Law covered in these questions
- Code of Conduct for Solicitors, RELs and RFLs, para 4.1
- Code of Conduct for Solicitors, RELs and RFLs, para 4.2
- SRA Accounts Rules 2019, rule 3.3
- SRA Accounts Rules 2019, rules 7.1 and 7.2
- SRA Accounts Rules 2019, rules 2.3 and 4.1
- SRA Accounts Rules 2019, rule 2.5
- SRA Accounts Rules 2019, rule 4.3
- SRA Accounts Rules 2019, rules 2.3 and 6.1
All 8 questions with answers
Try them above first, then read the worked answers below.
Question 1 · Client money and financial benefitsDraft, pending solicitor review
Nadia acts for Ben on the purchase of a flat. At Ben's request she arranges buildings insurance through a broker, which pays her firm £60 commission. Nadia's client care letter says nothing about commission, and Ben has not been told about the payment. Which of the following best describes Nadia's obligation?
- She may keep it, as the sum is small and falls below the de minimis level for commissions.
- She may keep it, provided the firm records the payment in its books as business money.
- She must pay it to Ben, but may set it off against her fees only with the SRA's permission.
- She must account to Ben for the commission unless he agrees that the firm may keep it.Correct answer
- She may keep it, as a payment by a third party is not a benefit received from the client.
Paragraph 4.1 of the Code requires a solicitor to account properly to clients for any financial benefit received as a result of their instructions, except where they have agreed otherwise. The commission arises from Ben's instructions, so it belongs to him unless he gives informed agreement to the firm keeping it, which requires him to be told about it. There is no de minimis threshold under the current Code, so the option relying on the small amount reflects older rules. Recording it as business money would compound the problem, and paying the benefit by deduction from fees needs Ben's agreement, not the SRA's.
Law basis: Code of Conduct for Solicitors, RELs and RFLs, para 4.1Question 2 · Client money and financial benefitsDraft, pending solicitor review
A high street firm holds about 2,000 original wills in its strongroom. To reduce storage costs, the managing partner proposes to shred the wills of any clients who have not contacted the firm for more than fifteen years, without trying to contact them first. Which of the following best describes the proposal?
- It would breach the duty to safeguard clients' assets, so the wills must not be destroyed.Correct answer
- It is permitted, because the firm's duty to store documents ends fifteen years after its last contact.
- It is permitted, provided the firm keeps scanned copies of each will on its electronic system.
- It is permitted, because a will is the client's property and the client should have collected it.
- It is permitted, provided the firm places a notice in a local newspaper before the shredding.
Paragraph 4.2 of the Code requires solicitors to safeguard money and assets entrusted to them by clients and others. An original will held for safekeeping is such an asset, and destroying it could defeat the testator's wishes, since a copy is not a substitute for a validly executed original. The firm must keep the wills safely or make proper arrangements, such as returning them with the clients' agreement or transferring them to another firm or a will storage provider, after reasonable efforts to contact clients. There is no rule that the duty lapses after fifteen years, and a newspaper notice would not justify destruction.
Law basis: Code of Conduct for Solicitors, RELs and RFLs, para 4.2Question 3 · Client money and financial benefitsDraft, pending solicitor review
Mr Volkov asks a firm to receive £200,000 from overseas into its client account and then pay it out in several amounts to various people, some of them in other countries. There is no property purchase, litigation or other legal work connected with the payments. He says he trusts solicitors more than banks. Which of the following best describes the firm's position?
- It may do this, provided it charges an appropriate fee for the work of handling the payments.
- It must not do this, as it would be providing a banking facility through its client account.Correct answer
- It may do this, provided Mr Volkov provides satisfactory evidence of his identity first.
- It may do this, because client money may be held for any purpose the client chooses.
- It may do this, provided the money is held in a separate designated deposit client account.
Rule 3.3 of the SRA Accounts Rules provides that you must not use a client account to provide banking facilities to clients or third parties; payments into and out of client account must relate to the delivery of regulated services. Receiving and distributing money with no underlying legal transaction is a banking facility and is prohibited. The proposal also has hallmarks of money laundering, so the firm should consider its obligations under the Proceeds of Crime Act 2002 and the Money Laundering Regulations 2017. Checking identity or charging a fee does not make the arrangement permissible, and using a separate designated account makes no difference.
Law basis: SRA Accounts Rules 2019, rule 3.3; Code of Conduct for Solicitors, RELs and RFLs, para 4.2Question 4 · Client money and financial benefitsDraft, pending solicitor review
A firm holds client money in a general client account which earns interest from the bank. Its terms of business say nothing about interest, and its practice is to keep all interest earned, however large the sum or however long it is held. Ms Ndlovu's £250,000 compensation award has been held for nine months. Which of the following best describes the firm's position?
- It may keep all the interest, because the money is held in the firm's own name at the bank.
- It may keep all the interest, because interest on client money is a benefit to the firm, not the client.
- It must account for a fair sum of interest unless it has agreed otherwise with the client in writing.Correct answer
- It need pay interest only if the client specifically asked for the money to be placed on deposit.
- It need pay interest only if the money was held in a separate designated deposit client account.
Rule 7.1 of the SRA Accounts Rules requires firms to account to clients or third parties for a fair sum of interest on client money held on their behalf, and rule 7.2 allows this to be excluded only by a written agreement with the client. This reflects the wider duty in paragraph 4.1 of the Code to account for financial benefits received as a result of clients' instructions. A blanket policy of keeping all interest, with nothing agreed in writing, breaches the rules, particularly where a large sum has been held for many months. The firm should have a written interest policy setting out how a fair sum is calculated. Holding the money in the firm's name makes no difference.
Law basis: SRA Accounts Rules 2019, rules 7.1 and 7.2; Code of Conduct for Solicitors, RELs and RFLs, para 4.1Question 5 · Client money and financial benefitsDraft, pending solicitor review
Mr Ozturk visits Ellie, a solicitor at a high street firm, and gives her £3,000 in cash on account of costs for his immigration appeal. Because the cashier has gone home, Ellie pays it into her own personal bank account, intending to transfer it to the firm on Monday. Which of the following best describes Ellie's conduct?
- It is acceptable, because she intends to transfer the money to the firm on the next working day.
- It is acceptable, provided she records the payment on Mr Ozturk's client ledger on Monday.
- It is acceptable, because money paid on account of costs belongs to the firm from the moment it is paid.
- It is acceptable, provided the sum is below the limit set for cash receipts in the firm's policy.
- It is improper, because client money must be paid promptly into a client account and kept separate.Correct answer
Money received on account of costs is client money until a bill has been delivered. Rule 2.3 of the SRA Accounts Rules requires client money to be paid promptly into a client account, and rule 4.1 requires client money to be kept separate from money belonging to the firm or its people. Paragraph 4.2 of the Code also requires client money to be safeguarded. Paying it into a personal account mixes client money with personal money and exposes it to risk, whatever Ellie's intentions. Recording it on the ledger later does not cure the breach.
Law basis: SRA Accounts Rules 2019, rules 2.3 and 4.1; Code of Conduct for Solicitors, RELs and RFLs, para 4.2Question 6 · Client money and financial benefitsDraft, pending solicitor review
A firm's annual review reveals £14,000 held in client account across forty matters that were completed between three and eight years ago. The balances range from £5 to £2,000. The firm has made no attempt to return them, saying it is simpler to leave them where they are. Which of the following best describes the firm's obligation?
- It may keep holding them indefinitely, because the money is safe and still properly recorded in client account.
- It may transfer the balances to its office account once six years have passed since the matters ended.
- It must pay all of them to charity, because client money cannot be held after a matter has ended.
- It need act only if a former client asks for the return of the balance held on their behalf.
- It must take reasonable steps to return the balances promptly, as there is no proper reason to hold them.Correct answer
Rule 2.5 of the SRA Accounts Rules requires client money to be returned promptly to the client or third party as soon as there is no longer any proper reason to hold it. Balances on completed matters must therefore be returned, and the firm should take reasonable steps to trace the people entitled to them. Only where those steps fail may the firm consider other options, such as paying the money to a charity under the rules on residual balances, with any necessary SRA authorisation. Moving the money to the firm's own office account would be a misappropriation, and the duty does not depend on former clients asking for the money.
Law basis: SRA Accounts Rules 2019, rule 2.5; Code of Conduct for Solicitors, RELs and RFLs, para 4.2Question 7 · Client money and financial benefitsDraft, pending solicitor review
A firm receives £45,000 in damages for its client, Ms Price, into client account. Without sending her a bill or any written notice of its charges, the firm transfers £6,000 from client account to office account for its costs, and sends her the balance with a covering letter. Which of the following best describes the firm's conduct?
- It should have given her a bill or written notification of costs before making the transfer.Correct answer
- It acted properly, because the firm was entitled to be paid its costs from the damages.
- It acted properly, provided the £6,000 does not exceed the estimate given at the outset.
- It acted properly, provided it sends her a bill within 28 days of making the transfer.
- It acted properly, because Ms Price signed terms allowing costs to be deducted from damages.
Rule 4.3 of the SRA Accounts Rules provides that where client money is to be used to pay the firm's costs, the firm must give a bill of costs, or other written notification of the costs incurred, to the client or paying party before transferring the money from client account. The firm's entitlement to be paid, and any contractual right to deduct costs from damages, do not remove this requirement, which ensures that clients know what they are being charged before their money is used. Sending a bill afterwards does not cure the breach, and the amount being within the estimate is irrelevant. Paragraph 4.2 of the Code also requires client money to be safeguarded.
Law basis: SRA Accounts Rules 2019, rule 4.3; Code of Conduct for Solicitors, RELs and RFLs, para 4.2Question 8 · Client money and financial benefitsDraft, pending solicitor review
A firm's cashier mistakenly pays a £20,000 cheque received from a buyer for a client's deposit into the firm's office account instead of client account. The error is spotted by a fee earner four days later. Which of the following best describes what the firm must do?
- Leave the money in office account, because it will be paid out on completion.
- Leave the money where it is until the firm's accountant prepares the next report.
- Transfer the money to client account promptly and correct the breach.Correct answer
- Transfer the money only if the client asks where the deposit is being held.
- Report the error to the client's lender before taking any corrective action.
Rule 2.3 of the SRA Accounts Rules requires client money to be paid promptly into a client account, and rule 6.1 requires any breach of the rules to be corrected promptly upon discovery, including replacing money improperly withheld or withdrawn from client account. The deposit is client money and must be transferred to client account immediately. Leaving it in office account would continue the breach and expose the money to the firm's creditors. Paragraph 4.2 of the Code also requires client money to be safeguarded. The firm should record the error and consider whether it needs to be reported, but correction cannot wait for the accountant's report or a client query.
Law basis: SRA Accounts Rules 2019, rules 2.3 and 6.1; Code of Conduct for Solicitors, RELs and RFLs, para 4.2More Ethics and Professional Conduct topics
Back to all Ethics and Professional Conduct questions, or sit a timed mock.