Law covered in these questions
- Companies Act 2006 s 175(1), (2), (4)
- Regal (Hastings) Ltd v Gulliver [1942] 1 All ER 378
- Companies Act 2006 s 171(b)
- Howard Smith Ltd v Ampol Petroleum Ltd [1974] AC 821
- Eclairs Group Ltd v JKX Oil & Gas plc [2015] UKSC 71
- Companies Act 2006 s 172(1)
- Companies Act 2006 s 174
- Re D'Jan of London Ltd [1994] 1 BCLC 561
- Companies Act 2006 s 1157
- Companies Act 2006 s 175(4)(b), (5)(a), (6)
- Companies Act 2006 ss 170(2)(a), 175
- Industrial Development Consultants Ltd v Cooley [1972] 1 WLR 443
- Companies Act 2006 ss 176, 180(4)
- Companies Act 2006 s 177(1), (6)(b)
All 17 questions with answers
Try them above first, then read the worked answers below.
Question 1 · Directors' dutiesDraft, pending solicitor review
Ravi is a director of Skyline Ltd, which builds loft conversions. Through his work he hears of a chance to buy a derelict warehouse, which Skyline cannot afford. He buys it himself without telling the board and sells it at a large profit. Which statement best describes his position?
- He is not in breach, because Skyline could not have afforded the warehouse.
- He is not in breach, because he used his own money and not the company's.
- He is in breach of the duty to avoid conflicts, because he exploited an opportunity learned as a director without authorisation, and it does not matter that the company could not have taken it.Correct answer
- He is in breach only if he intended to harm Skyline.
- He is in breach only if Skyline would have bought the warehouse had it been told.
Question 2 · Directors' dutiesDraft, pending solicitor review
Elsa holds 55% of the shares in Fenwick Ltd and plans to vote to replace the board. To stop her, the directors allot new shares to a friendly investor, reducing Elsa to 45%. They honestly believe that keeping the current board is in the company's best interests, and the company does need the money raised. Which of the following best describes the directors' position?
- They are not in breach, because they honestly believed that their actions would promote the company's success.
- They are not in breach, because the company needed the money raised by the allotment of the new shares.
- They are in breach only if the allotment was made at a price below the market value of the shares.
- They are in breach of their duty of care, but they owe no duty as to the purpose of their decisions.
- They are likely to be in breach of the duty to use powers for a proper purpose, despite their honest belief.Correct answer
Section 171(b) of the Companies Act 2006 requires directors to exercise powers only for the purposes for which they are conferred. In Howard Smith v Ampol Petroleum and Eclairs Group v JKX Oil & Gas, the courts held that the power to allot shares may not be used for the primary purpose of manipulating control or defeating a majority, even if the directors honestly believe this to be in the company's interests. Where there are mixed purposes, the court asks whether the improper purpose was the substantial or decisive purpose. On these facts, the main purpose was to defeat Elsa, so honest belief and a need for money do not prevent a breach.
Law basis: Companies Act 2006 s 171(b); Howard Smith Ltd v Ampol Petroleum Ltd [1974] AC 821; Eclairs Group Ltd v JKX Oil & Gas plc [2015] UKSC 71 ↗Question 3 · Directors' dutiesDraft, pending solicitor review
The board of Garrow Ltd decides to close one of its two factories, making 80 staff redundant. Before deciding, the directors considered a report on the impact on employees and the local community, and concluded in good faith that the closure was the best way to keep the company profitable. A shareholder claims that the directors breached their duty because employees will suffer. Which of the following best describes the position?
- There is a breach, because directors must give priority to the interests of employees over those of shareholders.
- There is a breach, because the decision will cause substantial harm to the local community in which the factory is located.
- There is no breach if the directors in good faith thought closure most likely to promote the company's success.Correct answer
- There is no breach only if the closure is later shown objectively to have increased the company's profits.
- There is a breach, unless the decision was first approved by an ordinary resolution of the shareholders.
Section 172 of the Companies Act 2006 requires a director to act in the way he considers, in good faith, would be most likely to promote the success of the company for the benefit of its members as a whole, having regard to factors including the interests of employees and the impact on the community. The test is primarily subjective: the court will not substitute its own business judgement. The directors here considered the relevant factors and concluded in good faith that closure was best. Having regard to employees' interests does not mean giving them priority, and hindsight about the outcome does not determine whether there was a breach.
Law basis: Companies Act 2006 s 172(1) ↗Question 4 · Directors' dutiesDraft, pending solicitor review
Hari is the finance director of Ingle Ltd and a qualified chartered accountant. Over two years he failed to notice that a junior bookkeeper was diverting company funds, although the irregularities would have been obvious to any accountant reviewing the monthly figures. Hari argues that he did his honest best. Which of the following best describes the standard by which his conduct will be judged?
- He is judged only by what he personally knew and believed, so honest effort is a complete answer to the claim.
- He is judged only against the standard of a reasonable director with no particular financial qualifications at all.
- He is judged against the standard of a reasonable chartered accountant, whatever his role in the company.
- He is liable only if he was grossly negligent, as directors are not liable for ordinary carelessness.
- He is judged against a reasonable finance director's general knowledge, raised by his own expertise.Correct answer
Section 174 of the Companies Act 2006 requires a director to exercise the care, skill and diligence that would be exercised by a reasonably diligent person with both the general knowledge, skill and experience that may reasonably be expected of a person carrying out the functions he carries out in relation to the company (the objective minimum), and the general knowledge, skill and experience that the director actually has (a subjective element that can raise the standard). Hari is measured against a reasonable finance director, raised by his accountancy expertise. Honest belief is not a defence, and the threshold is ordinary negligence, not gross negligence.
Law basis: Companies Act 2006 s 174; Re D'Jan of London Ltd [1994] 1 BCLC 561 ↗Question 5 · Directors' dutiesDraft, pending solicitor review
Jude is a director of a small family company. He signed an insurance proposal form prepared by a broker without reading it, and an incorrect answer on the form allowed the insurer to refuse a claim after a fire. He is found to have breached his duty of care. He acted honestly and the mistake was a single lapse. Which of the following best describes the court's power to help him?
- The court must relieve him in full, because he acted honestly and the mistake was a single isolated lapse on his part.
- The court may relieve him wholly or partly if he acted honestly and reasonably and ought fairly to be excused.Correct answer
- The court has no power to relieve him, because relief is available only for breaches of fiduciary duty.
- The court may relieve him only if the company's articles contain an indemnity in favour of directors.
- The court has no power to relieve him unless the shareholders have already ratified his breach of duty.
Under s 1157 of the Companies Act 2006, in proceedings for negligence, default, breach of duty or breach of trust against an officer of a company, the court may relieve him, wholly or partly, on such terms as it thinks fit, if it appears that he acted honestly and reasonably and that, having regard to all the circumstances, he ought fairly to be excused. In Re D'Jan of London a director who signed a proposal form without reading it was negligent, but was granted partial relief. Relief is discretionary, not automatic, and is not limited to fiduciary breaches. It does not depend on ratification or on an indemnity in the articles.
Law basis: Companies Act 2006 s 1157; Re D'Jan of London Ltd [1994] 1 BCLC 561 ↗Question 6 · Directors' dutiesDraft, pending solicitor review
Kian is one of three directors of Larkspur Ltd, a private company with articles that say nothing about conflicts of interest. He learns of an opportunity to buy a rival's client list, which Larkspur might want. He discloses it fully to the board. The other two directors, at a quorate meeting where Kian's vote is not counted, authorise him to buy it personally. Which of the following best describes Kian's position?
- He is in breach, because a conflict of interest can be authorised only by an ordinary resolution of members.
- He is in breach, because a director may never exploit an opportunity that the company could have taken.
- He is not in breach, but only if he pays the company a share of any profit that he makes from the list.
- He is not in breach of the conflict duty, because the independent directors authorised the conflict.Correct answer
- He is in breach, because the authorisation was invalid unless Kian voted on the resolution himself.
Section 175 of the Companies Act 2006 requires a director to avoid situations in which he has, or can have, a conflict of interest, including the exploitation of any opportunity. The duty is not infringed if the matter has been authorised by the directors. Under s 175(5)(a), for a private company, the directors may authorise the conflict provided nothing in the constitution invalidates such authorisation. Under s 175(6), the authorisation is effective only if the quorum is met without counting the interested director and it is agreed without his vote, or would have been agreed if his vote had not been counted. Those conditions are met here, so there is no breach.
Law basis: Companies Act 2006 s 175(4)(b), (5)(a), (6) ↗Question 7 · Directors' dutiesDraft, pending solicitor review
Mara was managing director of Noble Design Ltd. During talks with a public body about a big design contract for the company, the body made clear it would deal with her personally but not with the company. Mara resigned, citing ill health, and then took the contract through her own firm. Which of the following best describes Mara's position?
- She is liable to account for her profits, as the duty continues for opportunities learned of as a director.Correct answer
- She is not liable, because she had resigned before she took up the contract through her own firm.
- She is not liable, because the public body had refused to contract with the company in any event.
- She is liable only if the company can prove that it would have obtained the contract but for her own actions.
- She is not liable, because a director's duties end completely on the date of her resignation.
Section 170(2)(a) of the Companies Act 2006 provides that a person who ceases to be a director continues to be subject to the duty to avoid conflicts of interest under s 175 as regards the exploitation of any property, information or opportunity of which she became aware while a director. In IDC v Cooley a managing director who resigned to take a contract personally that he had learned of while acting for the company was liable to account for his profits, although the company would not have obtained the contract. The company's inability to take the opportunity is not a defence to the strict rule against profiting from a conflict.
Law basis: Companies Act 2006 ss 170(2)(a), 175; Industrial Development Consultants Ltd v Cooley [1972] 1 WLR 443 ↗Question 8 · Directors' dutiesDraft, pending solicitor review
Owen is a director of Pembroke Ltd. A supplier hoping to win a large contract offers him a free week's luxury holiday. Owen tells the board, and the other directors pass a resolution authorising him to accept the holiday. The articles contain nothing relevant. Which of the following best describes Owen's position if he accepts?
- He is not in breach, because the board has authorised the benefit in the same way as a conflict of interest.
- He is not in breach, because the benefit was disclosed to the other directors before he accepted it.
- He is in breach only if Pembroke Ltd later awards the contract to the supplier that gave the holiday.
- He is not in breach, because benefits worth less than £10,000 do not fall within the scope of the duty.
- The board cannot authorise the benefit, so he is likely to be in breach unless the members approve it.Correct answer
Section 176 of the Companies Act 2006 prohibits a director from accepting a benefit from a third party conferred by reason of his being a director or doing or not doing anything as a director. Unlike s 175, s 176 contains no mechanism for authorisation by the board. The duty is not infringed if acceptance cannot reasonably be regarded as likely to give rise to a conflict, but a luxury holiday from a bidder is likely to do so. Under s 180(4) the members may authorise it, or the articles may provide for it. Disclosure to the board is therefore insufficient, and there is no monetary threshold below which the duty does not apply.
Law basis: Companies Act 2006 ss 176, 180(4) ↗Question 9 · Directors' dutiesDraft, pending solicitor review
Quinn is a director of Rowan Ltd, which is about to enter into a supply contract with a company owned by Quinn's wife. Quinn does not formally declare his interest. However, all the other directors attended his wedding, know that his wife owns the supplier, and discussed this at the meeting that approved the contract. Which of the following best describes whether Quinn has breached s 177?
- He has breached s 177, as a director must always formally declare any interest in a proposed transaction to the board.
- He has breached s 177, as an interest held through a spouse cannot be disclosed informally to the board.
- He has not breached s 177, as an interest held by a spouse is never an interest of the director himself.
- He has not breached s 177, as no declaration is needed of an interest the other directors already know about.Correct answer
- He has breached s 177, unless the members approve the supply contract by an ordinary resolution.
Section 177 of the Companies Act 2006 requires a director who is in any way, directly or indirectly, interested in a proposed transaction with the company to declare the nature and extent of that interest to the other directors before the company enters into it. An interest through a spouse is an indirect interest. However, s 177(6)(b) provides that a director need not declare an interest if, or to the extent that, the other directors are already aware of it, or ought reasonably to be aware of it. The other directors knew of and discussed the connection, so Quinn has not breached the duty. Members' approval is not required for s 177 compliance.
Law basis: Companies Act 2006 s 177(1), (6)(b) ↗Question 10 · Directors' dutiesDraft, pending solicitor review
Sara is a director of Teasel Ltd. Six months after Teasel signed a long-term lease of a unit from Unicorn Properties Ltd, Sara inherited 60% of the shares in Unicorn. She has said nothing to her fellow directors. Which of the following best describes her obligations?
- She must declare the nature and extent of her interest as soon as reasonably practicable, or commit an offence.Correct answer
- She need not declare anything, because the lease was entered into before she acquired her interest.
- She must declare her interest only if Teasel proposes to renew the lease or to enter into a new one.
- She must obtain the members' approval of the existing lease, failing which the lease becomes voidable by the company.
- She must resign as a director, because she now has a conflict of interest that cannot be authorised.
Section 182 of the Companies Act 2006 requires a director who is in any way, directly or indirectly, interested in a transaction or arrangement that has been entered into by the company to declare the nature and extent of the interest to the other directors, unless it has already been declared under s 177. The declaration must be made as soon as is reasonably practicable. Under s 183, failure to comply is a criminal offence, although it does not affect the validity of the transaction. Sara must therefore declare her interest in Unicorn now. Resignation and members' approval are not required by s 182.
Law basis: Companies Act 2006 ss 182, 183 ↗Question 11 · Directors' dutiesDraft, pending solicitor review
The directors of Umbra Ltd know that the company is on the brink of insolvency, with insolvent liquidation now probable. To reward the shareholders, they propose to pay a dividend out of the company's remaining distributable profits, which would leave little cash to pay suppliers. Which of the following best describes the directors' duty?
- They must act only in the interests of the shareholders, as creditors are protected solely by insolvency law.
- They owe a duty to each individual creditor directly, enforceable by that creditor against them in contract.
- They must consider and give proper weight to creditors' interests, as the company is near insolvency.Correct answer
- They may pay the dividend, because a lawful dividend from distributable profits can never be a breach of duty.
- They must stop trading at once, as a director's only duty near insolvency is to minimise the losses to creditors.
In BTI 2014 LLC v Sequana SA the Supreme Court held that the duty under s 172 of the Companies Act 2006 to act in the interests of the company is modified by s 172(3) and the common law creditor duty when the company is insolvent or bordering on insolvency, or when insolvent liquidation or administration is probable. Directors must then consider creditors' interests, giving them more weight as the company's financial position worsens. A dividend that is lawful under Part 23 may still be a breach of this duty. The duty is owed to the company, not directly to individual creditors, and does not require trading to stop at once.
Law basis: BTI 2014 LLC v Sequana SA [2022] UKSC 25; Companies Act 2006 s 172(3)Question 12 · Directors' dutiesDraft, pending solicitor review
Venture capital fund Wild Oak has the right under its investment agreement to nominate a director to the board of Xylo Ltd, and it nominates Yasmin. Before each board meeting, Wild Oak emails Yasmin telling her how to vote, and she always follows its instructions without considering the matters herself. Which of the following best describes Yasmin's position?
- She is not in breach, because a nominee director's duties are owed primarily to the investor who nominated her to the board.
- She is likely to breach her duty to exercise independent judgment by simply following Wild Oak's instructions.Correct answer
- She is not in breach, because the investment agreement gave Wild Oak the right to nominate a director.
- She is in breach only if her votes caused the company loss, as the duty is concerned solely with outcomes.
- She is not in breach, because a director may always act on the instructions of the company's shareholders.
Section 173 of the Companies Act 2006 requires a director to exercise independent judgment. A nominee director may take account of the nominator's interests where consistent with her duties, but her duties are owed to the company, and she must not fetter her discretion by blindly following the nominator. The duty is not infringed by acting in accordance with an agreement duly entered into by the company that restricts the future exercise of discretion, or in a way authorised by the constitution, but a right to nominate is not such a restriction on voting. Yasmin's automatic compliance with Wild Oak's instructions is likely to breach s 173.
Law basis: Companies Act 2006 s 173 ↗Question 13 · Directors' dutiesDraft, pending solicitor review
Zak is a director of Alder Ltd and holds 60% of its shares. The other 40% are held by Bea, who is not connected with Zak. Zak negligently caused the company a £50,000 loss. He proposes an ordinary resolution at a general meeting to ratify his breach. Zak votes all his shares in favour and Bea votes against. Which of the following best describes the outcome?
- The resolution passes, as Zak holds a majority of the votes and is free to vote as a shareholder.
- The resolution passes, as negligence is not a breach of duty that the members can be asked to ratify.
- The resolution fails, as the ratification of any breach of duty requires the unanimous consent of members.
- The resolution fails, as Zak's votes must be disregarded and Bea's votes alone are against it.Correct answer
- The resolution passes, but only if it is later confirmed by a special resolution of the members.
Under s 239 of the Companies Act 2006 a decision by the company to ratify conduct by a director amounting to negligence, default, breach of duty or breach of trust must be taken by the members. Where it is proposed at a meeting, the votes in favour of the director concerned, as a member, and any member connected with him must be disregarded, although he may attend and count towards the quorum. Disregarding Zak's votes, only Bea's votes remain, and she votes against, so the resolution fails. Negligence is capable of ratification, and unanimity is not required.
Law basis: Companies Act 2006 s 239(3), (4) ↗Question 14 · Directors' dutiesDraft, pending solicitor review
Cal and Dev are directors of Ember Ltd, a property company. A building next door to Ember's main site comes up for sale. Cal and Dev buy it through their own company without telling Ember, arguing that Ember had no current plans to buy more property and so no conflict arose. Which of the following best describes their position?
- They are not in breach, because Ember had no current plans to acquire further property at the time.
- They are not in breach, because the opportunity came to them in a private capacity and not as directors.
- They are likely to be in breach, as the situation could reasonably be regarded as likely to cause a conflict.Correct answer
- They are in breach only if Ember could have raised the finance needed to buy the building itself.
- They are not in breach, because a conflict of interest arises only where the company has actively sought the opportunity.
Section 175 of the Companies Act 2006 requires directors to avoid situations in which they have, or can have, an interest that conflicts, or possibly may conflict, with the company's interests, including the exploitation of an opportunity. Under s 175(2) it is immaterial whether the company could take advantage of the opportunity. In Bhullar v Bhullar directors who bought property next to the company's land were liable even though the company was not then looking to acquire property: a reasonable person would think there was a real sensible possibility of conflict. Cal and Dev did not seek authorisation, so they are likely to be in breach and liable to account.
Law basis: Companies Act 2006 s 175(1), (2), (4)(a); Bhullar v Bhullar [2003] EWCA Civ 424 ↗Question 15 · Directors' dutiesDraft, pending solicitor review
Fiona, a director of Gorse Ltd, made a secret profit of £40,000 by diverting a contract opportunity to her own business in breach of s 175. The company has suffered no measurable loss because it lacked the capacity to perform the contract. Which of the following best describes the company's remedy against Fiona?
- The company has no remedy, because it suffered no loss and could not have performed the contract.
- The company may claim damages from Fiona only for a loss that it can prove it actually suffered.
- The company may only seek Fiona's removal from office, as the Act creates no monetary remedies.
- The company may recover the profit only if it shows that Fiona acted dishonestly and in bad faith.
- The company may require Fiona to account for the £40,000 profit, even though it suffered no loss.Correct answer
Section 178 of the Companies Act 2006 provides that the consequences of breach of the general duties are the same as would apply if the corresponding common law rule or equitable principle applied. The duty to avoid conflicts is fiduciary, and equity requires a fiduciary to account for unauthorised profits made in breach, whether or not the company suffered loss or could have made the profit itself (Regal (Hastings) v Gulliver). Fiona must therefore account for the £40,000. Good faith is not a defence, and the remedy is not confined to compensatory damages. Removal may also be possible, but it is not the only consequence.
Law basis: Companies Act 2006 s 178; Regal (Hastings) Ltd v Gulliver [1967] 2 AC 134 ↗Question 16 · Directors' dutiesDraft, pending solicitor review
The articles of Heron Ltd contain a clause stating that no director shall be liable to the company for any loss caused by the director's negligence. Ida, a director, negligently causes the company a large loss and relies on the clause. The company also holds directors' and officers' liability insurance. Which of the following best describes the position?
- The exemption clause is valid, as the articles form a binding contract between the company and its directors.
- The exemption clause is void, but the company was entitled to buy insurance covering Ida's liability.Correct answer
- The exemption clause is valid, provided that the members approved it by special resolution when it was adopted.
- The exemption clause is void, and the insurance policy is also void as an indirect form of exemption.
- The exemption clause is valid for negligence but would be void for a breach of the directors' fiduciary duties.
Under s 232(1) of the Companies Act 2006 any provision that purports to exempt a director from any liability that would otherwise attach to him in connection with negligence, default, breach of duty or breach of trust in relation to the company is void, whether contained in the articles or in a contract. Under s 233, however, a company may purchase and maintain insurance for a director against any such liability. Qualifying third party indemnity provisions are also permitted under s 234. So Ida cannot rely on the clause, but the D&O insurance is valid and may respond to the claim, subject to its terms.
Law basis: Companies Act 2006 ss 232, 233 ↗Question 17 · Directors' dutiesDraft, pending solicitor review
Jai, a director of Kite Ltd, wants to sell his own van to the company for £8,000, which is its market value. A fellow director says that Jai must avoid this situation altogether under the conflict duty in s 175 unless the board authorises it. Which of the following best describes the duty that applies to the sale?
- The conflict duty does not apply, as Jai must instead declare his interest in the transaction under s 177.Correct answer
- The conflict duty applies, so the sale needs board authorisation under s 175 before the company can enter into it.
- The conflict duty applies, so the sale needs the members' approval by ordinary resolution before it proceeds.
- No duty applies, because the van is being sold to the company at its full market value of £8,000.
- The conflict duty applies, but only because the value of the van exceeds the £5,000 minimum for approval.
Section 175(3) of the Companies Act 2006 provides that the duty to avoid conflicts of interest does not apply to a conflict arising in relation to a transaction or arrangement with the company. Such transactions are governed instead by s 177, which requires the director to declare the nature and extent of his interest in a proposed transaction to the other directors before the company enters into it. Selling at market value does not remove the need for declaration. The £5,000 figure relates to the substantial property transaction rules, and a transaction of £8,000 would not be substantial unless it also exceeded 10% of the company's net assets.
Law basis: Companies Act 2006 ss 175(3), 177 ↗More Business Law and Practice topics
Back to all Business Law and Practice questions, or sit a timed mock.