Law covered in these questions
- Banks v Goodfellow (1870) LR 5 QB 549
- Parker v Felgate (1883) 8 PD 171
- Key v Key [2010] EWHC 408 (Ch)
- Kenward v Adams (1975)
- Re Simpson (1977) 121 SJ 224
- Non-Contentious Probate Rules 1987 r 13
- Barry v Butlin (1838) 2 Moo PC 480
- Wintle v Nye [1959] 1 WLR 284
- Wingrove v Wingrove (1885) 11 PD 81
- Hall v Hall (1868) LR 1 P&D 481
- Re Edwards [2007] EWHC 1119 (Ch)
- Wills Act 1837 s 7
- Wills Act 1837 s 11
- Wills (Soldiers and Sailors) Act 1918 s 1
All 15 questions with answers
Try them above first, then read the worked answers below.
Question 1 · Testamentary capacity and intentionDraft, pending solicitor review
Arthur, aged 82, instructs a solicitor to make a will leaving his estate equally to his three children. He has for years believed, wrongly, that his neighbours are spying on him through his television. He understands what he owns and who his children are. Which of the following best describes Arthur's testamentary capacity?
- He lacks capacity, because any insane delusion, whatever its subject, prevents a valid will.
- He lacks capacity, unless a doctor certifies that the delusion is harmless.
- He has capacity only if he can value each of his assets precisely.
- He lacks capacity, because the burden is on him to prove he is of sound mind.
- He has capacity, because his delusion does not influence the dispositions he is making.Correct answer
Under Banks v Goodfellow the testator must understand the nature of making a will and its effects, the extent of the property, and the claims to which he ought to give effect, and no disorder of mind must poison his affections or influence the dispositions. A delusion only defeats capacity if it bears on the gifts. Arthur's belief about his neighbours has nothing to do with his children, so he has capacity. Precise valuation is not required; a general understanding of the estate is enough.
Law basis: Banks v Goodfellow (1870) LR 5 QB 549Question 2 · Testamentary capacity and intentionDraft, pending solicitor review
Beatrice has believed for two years, without any basis, that her daughter Clare has been trying to poison her food. In her new will Beatrice leaves her whole estate to her son, expressly excluding Clare 'because of what she has tried to do to me'. Beatrice is otherwise lucid. Which of the following best describes the validity of the will?
- It is valid, because Beatrice understands the extent of her property and family.
- It is valid, because a testator may disinherit a child for any reason at all, rational or otherwise.
- It is void only to the extent that it fails to make reasonable provision for Clare.
- It is valid, because capacity is judged under the Mental Capacity Act 2005 alone.
- It is liable to fail for lack of capacity, because the delusion has influenced the disposition.Correct answer
The fourth limb of Banks v Goodfellow requires that no insane delusion influences the testator's will in disposing of property. Beatrice's unfounded belief that Clare is poisoning her is directly linked to the exclusion of Clare, so the will is vulnerable for want of capacity. Freedom of testation lets a testator disinherit for bad reasons, but not where the reason is a delusion that poisons the disposition. The 1975 Act is a separate remedy and does not make a will void.
Law basis: Banks v Goodfellow (1870) LR 5 QB 549Question 3 · Testamentary capacity and intentionDraft, pending solicitor review
Dorian gave clear instructions for a new will to his solicitor while fully capable. A week later, when the draft was brought to him in hospital, his condition had worsened. He could no longer follow each clause, but he understood that he was signing the will he had asked the solicitor to prepare. Which of the following best describes the position?
- The will is valid, because he understood he was executing a will drawn up on his instructions.Correct answer
- The will is invalid, because full capacity must exist at execution as each clause is read over.
- The will is valid only if the solicitor obtains a court order confirming capacity.
- The will is invalid, because instructions must be given and executed on the same day.
- The will is valid only as to gifts Dorian could still recall when signing it.
Under the rule in Parker v Felgate, where a testator had capacity when giving instructions, and the will is prepared in accordance with them, it is valid if at execution he understands that he is executing a will for which he gave instructions, even if he cannot follow its provisions. Dorian satisfies that relaxed test. The rule should be applied with caution, but there is no requirement that full Banks v Goodfellow capacity exists at the moment of signing.
Law basis: Parker v Felgate (1883) 8 PD 171Question 4 · Testamentary capacity and intentionDraft, pending solicitor review
Edna's will was professionally drafted, is rational on its face and was duly executed. Her nephew Frank challenges it, alleging lack of capacity. He produces medical records showing she had been diagnosed with moderate dementia six months before signing. Which of the following best describes the burden of proof?
- Frank must prove incapacity beyond reasonable doubt throughout, as the person alleging it.
- The diagnosis creates an irrebuttable presumption that Edna lacked capacity.
- The burden rests on Frank alone, because the will was duly executed.
- The evidence raises a real doubt, so the propounder must now establish capacity.Correct answer
- The burden is on the probate registry to decide capacity of its own motion.
A rational will that is duly executed raises a presumption of capacity. If the challenger adduces evidence raising a real doubt, the evidential burden shifts back to the person propounding the will to prove capacity on the balance of probabilities. A dementia diagnosis is not conclusive, since capacity is assessed at execution and may fluctuate, but it is enough to displace the presumption. Civil, not criminal, standards apply, so proof beyond reasonable doubt is wrong.
Law basis: Banks v Goodfellow (1870) LR 5 QB 549; Key v Key [2010] EWHC 408 (Ch)Question 5 · Testamentary capacity and intentionDraft, pending solicitor review
Gerald, aged 91, asks his solicitor to prepare a new will. He seems forgetful and repeats questions during the meeting. The solicitor is confident he understands his wishes but wants to reduce the risk of a later challenge. Which of the following is the best step for the solicitor to take?
- Arrange for a medical practitioner to assess him and witness the will, and record the findings.Correct answer
- Decline to act, because a solicitor may not prepare a will for a client over 90.
- Ask Gerald's main beneficiary to confirm in writing that he has capacity.
- Have Gerald sign a statement that he is of sound mind before execution.
- Delay execution of the will until the Court of Protection has formally confirmed that he has capacity.
The 'golden rule' suggests that where a testator is elderly or seriously ill, the will should be witnessed or approved by a medical practitioner who has satisfied himself of capacity and recorded his examination. It is guidance, not a rule of law, but following it greatly reduces the risk of a successful challenge. Statements by a beneficiary or by the testator himself carry little weight, and there is no age bar to making a will. Court approval is not required for a capable testator.
Law basis: Kenward v Adams (1975); Re Simpson (1977) 121 SJ 224Question 6 · Testamentary capacity and intentionDraft, pending solicitor review
Harriet is registered blind. She instructs her solicitor to make a will, which the solicitor reads aloud to her in full before she signs it in front of two witnesses. The attestation clause is in standard form and does not mention her blindness. Which of the following best describes what the probate registry is likely to require?
- Nothing further, because a standard attestation clause raises a presumption of knowledge and approval.
- A fresh will, because a blind person cannot make a valid will by signing.
- A medical report confirming Harriet's capacity before the grant can issue.
- A statement from each beneficiary that they accept the will's validity.
- Evidence that the will was read over to Harriet and that she knew and approved its contents.Correct answer
Where a testator was blind or illiterate, the registrar must be satisfied that the testator had knowledge of the will's contents at execution. Unless the attestation clause recites that the will was read over and appeared to be understood, affidavit or witness evidence is required. A blind person can make a valid will. The standard clause here is silent on blindness, so the usual presumption of knowledge and approval is not enough and supporting evidence is needed.
Law basis: Non-Contentious Probate Rules 1987 r 13Question 7 · Testamentary capacity and intentionDraft, pending solicitor review
Ian's carer, Jill, found a will form online, filled it in according to what she said were Ian's wishes and arranged for it to be witnessed. The will leaves most of Ian's estate to Jill. Ian had capacity. His children dispute the will. Which of the following best describes the legal position?
- The children must prove fraud, because the will is presumed valid once duly executed.
- Jill must affirmatively prove that Ian knew and approved of the contents of the will.Correct answer
- The will is automatically void, because a beneficiary was involved in its preparation.
- The will is valid, because knowledge and approval is presumed from capacity alone.
- The gift to Jill fails, but the remainder of the will takes effect without inquiry.
Knowledge and approval is normally presumed from capacity and due execution. Where the will is prepared by a person who takes a substantial benefit, suspicious circumstances arise and the propounder must remove the suspicion by proving that the testator knew and approved of the contents. Barry v Butlin and Wintle v Nye establish this heightened burden. Involvement of a beneficiary does not make the will void automatically, and the children need not prove fraud.
Law basis: Barry v Butlin (1838) 2 Moo PC 480; Wintle v Nye [1959] 1 WLR 284Question 8 · Testamentary capacity and intentionDraft, pending solicitor review
Kenneth, a widower, made a new will leaving everything to his son Leo, who lived with him. His daughter Mia says Leo repeatedly told their father he would 'end up in a care home' unless the will was changed, and that Leo pressed him about it every week. There is no other evidence. Which of the following best describes Mia's claim of undue influence?
- Undue influence is presumed, because Leo lived with Kenneth and benefits under the will.
- Leo must disprove any influence, because he lived with Kenneth and is now the main beneficiary.
- Mia must prove coercion that overpowered Kenneth's will, and persuasion alone is not enough.Correct answer
- The claim succeeds automatically if Leo encouraged Kenneth to change the will.
- The will fails unless Kenneth received independent legal advice before signing.
In probate, undue influence means coercion: pressure that overpowers the testator's volition so that the will does not reflect his own wishes. Persuasion, appeals to affection or pleas are legitimate. There is no presumption of undue influence in wills, unlike lifetime gifts, so the burden is on Mia to prove it, and the evidence must be inconsistent with any other hypothesis. Living together and benefiting does not shift the burden, and independent advice is not a requirement for validity.
Law basis: Wingrove v Wingrove (1885) 11 PD 81; Hall v Hall (1868) LR 1 P&D 481Question 9 · Testamentary capacity and intentionDraft, pending solicitor review
Nora's carer, Olive, repeatedly and falsely told her that Nora's son Paul had been stealing from her bank account. Believing this, Nora made a new will leaving nothing to Paul and her estate to Olive. Olive knew the allegations were untrue. Which of the following best describes the likely outcome of a challenge by Paul?
- The will stands, because Nora had capacity and signed it freely.
- The will stands, but Paul may bring a claim under the 1975 Act.
- The will is void for lack of capacity, because Nora held a false belief.
- The will is liable to be set aside for fraudulent calumny.Correct answer
- The will stands, because there is no evidence that Olive coerced Nora.
Fraudulent calumny occurs where a person poisons the testator's mind against a natural beneficiary by casting dishonest aspersions on their character, knowing them to be false or not caring whether they are true. It is a species of undue influence that does not require coercion. Olive's deliberate lies caused the disinheritance of Paul, so the will is liable to be set aside. Nora's false belief was induced by fraud, not a delusion arising from mental disorder, so capacity is not the correct ground.
Law basis: Re Edwards [2007] EWHC 1119 (Ch)Question 10 · Testamentary capacity and intentionDraft, pending solicitor review
Quentin is 17 and works as a trainee chef. He has inherited money from his grandmother and signs a will, properly witnessed by two adults, leaving everything to his girlfriend. He is not in the armed forces. Which of the following best describes the will?
- It is valid, because Quentin is old enough to marry or form a civil partnership.
- It is valid if his parents consented in writing before he signed it.
- It is valid, because it was signed in the presence of two adult witnesses.
- It becomes valid automatically when Quentin reaches the age of 18.
- It is invalid, because Quentin was under 18 when he made it.Correct answer
No will made by a person under 18 is valid, save for privileged wills of members of the armed forces on actual military service and mariners at sea. Quentin is a civilian aged 17, so his will is invalid however it was executed. Parental consent cannot cure this, and the will does not become valid on his 18th birthday; he would need to make a fresh will once he reaches majority. Note too that the minimum age for marriage is now 18 in England and Wales.
Law basis: Wills Act 1837 s 7Question 11 · Testamentary capacity and intentionDraft, pending solicitor review
Rhys, aged 17, is a soldier on active deployment overseas. Shortly before a patrol, he tells a fellow soldier that if anything happens to him, everything he has should go to his sister. He dies on the patrol. Nothing was written down. Which of the following best describes his oral statement?
- It is ineffective, because every will must be in writing and signed.
- It is ineffective, because a privileged will can only be made by a person aged 18.
- It may take effect as a privileged will despite his age and the lack of writing.Correct answer
- It is effective only if two witnesses heard the statement at the same time.
- It is ineffective, so his estate passes under the intestacy rules in all cases.
A soldier in actual military service may make a privileged will, which need not comply with s 9 of the Wills Act 1837 and may be oral. The Wills (Soldiers and Sailors) Act 1918 extends the privilege to those under 18. Rhys was on active deployment and expressed a testamentary intention, so his statement can operate as a will in favour of his sister. No witnessing formalities apply, although there must be clear evidence of the words and intention.
Law basis: Wills Act 1837 s 11; Wills (Soldiers and Sailors) Act 1918 s 1Question 12 · Testamentary capacity and intentionDraft, pending solicitor review
Sita has advanced dementia and lacks capacity to make a will. Her daughter Tara holds a registered lasting power of attorney for property and financial affairs. Sita's last will leaves everything to a charity she cut ties with years ago, and Tara believes Sita would want a new will. Which of the following best describes the position?
- Tara may sign a new will for Sita, because the power covers all her property and financial affairs.
- Tara cannot make a will for Sita, but may apply to the Court of Protection for a statutory will.Correct answer
- Tara may revoke the existing will so that Sita's estate passes on intestacy.
- No new will can ever be made for Sita, because she has lost capacity.
- Tara may make a codicil for Sita, but not a complete new will.
An attorney under a lasting power of attorney cannot make or revoke a will on the donor's behalf. Where a person lacks capacity, the Court of Protection may order the execution of a will for them, applying the best interests test. Tara's proper course is therefore an application for a statutory will. She cannot sign a will or codicil herself, nor destroy the existing will, and it is wrong to say no new will can be made.
Law basis: Mental Capacity Act 2005 s 18(1)(i) and Sch 2 ↗Question 13 · Testamentary capacity and intentionDraft, pending solicitor review
Ursula, who had mild Alzheimer's disease, made a will leaving her house to one of her three children. After her death, another child argues that capacity should be assessed under the Mental Capacity Act 2005 functional test rather than the common law. Which of the following best describes the test the court will apply to Ursula's will?
- The 2005 Act test only, because it replaced all common law tests of capacity.
- A test of whether Ursula's choices were wise and in her own best interests.
- The 2005 Act test, but with the burden always on the person challenging the will.
- The common law test in Banks v Goodfellow, which the 2005 Act has not displaced.Correct answer
- Whether Ursula could have managed her property and affairs without assistance.
The High Court has confirmed that, for a challenge to a will made by a person while alive and since deceased, testamentary capacity is assessed under Banks v Goodfellow rather than the functional test in the Mental Capacity Act 2005. The 2005 Act governs decisions made during life and statutory wills. Capacity is not about the wisdom of the dispositions, and ability to manage property generally is a different and higher question than capacity to make a will.
Law basis: Banks v Goodfellow (1870) LR 5 QB 549; Clitheroe v Bond [2021] EWHC 1102 (Ch)Question 14 · Testamentary capacity and intentionDraft, pending solicitor review
Victor executed a new will prepared by his solicitor. Through a drafting error, it contained a clause revoking a codicil that Victor had expressly said he wanted to keep. Victor never noticed the clause, which was not read over to him. Which of the following best describes how the court can deal with the clause?
- It can omit the clause from probate, as Victor did not know and approve of it.Correct answer
- It must admit the whole will, because Victor signed it with capacity.
- It must refuse probate of the whole will, because one clause was unintended.
- It can only deal with the error by a claim in negligence against the solicitor.
- It can admit the clause but direct that the codicil also be proved.
A testator must know and approve of the contents of the will. Where words were included without the testator's knowledge and approval, the court may omit them from probate while admitting the rest, as in Re Phelan, where revocation clauses were omitted. Victor approved the will generally but not the revocation clause, so it can be excluded and the codicil can be proved with the will. Refusing probate of the whole will would defeat his intentions unnecessarily.
Law basis: Re Phelan [1972] Fam 33Question 15 · Testamentary capacity and intentionDraft, pending solicitor review
Wanda has bipolar disorder. During a manic episode last year she was unable to manage her affairs. She executed a will in a stable period, when her psychiatrist recorded that she was well, understood her assets and family, and gave clear reasons for her choices. Which of the following best describes her capacity to make the will?
- She lacked capacity, because a previous episode creates a continuing presumption.
- She had capacity only if the Court of Protection had approved the will.
- She lacked capacity, because a diagnosed mental disorder bars making a will.
- She had capacity only if the will was executed within one week of her assessment.
- She had capacity if she satisfied the common law test at the time of execution.Correct answer
Testamentary capacity is assessed at the time the will is executed. A person with a fluctuating condition can make a valid will during a lucid interval, provided they then satisfy the Banks v Goodfellow test. A diagnosis of mental disorder is not a bar, and a past episode does not create a continuing presumption of incapacity, although it may require the propounder to show capacity if doubt is raised. The contemporaneous psychiatric record will be strong evidence in support.
Law basis: Banks v Goodfellow (1870) LR 5 QB 549More Wills and Administration of Estates topics
Back to all Wills and Administration of Estates questions, or sit a timed mock.