Law covered in these questions
- Partnership Act 1890 s 17(1)
- Partnership Act 1890 ss 1, 2
- Partnership Act 1890 s 5
- Mercantile Credit Co Ltd v Garrod [1962] 3 All ER 1103
- Partnership Act 1890 s 36(1), (2)
- Partnership Act 1890 s 24(1), (4), (6)
- Partnership Act 1890 s 25
- Partnership Act 1890 ss 26(1), 32(c)
- Partnership Act 1890 s 33(1)
- Partnership Act 1890 s 24(8)
- Partnership Act 1890 s 14(1)
- Tower Cabinet Co Ltd v Ingram [1949] 2 KB 397
- Partnership Act 1890 ss 10, 12
- Dubai Aluminium Co Ltd v Salaam [2002] UKHL 48
All 15 questions with answers
Try them above first, then read the worked answers below.
Question 1 · PartnershipsDraft, pending solicitor review
Ben, Cara and Dev run a printing firm as an ordinary partnership. In March the firm bought paper on credit from a supplier. In June Zoe joined the partnership. The firm cannot pay the supplier. Which statement best describes Zoe's position?
- Zoe is liable for it, but only up to the amount of capital she contributed.
- Zoe is not liable for the debt incurred before she became a partner, unless she agrees to be.Correct answer
- Zoe is liable for it jointly with the others, but only if the supplier knew of her when it supplied the paper.
- Zoe is liable for it, because she shares in the firm's profits.
- Zoe is liable for it, because partners are liable for all the firm's debts whenever incurred.
Question 2 · PartnershipsDraft, pending solicitor review
Leah and Marco inherited a holiday cottage as joint owners. They let it to tourists through an agency, split the rental income equally and each pay half the maintenance costs. They have no written agreement and do nothing else together. A cleaner engaged by Leah is unpaid and claims that Marco is liable as her partner. Which of the following best describes whether a partnership exists?
- A partnership exists, because they share the net income from the cottage and so carry on a business in common.
- A partnership exists, because sharing income is conclusive evidence of partnership unless a written agreement says otherwise.
- A partnership exists only for the purposes of the cleaner's claim, because she was engaged for the benefit of both owners.
- A partnership cannot exist between them, because a partnership can only be created by a written partnership agreement.
- Joint ownership and sharing of the rent does not of itself make them partners, so a partnership is unlikely to exist.Correct answer
A partnership is the relation between persons carrying on a business in common with a view to profit. Section 2(1) of the Partnership Act 1890 provides that joint ownership of property does not of itself create a partnership, whether or not the co-owners share any profits from its use. Section 2(2) adds that sharing gross returns does not of itself create a partnership. Leah and Marco simply co-own and let an inherited asset, so a partnership is unlikely. Receipt of a share of profits is only prima facie evidence under s 2(3), not conclusive. No written agreement is needed to form a partnership, so the suggestion that one is required misstates the law.
Law basis: Partnership Act 1890 ss 1, 2Question 3 · PartnershipsDraft, pending solicitor review
Nia, Owen and Pip are partners in a florist business. Their partnership agreement says that no partner may buy any item costing more than £5,000 without the consent of all partners. Without consulting the others, Nia buys a £9,000 refrigerated delivery van on credit from a dealer, who knows nothing of the agreement. The firm refuses to pay. Which of the following best describes the firm's liability?
- The firm is not bound, because the partnership agreement expressly limited Nia's authority to purchases of £5,000 or less in value.
- The firm is bound only if Owen and Pip later ratify the purchase, as Nia acted outside her actual authority.
- The firm is not bound, but Nia is personally liable to the dealer for breach of warranty of authority.
- The firm is bound, as buying a van is within the usual course of a florist's business and the dealer did not know of the limit.Correct answer
- The firm is bound only to the extent of £5,000, and Nia is personally liable for the remaining £4,000.
Under s 5 of the Partnership Act 1890 every partner is an agent of the firm, and acts done for carrying on in the usual way business of the kind carried on by the firm bind the firm. The exception is where the partner has no authority and the third party either knows that or does not know or believe the person to be a partner. Buying a delivery van is within the usual course of a florist's business, and the dealer did not know of the internal restriction, so the firm is bound. The restriction matters only between the partners: Nia may have to indemnify Owen and Pip for breach of the agreement.
Law basis: Partnership Act 1890 s 5; Mercantile Credit Co Ltd v Garrod [1962] 3 All ER 1103Question 4 · PartnershipsDraft, pending solicitor review
Rhys retired from a building partnership in May. The firm published a notice of his retirement in the London Gazette but did not write to its customers or suppliers. In August, a timber merchant that had supplied the firm regularly for years, and which knew Rhys was a partner, supplied timber on credit. The firm cannot pay. Which of the following best describes Rhys's liability to the timber merchant?
- Rhys is liable, because an existing customer may treat him as a partner until it receives actual notice of his retirement.Correct answer
- Rhys is not liable, because a notice in the London Gazette is effective notice of retirement against everyone dealing with the firm.
- Rhys is not liable, because a retiring partner is never liable for debts incurred by the firm after his retirement.
- Rhys is liable only if he had held himself out as a partner to the timber merchant after the date of his retirement.
- Rhys is liable only for a share of the debt in proportion to his share of the profits before he retired.
Section 36 of the Partnership Act 1890 provides that a person dealing with a firm after a change in its constitution is entitled to treat all apparent members of the old firm as still members until he has notice of the change. For people who had dealings with the firm before the change, actual notice is required; an advertisement in the London Gazette is notice only to people who had no prior dealings. The timber merchant was an existing supplier and received no actual notice, so it can treat Rhys as a partner and he is liable. Holding out under s 14 is a separate route and is not needed here.
Law basis: Partnership Act 1890 s 36(1), (2)Question 5 · PartnershipsDraft, pending solicitor review
Ana and Ben set up a café in partnership with no written agreement. Ana contributed £80,000 of capital and Ben contributed £20,000. Ben works full time in the café and Ana works two days a week. The firm's profit for the year is £60,000. Which of the following best describes how that profit should be shared?
- Ana receives £48,000 and Ben £12,000, because profits are shared in proportion to capital contributed.
- Ben receives a salary for his extra work first, and the balance is then divided equally between them.
- Ana and Ben each receive £30,000, as partners share profits equally unless they agree otherwise.Correct answer
- Ana first receives interest at 5% on her capital, and the balance is then divided equally between them.
- Ana and Ben share the profit in proportion to the hours each of them works in the business during the year.
Section 24 of the Partnership Act 1890 sets default rules that apply subject to any express or implied agreement between the partners. Under s 24(1) partners are entitled to share equally in the capital and profits of the business, regardless of how much capital each contributed. Under s 24(4) a partner is not entitled to interest on capital, and under s 24(6) no partner is entitled to remuneration for acting in the partnership business. With no agreement, Ana and Ben each receive £30,000. The proportionate-to-capital approach is a common misconception; it would require an agreement between them.
Law basis: Partnership Act 1890 s 24(1), (4), (6)Question 6 · PartnershipsDraft, pending solicitor review
Cora, Dan, Eve and Finn are partners in a design firm with no written partnership agreement. Cora, Dan and Eve are unhappy with Finn's poor timekeeping and hold a meeting at which they vote to expel him from the partnership with immediate effect. Which of the following best describes the effect of the vote?
- The vote is effective, because ordinary matters connected with the business may be decided by a majority of the partners.
- The vote is ineffective, because a majority cannot expel a partner unless a power to do so has been expressly agreed.Correct answer
- The vote is effective, provided that Finn is given reasonable notice and an opportunity to answer the complaints.
- The vote is ineffective unless it is confirmed by the court on the ground of Finn's persistent breach of the agreement.
- The vote is effective, because it was passed by partners holding at least three-quarters of the votes in the firm.
Section 25 of the Partnership Act 1890 provides that no majority of the partners can expel any partner unless a power to do so has been conferred by express agreement between the partners. There is no such agreement, so the vote has no effect and Finn remains a partner. Majority decision-making under s 24(8) covers ordinary matters connected with the business, not expulsion. The other partners' options include dissolving a partnership at will by notice or applying to court under s 35, but they cannot simply vote Finn out. Giving notice or a hearing does not cure the absence of an express power.
Law basis: Partnership Act 1890 s 25Question 7 · PartnershipsDraft, pending solicitor review
Gus, Hana and Ivan have run a recruitment business in partnership for six years. There is no partnership agreement and no fixed term was ever agreed. After a dispute, Gus sends an email to Hana and Ivan stating that he is dissolving the partnership with effect from the end of the month. Which of the following best describes the effect of the email?
- The partnership is not dissolved, because dissolution requires the unanimous agreement of all the partners.
- The partnership is dissolved from the date in the notice, as a partnership at will may be ended by notice.Correct answer
- The partnership continues between Hana and Ivan, and Gus is treated as having retired at the end of the month.
- The partnership is not dissolved until the court makes an order, because Gus has no ground for dissolution.
- The partnership is dissolved, but only after a minimum period of three months' notice has expired.
A partnership with no fixed term is a partnership at will. Under ss 26 and 32(c) of the Partnership Act 1890 any partner may determine it by giving notice to the others of his intention to do so. If the notice states a date, the partnership is dissolved from that date; otherwise it is dissolved from the date the notice is communicated. No consent, court order or minimum notice period is required. The default position is dissolution of the whole firm, not the retirement of Gus with the others continuing; that outcome would need agreement between the partners.
Law basis: Partnership Act 1890 ss 26(1), 32(c)Question 8 · PartnershipsDraft, pending solicitor review
Jade, Kit, Lou and Max are partners in a veterinary practice. There is no written partnership agreement. Max dies suddenly. Jade, Kit and Lou want to carry on the practice and assume that it simply continues without Max. Which of the following best describes the legal effect of Max's death?
- The partnership is dissolved as regards all the partners, as there is no agreement for it to continue.Correct answer
- The partnership continues automatically between the surviving partners, and Max's estate is paid his share.
- The partnership continues, but Max's personal representatives become partners in his place until it is wound up.
- The partnership is dissolved only if the surviving partners vote by majority to bring it to an end.
- The partnership is dissolved only as regards Max, and the surviving partners continue the existing firm.
Section 33(1) of the Partnership Act 1890 provides that, subject to any agreement between the partners, every partnership is dissolved as regards all the partners by the death or bankruptcy of any partner. With no agreement providing for continuation, Max's death dissolves the whole firm, and the business must be wound up or a new partnership formed by the survivors, who will need to deal with Max's estate as to his share. Personal representatives do not become partners. This default rule is why well-drafted partnership agreements expressly provide for the firm to continue after a death.
Law basis: Partnership Act 1890 s 33(1)Question 9 · PartnershipsDraft, pending solicitor review
Kai, Lena and Moss run a cycle repair shop in partnership with no written agreement. Kai and Lena want the firm to start selling second-hand cars as well, which would require a large investment. Moss objects strongly. Which of the following best describes whether the firm can expand into car sales?
- The firm can expand into car sales, because ordinary business decisions may be taken by a majority of the partners.
- The firm cannot expand into car sales, because a change in the nature of the business needs every partner's consent.Correct answer
- The firm can expand into car sales, provided that Moss is offered the chance to retire and be paid out his share.
- The firm can expand into car sales only if Kai and Lena bear all the costs and take all of the resulting profits.
- The firm cannot expand into car sales unless the court grants permission on the application of the majority partners.
Under s 24(8) of the Partnership Act 1890, any differences arising as to ordinary matters connected with the partnership business may be decided by a majority of the partners, but no change may be made in the nature of the partnership business without the consent of all existing partners. Moving from cycle repairs into second-hand car sales is a change in the nature of the business, so Moss's objection is decisive. The majority rule does not apply to such fundamental changes. Kai and Lena could instead dissolve the partnership at will by notice and start a new venture, or agree new terms with Moss.
Law basis: Partnership Act 1890 s 24(8)Question 10 · PartnershipsDraft, pending solicitor review
Nell is not a partner in her son's accountancy firm, but she agreed that the firm's website could describe her as 'Senior Partner' to give clients confidence. A software supplier read the website and gave the firm credit in reliance on Nell's apparent involvement. The firm has not paid. Which of the following best describes Nell's liability?
- Nell is liable, as she knowingly let herself be represented as a partner and the supplier relied on it.Correct answer
- Nell is not liable, because only the true partners of a firm can be liable for its debts to creditors.
- Nell is liable only if she has received a share of the firm's profits during the relevant period of time.
- Nell is not liable, because a representation made on a website cannot amount to holding out as a partner.
- Nell is liable only if she personally signed the contract with the supplier or spoke to the supplier.
Section 14(1) of the Partnership Act 1890 provides that everyone who by words or conduct represents herself, or knowingly suffers herself to be represented, as a partner is liable as a partner to anyone who has on the faith of that representation given credit to the firm. Nell knowingly allowed the website to describe her as a partner, and the supplier gave credit in reliance on it, so she is liable under s 14 despite not being a true partner. The representation need not be made directly to the creditor, and a website is capable of being such a representation. Profit-sharing is not required for holding out.
Law basis: Partnership Act 1890 s 14(1); Tower Cabinet Co Ltd v Ingram [1949] 2 KB 397Question 11 · PartnershipsDraft, pending solicitor review
Odette and Piers are partners in a removals firm. While moving a client's furniture in the course of the business, Piers negligently drops a piano on the client, Quinn, causing serious injury. Quinn sues Odette alone for the full amount of his damages, because Piers has no assets. Which of the following best describes Odette's position?
- Odette is liable for only half of the damages, because liability for wrongs is divided equally between the two partners.
- Odette is not liable, because liability in tort is personal to the partner who actually committed the wrong.
- Odette is liable only if Quinn first obtains judgment against Piers and shows that it cannot be satisfied.
- Odette is liable in full, as partners are jointly and severally liable for wrongs in the ordinary course of business.Correct answer
- Odette is liable only if she was present when the accident occurred and failed to prevent it from happening.
Under s 10 of the Partnership Act 1890 the firm is liable for loss caused by a partner's wrongful act or omission in the ordinary course of the firm's business, and under s 12 every partner is jointly and severally liable for such wrongs. Moving a client's furniture is plainly in the ordinary course of a removals business, so Quinn may sue Odette alone for the whole of his damages. Odette may then seek a contribution or indemnity from Piers, but that is a matter between the partners. Liability is not divided between partners as against the claimant, and Odette's personal fault is irrelevant.
Law basis: Partnership Act 1890 ss 10, 12; Dubai Aluminium Co Ltd v Salaam [2002] UKHL 48Question 12 · PartnershipsDraft, pending solicitor review
Rafe is a partner in a plumbing firm. Without telling his partners, he has been doing plumbing jobs for his own customers at weekends and keeping the payments, which total £15,000 over the year. The partnership agreement says nothing about outside work. His partners find out. Which of the following best describes Rafe's position?
- Rafe may keep the money, because the partnership agreement did not expressly prohibit him from doing outside work.
- Rafe may keep the money, provided that the weekend jobs did not reduce the time he spent on the firm's business.
- Rafe must pay the firm interest on the £15,000 but may keep the payments themselves as his own personal earnings.
- Rafe must account for the profits only if his partners can prove that the firm lost those particular customers.
- Rafe must account to the firm for the profits, as he ran a competing business without his partners' consent.Correct answer
Section 30 of the Partnership Act 1890 provides that if a partner, without the consent of the other partners, carries on any business of the same nature as and competing with that of the firm, he must account for and pay over to the firm all profits made by him in that business. Rafe's weekend plumbing competes with the firm's business, and his partners did not consent, so he must account for the £15,000 profits. An express prohibition is not needed, because the duty arises from statute and the fiduciary nature of partnership. The firm does not need to prove that it lost particular customers.
Law basis: Partnership Act 1890 s 30Question 13 · PartnershipsDraft, pending solicitor review
Sid retired from a garage partnership in March. Under the retirement deed, the continuing partners agreed to indemnify him against all the firm's existing debts. In February the firm had bought equipment on credit from Tyne Tools, which was not a party to the deed and was simply told of Sid's retirement. The debt is unpaid. Which of the following best describes Sid's liability to Tyne Tools?
- Sid is not liable, because the indemnity in the retirement deed transferred the debt to the continuing partners.
- Sid is not liable, because Tyne Tools received actual notice of his retirement before it demanded payment.
- Sid remains liable to Tyne Tools, but he may claim an indemnity from the continuing partners under the deed.Correct answer
- Sid is liable only for a share of the debt matching his share of the profits before he retired from the firm.
- Sid is liable only if Tyne Tools can show that the continuing partners are unable to pay the debt themselves.
Under s 17(2) of the Partnership Act 1890 a retiring partner does not cease to be liable for partnership debts or obligations incurred before his retirement. Under s 17(3) he may be discharged by an agreement to that effect between himself, the members of the firm as newly constituted and the creditor, which may be express or inferred from a course of dealing. Tyne Tools is not a party to any such agreement, so Sid remains liable for the February debt. The indemnity operates only between the partners. Notice of retirement under s 36 protects against liability for later debts, not existing ones.
Law basis: Partnership Act 1890 s 17(2), (3)Question 14 · PartnershipsDraft, pending solicitor review
Uri and Vee agreed to open an Indian restaurant together. Over several months they signed a lease in both names, opened a joint business bank account, bought kitchen equipment and hired a designer. They fell out before the restaurant opened and it never traded. Uri argues that no partnership ever existed because no food was ever sold. Which of the following best describes the position?
- No partnership existed, because a business is not carried on until it starts trading with its customers.
- No partnership existed, because Uri and Vee never made a written partnership agreement between them.
- A partnership existed only from the date on which they opened the joint business bank account together.
- A partnership existed, as they had begun carrying on the business in common through those steps.Correct answer
- No partnership existed, because a partnership requires that profits have actually been made and shared.
A partnership exists where persons carry on a business in common with a view to profit (Partnership Act 1890 s 1). In Khan v Miah the House of Lords held that parties who had agreed to open a restaurant and had taken steps such as acquiring premises, opening a bank account and buying equipment were already carrying on business in partnership, even though the restaurant had not opened. Trading with customers is not required for business to have commenced. There is no requirement of a written agreement, and a 'view to profit' does not mean profits must actually have been made.
Law basis: Partnership Act 1890 s 1; Khan v Miah [2000] 1 WLR 2123Question 15 · PartnershipsDraft, pending solicitor review
Ivy and Jon's partnership is being wound up. After the assets are sold the firm has £100,000. It owes £40,000 to outside creditors. Ivy earlier lent the firm £10,000, separately from her capital. Ivy's capital contribution was £30,000 and Jon's was £10,000. They share profits equally and there is no agreement about dissolution. Which of the following best describes the distribution to the partners?
- Ivy receives £30,000 and Jon receives £30,000.
- Ivy receives £40,000 and Jon receives £20,000.
- Ivy receives £45,000 and Jon receives £15,000.Correct answer
- Ivy receives £50,000 and Jon receives £10,000.
- Ivy receives £42,500 and Jon receives £17,500 in total.
Section 44 of the Partnership Act 1890 sets the default order for applying assets on dissolution: first, debts to outside creditors; second, advances made by partners as distinct from capital; third, partners' capital; and finally any residue is divided in the proportion in which profits are shared. After paying £40,000 to creditors, £60,000 remains. Ivy's £10,000 loan is repaid, leaving £50,000. Capital of £30,000 and £10,000 is returned, leaving £10,000, which is split equally. Ivy therefore receives £10,000 + £30,000 + £5,000 = £45,000 and Jon receives £10,000 + £5,000 = £15,000. The equal-split answer ignores the order of repayment.
Law basis: Partnership Act 1890 s 44More Business Law and Practice topics
Back to all Business Law and Practice questions, or sit a timed mock.