Following an investigation, the SRA concludes that Neil, a solicitor, failed to supervise a junior colleague, causing delay to several client matters. There is no dishonesty or economic crime issue. The SRA considers a financial penalty of £40,000 appropriate. Which of the following best describes the SRA's powers?
- The SRA may impose the £40,000 fine itself, because there is no limit on fines the SRA can impose on individual solicitors.
- The SRA cannot fine Neil at all, because only the SDT can impose financial penalties on individual solicitors.
- The SRA may impose the fine, but the Legal Ombudsman must first approve it because it arises from client delays.
- The SRA may impose the fine only with Neil's written consent, because fines above £10,000 require agreement.
- The SRA cannot itself impose a fine above £25,000 in this case, so it would need to refer the matter to the SDT.Correct answer
Section 44D of the Solicitors Act 1974 gives the SRA power to impose a written rebuke or a financial penalty on a solicitor or a traditional firm. The maximum penalty the SRA can impose itself was raised to £25,000 in 2022. For misconduct outside the economic crime regime, a larger fine would require prosecution before the Solicitors Disciplinary Tribunal, which can impose an unlimited fine. Separate, higher limits apply to licensed bodies under the Legal Services Act 2007, and the cap has been removed for economic crime matters. Consent is not needed, and the Legal Ombudsman has no role in disciplinary penalties.
Law basis: Solicitors Act 1974, s44D ↗