Law covered in these questions
- Companies Act 2006 s 51
- Phonogram Ltd v Lane [1982] QB 938
- Companies Act 2006 ss 21, 22
- Companies Act 2006 s 33
- Eley v Positive Government Security Life Assurance Co (1876) 1 Ex D 88
- Companies Act 2006 s 20
- Companies (Model Articles) Regulations 2008, Sch 1 art 13
- Companies Act 2006 ss 31, 39, 171
- Companies Act 2006 ss 77, 78, 81
- Companies Act 2006 ss 8, 9, 10
- Allen v Gold Reefs of West Africa Ltd [1900] 1 Ch 656
- Sidebottom v Kershaw, Leese & Co Ltd [1920] 1 Ch 154
- Companies Act 2006 ss 69, 73
- Russell v Northern Bank Development Corp Ltd [1992] 1 WLR 588
All 13 questions with answers
Try them above first, then read the worked answers below.
Question 1 · Company formation and constitutionDraft, pending solicitor review
Harriet is about to form Harriet's Bakes Ltd. Before the company is registered, she signs a contract to lease a commercial oven, signing 'for and on behalf of Harriet's Bakes Ltd'. The company is incorporated a week later. The supplier is now unpaid. Which of the following best describes who is liable under the contract?
- The company is liable, because it automatically adopted the contract on being registered at Companies House.
- The company is liable once its board passes a resolution ratifying the contract that Harriet made on its behalf.
- No one is liable, because a contract made on behalf of a company that does not yet exist is void.
- Harriet and the company are jointly liable, because she was acting as promoter for the company.
- Harriet is personally liable, unless otherwise agreed, as the company did not exist when the contract was made.Correct answer
Section 51 of the Companies Act 2006 provides that a contract purporting to be made by or on behalf of a company at a time when it has not been formed has effect, subject to any agreement to the contrary, as one made with the person acting for the company, and that person is personally liable. Harriet is therefore liable. A company cannot ratify or adopt a contract made before it existed, because it was not a party; the solution is for the company to enter a new contract or a novation with the supplier. The contract is not void, and there is no automatic joint liability.
Law basis: Companies Act 2006 s 51; Phonogram Ltd v Lane [1982] QB 938 ↗Question 2 · Company formation and constitutionDraft, pending solicitor review
The articles of Elmhurst Ltd were adopted on incorporation and contain a provision that the clause giving each founder the right to appoint a director may be amended only with the written consent of every founder. At a general meeting, shareholders holding 90% of the votes pass a special resolution removing that clause, but one founder has not consented. Which of the following best describes the effect of the resolution?
- The amendment is effective, because any article can be amended by a special resolution of the members.
- The amendment is ineffective, because the clause is entrenched and the condition for amending it is unmet.Correct answer
- The amendment is effective, because a provision for entrenchment can only be included in a public company's articles.
- The amendment is ineffective unless it is also approved by the court on an application by the majority.
- The amendment is effective, because 90% of the votes is greater than the majority required for a special resolution.
A company may amend its articles by special resolution under s 21 of the Companies Act 2006, but s 22 allows articles to contain a 'provision for entrenchment', under which specified provisions may be amended or repealed only if conditions more restrictive than a special resolution are met. Entrenchment may be included on formation or later with the agreement of all members. Here the condition (every founder's consent) has not been satisfied, so the clause cannot be removed by special resolution, however large the majority. Entrenchment is not limited to public companies, and no court approval route is relevant.
Law basis: Companies Act 2006 ss 21, 22 ↗Question 3 · Company formation and constitutionDraft, pending solicitor review
The articles of Pendle Ltd state that Paula shall be the company's solicitor for life. Paula is also a shareholder. The board has now instructed a different firm of solicitors, and Paula wants to rely on the articles to enforce her appointment. Which of the following best describes her position?
- Paula cannot enforce it, because the articles are enforceable under s 33 only in respect of membership rights.Correct answer
- Paula can enforce the provision, because the articles form a contract between the company and each of its members.
- Paula can enforce the provision, because she was a shareholder at the time when the articles were adopted.
- Paula can enforce the provision only by bringing a derivative claim on behalf of the company against its directors.
- Paula cannot enforce the provision, because the articles may never confer any rights on an individual person.
Under s 33 of the Companies Act 2006 the provisions of a company's constitution bind the company and its members as if there were covenants on their part to observe them. However, the courts have held that this statutory contract is enforceable only in respect of rights and obligations held in the capacity of a member. In Eley v Positive Government Security Life Assurance Co, a solicitor named in the articles could not enforce his appointment even though he later became a member. Paula's right to act as solicitor is an outsider right, not a membership right, so she cannot enforce it under s 33. She would need a separate contract.
Law basis: Companies Act 2006 s 33; Eley v Positive Government Security Life Assurance Co (1876) 1 Ex D 88 ↗Question 4 · Company formation and constitutionDraft, pending solicitor review
Calder Ltd was incorporated with bespoke articles drafted by its founders. The bespoke articles deal with directors' meetings but say nothing about whether the chair has a casting vote. The board is deadlocked on a decision, and the chair wishes to use a casting vote. Which of the following best describes the source of any casting vote?
- The model articles apply so far as not excluded or modified, so the model casting vote may apply.Correct answer
- No casting vote exists, because bespoke articles wholly displace the model articles for a private company.
- A casting vote exists only if the shareholders confer it on the chair by ordinary resolution at a general meeting.
- The chair has a casting vote at common law in all companies, whatever the company's articles provide.
- A casting vote exists only if the bespoke articles were filed together with a copy of the model articles.
Under s 20 of the Companies Act 2006, where a limited company registers articles that do not exclude or modify the relevant model articles, the model articles form part of the company's articles in so far as they are not excluded or modified. Bespoke articles often expressly exclude the model articles; if Calder's do not, the model articles fill the gaps. For a private company limited by shares, model article 13 gives the chair a casting vote where the numbers of votes for and against are equal, subject to exceptions. There is no general common law casting vote, and no shareholder resolution or filing step is needed.
Law basis: Companies Act 2006 s 20; Companies (Model Articles) Regulations 2008, Sch 1 art 13 ↗Question 5 · Company formation and constitutionDraft, pending solicitor review
The articles of Bistro Group Ltd restrict its objects to running restaurants. The directors cause the company to buy a vineyard in France, and the seller had read the articles. Some shareholders object after completion. Which of the following best describes the position?
- The purchase is void, because the company lacked the capacity to act outside the objects stated in its articles.
- The purchase is valid against the seller, but the directors may be liable for acting outside the constitution.Correct answer
- The purchase is voidable by the company, because the seller had actual knowledge of the restriction on the objects.
- The purchase is valid, and the directors cannot be liable because restrictions on objects no longer have any legal effect.
- The purchase is void unless the shareholders ratify it by special resolution within 28 days of completion.
Under s 39 of the Companies Act 2006 the validity of an act done by a company cannot be called into question on the ground of lack of capacity by reason of anything in its constitution, so the purchase is valid against the seller whatever it knew. A restriction on objects still has internal effect: under s 171 directors must act in accordance with the constitution, so the directors may be liable to the company. Shareholders could have sought an injunction before the act was done, but not once the legal obligation had been fulfilled. The seller's knowledge does not make the purchase voidable for lack of capacity.
Law basis: Companies Act 2006 ss 31, 39, 171 ↗Question 6 · Company formation and constitutionDraft, pending solicitor review
The directors of Quayside Supplies Ltd want to change the company's name to Quayside Marine Ltd. The articles say nothing about changing the name. At a board meeting, the directors unanimously resolve to adopt the new name and instruct the company secretary to notify Companies House. Which of the following best describes the effect of the board resolution?
- The resolution is effective, because the choice of company name is a matter of management for the board.
- The resolution is effective, provided that the new name is not the same as a name already on the register.
- The resolution is insufficient, because absent provision in the articles a special resolution is needed.Correct answer
- The resolution is insufficient, because a change of name requires an ordinary resolution of the members.
- The resolution is effective once the board's decision is confirmed in writing by the majority shareholder.
Section 77 of the Companies Act 2006 allows a company to change its name by special resolution or by other means provided for by its articles. Quayside's articles make no provision, so a special resolution of the members is required, followed by notice to the registrar. The change takes effect when the registrar issues a new certificate of incorporation. A board resolution, however unanimous, is not enough, and an ordinary resolution is the wrong threshold. The rule against a name that is the same as an existing name is a separate requirement that must also be satisfied, not an alternative to the resolution.
Law basis: Companies Act 2006 ss 77, 78, 81 ↗Question 7 · Company formation and constitutionDraft, pending solicitor review
Saoirse is forming a new private company. Her accountant tells her that the company's memorandum of association must set out the company's objects, its share capital and the rights attached to each class of shares. Which of the following best describes the role of the memorandum for a company formed today?
- The memorandum is the company's main constitutional document, containing its objects and the rights attached to its shares.
- The memorandum sets out the company's internal management rules and may be amended by ordinary resolution.
- The memorandum must state the company's objects, and the company has no capacity to act outside them.
- The memorandum simply records that the subscribers wish to form a company and agree to become members.Correct answer
- The memorandum sets out the share capital and may be altered only with the consent of every member.
Under s 8 of the Companies Act 2006 a memorandum of association is a memorandum stating that the subscribers wish to form a company under the Act and agree to become members, and, in the case of a company having share capital, to take at least one share each. It is a historical snapshot, not part of the company's ongoing constitution for these purposes. The company's internal rules, including any restriction on objects and class rights, are in its articles. Share capital details are given in the statement of capital delivered on registration. The accountant's description reflects the position under earlier legislation.
Law basis: Companies Act 2006 ss 8, 9, 10 ↗Question 8 · Company formation and constitutionDraft, pending solicitor review
Tolland Ltd has three shareholders. Ursula holds 10% and runs a rival business through another company. The majority pass a special resolution adding an article requiring any member who carries on a competing business to transfer her shares to the other members at fair value. Ursula says the amendment is invalid because it targets her. Which of the following best describes the likely position?
- The amendment is invalid, because articles cannot be amended to permit the compulsory acquisition of a member's shares.
- The amendment is invalid, because an alteration that affects only one member requires that member's consent.
- The amendment is valid automatically, because the court never reviews a special resolution passed by the requisite majority.
- The amendment is valid only if Ursula is first offered the chance to sell her shares to an outside buyer.
- The amendment is likely to be valid if passed in good faith for the benefit of the company as a whole.Correct answer
A special resolution to alter the articles under s 21 of the Companies Act 2006 must be passed bona fide for the benefit of the company as a whole (Allen v Gold Reefs of West Africa). In Sidebottom v Kershaw Leese & Co the Court of Appeal upheld a new article allowing the compulsory purchase of shares held by members who competed with the company, because removing competitors was in the company's interest. The fact that the alteration presently affects only Ursula does not invalidate it. The court does review alterations for good faith, so a resolution passed purely to oppress a minority would be open to challenge.
Law basis: Allen v Gold Reefs of West Africa Ltd [1900] 1 Ch 656; Sidebottom v Kershaw, Leese & Co Ltd [1920] 1 Ch 154Question 9 · Company formation and constitutionDraft, pending solicitor review
Holt Kitchens Ltd has traded under that name for 20 years and has substantial goodwill. A new company, Holt Kitchen Ltd, has been registered by a stranger who has written to Holt Kitchens offering to change the name for a payment of £20,000. Which of the following best describes Holt Kitchens' most appropriate remedy under the Companies Act 2006?
- Holt Kitchens can do nothing, because the names differ by one letter and so both may be registered.
- Holt Kitchens must pay the £20,000, because the registrar has no power to require a registered name to be changed.
- Holt Kitchens may object to a company names adjudicator that the new name is misleadingly similar.Correct answer
- Holt Kitchens may apply to the registrar to strike the new company off the register for bad faith.
- Holt Kitchens may only bring a claim in passing off, as the Act provides no remedy for similar names.
Under s 69 of the Companies Act 2006 a person may object to a company names adjudicator on the ground that a company's registered name is the same as a name associated with the applicant in which it has goodwill, or is sufficiently similar to such a name that its use would be likely to mislead by suggesting a connection. Evidence that the name was registered to obtain money from the objector supports the objection, and the opportunistic registration defences under s 69(4) are unlikely to apply. The adjudicator may order the name to be changed. Passing off remains possible, but it is not the only route, and striking off is not the remedy for a misleading name.
Law basis: Companies Act 2006 ss 69, 73 ↗Question 10 · Company formation and constitutionDraft, pending solicitor review
Ilsa, Joel and Kim are the shareholders of Larch Ltd. They and the company signed a shareholders' agreement providing that the company's share capital would not be increased without all three shareholders' written consent. Ilsa and Joel now want to vote for a resolution to issue new shares, but Kim refuses to consent. Which of the following best describes the effect of the agreement?
- The agreement is wholly void, because shareholders cannot lawfully agree in advance how they will cast their votes.
- The agreement binds the company, which is therefore prevented from ever issuing any further shares in the future.
- The agreement is unenforceable, because any restriction on issuing shares must be contained in the company's articles.
- The agreement binds the shareholders as a personal voting agreement but cannot fetter the company's statutory powers.Correct answer
- The agreement binds the shareholders only if it is filed at Companies House within 15 days of being signed.
In Russell v Northern Bank Development Corp the House of Lords held that a company cannot contract out of its statutory power to alter its constitution or capital, so an undertaking by the company itself in such terms is unenforceable against it. However, an agreement between the shareholders as to how they will exercise their votes is a personal contract and is enforceable between them. Kim can therefore enforce the agreement against Ilsa and Joel, for example by seeking an injunction to restrain them from voting in breach. Shareholders' agreements are private contracts and do not need to be filed, unlike resolutions affecting the constitution.
Law basis: Russell v Northern Bank Development Corp Ltd [1992] 1 WLR 588Question 11 · Company formation and constitutionDraft, pending solicitor review
Marlow plc was registered as a public company last month with allotted share capital of £50,000. Before it has obtained a trading certificate from the registrar, its directors sign a £200,000 contract with Neve Ltd for office equipment. Neve did not know that no trading certificate had been issued. Which of the following best describes the effect of the contract?
- The contract is void, because a public company cannot do business or exercise borrowing powers without a trading certificate.
- The contract is voidable at the option of Marlow plc until it obtains a trading certificate from the registrar.
- The contract binds the directors personally, and Marlow plc is never bound by it even after it obtains a certificate.
- The contract is valid, and no consequence follows because Neve was unaware that no certificate had been issued.
- The contract is valid, but the directors may have to indemnify Neve if the company fails to perform within 21 days.Correct answer
Under s 761 of the Companies Act 2006 a company registered as a public company must not do business or exercise borrowing powers until the registrar has issued a trading certificate. Breach is an offence, but under s 767(3) the validity of the transaction is not affected. If the company fails to comply with its obligations under the transaction within 21 days of being called on to do so, the directors who were in office at the time are jointly and severally liable to indemnify the other party for its loss. The contract is therefore valid, but Neve has added protection. The answer that the contract is void reflects a common misconception.
Law basis: Companies Act 2006 ss 761, 767 ↗Question 12 · Company formation and constitutionDraft, pending solicitor review
Orla holds 5% of the shares in Pike Ltd, which are fully paid. The other shareholders pass a valid special resolution adding a new article that requires every member to lend the company £10,000 on demand. Orla did not vote for the change and has not agreed to it in writing. The company now demands £10,000 from her. Which of the following best describes Orla's position?
- Orla is bound, because the alteration was validly made by special resolution and binds every member equally.
- Orla is bound, unless she applies to the court within 21 days to have the special resolution cancelled on the ground of unfairness.
- Orla is not bound, as she has not agreed in writing to an alteration increasing her liability to the company.Correct answer
- Orla is bound only if the alteration was made bona fide for the benefit of the company as a whole.
- Orla is not bound, because articles can never impose any financial obligation on members of the company.
Section 25 of the Companies Act 2006 provides that a member is not bound by an alteration to the articles made after she became a member, so far as it requires her to take or subscribe for more shares or in any way increases her liability to contribute to the company's share capital or otherwise to pay money to the company, unless she agrees in writing. Orla has not agreed, so she is not bound to lend the money. The good faith test for alterations is relevant to the validity of the resolution generally, but s 25 gives Orla specific protection regardless. The 21-day court application relates to class rights variations, not this situation.
Law basis: Companies Act 2006 s 25 ↗Question 13 · Company formation and constitutionDraft, pending solicitor review
Quill Ltd has an issued share capital of 100 ordinary shares held equally by Rosa and Sven. They want to convert the company into a public company so that it can later offer shares to investors. The company's issued share capital is currently £100. Which of the following best describes what is required?
- A board resolution, a fresh certificate of incorporation, and a public offer document filed before re-registration.
- An ordinary resolution to re-register, with no change to the share capital, as a private company may convert freely.
- A special resolution to re-register and a statement of solvency signed by all of the directors of the company.
- A unanimous written resolution of the members and a court order confirming that the existing creditors will not be prejudiced.
- A special resolution to re-register, altered articles, and allotted share capital of at least the authorised minimum.Correct answer
Under ss 90 and 91 of the Companies Act 2006 a private company may re-register as a public company if a special resolution to do so is passed, the conditions as to share capital are met, and the application is accompanied by the necessary documents, including the altered articles. The company's allotted share capital must be at least the authorised minimum (£50,000), with each share paid up to at least one quarter of its nominal value plus any premium. Quill's £100 capital is therefore insufficient, and it must allot more shares first. An ordinary resolution or board resolution is not enough, and a solvency statement or court order is not part of this process.
Law basis: Companies Act 2006 ss 90, 91, 763 ↗More Business Law and Practice topics
Back to all Business Law and Practice questions, or sit a timed mock.