Law covered in these questions
- Land Registration Act 2002 s 97, Sch 6
- Land Registration Act 2002 Sch 6 paras 1, 5, 6
- Land Registration Act 2002 Sch 6 para 5(4)
- Land Registration Act 2002 Sch 6 paras 6, 7
- JA Pye (Oxford) Ltd v Graham [2002] UKHL 30
- Powell v McFarlane (1977) 38 P & CR 452
- Limitation Act 1980 ss 15, 17
- BP Properties Ltd v Buckler (1987) 55 P & CR 337
- Limitation Act 1980 s 15
- Best v Chief Land Registrar [2015] EWCA Civ 17
- Legal Aid, Sentencing and Punishment of Offenders Act 2012 s 144
All 9 questions with answers
Try them above first, then read the worked answers below.
Question 1 · Adverse possessionDraft, pending solicitor review
A squatter has occupied a strip of registered land without permission for 10 years and applies to be registered as proprietor. Which statement best describes the position under the Land Registration Act 2002?
- He can apply only if the owner has died.
- He may apply after 10 years, but the registered owner is notified and can object, and registration will be refused unless a limited condition is met.Correct answer
- He can apply only if the land is unregistered.
- He becomes the owner automatically after 10 years, without notice.
- He cannot apply until he has been in possession for 30 years.
Question 2 · Adverse possessionDraft, pending solicitor review
Nia has been in adverse possession of a strip of registered land belonging to Owen for 11 years. She applies to be registered as proprietor. Owen is notified and serves a counter-notice objecting. None of the special conditions apply. Which of the following best describes what happens next?
- Nia is registered, because she has been in possession for over ten years.
- Nia's application is rejected, and Owen then has two years to evict her.Correct answer
- Nia is registered, but Owen may claim compensation.
- Nia's application is rejected permanently.
- Nia's application is referred to a court to decide.
Under LRA 2002 Sch 6 para 1, a person in adverse possession of registered land for ten years ending on the date of application may apply to be registered. The registered proprietor is notified and may require the application to be dealt with under para 5, under which the squatter can succeed only if she satisfies one of three conditions (estoppel, some other entitlement, or the boundary condition). None applies, so the application is rejected. If Nia remains in adverse possession for two more years without Owen evicting her, she may reapply under para 6 and will be entitled to be registered.
Law basis: Land Registration Act 2002 Sch 6 paras 1, 5, 6 ↗Question 3 · Adverse possessionDraft, pending solicitor review
Paul and Rita are neighbours with registered titles. Twelve years ago Paul fenced in a strip of Rita's garden, believing on reasonable grounds that it was his, as the old fence line suggested. The exact boundary has never been determined. Paul applies to be registered; Rita objects. Which of the following best describes Paul's position?
- His application fails, because Rita objected.
- He succeeds only if Rita fails to evict him within two years.
- He may succeed under the boundary condition, as he reasonably believed the land was his.Correct answer
- His application fails, because a mistaken belief is not adverse possession.
- He succeeds only if he paid for the strip.
Under LRA 2002 Sch 6 para 5(4), a squatter may be registered despite the proprietor's objection if the land is adjacent to land belonging to the applicant, the exact line of the boundary has not been determined, for at least ten years of the period of adverse possession ending on the date of application the applicant reasonably believed the land belonged to him, and the estate was registered more than one year before the application. Paul satisfies these requirements, so his application may succeed. A mistaken belief does not prevent possession from being adverse.
Law basis: Land Registration Act 2002 Sch 6 para 5(4) ↗Question 4 · Adverse possessionDraft, pending solicitor review
Sam's application to be registered with title to Tom's registered land by adverse possession was rejected after Tom objected. Tom then did nothing. Two and a half years later Sam, still in possession, applies again. Which of the following best describes Sam's position?
- His application will be rejected again if Tom objects.
- He is entitled to be registered as proprietor.Correct answer
- He must wait a further ten years before reapplying.
- He is entitled to be registered only if a boundary condition applies.
- He is entitled to compensation, but not registration.
Under LRA 2002 Sch 6 para 6, where a squatter's application has been rejected, he may make a further application if he has remained in adverse possession for the period of two years beginning with the date of the rejection, provided the proprietor has not brought possession proceedings or obtained judgment against him. Under para 7, on such a further application the squatter is entitled to be registered as proprietor, and the proprietor cannot object. Tom took no action within the two years, so Sam is entitled to registration.
Law basis: Land Registration Act 2002 Sch 6 paras 6, 7 ↗Question 5 · Adverse possessionDraft, pending solicitor review
Uma grazed cattle on Vale Ltd's registered field under an annual grazing licence. When the licence expired, Vale Ltd refused to renew it, but Uma continued to graze and maintain the field for over ten years, keeping the gate padlocked. She was willing to pay for a licence if asked. Vale Ltd planned to develop the field one day. Which of the following best describes whether Uma was in adverse possession?
- No, because she was willing to pay for a licence.
- No, because grazing can never amount to possession.
- No, because Vale Ltd intended to develop the field in the future.
- Yes, because she had factual possession and an intention to possess.Correct answer
- Yes, but only because she paid nothing after the licence expired.
Adverse possession requires factual possession, meaning an appropriate degree of physical control, and an intention to possess, not an intention to own (JA Pye (Oxford) Ltd v Graham). In Pye, the House of Lords held that farmers who continued grazing after their licence expired, with the land in their exclusive control, were in adverse possession despite being willing to pay for a licence. The owner's future plans for the land are irrelevant (see also Buckinghamshire CC v Moran). Grazing combined with exclusive control can amount to possession.
Law basis: JA Pye (Oxford) Ltd v Graham [2002] UKHL 30Question 6 · Adverse possessionDraft, pending solicitor review
For many years Wren, a teenager living next to an unfenced registered field, occasionally picked fruit there, played games and grazed his pony on it a few times a year. No one else used the field. Wren now claims to have acquired it by adverse possession. Which of the following best describes his claim?
- He succeeds, because no one else used the field.
- He fails, because minors cannot acquire land by adverse possession.
- He succeeds, because grazing is always enough.
- He fails, because his acts were too trivial to amount to factual possession.Correct answer
- He succeeds after twelve years' use.
In Powell v McFarlane, on similar facts, the court held that a teenager who occasionally grazed a cow, cut hay and engaged in other intermittent activities on an unfenced field did not have factual possession, as the acts were not sufficient to show a single and conscious possession with an appropriate degree of physical control. He also failed to show a clear intention to possess. Equivocal acts of this kind do not amount to adverse possession. The issue is the quality of the acts, not the claimant's age or the absence of other users.
Law basis: Powell v McFarlane (1977) 38 P & CR 452Question 7 · Adverse possessionDraft, pending solicitor review
Xia has been in adverse possession of an unregistered plot of land since 2008. The paper owner has never taken any action. Xia now wishes to sell the plot. Which of the following best describes Xia's position?
- She has no title until she has occupied for 20 years.
- She must give the paper owner two years' notice before claiming.
- She must first obtain the paper owner's consent to registration.
- The paper owner's title has been extinguished.Correct answer
- She holds the land on trust for the paper owner.
Where land is unregistered, the Limitation Act 1980 governs. Under s 15, no action may be brought to recover land after 12 years from the date the right of action accrued, and under s 17, at the end of that period the paper owner's title is extinguished. Xia's possession began in 2008, so the owner's title was extinguished in 2020, and she has an independent fee simple. She may apply for first registration, likely with possessory title. The notice procedure in Schedule 6 to the Land Registration Act 2002 applies only to registered land.
Law basis: Limitation Act 1980 ss 15, 17 ↗Question 8 · Adverse possessionDraft, pending solicitor review
Yan has occupied a strip of unregistered land owned by Zara Ltd since 2016, without permission. In 2021, Zara Ltd sent Yan a letter stating that it was happy for him to continue using the strip until further notice. Yan did not reply but carried on as before. Yan now claims title. Which of the following best describes the effect of the letter?
- It probably stopped time running from 2021.Correct answer
- No effect, because Yan never accepted the permission.
- It had no effect, because only a court order can stop time running.
- It extended the limitation period by five years.
- It made Yan a tenant of Zara Ltd.
Possession is not adverse if it is enjoyed with the owner's permission. In BP Properties Ltd v Buckler, the owner wrote to the occupier giving her permission to remain rent-free; although she neither accepted nor rejected it, she continued in occupation and was treated as being there by permission, which stopped time running. Yan had not completed 12 years by 2021, so time stopped running and he has no title. An owner may also stop time by bringing proceedings, but a court order is not the only way.
Law basis: BP Properties Ltd v Buckler (1987) 55 P & CR 337; Limitation Act 1980 s 15Question 9 · Adverse possessionDraft, pending solicitor review
Ali squatted in an empty registered residential house from 2014, living there, changing the locks and making repairs. Since 2012, squatting in a residential building has been a criminal offence. Ali applies for registration based on ten years' adverse possession. The owner argues that criminal conduct cannot found a claim. Which of the following best describes the position?
- The claim fails, because no one may benefit from their own crime.
- The offence does not of itself prevent the claim.Correct answer
- The claim fails, because the offence suspends the limitation period.
- The claim succeeds only for the period before 2012.
- The claim fails automatically if Ali has been convicted.
Under the Legal Aid, Sentencing and Punishment of Offenders Act 2012 s 144, it is an offence to live in a residential building as a trespasser. In Best v Chief Land Registrar the Court of Appeal held that this does not prevent a squatter from relying on a period of adverse possession that involved committing the offence, when applying under LRA 2002 Sch 6. The policy of adverse possession and the criminal law serve different purposes, and the illegality principle does not bar the application. Ali's claim is therefore not defeated by the offence alone.
Law basis: Best v Chief Land Registrar [2015] EWCA Civ 17; Legal Aid, Sentencing and Punishment of Offenders Act 2012 s 144 ↗More Land Law topics
Back to all Land Law questions, or sit a timed mock.