Law covered in these questions
- Code of Conduct for Solicitors, RELs and RFLs, para 6.4(d)
- CPR 31.20
- Al Fayed v Commissioner of Police of the Metropolis [2002] EWCA Civ 780
- Code of Conduct for Solicitors, RELs and RFLs, para 6.4(c)
- Code of Conduct for Solicitors, RELs and RFLs, paras 6.3 and 6.4
- Code of Conduct for Solicitors, RELs and RFLs, para 6.4
- Code of Conduct for Solicitors, RELs and RFLs, para 6.4(b)
- Code of Conduct for Solicitors, RELs and RFLs, paras 3.1 and 6.4
- Code of Conduct for Solicitors, RELs and RFLs, para 6.4(a)
- Code of Conduct for Solicitors, RELs and RFLs, paras 1.4 and 6.4
- SRA Principles 2019, Principles 4 and 7
- SRA Principles 2019, Principles 5 and 7
All 10 questions with answers
Try them above first, then read the worked answers below.
Question 1 · Disclosure of material informationDraft, pending solicitor review
Imran acts for a claimant in a professional negligence claim. Opposing solicitors accidentally email him a copy of counsel's advice to their client on the weaknesses of their defence. It is obvious from the first page what the document is and that it was sent in error. Which of the following best describes Imran's position?
- He must tell his client its contents, because he must disclose all information material to the matter.
- He may use it freely, because sending it to him has waived privilege in the advice.
- He may keep and use it, provided he tells the other side that he has received a copy.
- He must forward it to his client and let the client decide whether it should be used.
- He need not tell his client its contents, and should notify the sender and return it.Correct answer
Paragraph 6.4 requires a solicitor to make the client aware of all material information, but paragraph 6.4(d) excepts information contained in a privileged document which the solicitor knows of only because it has been mistakenly disclosed. Where the mistake is obvious to a reasonable solicitor, the court may restrain use of the document, as recognised in Al Fayed v Commissioner of Police of the Metropolis, and acting with integrity requires Imran to notify the sender and return it. In litigation, CPR 31.20 also prevents use of inadvertently disclosed privileged material without the court's permission. Privilege is not waived merely because the document was sent by mistake.
Law basis: Code of Conduct for Solicitors, RELs and RFLs, para 6.4(d); CPR 31.20; Al Fayed v Commissioner of Police of the Metropolis [2002] EWCA Civ 780Question 2 · Disclosure of material informationDraft, pending solicitor review
Kirsty acts for Mr Evans in a clinical negligence claim. An expert's report she has obtained contains a prognosis that Mr Evans is unlikely to live more than a year. His treating psychiatrist writes to Kirsty saying that, given his fragile mental state, disclosing this to him now is likely to cause him serious psychological harm. Which of the following best describes Kirsty's duty?
- She must disclose the prognosis, because she must tell the client all information material to his claim.
- She need not disclose the prognosis if she has reason to believe it would cause serious mental injury.Correct answer
- She may withhold the prognosis only if Mr Evans gives informed consent in writing to not being told.
- She must disclose the prognosis to his family instead, so that they can decide what he should be told.
- She may withhold the prognosis only for as long as it takes to obtain a second expert's medical opinion.
Paragraph 6.4 requires a solicitor to make the client aware of all information material to the matter, subject to exceptions. Paragraph 6.4(c) applies where you have reason to believe that serious physical or mental injury will be caused to the client or another if the information is disclosed. The psychiatrist's letter gives Kirsty such reason, so she need not disclose the prognosis for the time being, although she should keep the position under review. Client consent under paragraph 6.4(b) is a separate exception. Disclosing to family members would breach confidentiality under paragraph 6.3, and there is no requirement to obtain a second opinion first.
Law basis: Code of Conduct for Solicitors, RELs and RFLs, para 6.4(c)Question 3 · Disclosure of material informationDraft, pending solicitor review
Lena acts for Mrs Abbott, who is buying a house on Orchard Road. Lena's colleague acts for a developer client which, in confidence, has just agreed to buy the field behind the house for a large housing estate. Mrs Abbott would be very concerned to know this. The developer will not consent to disclosure. Which of the following best describes the firm's position?
- It must tell Mrs Abbott, because the duty to disclose material information overrides confidentiality.
- It may continue to act for Mrs Abbott without telling her, because the information came from another client.
- It may continue provided Lena personally does not know the details of the developer's plans.
- It cannot tell Mrs Abbott and so cannot properly continue to act for her on the purchase.Correct answer
- It must tell Mrs Abbott, provided it does not reveal the identity of the developer client.
Paragraph 6.4 requires the firm to make Mrs Abbott aware of all information material to her matter of which it has knowledge, and the knowledge of one fee earner is treated as the firm's knowledge. Paragraph 6.3 requires the developer's affairs to be kept confidential. Where the duty of confidentiality to one client prevents the firm from disclosing material information to another, and none of the exceptions in paragraph 6.4 applies, the firm cannot properly act for Mrs Abbott. Disclosure without the developer's consent would breach paragraph 6.3, even if the developer is not named, because the information itself is confidential.
Law basis: Code of Conduct for Solicitors, RELs and RFLs, paras 6.3 and 6.4Question 4 · Disclosure of material informationDraft, pending solicitor review
Chloe acts for Mr Singh on the purchase of a house. At a barbecue, her neighbour, who lives on the same street as the property, mentions that the house flooded badly two winters ago. The seller's replies to enquiries say the property has never flooded. The information did not come from any client. Which of the following best describes Chloe's duty?
- She need not tell Mr Singh, because she learned the information socially and not in practice.
- She need not tell Mr Singh, because he is entitled to rely on the seller's replies to enquiries.
- She must tell Mr Singh only if he asks her a specific question about flooding.
- She must tell Mr Singh, as the duty covers material information however she learned it.Correct answer
- She must tell the seller's solicitor first so that the seller can correct the replies before exchange.
Paragraph 6.4 requires a solicitor acting for a client to make the client aware of all information material to the matter of which the solicitor has knowledge, subject to limited exceptions. The duty is not confined to information obtained in the course of practice. Previous flooding is plainly material to a buyer, and none of the exceptions applies: the information is not confidential to another client, there is no legal restriction, and there is no risk of serious injury. Chloe should tell Mr Singh, who may then raise further enquiries and consider insurance and surveys. Reliance on the seller's replies may give a remedy, but it does not displace her duty.
Law basis: Code of Conduct for Solicitors, RELs and RFLs, para 6.4Question 5 · Disclosure of material informationDraft, pending solicitor review
Rafael acts for a property investment company on the purchase of a portfolio of 40 shops. The company's in-house counsel emails him: 'We have no interest in minor title points such as rights of way for drains. Please don't report them; just deal with them.' Rafael identifies several such points. Which of the following best describes Rafael's duty?
- He must report every title point, because the duty to disclose material information cannot be waived.
- He need not report those points, as the client has given informed written consent to not being told.Correct answer
- He need not report them, because minor title points are never material to a commercial purchase.
- He must report them unless the client's board passes a resolution confirming that it does not wish to know.
- He need not report them, because in-house counsel is a lawyer and can assess their importance alone.
Paragraph 6.4 requires solicitors to make clients aware of all information material to the matter, but paragraph 6.4(b) excepts information where the client gives informed consent, given or evidenced in writing, to its not being disclosed. The in-house counsel's email is written consent from a person authorised to instruct the company, and it is informed because it identifies the type of information concerned. Rafael may therefore deal with the minor points without reporting each one, but he must still report anything outside the scope of the consent, such as a serious title defect. No board resolution is needed, and materiality does not depend on the client being a lawyer.
Law basis: Code of Conduct for Solicitors, RELs and RFLs, para 6.4(b)Question 6 · Disclosure of material informationDraft, pending solicitor review
Alfie acts for Mrs Short in a dispute with her builder. Early on, she said she would 'never accept less than £50,000'. The builder's solicitors now make a written offer of £35,000. Alfie thinks it is too low and, knowing her view, rejects it without telling her. Which of the following best describes Alfie's conduct?
- He acted properly, because the offer was below the minimum figure Mrs Short had stated.
- He should have told Mrs Short about the offer and taken her instructions on it.Correct answer
- He acted properly, because rejecting low offers is within a solicitor's implied authority.
- He acted properly, provided he tells Mrs Short about the offer if the case does not settle.
- He acted properly, because he believed rejecting the offer was in Mrs Short's best interests.
Paragraph 6.4 requires a solicitor to make the client aware of all information material to the matter, and a settlement offer is plainly material. Paragraph 3.1 requires him to act on the client's instructions, and decisions on settlement are for the client. Mrs Short's earlier statement about her minimum figure does not authorise Alfie to reject future offers without consulting her; her view may have changed, and offers can have costs consequences. He should have reported the offer promptly with his advice and taken her instructions. His belief that rejection was in her best interests does not entitle him to take the decision himself.
Law basis: Code of Conduct for Solicitors, RELs and RFLs, paras 3.1 and 6.4Question 7 · Disclosure of material informationDraft, pending solicitor review
Mona acts for Mr Gill in a commercial lease matter. Her firm is served with a court order requiring it to produce information about Mr Gill's client account transactions to an investigating authority, which contains a prohibition on telling Mr Gill about the order. Which of the following best describes Mona's duty to tell Mr Gill?
- She must tell him, because she must make her client aware of all material information.
- She may tell him, provided she does not reveal the name of the investigating authority to him.
- She must not tell him, as the duty to disclose does not apply where the law prohibits it.Correct answer
- She must tell him once the firm has produced the information required by the order.
- She may tell him if he gives his informed consent in writing to being told about it.
Paragraph 6.4 of the Code requires solicitors to make clients aware of all material information, but paragraph 6.4(a) provides an exception where disclosure is prohibited by legal restrictions imposed in the interests of national security or the prevention of crime. A court order containing a prohibition on disclosure is such a restriction, so Mona must not tell Mr Gill, either before or after producing the information, unless the restriction is lifted. Disclosing the order could also amount to contempt of court or an offence of prejudicing an investigation. Concealing the authority's identity would not avoid the prohibition, and client consent cannot override a legal restriction.
Law basis: Code of Conduct for Solicitors, RELs and RFLs, para 6.4(a)Question 8 · Disclosure of material informationDraft, pending solicitor review
Gemma acts for Mr Hale in contact proceedings concerning his children. The court bundle includes the address of a refuge where his former partner and the children are living, which the court has not ordered to be withheld. Gemma has good reason to believe, from police reports, that if Mr Hale learns the address he will seriously assault his former partner. Which of the following best describes Gemma's position?
- She need not disclose the address if she reasonably believes serious injury to another will result.Correct answer
- She must disclose the address, because all information in the court bundle is treated as material to Mr Hale.
- She must disclose the address, because the court has not ordered that it be withheld from him.
- She may withhold the address only if Mr Hale gives informed consent in writing to not being told.
- She must cease acting immediately without giving Mr Hale any further information about the case.
Paragraph 6.4 requires a solicitor to make the client aware of all information material to the matter, but paragraph 6.4(c) provides an exception where the solicitor has reason to believe that serious physical or mental injury will be caused to the client or another if the information is disclosed. Police reports indicating a risk of serious assault give Gemma such a reason, so she need not disclose the refuge address to Mr Hale. She should also consider raising the issue with the court so that the address can be protected. Client consent under paragraph 6.4(b) is a different exception and is not required here, and she need not cease acting.
Law basis: Code of Conduct for Solicitors, RELs and RFLs, para 6.4(c)Question 9 · Disclosure of material informationDraft, pending solicitor review
Tobias acts for Ms Grey in a claim against her former business partner. Counsel's written opinion concludes that her claim has less than a 30% chance of success. Tobias fears Ms Grey will move to another firm if she sees it, so he tells her only that counsel 'sees some difficulties but thinks the case is worth pursuing'. Which of the following best describes Tobias's conduct?
- He has acted properly, because a solicitor may summarise counsel's advice in his own words.
- He has acted properly, provided he sends her the opinion once the case has concluded.
- He has acted properly, because counsel's opinion is privileged and need not be shown to her.
- He has acted improperly only if Ms Grey loses the case and incurs adverse costs.
- He has failed to give her material information and has misled her about counsel's view.Correct answer
Paragraph 6.4 requires solicitors to make clients aware of all information material to the matter, and paragraph 1.4 prohibits misleading clients. Counsel's view that the claim has under a 30% chance of success is highly material to Ms Grey's decision whether to continue and incur costs. Describing it as worth pursuing misrepresents the advice, and Tobias's motive of keeping the client also suggests his own interests are affecting his conduct, contrary to Principle 7. Summarising advice is fine if accurate, but this summary is not. Privilege protects the opinion from the other side, not from the client, and the breach does not depend on the outcome.
Law basis: Code of Conduct for Solicitors, RELs and RFLs, paras 1.4 and 6.4; SRA Principles 2019, Principles 4 and 7Question 10 · Disclosure of material informationDraft, pending solicitor review
Imogen is a non-executive director of Pellow plc. Through board meetings she learns, in confidence, that Pellow will soon close a factory next to land her client, Mr Ross, is about to buy for housing. The closure would significantly increase the land's value. Pellow is not her firm's client. Which of the following best describes Imogen's position?
- She must tell Mr Ross, because the duty to disclose material information overrides all other duties.
- She cannot use or disclose Pellow's confidential information, so she should not continue to act.Correct answer
- She may tell Mr Ross, because the Code's confidentiality duty protects only the firm's own clients.
- She may continue to act without telling Mr Ross, because the information came from outside her practice.
- She must tell Mr Ross, provided she does not reveal that the information came from Pellow's board.
Paragraph 6.4 requires Imogen to make Mr Ross aware of information material to his matter of which she has knowledge, but she also owes Pellow duties of confidentiality as a director, and disclosing board information could breach those duties and potentially insider dealing law. Where a solicitor cannot comply with paragraph 6.4 because of a legal duty of confidentiality owed elsewhere, and no exception applies, she should not continue to act, because she cannot give her client full disclosure. Continuing in silence would leave her acting with material information she is withholding. Disguising the source would not avoid breaching her duties to Pellow.
Law basis: Code of Conduct for Solicitors, RELs and RFLs, para 6.4; SRA Principles 2019, Principles 5 and 7More Ethics and Professional Conduct topics
Back to all Ethics and Professional Conduct questions, or sit a timed mock.