Law covered in these questions
- Code of Conduct for Solicitors, RELs and RFLs, para 1.3
- SRA Glossary, definition of 'undertaking'
- Udall v Capri Lighting Ltd [1988] QB 907
- Code of Conduct for Solicitors, RELs and RFLs, paras 1.3 and 3.5
- Code of Conduct for Solicitors, RELs and RFLs, paras 1.3 and 7.7
- Code of Conduct for Solicitors, RELs and RFLs, paras 1.3 and 2.5
- SRA Accounts Rules 2019, rule 6.1
- Law Society Formulae for Exchanging Contracts by Telephone (Formula B)
- SRA Code of Conduct for Solicitors, para 1.3
All 15 questions with answers
Try them above first, then read the worked answers below.
Question 1 · UndertakingsDraft, pending solicitor review
Leah acts for Mr Grant, who is selling a house. The buyer's solicitor asks Leah to undertake that Mr Grant's builder will remove a skip and rubble from the drive before completion. The builder is unreliable and Leah has no control over him. Which of the following best describes Leah's position?
- She may give it, because an undertaking dependent on a third party's actions cannot be enforced against her.
- She may give it, provided she records on her file that performance depends on the builder.
- She should not give it, because she would be bound even though performance depends on the builder.Correct answer
- She may give it, because only a written statement using the word 'undertake' will bind her.
- She may give it, because the buyer's only remedy for non-performance lies against Mr Grant.
Paragraph 1.3 of the Code requires a solicitor to perform all undertakings within the agreed timescale or, if none, within a reasonable time. An undertaking binds the giver even where performance depends on someone else, so a solicitor should not undertake to do something she cannot ensure happens. The SRA Glossary defines an undertaking as a statement, given orally or in writing and whether or not it includes the word 'undertake', on which someone reasonably relies. A private file note does nothing to limit the undertaking as communicated. The suggestion that the buyer can only pursue Mr Grant overlooks the court's supervisory jurisdiction over solicitors and the regulatory consequences of breach.
Law basis: Code of Conduct for Solicitors, RELs and RFLs, para 1.3; SRA Glossary, definition of 'undertaking'Question 2 · UndertakingsDraft, pending solicitor review
Jun acts for the seller of a house. On completion he gives the buyer's solicitor the usual undertaking to redeem the seller's mortgage. After completion the lender says the redemption figure it supplied was wrong and a further £3,000 is owed. The net sale proceeds held by Jun are insufficient to cover it. Which of the following best describes Jun's position?
- He is released from the undertaking, because the shortfall was caused entirely by the lender's incorrect redemption figure.
- His obligation is limited to paying over the sale proceeds which his firm actually received on completion.
- He is released from the undertaking if his client agrees to pay the shortfall directly to the lender.
- His obligation is converted into a contractual claim which the buyer must pursue against the seller.
- He remains bound by the undertaking and must ensure the mortgage is redeemed, if necessary from his own funds.Correct answer
Paragraph 1.3 requires solicitors to perform all undertakings they give. An unqualified undertaking to redeem a mortgage is a personal obligation which does not depend on the sufficiency of the sale proceeds, so Jun must ensure the charge is discharged, using his firm's own money if necessary, and then seek recovery from his client. The court can enforce a solicitor's undertaking summarily under its supervisory jurisdiction, as in Udall v Capri Lighting. An undertaking can be released only by the person to whom it was given, not by the client. This is why careful solicitors obtain an accurate redemption statement before giving the undertaking.
Law basis: Code of Conduct for Solicitors, RELs and RFLs, para 1.3; Udall v Capri Lighting Ltd [1988] QB 907Question 3 · UndertakingsDraft, pending solicitor review
A paralegal at Wells & Co, acting under the supervision of a partner, tells the buyer's solicitor on the telephone: 'We undertake to send you the original lease within seven days.' The partner later says the paralegal had no authority to give undertakings and that the firm will not be bound. Which of the following best describes the position?
- The undertaking is void because a paralegal is not a solicitor and has no power to give undertakings.
- The undertaking is unenforceable because it was given orally and was never confirmed in writing.
- The undertaking binds only the paralegal personally, because the firm did not authorise it in advance.
- The undertaking binds the firm only if the paralegal used the firm's agreed written form of undertaking.
- The undertaking binds the firm, and the supervising partner remains accountable for its performance.Correct answer
An undertaking is a statement, oral or written, on which someone reasonably relies, that you or your business will do or refrain from doing something. The buyer's solicitor was entitled to rely on a statement made by a member of the firm's staff, so the undertaking binds the firm and must be performed under paragraph 1.3. Under paragraph 3.5, a solicitor who supervises others remains accountable for work carried out through them. Firms should have clear internal policies on who may give undertakings, but a breach of internal policy does not defeat the reliance of the recipient. Oral undertakings are binding.
Law basis: Code of Conduct for Solicitors, RELs and RFLs, paras 1.3 and 3.5; SRA Glossary, definition of 'undertaking'Question 4 · UndertakingsDraft, pending solicitor review
In March, Tariq undertook to the landlord's solicitors to deliver the signed counterpart lease and the tenant's guarantor's deed 'as soon as they are received'. No date was agreed. He received both documents in April but, owing to pressure of work, has still not sent them by August. Which of the following best describes Tariq's position?
- He has not breached it, because no timescale was agreed when the undertaking was given.
- He has not breached it, provided he delivers the documents before the landlord takes any action.
- He has breached it only if the landlord has suffered financial loss as a result of the delay.
- He has breached his undertaking by failing to perform it within a reasonable time.Correct answer
- He has not breached it, because the undertaking was conditional on the documents being received.
Paragraph 1.3 of the Code requires solicitors to perform all undertakings within an agreed timescale or, if no timescale has been agreed, within a reasonable amount of time. The condition, receipt of the documents, was satisfied in April, so the obligation became live then. A delay of four months caused only by pressure of work is unlikely to be reasonable, so Tariq is in breach. Loss is not required for a regulatory breach, although it may be relevant to any compensation the court orders. Late performance does not undo the breach of the requirement to perform within a reasonable time.
Law basis: Code of Conduct for Solicitors, RELs and RFLs, para 1.3Question 5 · UndertakingsDraft, pending solicitor review
Sara acts for a tenant taking a new lease. The landlord's solicitor agrees to hand over the keys before completion if Sara confirms in writing: 'I undertake that my client will pay your client's legal costs of £2,500 on or before completion.' Sara sends the email. Completion then falls through and her client refuses to pay the costs. Which of the following best describes Sara's position?
- She is not bound, because the email made clear that payment was to be made by her client.
- She is not bound, because her undertaking was conditional on completion taking place.
- She is personally bound to ensure that the £2,500 is paid, even though her client refuses.Correct answer
- She is bound only to use reasonable endeavours to persuade her client to pay the costs.
- She is not bound unless she was holding money from her client when she gave the undertaking.
Words such as 'I undertake that my client will pay' are an undertaking by the solicitor to ensure that the payment is made, and the SRA Glossary treats any statement on which someone reasonably relies that 'you or your business will do something or cause something to be done' as an undertaking. Paragraph 1.3 requires Sara to perform it. The undertaking was to pay 'on or before completion', so the failure of completion does not discharge it; payment was due by the intended date. A solicitor should not give such an undertaking unless she already holds the money or has irrevocable authority to use it. The court may enforce the undertaking against her personally.
Law basis: Code of Conduct for Solicitors, RELs and RFLs, para 1.3; SRA Glossary, definition of 'undertaking'Question 6 · UndertakingsDraft, pending solicitor review
Kerry gives the following undertaking to a buyer's solicitor: 'We undertake to send you the discharge of the second charge upon completion.' After completion, Kerry argues that she meant she would send it once the lender had supplied it, however long that took. The buyer's solicitor understood that it would be sent on the day of completion. Which of the following best describes the likely position?
- Kerry's interpretation prevails, because the meaning of an undertaking depends on the giver's intention.
- The undertaking is void for uncertainty, so Kerry has no obligation to send the discharge at all.
- The buyer's solicitor's interpretation prevails only if it confirmed its understanding in writing.
- The undertaking binds Kerry only if the second charge lender has agreed to supply the discharge.
- Ambiguity in an undertaking is generally construed in favour of the person who received it.Correct answer
Paragraph 1.3 requires solicitors to perform their undertakings within the agreed timescale or, if none, within a reasonable time. Because undertakings are relied on by recipients, the courts and the SRA generally construe any ambiguity in favour of the recipient, so the solicitor who gave it bears the risk of unclear wording. The buyer's solicitor's understanding that the discharge would be sent on completion is a reasonable reading, so Kerry is at serious risk of being in breach. An undertaking is not treated as void simply because it is ambiguous, and the recipient need not have confirmed its understanding. This illustrates why undertakings should be drafted precisely.
Law basis: Code of Conduct for Solicitors, RELs and RFLs, para 1.3; SRA Glossary, definition of 'undertaking'Question 7 · UndertakingsDraft, pending solicitor review
At 10am Sanjay emails the landlord's solicitor undertaking to pay its legal costs of £1,200 whether or not the lease completes. At 11am his client tells him she has changed her mind about giving the costs undertaking and asks him to withdraw it. The landlord's solicitor has not replied or taken any action. Which of the following best describes Sanjay's position?
- He may withdraw it unilaterally, because the recipient has not yet relied on it.
- He must withdraw it, because a solicitor must always act on his client's instructions.
- He may withdraw it, because his client has not yet put him in funds for the costs.
- He can withdraw it only with the landlord's solicitor's agreement.Correct answer
- He may withdraw it by email at any time before the lease is completed.
Once given, an undertaking binds the solicitor and can be withdrawn or varied only with the agreement of the person to whom it was given, as SRA guidance on undertakings makes clear. Paragraph 1.3 requires all undertakings to be performed. Sanjay should explain to his client that he cannot simply withdraw it, and ask the landlord's solicitor whether it will agree to release him. The client's change of mind does not release the undertaking, and the absence of funds is precisely why solicitors should not give costs undertakings without holding money or irrevocable authority. The fact that the recipient has not yet acted does not entitle Sanjay to withdraw unilaterally.
Law basis: Code of Conduct for Solicitors, RELs and RFLs, para 1.3; SRA Glossary, definition of 'undertaking'Question 8 · UndertakingsDraft, pending solicitor review
Victor acts for a tenant. He writes to the landlord's solicitor: 'On receipt of funds from my client, I undertake to pay your client's reasonable legal costs of the licence to assign.' The deal later collapses. Victor's client never sends him any money, and the landlord's solicitor demands payment from Victor. Which of the following best describes Victor's position?
- He is not in breach, because his undertaking depended on receiving funds that never arrived.Correct answer
- He must pay the costs himself, because all costs undertakings are personal and unconditional.
- He must pay the costs, because the collapse of the deal makes the undertaking unconditional.
- He is in breach, because he should have obtained the funds before the deal collapsed.
- He must pay the costs, because the landlord's solicitor relied on the undertaking to proceed.
Paragraph 1.3 requires solicitors to perform their undertakings, but the content of the obligation depends on the undertaking's terms. Victor's undertaking was expressly conditional on receiving funds from his client, so no obligation to pay arose because the condition was never met. This illustrates the value of carefully qualified undertakings. The position would be different if he had given an unconditional undertaking, or if he had received the funds and failed to pay them over. Ambiguity is construed against the giver, but here the condition is clear. The recipient's reliance on the undertaking does not convert a conditional undertaking into an unconditional one.
Law basis: Code of Conduct for Solicitors, RELs and RFLs, para 1.3Question 9 · UndertakingsDraft, pending solicitor review
On completion of a sale, the seller's solicitor, Mr Pryce, gave Sara an undertaking to send her the signed release of a restrictive covenant within 14 days. Two months later it has not arrived, and Mr Pryce does not reply to letters. Sara's client asks what can be done. Which of the following best describes the options available?
- The client can only sue the seller under the contract, because the undertaking binds only the seller.
- The court can enforce the undertaking against Mr Pryce, and the breach may be reported to the SRA.Correct answer
- Nothing can be done, because undertakings are binding in honour only and are not enforceable.
- The client must first obtain the seller's written consent before taking any action against Mr Pryce.
- The only remedy is a complaint to the Legal Ombudsman about Mr Pryce's poor service.
A solicitor's undertaking is personally binding, and the court has a supervisory jurisdiction over solicitors as its officers which allows it to enforce undertakings summarily and to order compensation, as illustrated by Udall v Capri Lighting. Failure to perform an undertaking also breaches paragraph 1.3 of the Code, so the matter may be reported to the SRA, and paragraph 7.7 may require Sara to report it if the breach appears serious. These remedies are in addition to any contractual claim against the seller. Undertakings are not binding in honour only, the seller's consent is not needed, and the Legal Ombudsman deals with complaints from a solicitor's own clients, not with enforcing undertakings.
Law basis: Code of Conduct for Solicitors, RELs and RFLs, paras 1.3 and 7.7; Udall v Capri Lighting Ltd [1988] QB 907Question 10 · UndertakingsDraft, pending solicitor review
A lender sends the title deeds to Fern's client's flat to Fern under her undertaking to 'hold them to our order' while a remortgage is being arranged. The remortgage falls through. The client asks Fern to hand him the deeds so that he can approach another lender himself. Which of the following best describes Fern's position?
- She must release the deeds, because they relate to the client's own property.
- She may release the deeds, because the undertaking ended when the remortgage fell through.
- She may release the deeds, provided the client signs a receipt for them.
- She must not release the deeds to the client without the lender's agreement.Correct answer
- She may release the deeds, provided she informs the lender within a reasonable time.
An undertaking to hold documents to a third party's order means that Fern may deal with them only as that party directs. Paragraph 1.3 requires her to perform the undertaking, and it continues until the lender releases her or she returns the deeds as directed, so the collapse of the remortgage does not end it. Releasing the deeds to the client would breach the undertaking, whatever his ownership of the property, and a receipt or later notice to the lender would not cure the breach. Fern should explain this to the client and, if appropriate, ask the lender for instructions or its consent to release the deeds.
Law basis: Code of Conduct for Solicitors, RELs and RFLs, para 1.3Question 11 · UndertakingsDraft, pending solicitor review
At an interim hearing in a dispute over the proceeds of a property sale, Ahmed tells the judge: 'My firm will hold the £90,000 net proceeds in its client account and not release them pending trial.' The judge adjourns on that basis. A month later, his client tells Ahmed to pay the money to him. Which of the following best describes Ahmed's position?
- He must pay the money to his client, because it belongs to the client and not to the firm.
- He may release the money, because an oral statement in court is not a formal undertaking.
- He may release the money if his client gives a written indemnity to the firm.
- He may release the money if he gives the other side seven days' notice first.
- He has given an undertaking to the court and must not release the money pending trial.Correct answer
A clear statement to the court that the firm will hold money and not release it, on which the court acts, is an undertaking given to the court. Paragraph 1.3 requires solicitors to perform their undertakings, and paragraph 2.5 requires them not to place themselves in contempt of court; breach of an undertaking to the court can be punished as contempt. Ahmed must keep the money in client account until the court orders otherwise or releases him, whatever his client now wants. Undertakings need not be in writing, an indemnity cannot authorise a breach, and notice to the other side cannot release an undertaking given to the court.
Law basis: Code of Conduct for Solicitors, RELs and RFLs, paras 1.3 and 2.5Question 12 · UndertakingsDraft, pending solicitor review
Ravi, a solicitor at Marsh LLP, gave an undertaking to another firm to deliver a signed deed of variation within 21 days. A week later, Ravi left Marsh LLP to join a firm abroad. The deed has not been sent, and Marsh LLP says the undertaking was Ravi's personal matter. Which of the following best describes the position?
- Only Ravi is bound, because the undertaking was given by him personally.
- The undertaking lapsed when Ravi left, because he can no longer perform it.
- Marsh LLP remains bound by the undertaking given by Ravi while he worked for it.Correct answer
- The undertaking binds Marsh LLP only if it was given on headed notepaper.
- The undertaking is suspended until the recipient obtains Ravi's new contact details.
An undertaking is a statement on which someone reasonably relies that 'you or your business' will do something. Ravi gave the undertaking in the course of his work for Marsh LLP, so the firm, as well as Ravi personally, is bound by it, and paragraph 1.3 of the Code requires it to be performed. The firm cannot avoid responsibility because the individual has left; firms should have systems for recording undertakings and ensuring they are honoured, whoever gave them. Undertakings do not lapse when the solicitor who gave them changes jobs, and there is no requirement for headed notepaper.
Law basis: Code of Conduct for Solicitors, RELs and RFLs, para 1.3; SRA Glossary, definition of 'undertaking'Question 13 · UndertakingsDraft, pending solicitor review
On exchange, Yvonne undertook to the seller's solicitor to send the £45,000 deposit by bank transfer that afternoon. Before she sends it, fraudsters hack her firm's email system and divert the money from client account to their own account. The deposit never reaches the seller's solicitor. Which of the following best describes Yvonne's position?
- She is released from the undertaking, because the money was stolen by criminals.
- She is released from the undertaking, because she took reasonable care with the funds.
- She is bound only to report the fraud to the police and to the seller's solicitor.
- She remains bound by the undertaking, and the firm must ensure the deposit is paid.Correct answer
- She is bound only if her firm's insurers agree to cover the loss caused by the fraud.
Paragraph 1.3 of the Code requires solicitors to perform their undertakings. An undertaking to pay money is not discharged because the money was lost through fraud, even where the solicitor was not at fault; Yvonne and her firm must ensure the deposit is paid, using the firm's own funds if necessary. The firm must also replace the money missing from client account promptly under rule 6.1 of the SRA Accounts Rules, and consider reporting obligations to the SRA under paragraph 7.7. Reporting the fraud to the police is appropriate, but it does not satisfy the undertaking. The firm's arrangements with its insurers do not affect its obligation to the recipient.
Law basis: Code of Conduct for Solicitors, RELs and RFLs, paras 1.3 and 7.7; SRA Accounts Rules 2019, rule 6.1Question 14 · UndertakingsDraft, pending solicitor review
Contracts for a house sale are exchanged by telephone using Law Society Formula B. The buyer's solicitor, Morgan, thereby undertakes to send the deposit to the seller's solicitor that day. Due to an oversight, Morgan does not send the deposit for six days. Which of the following best describes Morgan's position?
- He has not breached any undertaking, because the contract itself governs payment of the deposit.
- He has not breached any undertaking, provided the deposit arrived before the completion date.
- He breached an undertaking only if the seller suffered loss as a result of the delay.
- He has not breached any undertaking, because telephone exchanges involve no undertakings.
- He breached an undertaking given on exchange by failing to send the deposit that day.Correct answer
Exchange of contracts by telephone under the Law Society's formulae depends on undertakings between the solicitors. Under Formula B, the buyer's solicitor undertakes to send the deposit to the seller's solicitor on the day of exchange, and each solicitor undertakes to send the signed contract. Paragraph 1.3 of the Code requires undertakings to be performed within the agreed timescale. By failing to send the deposit that day, Morgan breached his undertaking, whatever the contractual position between the parties. Later receipt of the deposit does not undo the breach, and no loss is required for a regulatory breach. Telephone exchanges are binding precisely because of these undertakings.
Law basis: Code of Conduct for Solicitors, RELs and RFLs, para 1.3; Law Society Formulae for Exchanging Contracts by Telephone (Formula B)Question 15 · UndertakingsDraft, pending solicitor review
A solicitor tells the other side's solicitor in an email, 'We undertake to pay your costs of £2,000 on completion.' Completion then takes place but the firm does not pay. Which statement best describes the position?
- The undertaking is not binding, because it was given by email.
- The undertaking binds only the client, not the solicitor who gave it.
- The undertaking ends automatically when completion takes place.
- The undertaking is enforceable only if it is signed on paper.
- The solicitor must honour the undertaking, because a solicitor must perform undertakings given in the course of practice promptly, and the SRA can take action for breach.Correct answer
Solicitors must perform undertakings given in the course of practice and do so within an agreed time or, if none, a reasonable time. An undertaking can be given in any form, and breach is a conduct matter.
Law basis: SRA Code of Conduct for Solicitors, para 1.3More Ethics and Professional Conduct topics
Back to all Ethics and Professional Conduct questions, or sit a timed mock.