Law covered in these questions
- Companies Act 2006 s 40(1), (2)(b)
- Companies Act 2006 ss 168, 288(2)(a), 312
- Bushell v Faith [1970] AC 1099
- Companies Act 2006 s 168
- Companies Act 2006 s 169
- Companies Act 2006 s 168(1), (5)
- Southern Foundries (1926) Ltd v Shirlaw [1940] AC 701
- Companies (Model Articles) Regulations 2008, Sch 1 art 17
- Companies Act 2006 s 167
- Companies Act 2006 s 157
- Companies Act 2006 ss 154, 155
- Companies Act 2006 ss 170(5), 251
- Secretary of State for Trade and Industry v Deverell [2001] Ch 340
- Holland v Revenue and Customs Commissioners [2010] UKSC 51
All 15 questions with answers
Try them above first, then read the worked answers below.
Question 1 · Directors: appointment, removal and authorityDraft, pending solicitor review
The articles of Orbit Ltd say its directors may not borrow more than £100,000 without shareholder approval. The directors borrow £150,000 from Brightbank without that approval. Brightbank knew of the limit in the articles but was not told that approval was missing, and it acted honestly. Which statement best describes the position?
- The company is not bound, because Brightbank knew of the limit in the articles.
- The company is bound only if Brightbank asked for and received evidence of shareholder approval.
- The company is bound only if the shareholders later ratify the loan by ordinary resolution.
- The company is bound, because s 40 treats the directors' power to bind the company as free of limits in the constitution in favour of a person dealing in good faith.Correct answer
- The company is not bound, because the articles bind outsiders dealing with the company.
Under s 40 a person dealing in good faith can rely on the directors' power, and knowing of a limit in the constitution does not itself amount to bad faith. The person has no duty to enquire.
Law basis: Companies Act 2006 s 40(1), (2)(b) ↗Question 2 · Directors: appointment, removal and authorityDraft, pending solicitor review
Arlo holds 70% of the shares in Brook Ltd and wants to remove Cass from the board quickly. He asks his solicitor to circulate a written resolution to the members for Cass's removal, which he alone can pass. The articles contain no relevant provisions. Which of the following best describes how Cass can be removed?
- By a written ordinary resolution signed by Arlo, because he holds a majority of the total voting rights.
- By an ordinary resolution at a general meeting after special notice, as a written resolution is barred.Correct answer
- By a written special resolution signed by Arlo, because removal of a director requires a 75% majority.
- By a board resolution of the other directors, after giving Cass at least 14 days' written notice.
- By an ordinary resolution at a general meeting, but only if Cass has committed a serious breach of duty.
Section 168 of the Companies Act 2006 allows a company to remove a director by ordinary resolution at a meeting, notwithstanding anything in any agreement between the company and the director. Special notice of 28 days must be given to the company under s 312. Section 288(2)(a) provides that a written resolution cannot be used to remove a director under s 168 before the end of his period of office, because the director has a right to be heard at the meeting. Arlo can still achieve removal, as his 70% is enough to pass an ordinary resolution. No ground or misconduct is required, and the board cannot remove a director under s 168.
Law basis: Companies Act 2006 ss 168, 288(2)(a), 312 ↗Question 3 · Directors: appointment, removal and authorityDraft, pending solicitor review
Dana is a director of Elm Tree Ltd and holds 30 of its 100 shares. The other 70 shares are held by Ezra and Faith, who want to remove her. The articles provide that on any resolution to remove a director, that director's shares carry three votes each. A valid meeting is held and every shareholder votes. Which of the following best describes the outcome?
- The resolution fails, as Dana casts 90 votes against 70, and a weighted voting clause of this kind is valid.Correct answer
- The resolution passes, as weighted voting clauses are void as an attempt to override the statutory removal power.
- The resolution passes, as Ezra and Faith hold a majority of the issued shares in the company.
- The resolution fails only if Dana has a service contract that was approved by the members.
- The resolution passes, as a director may not vote her own shares on a resolution for her removal.
Section 168 of the Companies Act 2006 allows removal by ordinary resolution, but it does not dictate how votes attached to shares are allocated. In Bushell v Faith the House of Lords upheld an article giving a director's shares weighted votes on a resolution to remove him. Here Dana's 30 shares carry 90 votes against the 70 votes of Ezra and Faith, so the resolution fails. A director who is a shareholder may vote her shares on her own removal. Majority shareholders should check articles for such clauses and may need to change them first, though removing the clause itself may be subject to similar protection.
Law basis: Bushell v Faith [1970] AC 1099; Companies Act 2006 s 168Question 4 · Directors: appointment, removal and authorityDraft, pending solicitor review
The shareholders of Gale Ltd have given special notice of a resolution to remove Hugo as a director at a general meeting next month. Hugo wants to fight the resolution and asks what procedural rights he has. Which of the following best describes his rights?
- He may veto the resolution if he has served on the board for more than two years.
- He may require the meeting to be adjourned until an independent valuation of his shares is obtained.
- He may insist that the resolution be passed only as a special resolution of the members.
- He may be heard at the meeting and require his written representations to be sent to the members.Correct answer
- He may require the company to pay his legal costs of opposing the resolution in advance.
Under s 169 of the Companies Act 2006, on receipt of notice of an intended resolution to remove a director, the company must send a copy to the director concerned. He is entitled to be heard on the resolution at the meeting, whether or not he is a member. He may also make written representations of a reasonable length and request that they be notified to the members; if they are received too late to circulate, he may require them to be read out at the meeting. These rights explain why a written resolution cannot be used. The director has no veto, and the resolution remains an ordinary resolution.
Law basis: Companies Act 2006 s 169 ↗Question 5 · Directors: appointment, removal and authorityDraft, pending solicitor review
Isla has a two-year fixed-term service contract as sales director of Juno Ltd, with 18 months left to run and no provision for early termination. The shareholders validly remove her as a director by ordinary resolution under s 168. Which of the following best describes Isla's position?
- Her removal is ineffective while her fixed-term service contract still has time to run.
- Her removal is effective, and she has no claim because s 168 overrides her service contract.
- Her removal is effective only if the company first pays her 18 months' salary in lieu.
- Her removal is effective, but she remains employed as sales director until the term ends.
- Her removal is effective, but she may claim damages for breach of her service contract.Correct answer
Section 168(1) allows removal of a director by ordinary resolution notwithstanding any agreement between the company and the director. However, s 168(5) provides that this does not deprive the director of compensation or damages payable in respect of the termination of her appointment as director or of any appointment terminating with it. Removal will usually terminate her executive role, and if the company has broken her fixed-term contract, she may claim damages, subject to mitigation, as in Southern Foundries v Shirlaw. The contract does not prevent removal, and payment in advance is not a precondition. The contract is two years, so no members' approval was needed under s 188.
Law basis: Companies Act 2006 s 168(1), (5); Southern Foundries (1926) Ltd v Shirlaw [1940] AC 701 ↗Question 6 · Directors: appointment, removal and authorityDraft, pending solicitor review
Kestrel Ltd has adopted the model articles for private companies without amendment. At a quorate board meeting, the directors unanimously resolve to appoint Lena as an additional director. No shareholder resolution is passed. A shareholder argues that only the members can appoint directors. Which of the following best describes the position?
- The appointment is invalid, as directors may be appointed only by an ordinary resolution of the members.
- The appointment is valid only until the next annual general meeting, when it must be confirmed by the members.
- The appointment is valid, as the model articles allow the board to appoint directors.Correct answer
- The appointment is invalid unless the members first approve it by special resolution under the articles.
- The appointment is valid, but Lena cannot vote at board meetings until it is confirmed by the members.
Model article 17 for private companies limited by shares provides that a person willing to act as a director may be appointed either by ordinary resolution or by a decision of the directors. The board's unanimous decision is therefore effective. Under s 167 of the Companies Act 2006 the company must notify the registrar of the appointment within 14 days, with the required particulars and consent to act. The requirement for confirmation at the next AGM appears in the model articles for public companies, not private companies, and private companies are not required to hold AGMs at all. Lena may act and vote immediately.
Law basis: Companies (Model Articles) Regulations 2008, Sch 1 art 17; Companies Act 2006 s 167 ↗Question 7 · Directors: appointment, removal and authorityDraft, pending solicitor review
Milo, aged 15, is a gifted coder. His mother, the sole shareholder of Nimbus Apps Ltd, wants to appoint him to the board alongside herself so that he can sign contracts with app developers. Which of the following best describes whether Milo can be appointed?
- He can be validly appointed, as there is no minimum age provided the company has another adult director.
- He can be validly appointed if his mother consents in writing as his parent and as the sole shareholder.
- He can be validly appointed, but any contracts he signs will be voidable because he is a minor.
- He cannot be validly appointed, as a person must be at least 16 to be appointed as a director.Correct answer
- He cannot be validly appointed, as a person must be at least 18 to be appointed as a director.
Section 157 of the Companies Act 2006 provides that a person may not be appointed a director of a company unless he has attained the age of 16, and an appointment in contravention of this is void. Milo is 15, so any purported appointment is void, and parental or shareholder consent cannot cure it. The minimum age is 16, not 18, and the presence of another director does not displace the rule. Milo could be employed or engaged in another capacity, and the company could authorise him to act as its agent, but he cannot be a director until he turns 16.
Law basis: Companies Act 2006 s 157 ↗Question 8 · Directors: appointment, removal and authorityDraft, pending solicitor review
Orion Holdings Ltd is the only director of its subsidiary, Orion Retail Ltd. No individual sits on the subsidiary's board. The group's company secretary asks whether this arrangement complies with the Companies Act 2006. Which of the following best describes the position?
- It complies, because a private company needs only one director and that director may be any legal person.
- It complies, provided that the company secretary of the subsidiary is an individual who lives in the UK.
- It does not comply, because every company must have at least one director who is a natural person.Correct answer
- It does not comply, because a private company must have at least two directors, one of them an individual.
- It complies, provided that the corporate director is a company registered in England and Wales.
Under s 154 of the Companies Act 2006 a private company must have at least one director, but s 155 requires every company to have at least one director who is a natural person. A board consisting solely of a corporate director does not meet that requirement, whatever the corporate director's place of registration. The subsidiary must appoint at least one individual as director. Private companies do not need two directors, and they do not need a company secretary at all. The Economic Crime and Corporate Transparency Act 2023 contains further restrictions on corporate directors, which reinforce rather than relax this position.
Law basis: Companies Act 2006 ss 154, 155 ↗Question 9 · Directors: appointment, removal and authorityDraft, pending solicitor review
Pavel is not on the board of Quartz Ltd, but he funded the company and holds 40% of its shares. For two years the directors have routinely implemented whatever he tells them to do on pricing, hiring and expansion, often after he emails instructions. Which of the following best describes Pavel's status?
- He cannot be a director of any kind, because he has never been validly appointed to the board.
- He is a shadow director only if he also attends the board meetings and votes on the board's resolutions.
- He is likely to be a shadow director, but shadow directors owe no duties of any kind to the company.
- He is not a shadow director, because shareholders are entitled to tell the directors what to do.
- He is likely to be a shadow director, owing the general duties so far as they are capable of applying.Correct answer
Under s 251 of the Companies Act 2006 a shadow director is a person in accordance with whose directions or instructions the directors are accustomed to act, other than advice given in a professional capacity. In Secretary of State v Deverell the Court of Appeal held that the board need not act in a subservient way; it is enough that the person's directions have real influence on the company's affairs. The directors routinely implement Pavel's instructions, so he is likely to be a shadow director. Under s 170(5) the general duties apply to shadow directors where and to the extent they are capable of applying. Attending board meetings would make him more like a de facto director.
Law basis: Companies Act 2006 ss 170(5), 251; Secretary of State for Trade and Industry v Deverell [2001] Ch 340 ↗Question 10 · Directors: appointment, removal and authorityDraft, pending solicitor review
Rosa was never formally appointed as a director of Sable Ltd. However, for three years she has attended every board meeting, voted on board decisions, signed contracts describing herself as 'Director', and been treated by staff and customers as a director. Sable is now insolvent. Which of the following best describes Rosa's status?
- She cannot be treated as a director, because her name never appeared on the register of directors.
- She is likely to be a de facto director, and so subject to the duties and liabilities of a director.Correct answer
- She is a shadow director, because she gave instructions to the board without being validly appointed.
- She is a de facto director, but only for the purposes of contracts that she signed personally.
- She cannot be treated as a director unless the members later ratify her appointment by resolution.
A de facto director is a person who assumes to act as a director and is held out as such, though not validly appointed. In Holland v HMRC the Supreme Court considered whether the person was part of the corporate governing structure and had assumed the role of a director. Rosa sat and voted on the board, signed as 'Director' and was treated as one, so she is very likely a de facto director, subject to the general duties and to liabilities such as wrongful trading and disqualification. A shadow director, by contrast, directs the board from outside it. Registration is not the test.
Law basis: Holland v Revenue and Customs Commissioners [2010] UKSC 51; Re Hydrodam (Corby) Ltd [1994] 2 BCLC 180Question 11 · Directors: appointment, removal and authorityDraft, pending solicitor review
The board of Tarn Ltd has never appointed a managing director, but for a year it has knowingly allowed Uma, one of its directors, to act as managing director, negotiating and signing major contracts. Uma engages Vale Architects to design a new headquarters. The board now says Uma had no authority. Vale relied on her apparent role. Which of the following best describes the position?
- The company is likely to be bound, as the board held Uma out as having a managing director's authority.Correct answer
- The company is not bound, because Uma was never formally appointed by the board as managing director.
- The company is bound only if the board passes a resolution ratifying the contract with Vale Architects.
- The company is not bound, and Vale's only remedy is a claim against Uma for breach of warranty of authority.
- The company is bound only if Vale inspected the board minutes before it entered into the contract with Uma.
In Freeman & Lockyer v Buckhurst Park Properties the Court of Appeal held a company bound where the board had allowed a director to act as managing director without appointing him. Apparent authority arises where the company, through those with actual authority, represents that the agent has authority, the third party relies on the representation, and the contract is of a kind within the usual authority of that role. By acquiescing in Uma's conduct for a year, the board made such a representation, and Vale relied on it. No ratification is needed, and Vale had no duty to inspect internal documents.
Law basis: Freeman & Lockyer v Buckhurst Park Properties (Mangal) Ltd [1964] 2 QB 480Question 12 · Directors: appointment, removal and authorityDraft, pending solicitor review
The articles of Wexford Ltd prohibit the company from selling land without shareholder approval. Without obtaining approval, the board sells a warehouse belonging to the company to Xena, who is one of the company's directors. Which of the following best describes the effect of the sale?
- The sale is voidable by the company, and Xena may have to account for any gain or indemnify the company.Correct answer
- The sale is valid, because a person dealing with the company in good faith can rely on the directors' powers.
- The sale is void, because the company has no capacity to act in breach of a limit in its articles.
- The sale is valid, because Xena is entitled to the same protection under s 40 as any outside buyer.
- The sale is void unless the members ratify it by special resolution within one month of completion.
Section 40 of the Companies Act 2006 protects persons dealing with the company in good faith, but s 41 provides that where the parties to a transaction include a director of the company, and the directors exceed a limitation on their powers under the constitution, the transaction is voidable at the instance of the company. The director, and any director who authorised the transaction, is liable to account for any gain and to indemnify the company for any loss. Xena is a director, so she cannot rely on s 40. The sale is voidable, not void, and the company may affirm it, for example by ordinary resolution.
Law basis: Companies Act 2006 ss 40, 41 ↗Question 13 · Directors: appointment, removal and authorityDraft, pending solicitor review
Yves was disqualified from acting as a company director for six years. Despite this, he has been managing the day-to-day business of Zephyr Ltd, including ordering stock on credit, although his name is not on the register. Zephyr has gone into insolvent liquidation owing suppliers £90,000 for stock he ordered. Which of the following best describes Yves's liability?
- Yves is not personally liable, because the debts were incurred by the company as a separate legal person.
- Yves is personally liable for debts incurred while he was involved in management in breach of the order.Correct answer
- Yves is liable only if the liquidator proves that he intended to defraud the company's suppliers.
- Yves commits a criminal offence, but he cannot be made personally liable for any of the company's unpaid debts.
- Yves is liable only if he was formally appointed as a director of the company while disqualified.
Under s 15 of the Company Directors Disqualification Act 1986, a person who is involved in the management of a company in contravention of a disqualification order or undertaking is personally responsible for the relevant debts of the company incurred while he was so involved. Liability is joint and several with the company and anyone else liable. Acting in breach is also a criminal offence under s 13, but criminal liability does not exclude personal civil liability. Formal appointment and intent to defraud are not required: being concerned in management is enough. Zephyr's creditors and liquidator can therefore pursue Yves personally for the £90,000.
Law basis: Company Directors Disqualification Act 1986 ss 11, 13, 15 ↗Question 14 · Directors: appointment, removal and authorityDraft, pending solicitor review
Ash was a director of Birch Ltd, which went into insolvent liquidation. The Secretary of State has applied for a disqualification order, and the court finds that Ash's conduct, including allowing the company to trade on using unpaid VAT and PAYE, makes him unfit to be concerned in the management of a company. Which of the following best describes the order the court must make?
- A disqualification order for any period the court thinks fit, up to a maximum of ten years.
- A disqualification order only if the court is satisfied that Ash acted dishonestly.
- A disqualification order for a minimum of two years and a maximum of 15 years.Correct answer
- A disqualification order for a fixed period of five years for a first finding of unfitness.
- A disqualification order for a maximum of five years, unless Ash has a previous disqualification.
Under s 6 of the Company Directors Disqualification Act 1986, where the court is satisfied that a person has been a director of a company that has become insolvent and that his conduct makes him unfit to be concerned in the management of a company, it must make a disqualification order. The minimum period is two years and the maximum 15 years. The Sevenoaks Stationers brackets guide the length, with serious cases at the top and less serious cases at the bottom. Dishonesty is not required; incompetence or using Crown monies to fund trading can establish unfitness. The director may instead offer a disqualification undertaking.
Law basis: Company Directors Disqualification Act 1986 s 6; Re Sevenoaks Stationers (Retail) Ltd [1991] Ch 164 ↗Question 15 · Directors: appointment, removal and authorityDraft, pending solicitor review
Cara is a director of Dell Ltd, which has adopted the model articles for private companies without amendment. A bankruptcy order is made against Cara personally. She tells the board she intends to carry on as a director because her bankruptcy has nothing to do with the company. Which of the following best describes the position?
- She may remain a director, because only a disqualification order made by a court can prevent a person from acting as a director.
- She may remain a director, provided that the other directors pass a resolution confirming her appointment.
- She ceases to be a director only if the shareholders pass an ordinary resolution removing her from office.
- She ceases to be a director under the articles, and acting as one while bankrupt is an offence without leave.Correct answer
- She may remain a director, but must resign as soon as her trustee in bankruptcy requests her to do so.
Model article 18 provides that a person ceases to be a director as soon as a bankruptcy order is made against that person. Separately, s 11 of the Company Directors Disqualification Act 1986 makes it an offence for an undischarged bankrupt to act as director of, or directly or indirectly take part in the promotion, formation or management of, a company without the leave of the court. Cara therefore ceases to be a director automatically and must not act as one. No board or shareholder resolution is needed to end her office, and the board cannot override the statutory prohibition.
Law basis: Companies (Model Articles) Regulations 2008, Sch 1 art 18; Company Directors Disqualification Act 1986 s 11 ↗More Business Law and Practice topics
Back to all Business Law and Practice questions, or sit a timed mock.