Law covered in these questions
- Wills Act 1837 s 9
- Wills Act 1837 s 9 (as substituted by Administration of Justice Act 1982 s 17)
- Wills Act 1837 s 9(a)
- In the Estate of Finn (1935) 105 LJP 36
- Wills Act 1837 s 9(b)
- Wood v Smith [1993] Ch 90
- Wills Act 1837 s 9(c) and (d)
- Wills Act 1837 (Electronic Communications) (Amendment) (Coronavirus) Order 2020
- Sherrington v Sherrington [2005] EWCA Civ 326
- Wills Act 1837 s 9(c)
- In the Estate of Gibson [1949] P 434
- Casson v Dade (1781) 1 Bro CC 99
- Couser v Couser [1996] 1 WLR 1301
- Wills Act 1837 ss 15 and 17
All 18 questions with answers
Try them above first, then read the worked answers below.
Question 1 · Formalities of executionDraft, pending solicitor review
Gina signs her will in the presence of one witness, who signs immediately. A second person, Harry, is in the next room and later signs as the second witness without seeing Gina sign. Which statement best describes the will's validity?
- It is valid, because two witnesses have signed.
- It is invalid, because two witnesses must be present at the same time when the testator signs or acknowledges the signature, and each must attest.Correct answer
- It is valid, because witnesses may sign at any later time.
- It is valid, because a will needs only one witness if the testator is an adult.
- It is valid if Gina later tells Harry that it is her will.
A will must be in writing, signed by the testator (or by another in their presence and by their direction), intended to give effect to the will, and witnessed by two or more witnesses present at the same time, each attesting in the testator's presence.
Law basis: Wills Act 1837 s 9 ↗Question 2 · Formalities of executionDraft, pending solicitor review
Xavier signed his will alone at home. The next day he took it to two neighbours, Yasmin and Zac, who were together in a room. He showed them his signature, told them 'this is my will and my signature', and each then signed as a witness in his presence. Which of the following best describes the will's validity?
- It is invalid, because the witnesses must actually see the testator sign.
- It is invalid, because the witnesses did not read the contents of the will.
- It is valid only if Xavier signs again in front of both witnesses.
- It is valid, because Xavier acknowledged his signature to both witnesses present together.Correct answer
- It is valid only if the witnesses were told who the beneficiaries were before they signed it.
A will is validly executed if the testator signs, or acknowledges his signature, in the presence of two or more witnesses present at the same time, and each witness then attests and signs, or acknowledges their signature, in the testator's presence. Xavier acknowledged his existing signature to Yasmin and Zac while both were present, and they signed in his presence. The witnesses need not see him sign, read the will, or know its contents.
Law basis: Wills Act 1837 s 9 (as substituted by Administration of Justice Act 1982 s 17)Question 3 · Formalities of executionDraft, pending solicitor review
Amira gathered two witnesses at her kitchen table. To save time, both witnesses signed the attestation clause first. Amira then signed the will at the foot while they watched. Nobody signed again afterwards. Which of the following best describes the will?
- It is invalid, because the witnesses signed before Amira signed or acknowledged her signature.Correct answer
- It is valid, because all three signed in each other's presence at the same sitting.
- It is valid, because the order of signing is irrelevant where all sign as part of one transaction.
- It is invalid, because a will must be signed by the testator at the very top.
- It is valid, provided the attestation clause records that all were present together.
Section 9 requires the testator's signature to be made or acknowledged in the presence of two witnesses present at the same time, and then each witness must attest and sign or acknowledge in the testator's presence. A witness's signature can only attest a signature already made or acknowledged. As the witnesses signed before Amira signed, they were not attesting anything, so the will fails. The solution is fresh execution in the correct order. A signature need not be at the top.
Law basis: Wills Act 1837 s 9Question 4 · Formalities of executionDraft, pending solicitor review
Bernard, who has severe arthritis, cannot hold a pen. With two witnesses present, he asks his daughter to sign his name at the end of his will. She does so in front of him, and the witnesses then sign in his presence. His daughter is not a beneficiary. Which of the following best describes the will?
- It is invalid, because the testator must sign personally, even if by a mark.
- It is valid, because it was signed by another person in his presence and by his direction.Correct answer
- It is valid only if the daughter signs her own name, rather than Bernard's name, on his behalf.
- It is invalid, because the daughter's signature requires a third witness.
- It is valid only if a court order authorising the signature is first obtained.
Section 9(a) permits a will to be signed by the testator or by some other person in his presence and by his direction. Bernard directed his daughter to sign in his presence, and the will was then properly witnessed. It does not matter whether she writes Bernard's name or her own, though best practice is for the attestation clause to record what happened. No extra witness or court order is needed. As she is not a beneficiary, no s 15 issue arises.
Law basis: Wills Act 1837 s 9(a)Question 5 · Formalities of executionDraft, pending solicitor review
Celia, who had suffered a stroke, could not write her name. In front of two witnesses present together, she made a cross at the end of her will, intending it to be her signature. The witnesses then signed in her presence. The attestation clause does not explain why she used a mark. Which of the following best describes the will?
- It is invalid, because a signature must consist of the testator's name.
- It is invalid, because a mark is only valid for a testator who is blind.
- It is validly signed only if Celia also added her initials to the mark.
- It is validly signed, although evidence explaining the mark may be needed for probate.Correct answer
- It is invalid unless a medical practitioner was present and witnessed the making of the mark.
A signature can take any form, including initials, a mark or a thumbprint, provided the testator intended it to operate as a signature. Celia's cross satisfies s 9. Because the attestation clause does not deal with the mark or her illness, the registry is likely to want evidence of due execution and of knowledge and approval from a witness before issuing the grant. The will is not invalid for lack of a written name, and initials are not required in addition.
Law basis: Wills Act 1837 s 9; In the Estate of Finn (1935) 105 LJP 36Question 6 · Formalities of executionDraft, pending solicitor review
Desmond wrote his will by hand. He began with 'My will, by Desmond Evans', then wrote his gifts beneath it. He did not sign at the end. In one continuous sitting, with two witnesses present throughout, he told them the document was his will and they signed below. Which of the following best describes whether the will is signed?
- It may be validly signed, because the name written at the top can be a signature if intended.Correct answer
- It cannot be validly signed, because a signature must always appear at the foot or end of the will.
- It is validly signed only if Desmond adds his initials beside the last gift.
- It cannot be validly signed, because the name was written before the gifts.
- It is validly signed only if the witnesses watched him write each gift.
Since 1982, s 9 does not require the signature to be at the foot or end of the will; it must appear that the testator intended by the signature to give effect to the will. In Wood v Smith, a name written at the top was capable of being a signature where the will was written in a single operation and intended to be signed in that way. Desmond's acknowledgment before both witnesses supports this, so the will can be valid.
Law basis: Wills Act 1837 s 9(b); Wood v Smith [1993] Ch 90Question 7 · Formalities of executionDraft, pending solicitor review
Ella signs her will in front of two witnesses present together. The first witness, Finn, signs and then leaves for work. A few minutes later the second witness, Gail, signs in Ella's presence. Finn did not see Gail sign. Which of the following best describes the will?
- It is invalid, because both witnesses must sign in each other's presence.
- It is invalid, because the witnesses did not sign at the same moment.
- It is valid, because each witness signed in Ella's presence after she signed.Correct answer
- It is valid only if Finn returns to acknowledge his own signature before Gail signs as witness.
- It is valid only if Gail signs immediately below Finn's signature.
The witnesses must both be present when the testator signs or acknowledges her signature. After that, s 9(d) requires each witness to attest and sign, or acknowledge their signature, in the presence of the testator, but not necessarily in the presence of each other. Ella signed in front of Finn and Gail together, and each then signed in her presence. Finn's departure before Gail signed does not affect validity.
Law basis: Wills Act 1837 s 9(c) and (d)Question 8 · Formalities of executionDraft, pending solicitor review
In March 2025 Harold signed his will on a video call while his two witnesses watched from their own homes. The paper will was then posted to each witness, who signed it while Harold watched them on another video call. Which of the following best describes the will?
- It is valid, because video witnessing of wills has been permanently permitted since 2020.
- It is valid, because each signature was made in the visual presence of the others.
- It is invalid, because the temporary provision for video witnessing no longer applies.Correct answer
- It is valid only if all three signatures were completed within 24 hours.
- It is invalid only if the witnesses signed different counterparts of the will.
Temporary legislation allowed witnessing by video link for wills made between 31 January 2020 and 31 January 2024. It has not been extended, so for a will made in March 2025 'presence' in s 9 means physical presence, as it always did before the pandemic changes. Harold's witnesses were not physically present, so the will is invalidly executed. He should re-execute it with two witnesses physically present at the same time.
Law basis: Wills Act 1837 s 9; Wills Act 1837 (Electronic Communications) (Amendment) (Coronavirus) Order 2020Question 9 · Formalities of executionDraft, pending solicitor review
Irene's will contains a standard attestation clause stating that it was signed by her in the joint presence of the two witnesses, who signed in her presence. Twelve years later, one witness says she cannot remember the occasion and the other has died. Irene's son claims the will was not properly executed. Which of the following best describes the position?
- The will fails, because a surviving witness must positively confirm that it was duly executed.
- The will fails, unless the son consents to it being admitted to probate.
- There is a strong presumption of due execution, which needs clear evidence to rebut.Correct answer
- The presumption of due execution applies only if both witnesses are alive.
- The burden is on the executors to prove execution beyond reasonable doubt.
Where a will appears to be duly executed and has a proper attestation clause, there is a presumption that the formalities were complied with. The courts treat it as a strong presumption, which can only be rebutted by the strongest evidence, and a witness's lack of recollection years later is not enough. The son would need positive evidence that the witnesses were not present together. The civil standard of proof applies.
Law basis: Sherrington v Sherrington [2005] EWCA Civ 326Question 10 · Formalities of executionDraft, pending solicitor review
Jack signed his will in front of his neighbour Kim, who signed as a witness. Kim's husband Lee was in the garden and did not see Jack sign. Later that afternoon Jack showed Lee the will, pointing to his signature, and Lee signed as the second witness in Jack's presence. Kim was not then present. Which of the following best describes the will?
- It is valid, because Jack acknowledged his signature to Lee before Lee signed as a witness.
- It is invalid, because the witnesses were never together when Jack signed or acknowledged.Correct answer
- It is valid, because both witnesses signed in Jack's presence at some point that day.
- It is valid, because a spouse of a witness may act as the second witness.
- It is invalid only as to any gift made in the will to Kim or Lee.
Section 9(c) requires the testator's signature to be made or acknowledged in the presence of two or more witnesses present at the same time. Kim saw Jack sign, but Lee was absent; Lee later saw an acknowledgment, but Kim was then absent. At no point were both witnesses present together, so the will is invalid. Separate acknowledgments to each witness are not enough. The fact that a spouse of a witness is involved is relevant to s 15, not to execution.
Law basis: Wills Act 1837 s 9(c)Question 11 · Formalities of executionDraft, pending solicitor review
Mabel, who is blind, is asked by her friend Nina to witness Nina's will. Mabel sits at the table while Nina signs, and Mabel signs where she is shown. The other witness, Owen, is sighted and also signs. Which of the following best describes the will's execution?
- It is valid, because Mabel was physically present in the room at the moment Nina signed.
- It is invalidly witnessed, because a blind person cannot be a witness to a will.Correct answer
- It is valid, because only one of the two witnesses needs to be sighted.
- It is valid, because a witness need not see the contents of the will.
- It is invalid only if Mabel is related to a beneficiary under the will.
Presence for the purposes of s 9 involves being able to see the testator sign, or at least having a clear line of sight. A blind person cannot see the act of signing and so cannot be a witness, as held in In the Estate of Gibson. Nina's will therefore has only one effective witness and fails. It is true that witnesses need not read the will's contents, but the problem is the inability to see the signature itself.
Law basis: Wills Act 1837 s 9; In the Estate of Gibson [1949] P 434Question 12 · Formalities of executionDraft, pending solicitor review
Paula, in hospital, signs her will while two nurses stand just outside her room. The door is wide open and both nurses watch her sign from the doorway, then come in and sign in front of her. Which of the following best describes whether the nurses were 'present' when Paula signed?
- They were not present, because witnesses must be in the same room as the testator.
- They were not present, because they must stand beside the testator at the time of signing.
- They were present only if Paula also told them that the document was her will.
- They were present only because they were medical professionals attending Paula.
- They were present, because they could see her sign from where they stood.Correct answer
Presence for s 9 is a matter of visual presence: the witnesses must be able to see the testator sign, or would have been able to see had they looked. Being in the same room is neither necessary nor sufficient. In Casson v Dade, a will signed in a carriage visible through a window was validly witnessed. The nurses watched Paula sign through the open doorway and then signed in her presence, so execution is valid. Telling them it was a will is not required.
Law basis: Wills Act 1837 s 9; Casson v Dade (1781) 1 Bro CC 99Question 13 · Formalities of executionDraft, pending solicitor review
Quinn asks his 16-year-old nephew and an adult neighbour to witness his will. Both watch Quinn sign together and both sign in his presence. The nephew is not a beneficiary and understood what he was doing. Which of the following best describes the will?
- It is invalid, because every attesting witness must be aged at least 18.
- It is validly executed, because there is no minimum age for a witness.Correct answer
- It is invalid, because a relative of the testator cannot act as a witness.
- It is valid only if the nephew's parent consents in writing to his acting.
- It is valid only if a third, adult witness also attests the testator's signature.
The Wills Act 1837 sets no minimum age for witnesses. What matters is that the witness is capable of seeing the signature and attesting it. A 16-year-old who understands the act can be a valid witness, though an adult independent witness is better practice since witnesses may be needed to give evidence later. Relatives can witness; the only risk is under s 15 if the witness or their spouse or civil partner benefits, which is not the case here.
Law basis: Wills Act 1837 s 9Question 14 · Formalities of executionDraft, pending solicitor review
Rosa had already signed her will at the foot. She placed it, with her signature showing, in front of two neighbours sitting together and said, 'Could you both sign here, please?' She said nothing else. The neighbours saw her signature and signed in her presence. Which of the following best describes the will?
- It is invalid, because Rosa did not expressly state that the signature was hers.
- It is invalid, because the witnesses were not told that the document was a will.
- It is valid, because Rosa acknowledged her signature by her words and conduct.Correct answer
- It is valid only if Rosa signs again so that the witnesses can see her doing it.
- It is valid only if the witnesses read the attestation clause before they signed it.
A testator may acknowledge an existing signature instead of signing in front of the witnesses. Acknowledgment need not be in express words; it can be inferred from conduct, such as producing the will with the signature visible and asking the witnesses to sign. Rosa's conduct, with both witnesses present together, satisfies s 9(c). The witnesses need not know the document is a will, nor must she say expressly that the signature is hers.
Law basis: Wills Act 1837 s 9(c); Couser v Couser [1996] 1 WLR 1301Question 15 · Formalities of executionDraft, pending solicitor review
Samir appoints his friend Tom as his executor. Tom receives no gift under the will. Samir asks Tom and Samir's accountant to witness the will, and they do so correctly. After Samir's death, his daughter argues that Tom's role as executor makes the will invalid. Which of the following best describes the position?
- The will is invalid, because an executor can never witness the will he proves.
- The will is valid, because an executor is a competent witness.Correct answer
- The will is valid, but Tom loses his right to act as executor of the estate.
- The will is valid, but Tom must renounce probate before the grant is issued.
- The will is invalid unless the accountant was also appointed as an executor.
Section 17 of the Wills Act 1837 provides that a person is not incompetent to be a witness to prove the execution of a will by reason only of being an executor. Section 15 only affects gifts to a witness or the witness's spouse or civil partner, and Tom takes no beneficial gift. Tom can witness the will and still act as executor. If the will had left Tom a legacy, that gift would fail under s 15 unless saved, but his appointment would stand.
Law basis: Wills Act 1837 ss 15 and 17Question 16 · Formalities of executionDraft, pending solicitor review
Una's will is typed on four separate sheets, which are not stapled. She signs only the last sheet in front of two witnesses present together. All four sheets were lying on the table in front of her when she signed. Which of the following best describes the will?
- It is valid as to all four sheets, as long as they were present when she signed.Correct answer
- It is valid only as to the last sheet, because only that sheet bears her signature.
- It is invalid, because each separate sheet of a will must be signed or initialled.
- It is invalid, because the sheets were not fastened together before execution.
- It is valid only if the witnesses sign every one of the four separate sheets.
A will may consist of several sheets, and a single signature on the last sheet suffices if the other sheets were in the room and intended to form part of the will at the time of execution. Una's sheets were all on the table when she signed, so they form one will. Fastening the sheets is good practice, because a loose sheet may later be disputed, and initialling each page helps, but neither is a legal requirement.
Law basis: Wills Act 1837 s 9Question 17 · Formalities of executionDraft, pending solicitor review
Victoria writes her will by hand, dates it and signs it at the end. She does not ask anyone to witness it, believing that a handwritten will is valid without witnesses. She dies domiciled in England, owning a house in London. Which of the following best describes the document?
- It is valid, because a will entirely in the testator's handwriting needs no witnesses.
- It is valid as to her personal property, but not as to her house in London.
- It is valid if her handwriting can be verified by two people who knew her well.
- It is valid only if she gave a copy of it to a beneficiary or her executor before death.
- It is not a valid will, because it was not witnessed by two people.Correct answer
In England and Wales there is no special category of holograph will. Unless privileged, every will must be witnessed by two witnesses present at the same time under s 9 of the Wills Act 1837. Victoria's unwitnessed will is invalid, so her estate passes under any earlier valid will or under the intestacy rules. Proof of handwriting cannot cure the lack of attestation. The idea that holograph wills are valid comes from other legal systems.
Law basis: Wills Act 1837 s 9Question 18 · Formalities of executionDraft, pending solicitor review
Walter's will was correctly executed in 2021. In 2024 he writes a codicil by hand, leaving his car to his grandson. He signs it in front of his wife, who signs as the only witness. Which of the following best describes the codicil?
- It is valid, because a codicil only needs one witness if the original will was valid.
- It is valid, because the original will was correctly executed with two witnesses.
- It is invalid, because a codicil needs the same formalities as a will.Correct answer
- It is valid as to the car only, because the gift is a small specific legacy.
- It is valid, because a spouse may act alone as a witness to a document of this kind.
A codicil is a testamentary document and must be executed in accordance with s 9 of the Wills Act 1837, with two witnesses present at the same time. Walter's codicil has only one witness, so it is invalid and the gift of the car fails, leaving the 2021 will unaffected. The validity of the original will cannot supply the missing witness. Even had a second witness been present, using his wife would not affect the gift to the grandson under s 15.
Law basis: Wills Act 1837 s 9More Wills and Administration of Estates topics
Back to all Wills and Administration of Estates questions, or sit a timed mock.