Key rules
Power to borrow: a company's objects are unrestricted unless the articles say otherwise (CA 2006 s 31), and directors exercise its powers (MA art 3). Directors must still act within their duties when granting security or guarantees, judged company by company within a group (Charterbridge Corp Ltd v Lloyds Bank Ltd (1970); s 172).
Types of debt finance: overdraft (repayable on demand), term loan, revolving credit facility, debt securities. Facility agreements contain conditions precedent, representations, covenants (financial, information, negative pledge, restrictions on disposals) and events of default allowing acceleration.
Debt v equity: a lender is a creditor entitled to interest whatever the profits and repayment ahead of shareholders on insolvency; interest is generally deductible for corporation tax. Shareholders receive dividends only out of distributable profits and rank last.
Types of security:
- Mortgage – transfer of title (legal) with an equity of redemption.
- Fixed charge – attaches to specific identified assets; company cannot deal with them without the chargee's consent.
- Floating charge – over a fluctuating class of present and future assets; the company may deal with them in the ordinary course of business until crystallisation (Re Yorkshire Woolcombers Association Ltd (1903)). Labelling is not decisive: if the company is free to deal with assets (e.g. book debts and their proceeds) without consent, the charge is floating (Re Spectrum Plus Ltd (2005); Agnew v Commissioner of Inland Revenue (2001)).
- Crystallisation occurs on liquidation, administration, appointment of a receiver, cessation of business, or automatic or notice crystallisation events in the charge.
- Guarantees by directors or group companies; retention of title clauses in supply contracts keep ownership with the supplier (Clough Mill Ltd v Martin (1985)).
Registration (CA 2006 Part 25):
- A charge created by a company must be delivered with a certified copy of the instrument within 21 days beginning with the day after creation (s 859A). Registration can be by the company or any interested person.
- Failure: the charge is void against a liquidator, administrator and creditors (s 859H), but the debt remains and becomes immediately repayable (s 859H(4)). The court may extend time (s 859F).
- Charges over registered land also need registration at HM Land Registry to protect priority (Land Registration Act 2002 ss 27, 29).
Priority:
- Fixed charges over the same asset generally rank in order of creation, provided each is registered in time.
- A later fixed charge beats an earlier floating charge, because the floating chargee impliedly allows dealings.
- Exception: a negative pledge in the floating charge binds a later chargee with actual notice of it (Wilson v Kelland (1910)); registration alone is generally treated as notice of the charge, not of its terms.
- Lenders may vary priority by a deed of priority (intercreditor agreement).
- Floating charge holders are subject to liquidation expenses, preferential debts and the prescribed part (IA 1986 ss 175, 176A, 176ZA).
- A floating charge for past value granted shortly before insolvency may be invalid under IA 1986 s 245.
How it is tested
- Charge registered on day 25 after creation: void against the liquidator; lender unsecured, though the debt is still owed.
- Bank A takes a floating charge, Bank B a later fixed charge on the same machinery: B ranks first unless it had actual notice of a negative pledge.
- Directors of a subsidiary give a guarantee for parent's debts: consider s 172 for the subsidiary.
Exam traps
- Saying late registration makes the debt unenforceable – only the security is void.
- Assuming a charge called "fixed" is fixed – substance governs (Spectrum).
- Ranking an earlier floating charge ahead of a later fixed charge automatically.
- Counting 21 days from the date of the loan rather than the day after the charge was created.
- Forgetting that floating charge holders bear preferential debts and the prescribed part.
Quick check
Remember: Register every charge within 21 days or it is void against office-holders and creditors, and a floating charge yields to later fixed charges unless the later chargee knew of a negative pledge.