will order a rent increase, because that is the only remedy for breach of a keep-open covenant.
- The court will order Yarrow to reopen, because keep-open covenants are always specifically enforced.
- The court will dismiss the claim, because keep-open covenants are void as being in restraint of trade.
- The court will normally refuse specific performance of a keep-open covenant and award damages instead.Correct answer
- The court will order Yarrow to reopen, unless Yarrow offers to surrender its lease to the landlord.
In Co-operative Insurance Society Ltd v Argyll Stores (Holdings) Ltd [1998] AC 1, the House of Lords held that, as a matter of settled practice, the courts will not normally order specific performance of a covenant to carry on a business, because it would require constant supervision and could cause the defendant losses disproportionate to the claimant's gain. The landlord's remedy is damages, which can be substantial if the closure harms the rest of the centre. Keep-open covenants are valid, and there is no rule converting the remedy into increased rent.
Law basis: Co-operative Insurance Society Ltd v Argyll Stores (Holdings) Ltd [1998] AC 1Question 13 · Lease covenantsDraft, pending solicitor review
Zircon Ltd's lease of a factory is ending. During the term, Zircon bolted heavy machine presses to the floor for its manufacturing business. The landlord says these are fixtures which now belong to it. Which of the following best describes Zircon's position?
- The presses are tenant's trade fixtures, which Zircon may remove before the lease ends, making good any damage.Correct answer
- The presses may be removed at any time within six years after the end of the lease, without making good.
- The presses may be removed only if the landlord consents, because they are landlord's fixtures.
- The presses belong to the landlord, because anything fixed to the land becomes part of it permanently.
- The presses belong to the landlord unless the lease expressly reserved them to the tenant on grant.
Tenant's trade fixtures, installed for the purposes of the tenant's trade, may be removed by the tenant during the term (and, under some authorities, within a reasonable time if the tenant remains in possession), even though they are attached to the land. The tenant must make good damage caused by removal (Mancetter Developments Ltd v Garmanson Ltd [1986] QB 1212). If not removed by the end of the tenancy, they may become the landlord's property. The lease should be checked, as it may require reinstatement or deal with fixtures expressly.
Law basis: Mancetter Developments Ltd v Garmanson Ltd [1986] QB 1212Question 14 · Lease covenantsDraft, pending solicitor review
Aster Ltd's lease of offices expired a month ago and it has moved out. The landlord's surveyor has just served a schedule of dilapidations with a quantified demand. Aster's directors ask what happens next under the relevant pre-action protocol. Which of the following best describes the tenant's position?
- Aster must pay the full amount claimed within 14 days, or the landlord may forfeit the expired lease.
- Aster should refer the claim to the local authority, which decides dilapidations disputes for landlords.
- Aster must carry out all of the works itself within 56 days, as the lease has already come to an end.
- Aster need do nothing until court proceedings are issued, as the protocol imposes obligations on landlords only.
- Aster should respond within 56 days, setting out its case on each item, before any court proceedings are begun.Correct answer
The Pre-Action Protocol for Claims for Damages in relation to the Physical State of Commercial Property at Termination of a Tenancy (the Dilapidations Protocol) requires the landlord to send a schedule, normally within 56 days after termination, and the tenant to send a response within 56 days of receiving it, addressing each item and any s18 Landlord and Tenant Act 1927 cap. The parties should then try to resolve the dispute, considering ADR. Failure to comply can lead to costs sanctions. Forfeiture is irrelevant after expiry.
Law basis: Pre-Action Protocol for Claims for Damages in relation to the Physical State of Commercial Property at Termination of a TenancyQuestion 15 · Lease covenantsDraft, pending solicitor review
Birch Ltd leases a flat-roofed single-storey unit in a parade. The lease places repair of the structure, including the roof, on the landlord. Water has been leaking through the roof into Birch's unit for weeks, but Birch has not told the landlord, which has not inspected. Birch now claims damages for breach of the landlord's repairing covenant. Which of the following best describes the position?
- The landlord is not liable, because a landlord's repairing covenant only protects tenants of residential property.
- The landlord is generally liable only once it has notice of disrepair within the premises let, so Birch should notify it.Correct answer
- The landlord is not liable, because a tenant must repair defects that it discovers within its own premises.
- The landlord is strictly liable from the moment the leak began, whether or not it knew of the disrepair.
- The landlord is liable only if Birch first carries out the repairs and then claims the cost as a debt.
Where a landlord covenants to repair premises let to the tenant, it is generally not in breach until it has notice of the disrepair and a reasonable time to repair (O'Brien v Robinson [1973] AC 912), because the tenant, not the landlord, is in occupation. By contrast, for parts retained by the landlord, liability arises as soon as disrepair occurs (British Telecommunications plc v Sun Life Assurance Society plc [1996] Ch 69). Whether this roof is demised or retained depends on the lease, so Birch should notify the landlord promptly in writing.
Law basis: O'Brien v Robinson [1973] AC 912; British Telecommunications plc v Sun Life Assurance Society plc [1996] Ch 69Question 16 · Lease covenantsDraft, pending solicitor review
Cedar Ltd owns a shop in England, let on a lease due to expire next month. The shop has a valid EPC rating of F and no exemption is registered. Cedar plans to grant a new five-year lease to a new tenant. Which of the following best describes the position?
- Cedar may grant the lease, provided the tenant agrees in writing to carry out the improvements itself.
- Cedar may grant the lease, because the minimum standards apply only to leases of more than 99 years.
- Cedar may grant the lease, because a rating of F is the minimum lawful rating for commercial property.
- Cedar must not grant the new lease unless it improves the rating to at least E or registers a valid exemption.Correct answer
- Cedar may grant the lease, because the minimum standards apply only to residential lettings in England.
The Energy Efficiency (Private Rented Property) (England and Wales) Regulations 2015 prohibit a landlord of non-domestic private rented property from granting a new tenancy (and, since 1 April 2023, from continuing to let) where the EPC rating is below E, unless a valid exemption is registered on the PRS Exemptions Register. Cedar must improve the rating or register an exemption before granting the lease. The regulations apply to qualifying leases of between six months and 99 years, and responsibility cannot simply be shifted to the tenant by agreement.
Law basis: Energy Efficiency (Private Rented Property) (England and Wales) Regulations 2015, regs 27 and 33More Property Practice topics
Back to all Property Practice questions, or sit a timed mock.