Law covered in these questions
- SRA Standards and Regulations: Code of Conduct for Solicitors, RELs and RFLs, paras 3.1, 3.2
- SRA Standards and Regulations: Code of Conduct for Solicitors, RELs and RFLs, paras 3.1, 8.6 (information)
- Code of Conduct for Solicitors, RELs and RFLs, paras 3.1 and 3.4
- Code of Conduct for Solicitors, RELs and RFLs, para 3.1
- Mental Capacity Act 2005, ss 2 and 3
- Yonge v Toynbee [1910] 1 KB 215
- Solicitors Act 1974, s 65(2)
- SRA Principles 2019, Principle 7
- Code of Conduct for Solicitors, RELs and RFLs, paras 3.1 and 4.2
- CPR 21.2
- Mental Capacity Act 2005, ss 1 and 9
- Code of Conduct for Solicitors, RELs and RFLs, paras 3.1 and 8.1
- Code of Conduct for Solicitors, RELs and RFLs, paras 1.1, 3.2 and 3.3
- Code of Conduct for Solicitors, RELs and RFLs, paras 3.1, 3.4 and 6.3
All 16 questions with answers
Try them above first, then read the worked answers below.
Question 1 · Client instructions and authorityDraft, pending solicitor review
A solicitor is instructed by a client to sell her flat. A friend of the client phones and tells the solicitor to accept an offer of £280,000. The client has not said so. Which statement best describes what the solicitor should do?
- Not act on the friend's instructions without the client's authority, because the solicitor must act in accordance with the client's instructions, given by the client or someone properly authorised.Correct answer
- Accept the offer if the price seems fair.
- Accept the offer, because it can be reversed later.
- Ignore the offer and the friend and take no further steps.
- Accept the offer, because the friend is acting for the client.
A solicitor must act on the instructions of the client or someone entitled to give them and must be satisfied that those giving instructions on a client's behalf have authority to do so.
Law basis: SRA Standards and Regulations: Code of Conduct for Solicitors, RELs and RFLs, paras 3.1, 3.2Question 2 · Client instructions and authorityDraft, pending solicitor review
The other side in a claim makes a settlement offer to a solicitor late on Friday. The client is on holiday and cannot be reached until Monday. Which statement best describes what the solicitor should do about the offer?
- Tell the other side that the client agrees to it.
- Pass the offer to the client promptly, so the client can decide, and not accept or reject it without authority.Correct answer
- Reject it at once, because the client is away.
- Accept it, because the solicitor knows what is best.
- Keep it secret until the client returns and the offer expires.
A solicitor must tell clients promptly of any offer and cannot settle without the client's authority. The client decides whether to settle.
Law basis: SRA Standards and Regulations: Code of Conduct for Solicitors, RELs and RFLs, paras 3.1, 8.6 (information)Question 3 · Client instructions and authorityDraft, pending solicitor review
Megan telephones Hugo, a private client solicitor, saying that her 89-year-old father Ernest wants to change his will to leave his entire estate to her instead of equally to his three children. Megan says Ernest is frail, so she will pass on his instructions and bring him to sign the will. Which of the following best describes what Hugo should do?
- Act on Megan's instructions, because a close relative is presumed to have authority for a parent.
- Act provided Megan signs a declaration that the instructions reflect her father's wishes.
- Refuse to act, because the proposed will benefits the person who is conveying the instructions.
- Act if Ernest signs the will in Hugo's presence, as execution confirms that the will is his.
- Take instructions directly from Ernest, ideally seeing him alone, before preparing any will.Correct answer
Paragraph 3.1 of the Code requires a solicitor to act only on instructions from the client or someone properly authorised, and if there is reason to suspect that instructions do not represent the client's wishes, not to act unless satisfied that they do. Megan has no authority, benefits from the change and is controlling access to Ernest, which signals a risk of undue influence. Hugo should see Ernest, preferably alone, to confirm his wishes and assess capacity, taking account of his attributes and needs under paragraph 3.4. Refusing outright goes too far: Hugo can act once satisfied. Execution alone does not show the instructions were Ernest's own.
Law basis: Code of Conduct for Solicitors, RELs and RFLs, paras 3.1 and 3.4Question 4 · Client instructions and authorityDraft, pending solicitor review
Mrs Patel instructed Daniel to sell her house. Before exchange, her son tells Daniel she has been diagnosed with advanced dementia and no longer understands the transaction. There is no lasting power of attorney and no deputy. The buyer wants to exchange this week. Which of the following best describes Daniel's position?
- He may exchange on her original instructions, because these were given while she still had capacity.
- He cannot exchange on her behalf, as he has no valid instructions without someone authorised to act.Correct answer
- He may exchange if her son, as her next of kin, confirms that she would have wanted the sale to proceed.
- He may exchange, provided he first obtains a medical report confirming the diagnosis of her condition.
- He must exchange this week, because delay would expose Mrs Patel to a claim by the disappointed buyer.
A solicitor's authority to act comes from the client, and the retainer is generally terminated if the client loses the mental capacity to give instructions; acting on in such circumstances risks liability for breach of warranty of authority, as in Yonge v Toynbee. Paragraph 3.1 requires instructions from the client or someone properly authorised. Capacity must be assessed under the Mental Capacity Act 2005, and if Mrs Patel lacks capacity, an application to the Court of Protection for a deputy will be needed before the sale proceeds. Her son, as next of kin, has no authority. Pressure from the buyer cannot justify proceeding without authority.
Law basis: Code of Conduct for Solicitors, RELs and RFLs, para 3.1; Mental Capacity Act 2005, ss 2 and 3; Yonge v Toynbee [1910] 1 KB 215Question 5 · Client instructions and authorityDraft, pending solicitor review
Mr and Mrs Shaw jointly own their home and have both signed the firm's client care letter for its sale. Mr Shaw later emails Zara, the solicitor, telling her to accept a reduced offer and exchange contracts, adding that his wife 'is happy with whatever I decide'. Mrs Shaw has said nothing. Which of the following best describes what Zara should do?
- Accept the offer, because one joint client can always give instructions on behalf of both.
- Accept the offer, because Mr Shaw has stated in writing that his wife agrees with him.
- Confirm Mrs Shaw's instructions directly before accepting the offer or exchanging.Correct answer
- Refuse to act further for either client, because they now have a conflict of interest.
- Accept the offer only if the reduction is small compared with the original sale price.
Mrs Shaw is a client in her own right. Paragraph 3.1 requires a solicitor to act only on instructions from the client or someone properly authorised by them, and if there is reason to suspect instructions do not represent the client's wishes, not to act unless satisfied they do. Mr Shaw's assertion that his wife agrees is not her instruction, and accepting a reduced price is a significant decision. Zara should contact Mrs Shaw directly. There is no automatic conflict merely because one spouse has written alone, although Zara should be alert to one emerging. The size of the reduction does not affect the need for both clients' authority.
Law basis: Code of Conduct for Solicitors, RELs and RFLs, para 3.1Question 6 · Client instructions and authorityDraft, pending solicitor review
Clive's firm acts for Mr Grant in county court litigation. Mr Grant has ignored three requests to pay an agreed sum on account of costs, as required by the retainer. Clive is annoyed and, two days before trial, emails Mr Grant to say the firm has stopped acting with immediate effect. Which of the following best describes Clive's conduct?
- He acted properly, because a solicitor may stop acting at any time and for any reason.
- He acted properly, because a client who does not pay is treated as having ended the retainer.
- Non-payment can justify ending the retainer, but only on reasonable notice.Correct answer
- He acted improperly, because a solicitor can never end a retainer once a trial date is fixed.
- He acted improperly, because only the client can terminate a retainer in contentious business.
A solicitor may end a retainer only for good reason and on reasonable notice. Section 65(2) of the Solicitors Act 1974 provides that, in contentious business, a solicitor who has requested a reasonable sum on account of costs and not received it within a reasonable time may treat that as good cause to withdraw, on giving reasonable notice. Non-payment is therefore capable of justifying withdrawal, but stopping with immediate effect two days before trial is unlikely to be reasonable notice and may harm Mr Grant's interests, contrary to Principle 7. A trial date does not prevent withdrawal altogether.
Law basis: Solicitors Act 1974, s 65(2); SRA Principles 2019, Principle 7 ↗Question 7 · Client instructions and authorityDraft, pending solicitor review
Freya is acting for Tilbury Ltd on a share purchase. Shortly before completion she receives an email, apparently from the company's finance director, asking her to send the £400,000 completion surplus to a different bank account from the one previously given. The email address differs by one letter from the usual one. Which of the following best describes what Freya should do?
- Follow the instruction, because the finance director has authority to give instructions for the company.
- Follow the instruction, provided the new bank account is in the name of Tilbury Ltd.
- Verify the request with the client by telephone using contact details already held on file.Correct answer
- Reply to the email asking the sender to confirm the change of account in writing.
- Follow the instruction, because the firm's insurance will cover any loss if it proves fraudulent.
Paragraph 3.1 provides that if you have reason to suspect that instructions do not represent your client's wishes, you must not act unless you have satisfied yourself that they do. A late change of bank details from a slightly different email address is a classic sign of email interception fraud. Paragraph 4.2 also requires Freya to safeguard money entrusted to her. She should verify the instruction independently, using contact details already held rather than any supplied in the suspicious email, before sending any money. Replying to the same email would simply reach the fraudster. The account name shown in a request is easily faked, and insurance cover does not discharge her duty.
Law basis: Code of Conduct for Solicitors, RELs and RFLs, paras 3.1 and 4.2Question 8 · Client instructions and authorityDraft, pending solicitor review
Harvey, aged 16, was injured when a delivery van hit his bicycle. He visits a solicitor, Peter, alone and asks him to bring a claim for damages. He says his parents are busy but he understands what he wants. Which of the following best describes how the claim should be conducted?
- Harvey can conduct the claim himself and instruct Peter directly, because he is over 16.
- Peter can act only once Harvey reaches 18, because a child cannot bring a claim for damages.
- Peter may act on Harvey's instructions if one parent signs the firm's client care letter.
- Harvey must wait until he is 18 before any claim is issued, as limitation does not run until then.
- A litigation friend will normally be needed, and Peter should take instructions through them.Correct answer
Under CPR 21.2, a child, meaning a person under 18, must have a litigation friend to conduct proceedings on his behalf unless the court orders otherwise. A parent or another suitable adult can act as litigation friend, and Peter should take instructions through that person while also taking account of Harvey's own views and needs under paragraph 3.4 of the Code. A child can bring a claim, and although limitation does not run against a child until he reaches 18, there is no need to wait. A parent merely signing the client care letter is not the same as acting as litigation friend.
Law basis: CPR 21.2; Code of Conduct for Solicitors, RELs and RFLs, paras 3.1 and 3.4Question 9 · Client instructions and authorityDraft, pending solicitor review
Mrs Barr, who has advanced Alzheimer's disease and lacks capacity, is moving into a care home. Her son, Joseph, holds a registered lasting power of attorney for property and financial affairs. He instructs Lauren to sell his mother's house to pay the care home fees. Which of the following best describes Lauren's position?
- She cannot act, because instructions for a sale must come from Mrs Barr herself.
- She cannot act until the Court of Protection appoints a deputy for Mrs Barr.
- She may act only if Joseph also obtains the agreement of Mrs Barr's other children.
- She may act on Joseph's instructions, having checked the scope and registration of the power.Correct answer
- She may act on Joseph's instructions without checking the power, as he is her son and her main carer.
Paragraph 3.1 permits solicitors to act on instructions from someone properly authorised to give instructions on the client's behalf. An attorney under a registered lasting power of attorney for property and financial affairs may deal with the donor's property, including selling her home, provided the power covers it and the attorney acts in the donor's best interests as required by the Mental Capacity Act 2005. Lauren must check the power is registered and has no relevant restrictions, and remain alert to any sign that Joseph is not acting in his mother's best interests. A deputy is not needed where a valid power exists, and other relatives' agreement is not required.
Law basis: Code of Conduct for Solicitors, RELs and RFLs, para 3.1; Mental Capacity Act 2005, ss 1 and 9Question 10 · Client instructions and authorityDraft, pending solicitor review
Gable Ltd has two directors and shareholders, Tom and Uma, who hold 50% each and are in a bitter deadlock. Tom asks the company's long-standing solicitors to issue proceedings in Gable's name against a business owned by Uma's husband. Uma knows nothing about this, and there has been no board meeting. Which of the following best describes the firm's position?
- It may act, because any one director can instruct the company's solicitors on its behalf.
- It must be satisfied that Tom has authority to instruct for the company before acting.Correct answer
- It may act, because Tom has been the firm's main point of contact at the company.
- It may act, provided it issues the claim before Uma has an opportunity to object.
- It may act on Tom's instructions, provided Tom personally guarantees the firm's fees.
Under paragraph 3.1, a solicitor may act only on instructions from the client or from someone properly authorised to instruct on its behalf. The client here is the company, and whether a director can commit it to litigation depends on the company's constitution and board decisions. With a 50:50 deadlock and no board approval, Tom may well lack authority, and the claim also seems to be part of the directors' personal dispute. The firm must clarify authority before acting and should be alert to a conflict between the company and its directors. Being the usual contact gives Tom no special authority, and a fee guarantee is irrelevant to authority.
Law basis: Code of Conduct for Solicitors, RELs and RFLs, paras 3.1 and 8.1Question 11 · Client instructions and authorityDraft, pending solicitor review
Kim instructs her solicitor, Daniel, to buy a commercial unit at auction, with a strict maximum bid of £200,000. In the room the bidding reaches £200,000 and Daniel, sure that Kim would want the unit, bids £210,000 and wins. Kim is unhappy and says she cannot raise the extra money. Which of the following best describes Daniel's conduct?
- He acted properly, because he reasonably believed the purchase was in Kim's best interests.
- He acted properly, because a solicitor has implied authority to exceed a limit by up to 5%.
- He acted outside his client's instructions and so breached his duty to act on her instructions.Correct answer
- He acted properly, provided he can show the unit was worth more than £210,000.
- He acted improperly only if Kim is unable to complete the purchase within the auction timescale.
Paragraph 3.1 of the Code requires solicitors to act only on the instructions of the client or someone properly authorised. Kim set an express maximum of £200,000, so bidding £210,000 exceeded Daniel's authority, whatever his view of her interests. Principle 7 requires him to act in her best interests, but not to override her clear instructions; a binding auction contract with a price she cannot afford may expose her to serious loss. There is no implied authority to exceed an express limit by a percentage. The unit's value does not justify acting without authority, and the breach does not depend on whether she manages to complete.
Law basis: Code of Conduct for Solicitors, RELs and RFLs, para 3.1; SRA Principles 2019, Principle 7Question 12 · Client instructions and authorityDraft, pending solicitor review
Callum acts for a defendant in a county court claim. The defence must be filed tomorrow. His client, who approved a draft but has not confirmed final instructions, has gone abroad and cannot be contacted despite repeated attempts. Which of the following best describes what Callum may do?
- Do nothing until the client makes contact, because he has no final instructions on the defence.
- Take steps within his authority to protect the client's position, such as seeking an extension.Correct answer
- Admit the claim, because that would avoid the risk of the client paying further costs.
- Stop acting immediately, because a client who cannot be contacted has ended the retainer.
- File a defence that differs from the approved draft, based on his own view of the merits.
Paragraph 3.1 of the Code provides that where a solicitor has legal authority to act notwithstanding that it is not possible to obtain or ascertain the client's instructions, the solicitor is subject to the overriding obligation to protect the client's best interests. Callum is retained to defend the claim, so he may take protective steps within that retainer, such as seeking the claimant's agreement to an extension or applying to the court, or filing the defence in the form the client has approved. Doing nothing could result in default judgment. Admitting the claim or changing the defence would go beyond his instructions, and the client's absence does not end the retainer.
Law basis: Code of Conduct for Solicitors, RELs and RFLs, para 3.1; SRA Principles 2019, Principle 7Question 13 · Client instructions and authorityDraft, pending solicitor review
Isobel, a sole practitioner in family law, is approached by a prospective client who wants help with a complex international child abduction case. Isobel is fully booked for the next three months and has never handled abduction cases. She declines to act and gives the client contact details for specialist firms. Which of the following best describes Isobel's position?
- She was entitled to decline, as she had good reasons and her refusal was not discriminatory.Correct answer
- She was obliged to act, because a solicitor must accept any instructions within her practice area.
- She was obliged to act, because declining instructions in an urgent case breaches the Principles.
- She was entitled to decline only if she first obtained the SRA's permission to refuse the work.
- She was obliged to act unless the client's case was hopeless on its merits.
Solicitors are generally free to decide whether to accept instructions, provided they do not refuse for unlawful or unfairly discriminatory reasons, contrary to paragraph 1.1 of the Code and the Equality Act 2010. Isobel had good reasons: she lacked capacity to give the matter the timely attention required by paragraph 3.2 and lacked the specialist expertise needed for a competent service. Declining and pointing the client towards specialists serves the client's interests. There is no general obligation to accept work within one's practice area, no requirement for SRA permission, and the merits of the case are not the only legitimate reason for declining.
Law basis: Code of Conduct for Solicitors, RELs and RFLs, paras 1.1, 3.2 and 3.3Question 14 · Client instructions and authorityDraft, pending solicitor review
Jayden, aged 15, is charged with robbery and is represented by Nkechi in the youth court. Jayden tells Nkechi he wants to plead not guilty. His mother, who attends with him, tells Nkechi that Jayden must plead guilty 'to get it over with' and that, as his parent, her decision is final. Which of the following best describes Nkechi's position?
- She must act on Jayden's instructions, because he is her client and the plea is his decision.Correct answer
- She must follow the mother's instructions, because Jayden is under 18 and cannot instruct her.
- She must ask the court to decide the plea, because the youth and his parent disagree.
- She must withdraw, because she cannot act where a youth and his parent give conflicting instructions.
- She may follow whichever instruction she considers to be in Jayden's best interests overall.
In criminal proceedings the defendant is the client, even when he is a youth, and paragraph 3.1 of the Code requires Nkechi to act on instructions from the client. A parent has an important supporting role in the youth court but cannot override the young person's instructions on matters such as plea. Nkechi should ensure Jayden understands the charge, the evidence and the consequences of each plea, taking account of his age and needs under paragraph 3.4, and then act on his decision. Principle 7 does not permit her to substitute her own view or the mother's. The court does not decide a defendant's plea, and a disagreement with a parent is not a reason to withdraw.
Law basis: Code of Conduct for Solicitors, RELs and RFLs, paras 3.1 and 3.4; SRA Principles 2019, Principle 7Question 15 · Client instructions and authorityDraft, pending solicitor review
Ms Ashby has applied for a non-molestation order against her partner. She telephones her solicitor, Dev, saying she wants to withdraw the application. Her voice is shaky, she cannot explain why, and Dev can hear a man's voice prompting her in the background. Which of the following best describes what Dev should do?
- Withdraw the application at once, because the client has given a clear instruction.
- Refuse to withdraw the application, because it is plainly in her best interests to continue.
- Tell the court that the client is being coerced and ask it to continue the application.
- Try to speak to her privately to confirm her wishes before acting on the instruction.Correct answer
- Ask the man in the background to confirm the instruction before withdrawing the application.
Paragraph 3.1 of the Code provides that if a solicitor has reason to suspect that instructions do not represent the client's wishes, he must not act on them unless satisfied that they do. Paragraph 3.4 requires him to take account of the client's circumstances, including vulnerability. The signs of possible coercion in a domestic abuse case mean Dev should arrange to speak to Ms Ashby privately and safely before acting. If, having done so, she confirms that she wishes to withdraw, he must follow her instructions. He cannot simply override her wishes, and he must not reveal his concerns to the court without her consent under paragraph 6.3.
Law basis: Code of Conduct for Solicitors, RELs and RFLs, paras 3.1, 3.4 and 6.3Question 16 · Client instructions and authorityDraft, pending solicitor review
Fergus is retained only to check that a tenant's notice exercising a rent review right complies with the lease. While reading the lease, he notices that the tenant client's own break option must be exercised within the next three weeks, which the client has not mentioned. Fergus says nothing because it is outside the retainer. Which of the following best describes Fergus's conduct?
- He should have warned the client about the break deadline, despite the limited retainer.Correct answer
- He acted properly, because a solicitor's duties are strictly limited by the scope of the retainer.
- He acted properly, because the client is responsible for knowing the terms of its own lease.
- He acted properly, provided his client care letter clearly defined the scope of the work.
- He should have exercised the break option on the client's behalf without seeking instructions.
A solicitor's duties are generally defined by the scope of the retainer, but where he becomes aware of a risk to the client which is obvious and closely connected with the work, he may be expected to warn the client even though it is outside the retainer, as recognised in Credit Lyonnais SA v Russell Jones & Walker. A looming deadline for the client's own break option, discovered while reading the same lease, is such a risk. Principle 7 and paragraph 3.2 point the same way. Fergus need not advise in detail, but he should have flagged the deadline. He could not exercise the break without instructions, which paragraph 3.1 requires.
Law basis: Credit Lyonnais SA v Russell Jones & Walker [2002] EWHC 1310 (Ch); Code of Conduct for Solicitors, RELs and RFLs, paras 3.1 and 3.2More Ethics and Professional Conduct topics
Back to all Ethics and Professional Conduct questions, or sit a timed mock.