Law covered in these questions
- Proceeds of Crime Act 2002, s 333A
- Code of Conduct for Solicitors, RELs and RFLs, para 6.4(a)
- Proceeds of Crime Act 2002, s 328
- Bowman v Fels [2005] EWCA Civ 226
- Money Laundering, Terrorist Financing and Transfer of Funds (Information on the Payer) Regulations 2017, regs 28 and 31
- Proceeds of Crime Act 2002, s 330
- Proceeds of Crime Act 2002, s 330(6), (10) and (11)
- Proceeds of Crime Act 2002, ss 328, 333A and 335
- Money Laundering, Terrorist Financing and Transfer of Funds (Information on the Payer) Regulations 2017, regs 28 and 33
- Proceeds of Crime Act 2002, ss 330 and 333A
- Proceeds of Crime Act 2002, ss 333A and 333D(2)
All 8 questions with answers
Try them above first, then read the worked answers below.
Question 1 · Money laundering and confidentialityDraft, pending solicitor review
Grace, a conveyancing solicitor, became suspicious about the source of the deposit funds of her client, Felix, and reported to her firm's money laundering reporting officer, who then made a suspicious activity report to the National Crime Agency. Felix rings to ask why completion has been delayed. Which of the following best describes Grace's position?
- She must tell Felix, because she is under a duty to keep her client informed of all material information.
- She must not tell Felix that a report has been made, as this risks committing the offence of tipping off.Correct answer
- She may tell Felix provided she confirms the position in writing and keeps a copy on the file.
- She may tell Felix, because legal professional privilege overrides the offence of tipping off.
- She may tell Felix once the National Crime Agency has acknowledged receipt of the report.
Section 333A of the Proceeds of Crime Act 2002 makes it an offence, in the regulated sector, to disclose that a suspicious activity report has been made where the disclosure is likely to prejudice any resulting investigation. Grace must therefore avoid revealing the report when explaining the delay. Paragraph 6.4(a) of the Code recognises this, as the duty to tell clients all material information does not apply where disclosure is prohibited by legal restrictions in the interests of the prevention of crime. Legal professional privilege does not provide a general defence, and acknowledgement of the report by the National Crime Agency does not lift the prohibition.
Law basis: Proceeds of Crime Act 2002, s 333A; Code of Conduct for Solicitors, RELs and RFLs, para 6.4(a) ↗Question 2 · Money laundering and confidentialityDraft, pending solicitor review
Pieter acts for the claimant in a commercial debt claim. During settlement negotiations he comes to suspect that some of the money the defendant will use to pay the agreed settlement is the proceeds of the defendant's tax evasion. His client is not involved in any wrongdoing. Which of the following best describes Pieter's position under section 328 of the Proceeds of Crime Act 2002?
- He commits an offence if he negotiates the settlement without first obtaining consent from the National Crime Agency.
- He must stop acting for the claimant, because accepting suspected criminal property is always an offence.
- He commits an offence unless the settlement agreement is approved by the court before payment is made.
- He may continue only if his client agrees to pay the settlement sum into court rather than accept it directly.
- Negotiating a consensual settlement in ordinary litigation is not entering into a prohibited arrangement.Correct answer
Section 328 of the Proceeds of Crime Act 2002 makes it an offence to enter into or become concerned in an arrangement which facilitates the acquisition, retention, use or control of criminal property. In Bowman v Fels the Court of Appeal held that section 328 is not intended to cover the ordinary conduct of litigation by legal professionals, including the consensual resolution of issues in a litigious context. Pieter therefore does not need NCA consent to negotiate the settlement. He must still take care not to become involved in a sham or in arrangements outside ordinary litigation, and must remember the separate rules on tipping off.
Law basis: Proceeds of Crime Act 2002, s 328; Bowman v Fels [2005] EWCA Civ 226 ↗Question 3 · Money laundering and confidentialityDraft, pending solicitor review
Mr Lorne, a new client, instructs Chen to act on his £2.1 million cash purchase of a London flat. He wants to exchange within a week and refuses to provide identification or explain the source of the funds, saying his previous solicitors never asked for such things. Which of the following best describes Chen's position?
- She may proceed, provided the purchase money comes from a UK bank account in his name.
- She may proceed and complete due diligence after exchange, given the client's urgency.
- She may proceed, because a solicitor need only verify identity if a mortgage is involved.
- She may proceed if a partner at the firm accepts responsibility for the client's identity.
- She must not proceed with the transaction unless customer due diligence can be completed.Correct answer
Under the Money Laundering Regulations 2017, a solicitor acting in a property transaction is in the regulated sector and must apply customer due diligence measures, including identifying and verifying the client and, where appropriate, understanding the source of funds. Regulation 31 provides that where a relevant person is unable to apply customer due diligence measures, it must not carry out a transaction through a bank account with the customer or on its behalf, must not establish a business relationship or carry out the transaction, and must terminate any existing relationship. Chen must also consider whether a suspicious activity report is required. Urgency does not permit deferring due diligence in these circumstances.
Law basis: Money Laundering, Terrorist Financing and Transfer of Funds (Information on the Payer) Regulations 2017, regs 28 and 31 ↗Question 4 · Money laundering and confidentialityDraft, pending solicitor review
Nora acts on a property purchase for a client who pays the £600,000 price in instalments from six different overseas companies, then asks for any surplus to be returned to a seventh. Nora thinks it is odd but, being busy, does not consider it further and does not report it. She says she never actually suspected money laundering. Which of the following best describes her position?
- She cannot commit an offence, because she did not in fact suspect money laundering.
- She commits an offence only if the funds are later proved to be the proceeds of crime.
- She cannot commit an offence, because she received no payment for handling the funds.
- She may commit an offence if there were reasonable grounds to know or suspect laundering.Correct answer
- She commits an offence only if she personally helped to move the money between the companies.
Section 330 of the Proceeds of Crime Act 2002 makes it an offence for a person in the regulated sector to fail to make a required disclosure where she knows or suspects, or has reasonable grounds for knowing or suspecting, that another person is engaged in money laundering, based on information received in the course of business. The 'reasonable grounds' limb is objective, so Nora cannot avoid liability by ignoring obvious red flags such as multiple unconnected overseas payers and a request to return funds to a different entity. The offence does not require proof that the funds are criminal property or that she took part in moving them.
Law basis: Proceeds of Crime Act 2002, s 330 ↗Question 5 · Money laundering and confidentialityDraft, pending solicitor review
Mr Ash seeks Olga's advice on his tax position. He explains that for several years he did not declare rental income from a second property and asks how to regularise his affairs with HMRC. Olga suspects he has benefited from tax evasion. There is nothing to suggest he wants her help to commit any further offence. Which of the following best describes Olga's duty under the Proceeds of Crime Act 2002?
- She must make a report at once, because she now suspects that Mr Ash has laundered money.
- She is not required to report, as the information came to her in privileged circumstances.Correct answer
- She must refuse to advise Mr Ash, because advising someone about past tax evasion is an offence.
- She must report if Mr Ash decides not to disclose the income to HMRC after receiving her advice.
- She must tell HMRC herself, because privilege does not apply to admissions of tax evasion.
Section 330 of the Proceeds of Crime Act 2002 requires those in the regulated sector to report knowledge or suspicion of money laundering. However, section 330(6) and (10) provide that a professional legal adviser does not commit the offence if the information came to her in privileged circumstances, such as from a client seeking legal advice. Under section 330(11), this does not apply to information communicated with the intention of furthering a criminal purpose. Mr Ash is seeking advice on regularising his affairs, not help with a new offence, so Olga is not required to report. Advising him is lawful, and disclosing to HMRC would breach confidentiality.
Law basis: Proceeds of Crime Act 2002, s 330(6), (10) and (11) ↗Question 6 · Money laundering and confidentialityDraft, pending solicitor review
Kai's firm submitted a suspicious activity report to the National Crime Agency seeking consent to complete a purchase for a client whose source of funds was unclear. Two working days later, the client demands that completion take place that afternoon. The NCA has not responded. Which of the following best describes the firm's position?
- It may complete, because submitting the report provides a complete defence to any offence.
- It may complete, provided the client gives a written indemnity against any criminal liability.
- It must not complete until consent is given or the notice period expires without refusal.Correct answer
- It may complete once the NCA acknowledges receipt of the suspicious activity report.
- It must tell the client that the report has been made and that completion must be delayed.
Under section 335 of the Proceeds of Crime Act 2002, a firm which has made an authorised disclosure seeking consent has the appropriate consent only if the NCA consents, or if seven working days pass from the day after the disclosure without notice of refusal. If consent is refused, a further moratorium period applies. Completing earlier risks committing a principal money laundering offence, such as an arrangement under section 328, because the defence depends on appropriate consent. An acknowledgement of receipt is not consent, and an indemnity cannot protect against criminal liability. Telling the client that a report has been made would risk the offence of tipping off under section 333A.
Law basis: Proceeds of Crime Act 2002, ss 328, 333A and 335 ↗Question 7 · Money laundering and confidentialityDraft, pending solicitor review
Ms Ortiz, a first-time buyer on a modest salary, instructs Ben on a £400,000 purchase. She says the £150,000 deposit will come from a man overseas whom she calls a 'family friend'. She cannot explain how she knows him, why he is paying, or where the money comes from. Which of the following best describes what Ben should do?
- Proceed, because the source of a deposit is a matter for the mortgage lender to investigate.
- Proceed, provided the money is paid directly into the firm's client account by bank transfer.
- Proceed, provided Ms Ortiz signs a declaration confirming that the money is a genuine gift.
- Proceed, but tell Ms Ortiz that he is required to report her to the National Crime Agency.
- Make enquiries about the source of funds and the payer, and not proceed if suspicions remain.Correct answer
Question 8 · Money laundering and confidentialityDraft, pending solicitor review
Selma's firm has made a suspicious activity report about a client, Mr Quinn, who has asked the firm to receive £250,000 from an unknown overseas company and use it to buy a flat in his name. Selma believes the transaction would be an offence and wants to tell Mr Quinn that she cannot help with an arrangement that would be illegal, in the hope that he will abandon it. Which of the following best describes Selma's position?
- She must say nothing at all to Mr Quinn, because any discussion with him would amount to tipping off.
- She may tell Mr Quinn that a report has been made, provided she does so in writing.
- She must tell Mr Quinn about the report, because he is entitled to all material information.
- A legal adviser may disclose to a client to dissuade him from committing an offence.Correct answer
- She may speak to Mr Quinn only after the National Crime Agency has closed its investigation.
Section 333A of the Proceeds of Crime Act 2002 makes it an offence in the regulated sector to disclose that a suspicious activity report has been made where the disclosure is likely to prejudice an investigation. However, section 333D(2) provides that a professional legal adviser does not commit the offence if the disclosure is to the adviser's client and is made for the purpose of dissuading the client from engaging in conduct amounting to an offence. Selma may therefore explain to Mr Quinn that the proposed arrangement would be unlawful in order to dissuade him, but she should be cautious about volunteering more than is needed. Paragraph 6.4(a) of the Code otherwise permits withholding information where the law prohibits disclosure.
Law basis: Proceeds of Crime Act 2002, ss 333A and 333D(2); Code of Conduct for Solicitors, RELs and RFLs, para 6.4(a) ↗More Ethics and Professional Conduct topics
Back to all Ethics and Professional Conduct questions, or sit a timed mock.