Law covered in these questions
- SRA Principles 2019, Principle 2
- SRA Principles 2019, Principles 1, 2, 4 and 7
- Code of Conduct for Solicitors, RELs and RFLs, para 1.4
- SRA Principles 2019, Principles 2, 5 and 6
- Beckwith v SRA [2020] EWHC 3231 (Admin)
- SRA Principles 2019, Principles 3 and 7
- Code of Conduct for Solicitors, RELs and RFLs, para 5.1
- SRA Principles 2019, Principles 1, 2 and 5
- Code of Conduct for Solicitors, RELs and RFLs, para 2.1
- SRA Principles 2019, Principles 2 and 5
- Code of Conduct for Solicitors, RELs and RFLs, paras 1.2 and 1.4
- SRA Principles 2019, Principle 7
- Code of Conduct for Solicitors, RELs and RFLs, paras 3.1 and 3.4
- Code of Conduct for Solicitors, RELs and RFLs, paras 3.1 and 6.4
All 17 questions with answers
Try them above first, then read the worked answers below.
Question 1 · SRA PrinciplesDraft, pending solicitor review
A solicitor drives home after drinking, is convicted of drink-driving and does not tell the SRA. Which Principle is most directly engaged by the conviction itself?
- Encouraging equality, diversity and inclusion within the firm.
- Providing a proper standard of service to the clients.
- Acting in the best interests of each client in every case.
- Acting with honesty only where the client is aware.
- Acting in a way that upholds public trust and confidence in the solicitors' profession and in legal services provided by authorised persons.Correct answer
The SRA Principles include acting in a way that upholds public trust and confidence in the profession. Conduct outside practice can engage this Principle if it undermines trust.
Law basis: SRA Principles 2019, Principle 2Question 2 · SRA PrinciplesDraft, pending solicitor review
Priya, a solicitor, acts for Dev in a boundary dispute. At a hearing next week Dev wants Priya to tell the court that a surveyor's report supports his case, although Priya has read it and knows it does not. Dev says that his interests must come first. Which of the following best describes how Priya should resolve this?
- Acting in Dev's best interests prevails, because the Principles rank the client's interests first.
- She may comply if Dev confirms the instruction in writing and accepts responsibility for it.
- The Principles protecting the administration of justice and public trust prevail, so she must refuse.Correct answer
- She may comply provided she does not personally sign or file any document that contains the statement.
- All seven Principles carry equal weight, so she must balance them and use her own judgement.
The SRA Principles state that where they come into conflict, those which safeguard the wider public interest, such as upholding the proper administration of justice (Principle 1) and public trust and confidence in the profession (Principle 2), take precedence over an individual client's interests (Principle 7). Telling the court the report supports Dev would also mislead the court, contrary to paragraph 1.4 of the Code and the duty of honesty in Principle 4. Written instructions or avoiding a signature make no difference, because the duty is Priya's own. The 'equal weight' option is tempting, but the Principles expressly give priority to the public interest where they conflict.
Law basis: SRA Principles 2019, Principles 1, 2, 4 and 7; Code of Conduct for Solicitors, RELs and RFLs, para 1.4Question 3 · SRA PrinciplesDraft, pending solicitor review
Tom, a solicitor in a regional firm, posts a series of grossly offensive comments about a religious group on his personal social media account in the evenings. The posts make no reference to his firm or his work. A member of the public sends screenshots to the SRA. Which of the following best describes Tom's regulatory position?
- The SRA has no jurisdiction, because the Principles apply only to conduct in the course of legal practice.
- His posts can engage the Principles, notably public trust and integrity, despite being made outside practice.Correct answer
- Only the Code of Conduct can apply, and it governs only a solicitor's dealings with his own clients.
- He can be investigated only if a client of his firm, rather than a member of the public, complains about the posts.
- He is at regulatory risk only if the posts lead to a criminal conviction which he fails to report.
The SRA regulates conduct outside practice where it realistically touches on the solicitor's fitness to practise or public confidence in the profession. Beckwith v SRA confirmed that private conduct can fall within regulation where it engages the standards expected of a solicitor, and the SRA's guidance on offensive communications treats such posts as capable of breaching Principle 2 (public trust) and Principle 5 (integrity), as well as being inconsistent with Principle 6. There is no requirement for a client complaint or a conviction. The tempting view that the Principles stop at the office door is wrong: they can apply to private conduct which reflects on the profession.
Law basis: SRA Principles 2019, Principles 2, 5 and 6; Beckwith v SRA [2020] EWHC 3231 (Admin)Question 4 · SRA PrinciplesDraft, pending solicitor review
Hannah, a conveyancing solicitor, receives most of her work from Castle Estates, a local estate agency. Castle's director tells her that her detailed reports on search results are 'scaring buyers off' and that referrals will stop unless she keeps her advice to buyers brief and positive. Which of the following best describes Hannah's position?
- She may shorten her advice, because the agent's referrals are vital to the continued viability of her practice.
- She may shorten her advice provided each buyer agrees to receive only a summary report on searches.
- She may follow the agent's wishes, because the duty of independence is owed only to the court and not to clients.
- She must continue to advise each buyer fully, as she must not let the agent compromise her independence.Correct answer
- She must stop accepting referrals from the agent, because any referral arrangement compromises independence.
Principle 3 requires solicitors to act with independence, and Principle 7 requires them to act in the best interests of each client. A referrer's commercial pressure must not affect the advice given to clients; the Code also requires that introducers do not influence how the solicitor acts. Hannah must therefore continue to give each buyer full and proper advice about search results. The financial importance of the referrals is no justification. Referral arrangements are not prohibited as such, provided the Code's requirements are met, so ending all referrals is not required, although Hannah may decide the relationship is untenable if the pressure continues.
Law basis: SRA Principles 2019, Principles 3 and 7; Code of Conduct for Solicitors, RELs and RFLs, para 5.1Question 5 · SRA PrinciplesDraft, pending solicitor review
Eleni is an in-house solicitor employed by a logistics company. After a serious workplace accident, the operations director tells her to arrange for internal safety reports to be shredded before the Health and Safety Executive and the injured worker's solicitors ask for them. Which of the following best describes Eleni's position?
- She may comply, because her employer is her only client and she must act in its best interests.
- She may comply provided the reports are destroyed before any legal proceedings are actually issued.
- She must refuse, as in-house solicitors are bound by the same Principles as those in private practice.Correct answer
- She may comply, because the Code of Conduct applies only to solicitors who provide services to the public.
- She must comply if instructed by a director, but should record her objection in writing on the file.
In-house solicitors are subject to the SRA Principles and the Code in the same way as solicitors in private practice, save for limited provisions such as those in section 8 that apply only to services to the public. Destroying documents that are likely to be relevant to an investigation or claim would breach Principle 1 (upholding the rule of law and the proper administration of justice) and paragraph 2.1, which prohibits misusing or tampering with evidence. Where the Principles conflict, the public interest prevails over the employer's interests. Destruction before proceedings are issued is still tampering with evidence, and recording an objection does not excuse taking part.
Law basis: SRA Principles 2019, Principles 1, 2 and 5; Code of Conduct for Solicitors, RELs and RFLs, para 2.1Question 6 · SRA PrinciplesDraft, pending solicitor review
Marco, a partner in a litigation firm, is in a personal dispute with his neighbour about overhanging trees. He writes to the neighbour on firm letterhead, signed as 'Senior Partner', threatening 'proceedings in the High Court with costs running into tens of thousands' unless the trees are cut back within 48 hours. Which of the following best describes Marco's conduct?
- It is a private matter, so the Principles do not apply to his correspondence with the neighbour.
- It is acceptable, because a solicitor is entitled to use his own firm's resources for his own affairs.
- It is improper only if the High Court would in fact have no jurisdiction to hear the neighbour dispute.
- Using his professional status to intimidate in a private matter may breach the Principles.Correct answer
- It is acceptable provided he does not charge the cost of writing the letter to any client account.
Solicitors may act in their own affairs, but using firm letterhead and status to make exaggerated threats against a lay person in a private dispute can take unfair advantage of that person, contrary to paragraph 1.2, and can undermine public trust in the profession under Principle 2 and integrity under Principle 5. A claim about overhanging trees would not realistically be brought in the High Court with costs of that scale, so the threat is also misleading. The conduct is regulated because Marco is using his position as a solicitor. Whether he charges anyone for the letter is irrelevant to the breach.
Law basis: SRA Principles 2019, Principles 2 and 5; Code of Conduct for Solicitors, RELs and RFLs, paras 1.2 and 1.4Question 7 · SRA PrinciplesDraft, pending solicitor review
Joanna acts for Mrs Clay in a claim against her former landlord. Joanna considers the claim worth about £30,000. The landlord offers £12,000 in full settlement. Mrs Clay, who is tired of the dispute, wants to accept despite Joanna's advice. Which of the following best describes Joanna's position?
- Joanna must refuse to accept the offer, because acting in Mrs Clay's best interests overrides her wishes.
- Joanna may delay accepting until Mrs Clay has had time to reconsider, whatever her instructions say.
- Joanna must cease acting, because a client who rejects her solicitor's advice has ended the retainer.
- Joanna may accept only if a second fee earner agrees that the offer is within a reasonable range.
- After advising her clearly on the risks, Joanna should accept the offer on her instructions.Correct answer
Principle 7 requires a solicitor to act in the best interests of each client, but that does not mean overriding a competent client's informed decision. Joanna's duty is to give clear advice on the value of the claim and the consequences of accepting, and to make sure Mrs Clay understands it, taking account of her circumstances under paragraph 3.4. The decision whether to settle belongs to the client, and paragraph 3.1 requires Joanna to act on her instructions. Delaying in defiance of instructions would itself be improper. It is sensible to record the advice and instructions in writing, but there is no requirement for a second opinion.
Law basis: SRA Principles 2019, Principle 7; Code of Conduct for Solicitors, RELs and RFLs, paras 3.1 and 3.4Question 8 · SRA PrinciplesDraft, pending solicitor review
Yusuf acts for a claimant in a commercial dispute funded by a third-party litigation funder. The funder's representative emails Yusuf instructing him to reject a reasonable settlement offer because it would reduce the funder's return, and tells him not to discuss the offer with the client until the funder has 'decided strategy'. Which of the following best describes Yusuf's position?
- He must follow the funder's instructions, because the funder is paying for the litigation.
- He must tell the client about the offer and act on the client's instructions, not the funder's.Correct answer
- He may reject the offer if the funding agreement gives the funder contractual control over any settlement.
- He may delay telling the client until the funder has decided its preferred strategy.
- He must refer the offer to the court for approval, because a funder is involved in the claim.
Principle 3 requires Yusuf to act with independence, and Principle 7 requires him to act in the client's best interests. Under paragraph 3.1 he acts on the client's instructions, and under paragraph 6.4 he must make the client aware of material information such as a settlement offer. A funder may have contractual rights against the client, but it is not Yusuf's client and cannot direct him to withhold information or reject an offer. He should advise the client on the offer and on any relevant terms of the funding agreement. There is no general requirement for court approval of settlements in funded commercial claims.
Law basis: SRA Principles 2019, Principles 3 and 7; Code of Conduct for Solicitors, RELs and RFLs, paras 3.1 and 6.4Question 9 · SRA PrinciplesDraft, pending solicitor review
Mr Dale is being sued by a former business partner for £300,000 and expects to lose. He asks his solicitor, Grace, to arrange for his house and savings to be transferred to his adult daughter for nothing before judgment, 'so that there is nothing left to take'. Which of the following best describes Grace's position?
- She must not assist with transfers designed to defeat the claimant's legitimate claim.Correct answer
- She may assist, because a client is entitled to deal with his own property as he chooses.
- She may assist, provided the transfers are completed before any judgment is entered against him.
- She may assist, provided the daughter takes separate independent advice on the transfers.
- She may assist, but must first tell the claimant's solicitors about the proposed transfers.
Principle 1 requires solicitors to uphold the rule of law and the proper administration of justice, and Principle 5 requires integrity. Transferring assets at an undervalue to put them beyond the reach of a claimant is the kind of transaction which section 423 of the Insolvency Act 1986 allows the court to set aside, and helping a client to defeat a judgment creditor would undermine the administration of justice. Grace must refuse to assist and explain why. The timing of the transfers before judgment does not make them legitimate, and independent advice for the daughter does not address the purpose. Grace must not disclose the plan to the claimant without consent, as it is confidential under paragraph 6.3.
Law basis: SRA Principles 2019, Principles 1 and 5; Insolvency Act 1986, s 423Question 10 · SRA PrinciplesDraft, pending solicitor review
Kieran, a compliance partner, signs his firm's annual declaration to a lender panel confirming that all staff have completed anti-fraud training. He has not checked the records and assumes the training happened. In fact half the staff have not done it. He did not intend to deceive anyone. Which of the following best describes Kieran's position?
- He has not breached the Principles, because he did not intend to deceive the lender.
- He has breached the Principles only if the lender suffers loss as a result of a fraud.
- He has acted dishonestly, because any inaccurate statement to a third party is dishonest.
- He has not breached the Principles, because training is the responsibility of each fee earner.
- He may have failed to act with integrity, even if he was not dishonest.Correct answer
Principle 5 requires solicitors to act with integrity, which in Wingate v SRA and SRA v Malins the Court of Appeal described as adherence to the ethical standards of the profession, a broader concept than honesty. A solicitor who signs a formal confirmation to a third party without any basis for believing it to be true, recklessly disregarding whether it is accurate, may lack integrity even though he did not intend to deceive and so was not dishonest. An inaccurate statement is not automatically dishonest, since dishonesty depends on Kieran's state of mind under Ivey v Genting Casinos. No loss is required. As the person signing, Kieran cannot shift responsibility to fee earners.
Law basis: SRA Principles 2019, Principles 4 and 5; Wingate v SRA; SRA v Malins [2018] EWCA Civ 366Question 11 · SRA PrinciplesDraft, pending solicitor review
After losing a hearing, Desmond, a solicitor-advocate, posts on social media under his own name that the district judge 'is clearly in the pocket of the local council and should be investigated for corruption'. He has no evidence of any wrongdoing beyond his disagreement with the ruling. Which of the following best describes Desmond's conduct?
- Unfounded allegations of judicial corruption may breach the Principles on justice and public trust.Correct answer
- It is acceptable, because solicitors have exactly the same right to free expression as any other citizen.
- It is acceptable, provided Desmond's client has instructed him to appeal against the decision.
- It is improper only if Desmond made the post during working hours or using the firm's account.
- It is acceptable, because criticism of judges is permitted once a hearing has finished.
Solicitors may legitimately criticise judicial decisions, including through appeals and reasoned public comment. However, publicly accusing a judge of corruption without any evidence risks undermining public confidence in the administration of justice, contrary to Principle 1, and in the profession, contrary to Principle 2, and may lack integrity under Principle 5. The SRA's guidance on offensive communications and social media makes clear that personal accounts are not outside regulation where the conduct reflects on the solicitor's professional role. Freedom of expression is relevant but does not protect baseless allegations of criminality. Whether the post was made at work, or whether an appeal is planned, does not change its nature.
Law basis: SRA Principles 2019, Principles 1, 2 and 5Question 12 · SRA PrinciplesDraft, pending solicitor review
Mr Hurst is in a heated dispute with a contractor. He instructs his solicitor, Annika, to send the contractor a letter calling him 'a lying cowboy and a disgrace to his trade' and warning that Mr Hurst will 'make sure everyone in town knows what he is'. Which of the following best describes Annika's position?
- She must send the letter, because she must act on her client's instructions in his best interests.
- She should not send a letter in those terms, even though her client has instructed her to.Correct answer
- She may send it, provided the letter is marked 'without prejudice' and 'private and confidential'.
- She may send it, because strong language in correspondence is a matter of style, not regulation.
- She may send it, provided Mr Hurst signs it himself and it is sent on plain paper.
Principle 7 requires solicitors to act in clients' best interests, but where the Principles conflict, the public interest takes precedence. Sending abusive, offensive or threatening correspondence can undermine public trust in the profession under Principle 2 and show a lack of integrity under Principle 5, and the SRA has warned against offensive communications. A threat to damage the contractor's reputation may also take unfair advantage of him under paragraph 1.2. Annika should explain this to Mr Hurst and offer to send a firm but professional letter setting out his complaints. A 'without prejudice' label does not make offensive content acceptable, and arranging for the client to send it under her direction does not avoid her responsibility.
Law basis: SRA Principles 2019, Principles 2, 5 and 7; Code of Conduct for Solicitors, RELs and RFLs, para 1.2Question 13 · SRA PrinciplesDraft, pending solicitor review
Mrs Moss consults Theo about suing a garage for £4,000 over faulty repairs to her car. Theo agrees to act at his standard hourly rate of £250 without asking whether she has legal expenses insurance with her motor or home policy, or discussing any other way of funding the claim. Which of the following best describes Theo's approach?
- He acted properly, because a client who wants a solicitor at a particular rate may agree to it.
- He acted properly, because funding is the client's responsibility and not part of the advice.
- He acted properly, provided he warns her if the costs come to exceed the value of the claim.
- He acted improperly only if the garage would have been ordered to pay all of her costs.
- He should have considered with her how the claim could best be funded before agreeing terms.Correct answer
Acting in a client's best interests under Principle 7, and giving her the information she needs to make informed decisions under paragraphs 8.6 and 8.7, includes discussing how a matter will be funded and whether it is worth pursuing at the likely cost. For a £4,000 claim, which would normally be allocated to the small claims track where costs recovery is very limited, Theo should have asked about legal expenses insurance and explained the likely overall cost relative to the value of the claim. Warning her later about costs exceeding the claim is not a substitute for proper advice at the outset. Funding is part of the advice a client needs, not simply her own concern.
Law basis: SRA Principles 2019, Principle 7; Code of Conduct for Solicitors, RELs and RFLs, paras 8.6 and 8.7Question 14 · SRA PrinciplesDraft, pending solicitor review
Patrick, a solicitor working full-time in a law firm, is also the sole director of a lettings company he owns, which is unconnected with his legal practice. The company routinely tells tenants that their deposits have been protected in a government scheme when they have not been. Which of the following best describes Patrick's regulatory position?
- The SRA has no jurisdiction, because the lettings company is not a regulated legal business.
- Only the company can be held responsible, because it is a separate legal person distinct from Patrick himself.
- His conduct through the company can engage the Principles of honesty, integrity and public trust.Correct answer
- He can be investigated only if one of the tenants is also a client of his law firm.
- He is at regulatory risk only if the tenants obtain court judgments against the company.
The SRA Principles are not confined to the provision of legal services. Conduct outside practice can engage them where it reflects on a solicitor's honesty, integrity or fitness to practise. Repeatedly telling tenants that their deposits are protected when they are not is dishonest conduct for which Patrick, as sole director, is responsible, and it is likely to breach Principle 4 (honesty), Principle 5 (integrity) and Principle 2 (public trust). Running the business through a company does not shield him from regulatory consequences for his own conduct. There is no need for any tenant to be a client, or for a court judgment, before the SRA can act.
Law basis: SRA Principles 2019, Principles 2, 4 and 5Question 15 · SRA PrinciplesDraft, pending solicitor review
Gabriel acts for a local authority in negotiating a major regeneration contract with a developer. During the negotiations, the developer's managing director offers Gabriel two weeks in his villa in Portugal, free of charge, 'as a friend'. The negotiations are at a sensitive stage. Which of the following best describes how Gabriel should respond?
- He may accept, because the offer is a personal gift and is not connected with his legal work.
- He should decline, as accepting could compromise his independence and might be treated as a bribe.Correct answer
- He may accept, provided he declares the gift to his firm's managing partner after he returns.
- He may accept, provided the holiday is taken after the regeneration contract has been signed.
- He may accept, because gifts from the other side are relevant only if he acts for an individual client.
Principle 3 requires solicitors to act with independence, and Principle 5 requires integrity. Accepting a valuable benefit from the opposing party during sensitive negotiations would create a real risk, and at least the appearance, that Gabriel's advice to his client is influenced, and it is contrary to his client's best interests under Principle 7. Depending on the circumstances, offering or accepting such an advantage intended to induce improper performance could also amount to an offence under the Bribery Act 2010. Gabriel should decline and tell his client about the offer. Deferring the holiday until after signing, or declaring it later, would not remove the problem.
Law basis: SRA Principles 2019, Principles 3, 5 and 7; Bribery Act 2010, ss 1 and 2Question 16 · SRA PrinciplesDraft, pending solicitor review
Ivan acts for Ms Cross under a conditional fee agreement in a personal injury claim. The defendant makes an offer which Ivan privately thinks undervalues the claim, but accepting it would guarantee his firm's base costs and success fee, whereas going to trial carries a risk that the firm recovers nothing. Which of the following best describes Ivan's duty when advising on the offer?
- He may recommend acceptance, because a CFA gives the firm a legitimate interest in the result.
- He may recommend acceptance, provided he tells Ms Cross that the firm's fees would then be secure.
- He must recommend going to trial, because he believes the offer undervalues the claim.
- He may decide whether to accept the offer, because the CFA gives him authority over settlement.
- His advice must reflect Ms Cross's best interests, not the firm's interest in securing its fees.Correct answer
Principle 7 requires solicitors to act in each client's best interests, and Principle 3 requires independence. A conditional fee agreement gives the firm a financial interest in the outcome, but that interest must not influence the advice given; if it does, an own interest conflict can arise under paragraph 6.1. Ivan must give Ms Cross his honest assessment of the offer, including his view that it undervalues the claim, together with the risks of going to trial, and leave the decision to her under paragraph 3.1. He should not simply recommend trial either, because the risks are relevant, and the CFA does not give him authority to settle.
Law basis: SRA Principles 2019, Principles 3 and 7; Code of Conduct for Solicitors, RELs and RFLs, paras 3.1 and 6.1Question 17 · SRA PrinciplesDraft, pending solicitor review
Ms Rahman, a self-employed consultant, asks her solicitor, Grant, for help. She wants to know how to reduce the tax on her income and also asks him to help her route payments through a relative's account so that HMRC will not see some of her invoices. Which of the following best describes Grant's position?
- He must refuse all tax advice, because she has disclosed an intention to evade tax.
- He may assist with both, because tax matters are a private issue between the client and HMRC.
- He may advise on lawful ways to reduce tax but must not help her hide income from HMRC.Correct answer
- He may help route the payments, provided he does not prepare any of her tax returns himself.
- He must report her to HMRC immediately, whether or not he continues to act for her.
Principle 1 requires solicitors to uphold the rule of law, and Principle 5 requires integrity. Advising a client on lawful tax planning is a legitimate legal service, but helping her conceal income from HMRC would facilitate tax evasion, a criminal offence, and could involve Grant in money laundering offences under the Proceeds of Crime Act 2002. He should explain the difference, refuse to assist with the concealment and consider his position, including whether he can continue to act and whether a report is required. He need not refuse all tax advice. Reporting directly to HMRC without regard to confidentiality and the money laundering reporting regime would not be the correct approach.
Law basis: SRA Principles 2019, Principles 1 and 5; Proceeds of Crime Act 2002, ss 327 to 330More Ethics and Professional Conduct topics
Back to all Ethics and Professional Conduct questions, or sit a timed mock.