Law covered in these questions
- Law of Property Act 1925 s 36(2)
- Law of Property Act 1925 ss 34 to 36
- Law of Property Act 1925 ss 36(2) and 196
- Kinch v Bullard [1999] 1 WLR 423
- Married Women's Property Act 1882 s 11
- Inheritance Tax Act 1984 s 151
- scheme trust deed and rules
- King v Dubrey [2015] EWCA Civ 581
- Sen v Headley [1991] Ch 425
- Aroso v Coutts & Co [2002] 1 All ER (Comm) 241
- Administration of Estates Act 1925 ss 1 to 3
- Inheritance Tax Act 1984 s 5
- Inheritance Tax Act 1984 s 49
- Administration of Estates Act 1925 s 1
All 12 questions with answers
Try them above first, then read the worked answers below.
Question 1 · Property passing outside the willDraft, pending solicitor review
Xena and Yoko owned their home as beneficial joint tenants. Xena's will leaves 'my half share in our home' to her brother, and residue to charity. The joint tenancy was never severed. Xena dies, survived by Yoko. Which of the following best describes who takes Xena's interest in the home?
- Yoko takes it by survivorship, so the gift to the brother fails.Correct answer
- The brother takes it, because the will severs the joint tenancy on death.
- The charity takes it, because the specific gift of a joint interest fails.
- Yoko and the brother hold it as tenants in common in equal shares.
- The brother takes it, provided he survives Xena by at least 28 days.
On the death of a beneficial joint tenant, the deceased's interest passes automatically to the surviving joint tenant by survivorship. A joint tenancy cannot be severed by will, because a will speaks only at death, when survivorship has already operated. Xena's interest therefore vests in Yoko, and the gift to the brother has nothing to bite on. Severance during lifetime, for example by written notice, would have been needed for the share to pass under the will.
Law basis: Law of Property Act 1925 s 36(2)Question 2 · Property passing outside the willDraft, pending solicitor review
Zara and her sister owned a flat as tenants in common in equal shares. Zara's will leaves residue to her son. Her sister claims that she now owns the whole flat because Zara has died. Which of the following best describes the position?
- The sister takes the whole flat, because co-owners always take by survivorship.
- The sister takes the whole flat, unless Zara's will specifically mentioned it.
- Zara's half share passes under her will to her son.Correct answer
- Zara's half share passes to her sister on trust for Zara's son until he is 18.
- Zara's half share passes on intestacy, because it is not specifically given.
A tenancy in common gives each co-owner a separate undivided share, which does not pass by survivorship and forms part of the deceased's estate. Zara's half share therefore passes under her will, and as there is no specific gift of it, it falls within residue and goes to her son. The sister will remain a trustee of the legal title with Zara's personal representatives, but she has no beneficial claim to Zara's share.
Law basis: Law of Property Act 1925 ss 34 to 36Question 3 · Property passing outside the willDraft, pending solicitor review
Asif and Bina owned their house as beneficial joint tenants. During their separation, Asif sent Bina a signed letter saying he wished to sever the joint tenancy so that they held in equal shares. It was delivered to the house, but Bina never read it. Asif died a week later. His will leaves everything to his brother. Which of the following best describes Asif's interest?
- Bina takes the whole house, because severance requires her to have read the notice.
- His half share passes under his will, because the notice severed the joint tenancy.Correct answer
- Bina takes the whole house, because severance requires the consent of both owners.
- His half share passes on intestacy, because severance makes the will inapplicable.
- Bina takes the whole house, because notices of severance take effect only after 28 days.
Under s 36(2) of the Law of Property Act 1925, a joint tenant may sever by giving the other joint tenants notice in writing of the desire to sever. Notice is served when it is delivered to the recipient's last known place of abode, under s 196, even if it is not read, as held in Kinch v Bullard. Asif's letter severed the joint tenancy on delivery, so he held a half share as tenant in common, which passes under his will to his brother. Consent is not required.
Law basis: Law of Property Act 1925 ss 36(2) and 196; Kinch v Bullard [1999] 1 WLR 423Question 4 · Property passing outside the willDraft, pending solicitor review
Cyril took out a life policy and, at the outset, wrote it in trust for his two daughters. His will leaves residue to his second wife. He dies and the insurer pays out £200,000. His widow says the money belongs in his estate. Which of the following best describes the policy proceeds?
- They form part of residue, because Cyril paid the premiums during his lifetime.
- They are held by the trustees for the daughters, outside the estate.Correct answer
- They are paid to the executors, who must apply them under the terms of the will.
- They are divided between the widow and daughters under the intestacy rules.
- They form part of the estate, but the daughters have priority over the widow.
A life policy written in trust is held by the trustees for the trust beneficiaries from the outset. On death, the proceeds are paid to the trustees on production of the death certificate, without a grant, and do not pass under the will or form part of the estate for succession purposes. The daughters therefore benefit and the widow has no claim under the will. Payment of premiums by Cyril does not bring the proceeds into the estate.
Law basis: Married Women's Property Act 1882 s 11Question 5 · Property passing outside the willDraft, pending solicitor review
Dora was a member of an occupational pension scheme that pays a lump sum on death at the trustees' discretion. She completed an expression of wishes naming her partner, Ed. Her will leaves everything to her sister. Which of the following best describes the lump sum?
- It passes under Dora's will to her sister, as it arises from her own contributions.
- It must be paid to Ed, because an expression of wishes binds the scheme trustees.
- It is paid at the trustees' discretion, guided by the expression of wishes.Correct answer
- It passes on intestacy, because pension benefits cannot be left by will at all.
- It must be shared between the sister and Ed, unless the scheme rules say otherwise.
Discretionary death benefits under most pension schemes are held by the scheme trustees, who decide who receives them from a class of potential beneficiaries. They do not form part of the estate and do not pass under the will. An expression of wishes is not binding, but trustees will normally take it into account. Ed is therefore likely, but not certain, to receive the lump sum. The sister has no entitlement under the will.
Law basis: Inheritance Tax Act 1984 s 151; scheme trust deed and rulesQuestion 6 · Property passing outside the willDraft, pending solicitor review
Freya was due to undergo serious heart surgery the next day. In hospital, she handed her niece Gail the only key to a locked box containing share certificates, saying, 'If I don't come through this, the shares are yours.' Freya died during the operation. Her will leaves everything to charity. Which of the following best describes the shares?
- They pass to the charity, because a gift on death must be made by will.
- They pass to the charity, because share certificates cannot be handed over by key.
- They pass to Gail only if Freya signed stock transfer forms before she died.
- They pass to Gail only if two witnesses heard what Freya said in hospital.
- They pass to Gail as a valid donatio mortis causa.Correct answer
A donatio mortis causa is valid if the donor makes a gift in contemplation of impending death, the gift is conditional on death, and the donor parts with dominion over the property or the means of access to it. Freya faced serious surgery, made the gift conditional on not surviving, and handed over the only key to the box. The requirements set out in King v Dubrey are satisfied, so Gail takes the shares and the personal representatives must complete the transfer.
Law basis: King v Dubrey [2015] EWCA Civ 581Question 7 · Property passing outside the willDraft, pending solicitor review
Hector, aged 70 and in good health, gave his nephew Ian the deeds to his house, saying, 'This will be yours when I die, whenever that may be.' Hector continued living in the house and died suddenly six years later. His will leaves everything to his partner. Which of the following best describes Ian's claim?
- It succeeds, because handing over the deeds is enough to part with dominion over land.
- It succeeds, because a donatio mortis causa can be made in contemplation of death generally.
- It fails, because land can never be the subject of a valid donatio mortis causa.
- Ken is likely to take it by survivorship, given Jean's intention.Correct answer
- It succeeds, provided Ian registers the gift at HM Land Registry within one year.
A donatio mortis causa requires the donor to contemplate death in the near future for a specific reason, such as illness or a dangerous operation. In King v Dubrey, the Court of Appeal stressed that the doctrine must be kept within strict limits and that contemplation of death in general is not enough. Hector was in good health and contemplated only eventual death. Land can be the subject of a valid donatio, following Sen v Headley, but Ian's claim fails here and the house passes under the will.
Law basis: King v Dubrey [2015] EWCA Civ 581; Sen v Headley [1991] Ch 425Question 8 · Property passing outside the willDraft, pending solicitor review
Jean added her son Ken's name to her bank account when she became frail, so that he could pay her bills. All the money came from Jean. There is evidence that she intended Ken to have the balance on her death. Her will leaves residue to her two children equally. Which of the following best describes the account balance on Jean's death?
- It must form part of residue, because Jean provided all the money in the account.
- It must be divided equally, because a joint account is always held in equal shares.
- It passes to residue, because a bank account cannot be held by survivorship.
- Ken is likely to take it by survivorship, given the evidence of Jean's intention.Correct answer
- Ken takes it only if Jean's will refers to the joint account by name.
A joint account passes to the survivor by survivorship at law. In equity, where one party provided all the funds, there is a presumption of resulting trust unless a gift is intended, but evidence of the depositor's intention that the survivor should take the balance on death will rebut it. Here there is evidence that Jean intended Ken to take, so he is likely to receive the balance outside the will. Without that evidence, the balance would fall into residue.
Law basis: Aroso v Coutts & Co [2002] 1 All ER (Comm) 241Question 9 · Property passing outside the willDraft, pending solicitor review
Kara died leaving: a house held as joint tenants with her husband; a joint bank account with her husband; shares in her sole name worth £80,000; and a life policy written in trust for her children. Her husband asks which assets need a grant of representation. Which of the following is the best answer?
- All the assets require a grant, because Kara had an interest in each.
- The house and the shares require a grant, but the account and policy do not.
- Only the life policy requires a grant, because it pays out on death.
- Only the shares in Kara's sole name are likely to require a grant.Correct answer
- None of the assets requires a grant, because her husband survives her.
Assets passing by survivorship, such as jointly owned property and joint accounts, vest automatically in the surviving joint owner, who need only produce the death certificate. A life policy written in trust is paid to the trustees on proof of death, without a grant. Assets in the deceased's sole name, such as the shares, vest in the personal representatives and a grant is needed to prove their title to deal with them. Kara's husband will therefore need a grant for the shares.
Law basis: Administration of Estates Act 1925 ss 1 to 3Question 10 · Property passing outside the willDraft, pending solicitor review
Leo and his son owned a holiday cottage worth £400,000 as beneficial joint tenants. On Leo's death, the cottage passes to his son by survivorship. Leo's will leaves everything else to his son. The executors are preparing the inheritance tax account. Which of the following best describes the cottage?
- It is excluded for inheritance tax, because it passes by survivorship and not under the will.
- The whole £400,000 is included, because a joint tenant owns the whole property.
- It is included only if Leo provided all the purchase money for the cottage.
- Leo's share is included in his estate for IHT, despite passing outside the will.Correct answer
- It is exempt, because it passes to a lineal descendant of the deceased.
For inheritance tax, a person's estate includes all property to which he was beneficially entitled immediately before death, including his interest as a joint tenant, under s 5 of the Inheritance Tax Act 1984. Survivorship determines who receives the property, not whether it is taxed. Leo's half share is therefore included in his estate, possibly with a discount for joint ownership. There is no exemption for gifts to children, although the residence nil rate band is unlikely to apply to a holiday cottage that was never Leo's residence.
Law basis: Inheritance Tax Act 1984 s 5 ↗Question 11 · Property passing outside the willDraft, pending solicitor review
Mona was the life tenant of a trust set up by her late father's will. On her death the trust provides that the fund passes to her brother. Mona's own will leaves everything to her daughter, who claims the trust fund as part of residue. Which of the following best describes the trust fund?
- It passes to the daughter, because Mona was entitled to the income during her life.
- It passes to the daughter, because a life tenant can direct the fund by will.
- It passes to the brother under the father's trust, not under Mona's will.Correct answer
- It is divided between the brother and the daughter according to their needs.
- It passes on Mona's intestacy, because it cannot be disposed of by any will.
A life tenant has only an interest for her own life, which ends on her death. She has no power to dispose of the capital by will unless the trust gives her a general power of appointment. The trust fund therefore passes to the remainderman, Mona's brother, under the terms of her father's will trust. Mona's daughter takes only Mona's free estate. The trust fund may still be relevant to inheritance tax on Mona's death if it was a qualifying interest in possession.
Law basis: Inheritance Tax Act 1984 s 49 ↗Question 12 · Property passing outside the willDraft, pending solicitor review
Nico took out a life policy on his own life many years ago. He never wrote it in trust or nominated anyone. His will leaves £50,000 to a friend and residue to his niece. The insurer will pay £150,000 on his death. Which of the following best describes the policy proceeds?
- They are paid directly to his niece as his closest relative.
- They are held by the insurer until a court decides who takes.
- They form part of Nico's estate and pass under his will.Correct answer
- They pass to whoever paid the premiums under the policy.
- They are divided equally between the friend and the niece.
A life policy on the deceased's own life which is not written in trust and is not subject to a nomination is an asset of the deceased's estate. The proceeds are payable to the personal representatives on production of a grant, and they pass under the will in the same way as other assets. Nico's proceeds therefore form part of residue for his niece, after payment of the £50,000 legacy, debts and expenses. They also form part of his estate for inheritance tax.
Law basis: Administration of Estates Act 1925 s 1More Wills and Administration of Estates topics
Back to all Wills and Administration of Estates questions, or sit a timed mock.