Law covered in these questions
- Companies Act 2006 ss 549, 550
- Companies Act 2006 ss 550, 551
- Companies (Model Articles) Regulations 2008, Sch 1 art 22
- Companies Act 2006 s 551(3), (4), (8), (9)
- Companies Act 2006 ss 561, 563
- Companies Act 2006 s 565
- Companies Act 2006 ss 567, 569
- Companies Act 2006 ss 551, 570, 571
- Companies Act 2006 ss 560, 561
- Companies Act 2006 ss 554, 555, 769
- Companies Act 2006 s 580
- Companies Act 2006 s 610
- Companies Act 2006 ss 281(3), 618, 619
- Companies (Model Articles) Regulations 2008, Sch 1 arts 27, 28
All 15 questions with answers
Try them above first, then read the worked answers below.
Question 1 · Share capital and allotmentDraft, pending solicitor review
Tide Ltd was incorporated in 2020 under the Companies Act 2006 with the model articles, and has only ordinary shares in issue. The directors wish to allot 1,000 further ordinary shares to raise cash. No shareholder resolution has been passed about allotting shares. Which of the following best describes whether the directors have authority to allot?
- The directors may not allot, as authority must first be given by an ordinary resolution of the members.
- The directors may allot, as a private company with one class of shares does not need members' authority.Correct answer
- The directors may not allot, as authority must first be given by a special resolution of the members.
- The directors may allot, but only after the members have passed a resolution disapplying pre-emption rights.
- The directors may allot, but only up to the number of shares stated in the company's authorised capital.
Section 550 of the Companies Act 2006 provides that where a private company has only one class of shares, the directors may exercise any power of the company to allot shares of that class, or grant rights to subscribe for or convert into such shares, except to the extent that they are prohibited from doing so by the articles. The model articles contain no such prohibition, so no ordinary resolution under s 551 is needed. However, authority to allot is a separate question from pre-emption: the new shares must still be offered to existing shareholders under s 561 unless pre-emption is disapplied or excluded. Authorised share capital was abolished for companies formed under the 2006 Act.
Law basis: Companies Act 2006 ss 549, 550 ↗Question 2 · Share capital and allotmentDraft, pending solicitor review
Umbra Ltd, which has only ordinary shares in issue and the model articles, wants to raise money by issuing a new class of preference shares to an investor. The directors ask whether they can allot the preference shares without any members' resolution. Which of the following best describes the position?
- The directors need no authority, as a private company's directors may always allot shares of any class.
- The directors need authority by special resolution, as the allotment creates a second class of shares.
- The directors need no authority, provided that the preference shares carry no voting rights.
- The directors need authority by ordinary resolution, as the allotment creates a second class.Correct answer
- The directors need the written consent of every existing ordinary shareholder before allotting.
The simplified regime in s 550 of the Companies Act 2006 applies only where a private company has one class of shares and the directors allot shares of that class. Issuing preference shares means the company will have more than one class, so s 550 does not apply. Under s 551 the directors may allot only if authorised by the articles or by an ordinary resolution of the company, which must state the maximum number of shares and an expiry date of not more than five years. Model article 22 permits shares to be issued with rights determined by ordinary resolution. Voting rights are irrelevant to the authority required.
Law basis: Companies Act 2006 ss 550, 551; Companies (Model Articles) Regulations 2008, Sch 1 art 22 ↗Question 3 · Share capital and allotmentDraft, pending solicitor review
The members of Vane Holdings Ltd, which has two classes of shares, propose an ordinary resolution under s 551 authorising the directors to allot shares. The draft resolution gives the directors authority to allot an unlimited number of shares indefinitely. Which of the following best describes the position?
- The authority must state a maximum and expire within five years, so the draft is defective.Correct answer
- The authority is valid, because members may confer unlimited and indefinite authority by an ordinary resolution.
- The authority must be given by special resolution, because it is unlimited in amount.
- The authority is valid, provided that it is filed at Companies House within 15 days of being passed.
- The authority must state a maximum number of shares, but there is no time limit on how long it lasts.
Under s 551(3) of the Companies Act 2006, an authorisation to allot must state the maximum amount of shares that may be allotted under it and specify the date on which it will expire, which must be not more than five years from the date on which the resolution is passed (or, for authority in the articles at incorporation, the date of incorporation). The authority may be renewed by ordinary resolution for further periods of up to five years. An ordinary resolution suffices, even if it alters the articles, and it must be filed under s 551(9). The draft, conferring unlimited and indefinite authority, does not comply.
Law basis: Companies Act 2006 s 551(3), (4), (8), (9) ↗Question 4 · Share capital and allotmentDraft, pending solicitor review
Wren Ltd has one class of ordinary shares. Its directors, who have authority to allot, issue 5,000 new ordinary shares for cash to an outside investor without first offering them to the existing shareholders. Pre-emption rights have not been excluded or disapplied. Xia, who holds 20% of the shares, finds out. Which of the following best describes Xia's position?
- Xia has no claim, because the directors had authority to allot the shares to any person that they chose.
- The allotment is void, and the investor must return the shares to the company for cancellation.
- Xia may require the investor to transfer 20% of the new shares to her at the subscription price.
- Xia has no claim, because pre-emption rights apply only to public companies and not to private ones.
- The company and officers who knowingly authorised the breach must compensate her for her loss.Correct answer
Section 561 of the Companies Act 2006 requires a company proposing to allot equity securities for cash first to offer them to existing holders of ordinary shares on the same or more favourable terms, in proportion to their holdings. Authority to allot does not displace pre-emption. Under s 563, where there is a contravention, the company and every officer who knowingly authorised or permitted it are jointly and severally liable to compensate any person to whom an offer should have been made for any loss, damage, costs or expenses. A claim must be brought within two years. The allotment itself is not void, and Xia has no direct right against the investor.
Law basis: Companies Act 2006 ss 561, 563 ↗Question 5 · Share capital and allotmentDraft, pending solicitor review
Yarrow Ltd, a private company with one class of ordinary shares, agrees to buy a warehouse from Zed. Instead of paying cash, Yarrow will allot 50,000 new ordinary shares to Zed as the full consideration. Pre-emption rights have not been excluded or disapplied. An existing shareholder says the shares must first be offered to the members. Which of the following best describes the position?
- Pre-emption applies, because new ordinary shares must always be offered first to existing members.
- Pre-emption applies, unless the warehouse is valued by an independent expert before the allotment.
- Pre-emption does not apply, because Zed is not an existing member of the company.
- Pre-emption does not apply, because the shares are being allotted for a non-cash consideration.Correct answer
- Pre-emption applies, but the offer period is reduced to seven days for non-cash allotments.
Section 565 of the Companies Act 2006 provides that the statutory pre-emption rights in s 561 do not apply to an allotment of equity securities if they are, or are to be, wholly or partly paid up otherwise than in cash. Allotting shares to Zed as consideration for the warehouse is a non-cash allotment, so the shares do not need to be offered to the existing members first. Independent valuation of non-cash consideration is required for public companies under s 593, not private companies. Zed's status as an outsider is irrelevant; the key point is the nature of the consideration.
Law basis: Companies Act 2006 s 565 ↗Question 6 · Share capital and allotmentDraft, pending solicitor review
Amber Ltd has one class of ordinary shares and relies on s 550 for its directors' authority to allot. It needs to raise cash quickly from a new investor and does not want to offer the shares to its 30 existing shareholders first. The articles say nothing about pre-emption. Which of the following best describes how the company can avoid the pre-emption rights?
- The members may pass a special resolution disapplying pre-emption rights for the allotment.Correct answer
- The directors may resolve that pre-emption rights do not apply, as they have s 550 authority.
- The members may pass an ordinary resolution disapplying pre-emption rights for the allotment.
- The company cannot avoid pre-emption rights for an allotment of ordinary shares for cash.
- The company may avoid pre-emption only by obtaining the written waiver of every shareholder.
Under s 569 of the Companies Act 2006, the directors of a private company with only one class of shares may be given power by the articles or by a special resolution to allot equity securities as if s 561 did not apply, or applied with modifications. Amber can therefore disapply pre-emption by special resolution. Alternatively, a private company may exclude pre-emption entirely in its articles under s 567. Individual waivers from every shareholder would also work in practice, but they are not the only route. An ordinary resolution is not enough, and the directors cannot disapply pre-emption themselves.
Law basis: Companies Act 2006 ss 567, 569 ↗Question 7 · Share capital and allotmentDraft, pending solicitor review
Birch Ltd has two classes of shares. The members have passed an ordinary resolution under s 551 authorising the directors to allot up to 10,000 ordinary shares. The directors now want to allot those shares for cash to an outside investor without offering them to existing members. Which of the following best describes the resolution needed?
- No further resolution, because the s 551 authority automatically disapplies pre-emption.
- An ordinary resolution disapplying pre-emption, passed at the same meeting as the authority.
- A special resolution disapplying pre-emption, which may be tied to the s 551 authority.Correct answer
- A unanimous resolution of the ordinary shareholders, because the company has two classes.
- A board resolution, provided that the allotment is made within the five-year authority.
Where the directors are generally authorised under s 551 of the Companies Act 2006, ss 570 and 571 allow pre-emption to be disapplied, either generally by the articles or a special resolution (s 570), or in relation to a specified allotment by special resolution (s 571). A disapplication under s 570 ceases to have effect when the s 551 authority to which it relates is revoked or expires. A special resolution under s 571 to disapply for a specified allotment must be recommended by the directors with a written statement circulated to members setting out their reasons and the proposed price. The s 551 authority does not itself disapply pre-emption.
Law basis: Companies Act 2006 ss 551, 570, 571 ↗Question 8 · Share capital and allotmentDraft, pending solicitor review
Cobalt Ltd plans to issue new preference shares for cash. They will carry a fixed dividend of 6% a year and a right to a return of only their nominal value on a winding up, with no other right to participate in profits or capital. An ordinary shareholder argues that she must be offered the new preference shares first. Which of the following best describes the position?
- Statutory pre-emption applies, because every allotment of any shares for cash must first be offered to existing members.
- Statutory pre-emption does not apply, as shares with capped dividend and capital rights are not ordinary shares.Correct answer
- Statutory pre-emption applies, but only to existing holders of preference shares in the company.
- Statutory pre-emption does not apply, because shares without votes are excluded from the rules.
- Statutory pre-emption applies, because the new shares rank ahead of the ordinary shares for dividends.
Statutory pre-emption under s 561 of the Companies Act 2006 applies to allotments of 'equity securities', which means ordinary shares or rights to subscribe for or convert into ordinary shares (s 560). 'Ordinary shares' means shares other than shares that, as respects dividends and capital, carry a right to participate only up to a specified amount in a distribution. Preference shares with a fixed dividend and a right only to a return of their nominal value on winding up are therefore not ordinary shares, and pre-emption does not apply to their allotment. The test turns on participation rights, not voting rights or ranking.
Law basis: Companies Act 2006 ss 560, 561 ↗Question 9 · Share capital and allotmentDraft, pending solicitor review
On 1 June, Dune Ltd allotted 2,000 new ordinary shares to three investors. The company secretary has updated the board minutes but has done nothing else. Which of the following best describes the company's obligations in respect of the allotment?
- It must file a return of allotment within 14 days, but the register of members need not be updated until year end.
- It must file a return of allotment within one month and register the allotment within two months.Correct answer
- It must register the allotment within one month, but returns of allotment are only needed for public companies.
- It must file a confirmation statement within 14 days, which replaces the need for a return of allotment.
- It must file the board minutes approving the allotment at Companies House within 15 days.
Under s 555 of the Companies Act 2006, a limited company must, within one month after an allotment of shares, deliver to the registrar a return of allotment together with a statement of capital. Under s 554, the company must register the allotment, by entering the allottees in the register of members, as soon as practicable and in any event within two months after the date of allotment. Under s 769, it must also issue share certificates within two months unless the terms of issue provide otherwise. These obligations apply to private and public companies. A confirmation statement does not replace the return of allotment, and board minutes are not filed.
Law basis: Companies Act 2006 ss 554, 555, 769 ↗Question 10 · Share capital and allotmentDraft, pending solicitor review
Ember Ltd's ordinary shares have a nominal value of £1 each. To attract a key investor quickly, the directors agree to allot 10,000 shares to her at 80p each, paid in cash. Which of the following best describes the legal position?
- The shares cannot be allotted at a discount, and the investor must pay the shortfall with interest.Correct answer
- The allotment is valid, because a private company may issue its shares at any price that the directors agree.
- The allotment is valid, provided that the members approve the discount by ordinary resolution in advance.
- The allotment is void, and the investor is entitled to the return of her money with interest.
- The allotment is valid, but the 20p shortfall must be credited to the company's share premium account.
Section 580 of the Companies Act 2006 provides that a company's shares must not be allotted at a discount, meaning for less than their nominal value. If shares are allotted in contravention, the allottee is liable to pay the company an amount equal to the amount of the discount, with interest at the appropriate rate. The allotment is not void, and members cannot authorise a discount. The company and every officer in default also commit an offence. A share premium account arises only where shares are issued above nominal value, so the reference to crediting it is wrong.
Law basis: Companies Act 2006 s 580 ↗Question 11 · Share capital and allotmentDraft, pending solicitor review
Fern Ltd allots 20,000 ordinary shares of £1 each to an investor for £3 per share, paid in cash. The directors then propose to use the £40,000 premium to pay a dividend to shareholders. Which of the following best describes the treatment of the £40,000?
- It may be distributed as a dividend because it is a realised profit on the issue of shares.
- It must be credited to share capital and may be used only to pay up bonus shares.
- It may be distributed as a dividend if the members approve it by special resolution.
- It must be credited to the share premium account and cannot be used to pay a dividend.Correct answer
- It must be credited to the share premium account, which may be used for any purpose.
Under s 610 of the Companies Act 2006, if a company issues shares at a premium, whether for cash or otherwise, a sum equal to the aggregate amount or value of the premiums must be transferred to a share premium account. The share premium account is treated as if it were paid up share capital, except that it may be used to write off the expenses of the issue or commission paid on it, and to pay up new shares to be allotted to members as fully paid bonus shares. It is not a realised profit and cannot be used to pay a dividend. It may be reduced only through a formal capital reduction.
Law basis: Companies Act 2006 s 610 ↗Question 12 · Share capital and allotmentDraft, pending solicitor review
Gale Ltd has 1,000 ordinary shares of £10 each. To make the shares easier to transfer in small lots, the directors propose that each £10 share be divided into ten £1 shares. The articles say nothing on the matter. Which of the following best describes what is required?
- A special resolution of the members, as sub-division alters the company's share capital.
- A board resolution only, as sub-division does not change the total nominal value of share capital.
- A special resolution confirmed by the court, as any alteration of share capital needs court approval.
- A unanimous written resolution, because sub-division affects the rights of every shareholder.
- An ordinary resolution of the members authorising the sub-division, with notice to the registrar.Correct answer
Under s 618 of the Companies Act 2006 a limited company may sub-divide or consolidate all or any of its share capital, but only if its members have passed a resolution authorising it. Under s 281(3), where the Act requires a resolution without specifying the type, an ordinary resolution suffices unless the articles require a higher majority. Gale's articles are silent, so an ordinary resolution is enough. Under s 619 the company must give notice to the registrar within one month, with a statement of capital. The proportion between paid and unpaid amounts must stay the same. Court confirmation is needed only for certain reductions of capital.
Law basis: Companies Act 2006 ss 281(3), 618, 619 ↗Question 13 · Share capital and allotmentDraft, pending solicitor review
Hugh, a shareholder in Iris Ltd, has died. His executor, Jane, has produced the grant of probate to the company and wants to vote Hugh's shares at next week's general meeting. Jane has not elected to become the holder or to transfer the shares. The company has the model articles. Which of the following best describes Jane's position?
- Jane may vote at the meeting, because the shares vested in her automatically on Hugh's death as his executor.
- Jane may vote at the meeting, provided that she produces the grant of probate at the meeting.
- Jane may not vote at the meeting, as she is not yet the registered holder of the shares.Correct answer
- Jane may not vote, because shares held by a deceased member are cancelled on his death.
- Jane may vote at the meeting only if all other members consent to her doing so.
Model article 27 provides that if title to a share passes to a transmittee, the company may only recognise the transmittee as having title. A transmittee who produces evidence of entitlement may choose either to become the holder or to have the shares transferred to another person. Article 27(3) provides that transmittees do not have the right to attend or vote at a general meeting in respect of the shares unless they become the holders of those shares. Jane must therefore elect to be registered as holder before she can vote. The shares are not cancelled, and producing probate is necessary but not sufficient.
Law basis: Companies (Model Articles) Regulations 2008, Sch 1 arts 27, 28 ↗Question 14 · Share capital and allotmentDraft, pending solicitor review
Juno plc is a public company. It proposes to allot 100,000 ordinary shares of £1 each at a price of £2 per share, payable in instalments. The investor asks how much must be paid on allotment. Which of the following best describes the minimum amount payable on allotment?
- £50,000, being one quarter of the total subscription price of the shares.
- £25,000, being one quarter of the nominal value, with the premium payable later.
- £200,000, being the full subscription price, as a public company's shares must be fully paid.
- £125,000, being one quarter of the nominal value plus the whole of the premium.Correct answer
- Nothing, because the investor and the company may agree the payment terms freely.
Under s 586 of the Companies Act 2006, a public company must not allot a share except as paid up at least as to one-quarter of its nominal value and the whole of any premium on it. Here the nominal value is £100,000, so one-quarter is £25,000, and the premium is £1 per share, totalling £100,000. The minimum payable on allotment is therefore £125,000. If a share is allotted in contravention, it is treated as if one-quarter of the nominal value and the whole premium had been received, and the allottee is liable to pay the shortfall with interest. Private companies are not subject to this rule.
Law basis: Companies Act 2006 s 586 ↗Question 15 · Share capital and allotmentDraft, pending solicitor review
Kip Ltd allotted 500 new ordinary shares to Lola on 1 March for cash, on terms that said nothing about share certificates. By 15 May she has still not received a share certificate. The company says it issues certificates only when shares are sold. Which of the following best describes the company's obligation?
- It must issue a certificate only if Lola asks for one in writing and pays the prescribed fee.
- It is not obliged to issue certificates, because entry in the register of members proves title.
- It had to have a share certificate ready for delivery within two months after the allotment.Correct answer
- It had to issue a share certificate within 14 days after the allotment of the new shares.
- It must issue a certificate only when Lola wishes to transfer her shares to another person.
Under s 769 of the Companies Act 2006, a company must, within two months after the allotment of any of its shares, complete and have ready for delivery the certificates of the shares allotted, unless the conditions of issue provide otherwise. A share certificate is prima facie evidence of title under s 768. Kip's two-month period expired on 1 May, so it is in breach, and the company and every officer in default commit an offence. Model article 24 provides that certificates must be issued free of charge. Although the register of members is the primary record of membership, it does not remove the duty to issue certificates.
Law basis: Companies Act 2006 ss 768, 769 ↗More Business Law and Practice topics
Back to all Business Law and Practice questions, or sit a timed mock.