Three years ago a firm acted for Zenith Ltd on a long-term supply agreement and learned detailed information about Zenith's pricing and margins. Apex Ltd now asks the firm to sue Zenith for overcharging under a similar agreement. Zenith refuses to consent to the firm acting. Which of the following best describes whether the firm can act for Apex?
- Yes, because the duty of confidentiality owed to a former client comes to an end when the earlier retainer ends.
- Yes, provided that the partner who acted for Zenith takes no part in the new matter.
- No, because a firm can never act against a former client on any matter in any circumstances.
- Yes, because more than two years have passed since the firm last acted for Zenith.
- Only if effective measures mean there is no real risk of disclosing Zenith's confidential information.Correct answer
Paragraph 6.5 prohibits acting for a client whose interest is adverse to a former client where the firm holds confidential information material to the matter, unless effective measures result in there being no real risk of disclosure, or the former client gives informed consent, given or evidenced in writing. Zenith has refused consent, so the firm must show effective measures. Prince Jefri Bolkiah v KPMG places a heavy burden on the firm and indicates that ad hoc arrangements are rarely enough, so merely excluding one partner is unlikely to suffice. There is no absolute bar on acting against former clients and no time limit after which the duty lapses.
Law basis: Code of Conduct for Solicitors, RELs, RFLs and RSLs, para 6.5; Prince Jefri Bolkiah v KPMG [1999] 2 AC 222