Law covered in these questions
- Four-Maids Ltd v Dudley Marshall (Properties) Ltd [1957] Ch 317
- Administration of Justice Act 1970 s 36
- Samuel v Jarrah Timber and Wood Paving Corp Ltd [1904] AC 323
- Kreglinger v New Patagonia Meat and Cold Storage Co Ltd [1914] AC 25
- Knightsbridge Estates Trust Ltd v Byrne [1939] Ch 441
- Fairclough v Swan Brewery Co Ltd [1912] AC 565
- Royal Bank of Scotland plc v Etridge (No 2) [2001] UKHL 44
- CIBC Mortgages plc v Pitt [1994] 1 AC 200
- Law of Property Act 1925 s 87
- Administration of Justice Act 1973 s 8
- Cheltenham & Gloucester Building Society v Norgan [1996] 1 WLR 343
- Ropaigealach v Barclays Bank plc [2000] QB 263
- Law of Property Act 1925 ss 101, 103, 104
- Cuckmere Brick Co Ltd v Mutual Finance Ltd [1971] Ch 949
All 19 questions with answers
Try them above first, then read the worked answers below.
Question 1 · MortgagesDraft, pending solicitor review
A borrower defaults on a mortgage over a house and the lender wants possession. Which statement best describes the lender's right?
- The lender has no right to possession, only to sue for the debt.
- The lender can take possession only if the borrower agrees in writing.
- The lender can take possession only after 12 years.
- The lender has a right to take possession as soon as the mortgage is made, but in practice must get a court order if the property is a dwelling.Correct answer
- The lender may enter the house without a court order and change the locks at any time.
Question 2 · MortgagesDraft, pending solicitor review
Dina borrowed £200,000 from Elm Ltd, secured by a legal charge over her shop. The charge also gave Elm Ltd an option to buy the shop at a fixed price at any time during the mortgage. Dina repays the loan in full and Elm Ltd seeks to exercise the option. Which of the following best describes the validity of the option?
- It is valid, because Dina agreed to it freely in the charge.
- It is void, as a clog on the equity of redemption.Correct answer
- It is valid, because the parties were both commercial.
- It is valid only if exercised before redemption.
- It is void only if the price was below market value.
Equity will not allow any clog or fetter on the mortgagor's equity of redemption. An option for the mortgagee to purchase the mortgaged property, granted as part of the mortgage transaction, is void because it would allow the mortgagee to prevent redemption (Samuel v Jarrah Timber and Wood Paving Corp Ltd). This applies even between commercial parties and whatever the price. An option granted in a separate, independent transaction after the mortgage was created may be valid (Reeve v Lisle), but here it is in the charge itself.
Law basis: Samuel v Jarrah Timber and Wood Paving Corp Ltd [1904] AC 323Question 3 · MortgagesDraft, pending solicitor review
Iris, a meat trader, borrowed from Jax Ltd on a mortgage of her processing plant. A separate clause, negotiated as part of the deal, gave Jax Ltd a right of first refusal to buy her sheepskins for five years, whether or not the loan was repaid earlier. Iris repays after two years and argues the right ended on redemption. Which of the following best describes the position?
- The right ended on redemption, because collateral advantages cannot survive it.
- The right is void as a clog on the equity of redemption.
- The right survives only if registered as a land charge.
- The right may survive redemption, as a fair collateral advantage not clogging redemption.Correct answer
- The right is void because it was not in a separate deed.
A collateral advantage for the mortgagee is not objectionable if it is not unfair or unconscionable, is not in the nature of a penalty clogging the equity of redemption, and is not inconsistent with or repugnant to the right to redeem. In Kreglinger v New Patagonia Meat and Cold Storage Co Ltd, the House of Lords upheld a right of first refusal over sheepskins that continued after redemption, as it was a commercial bargain between parties of equal standing and was in substance independent of the mortgage. It does not need a separate deed.
Law basis: Kreglinger v New Patagonia Meat and Cold Storage Co Ltd [1914] AC 25Question 4 · MortgagesDraft, pending solicitor review
Kora Ltd, a property company, borrowed a large sum from an insurance company on a mortgage of its estate. Kora negotiated a term that the loan would be repaid by instalments over 40 years, with no right to redeem early. Interest rates have since fallen and Kora wants to redeem now. Which of the following best describes the position?
- Kora may redeem now, because postponement of redemption is always void.
- Kora may redeem after 21 years, under the rule against perpetuities.
- Kora may redeem now, because 40 years is an unreasonable period.
- Kora may not redeem early, because the postponement is a valid commercial term.Correct answer
- Kora may redeem now, on payment of a penalty fixed by the court.
A postponement of the contractual right to redeem is not void in itself. In Knightsbridge Estates Trust Ltd v Byrne the Court of Appeal upheld a term postponing redemption for 40 years in a mortgage between commercial parties dealing at arm's length, as it was not oppressive or unconscionable. By contrast, in Fairclough v Swan Brewery a postponement that made the right to redeem illusory, because the mortgaged lease would almost have expired, was void. Kora is bound by its bargain. The court has no general power to substitute a penalty.
Law basis: Knightsbridge Estates Trust Ltd v Byrne [1939] Ch 441; Fairclough v Swan Brewery Co Ltd [1912] AC 565Question 5 · MortgagesDraft, pending solicitor review
Leo charged his 20-year lease of a pub to a brewery to secure a loan. The mortgage provided that the loan could not be repaid until six weeks before the lease expired. Leo now wishes to redeem early. Which of the following best describes the validity of the postponement?
- It is valid, because Leo agreed to it.
- It is valid, because breweries may impose trading ties.
- It is void, because it renders the right to redeem illusory.Correct answer
- It is void only if the brewery is not a commercial lender.
- It is valid, but Leo may redeem on paying all future interest.
A term postponing redemption is void if it makes the equity of redemption illusory. In Fairclough v Swan Brewery Co Ltd, the Privy Council held that a provision preventing redemption of a mortgage of a lease until six weeks before the lease expired was invalid, because the mortgagor would recover only an almost worthless asset. Leo may therefore redeem. This contrasts with Knightsbridge Estates v Byrne, where the mortgaged estate was freehold and the postponement did not destroy the value of the property recovered.
Law basis: Fairclough v Swan Brewery Co Ltd [1912] AC 565Question 6 · MortgagesDraft, pending solicitor review
Mona agrees to charge the home she owns jointly with her husband Ned to Oak Bank to secure the overdraft of Ned's company, in which she has no interest. The bank sends the documents to Ned to get Mona's signature and takes no other steps. Ned had pressured Mona into signing. Which of the following best describes the bank's position?
- The bank is protected, because Mona signed the charge.
- The bank is fixed with notice only if Mona had no solicitor at all.
- The bank is protected, because the debt was a business debt.
- The bank is protected only if Ned's company repays.
- The bank is likely to be fixed with notice of the undue influence.Correct answer
In Royal Bank of Scotland plc v Etridge (No 2) the House of Lords held that a lender is put on inquiry whenever a wife stands surety for her husband's debts, or more generally whenever the relationship between surety and debtor is non-commercial. The lender must then take reasonable steps to satisfy itself that the surety understands the transaction, normally by requiring confirmation from a solicitor acting for her that she has been advised. Oak Bank left everything to Ned, so it is fixed with constructive notice of his undue influence and the charge may be set aside as against Mona.
Law basis: Royal Bank of Scotland plc v Etridge (No 2) [2001] UKHL 44Question 7 · MortgagesDraft, pending solicitor review
Pia and her husband Raj jointly borrow £300,000 from Sky Bank, secured on their jointly owned home. The application states the loan is to buy a holiday home in their joint names. In fact Raj pressured Pia into signing and used the money for his gambling debts. Pia argues the charge should be set aside. Which of the following best describes the bank's position?
- The bank is fixed with notice, because Pia is Raj's wife.
- The bank is fixed with notice, because the money was misused.
- The bank is fixed with notice, because it failed to interview Pia alone.
- The bank is protected only if it told Pia to take independent advice.
- The bank is not put on inquiry, because the loan appeared to be for their joint benefit.Correct answer
In CIBC Mortgages plc v Pitt the House of Lords held that where a loan is made to husband and wife jointly, for their joint purposes, the lender is not put on inquiry, because there is nothing to indicate that the transaction is not to the wife's financial advantage. Unless the lender is aware that the loan is really for the husband's sole purposes, it is not fixed with constructive notice of undue influence. This differs from a surety transaction, as in Etridge. The misuse of the money is irrelevant if the bank did not know of it.
Law basis: CIBC Mortgages plc v Pitt [1994] 1 AC 200; Royal Bank of Scotland plc v Etridge (No 2) [2001] UKHL 44Question 8 · MortgagesDraft, pending solicitor review
Tess guaranteed her partner's business debts, secured on her home. Her lender was put on inquiry and required written confirmation from a solicitor acting for Tess that he had explained the transaction to her. The solicitor sent the confirmation, but in fact his advice was careless and incomplete. Tess now seeks to set the charge aside against the lender. Which of the following best describes the likely outcome?
- The charge is set aside, because the advice was inadequate.
- The charge is set aside, because the lender must check the advice itself.
- The lender is protected, because it relied on the solicitor's confirmation.Correct answer
- The lender is protected only if it also met Tess in person.
- The charge is set aside, because Tess was the surety.
In Royal Bank of Scotland plc v Etridge (No 2) the House of Lords set out the steps a lender put on inquiry should take, the core one being to obtain written confirmation from a solicitor acting for the surety that the solicitor has advised her appropriately. A lender that receives such confirmation is ordinarily entitled to rely on it, and is not fixed with notice merely because the advice was in fact deficient, unless it knows or ought to know that the advice was not given. Tess's remedy is a negligence claim against her solicitor.
Law basis: Royal Bank of Scotland plc v Etridge (No 2) [2001] UKHL 44Question 9 · MortgagesDraft, pending solicitor review
Uma grants Vale Bank a legal charge over her office building. She is not in default and has made every payment on time. The charge says nothing about possession. The bank, worried about the property market, wants to take possession immediately. Which of the following best describes the bank's position in law?
- It has no right to possession unless Uma defaults.
- It needs a court order, which will be given only after three months' arrears.
- It is entitled to possession as soon as the charge is made, subject to any contrary term.Correct answer
- It may take possession only to sell, not to protect its security.
- It may take possession only if the building is empty.
A legal mortgagee, including a chargee by way of legal mortgage under LPA 1925 s 87, has the right to take possession of the mortgaged property as soon as the mortgage is made, even if the mortgagor is not in default, unless the mortgage expressly or impliedly excludes that right (Four-Maids Ltd v Dudley Marshall (Properties) Ltd). In practice, lenders seek possession only on default, and statutory protection under the Administration of Justice Act 1970 s 36 applies to dwelling-houses, not offices.
Law basis: Four-Maids Ltd v Dudley Marshall (Properties) Ltd [1957] Ch 317; Law of Property Act 1925 s 87Question 10 · MortgagesDraft, pending solicitor review
Will's mortgage of his home contains a clause that on any default the whole loan of £180,000 becomes immediately repayable. He is £4,000 in arrears after losing his job but has just found new work and can pay the instalments plus £300 a month off the arrears. The lender seeks possession. Which of the following best describes the court's powers?
- It may suspend possession if Will is likely to clear the arrears.Correct answer
- It must order possession, because the whole loan is now due.
- It may adjourn only if Will can repay the whole £180,000.
- It has no discretion, because the mortgage contains an acceleration clause.
- It may adjourn only for a maximum of 28 days.
Under the Administration of Justice Act 1970 s 36, where a mortgagee of a dwelling-house seeks possession, the court may adjourn, stay, suspend or postpone the order if it appears that the mortgagor is likely to be able within a reasonable period to pay any sums due under the mortgage. Section 8 of the Administration of Justice Act 1973 provides that, where the mortgage permits payment by instalments, 'sums due' means the arrears and current instalments, not the whole accelerated debt. Will can likely clear the arrears, so the court may suspend possession.
Law basis: Administration of Justice Act 1970 s 36; Administration of Justice Act 1973 s 8 ↗Question 11 · MortgagesDraft, pending solicitor review
Xena's 25-year residential mortgage has 18 years left to run. She has fallen into arrears but can now afford her monthly instalments plus a modest extra sum that would clear the arrears over about 15 years. The lender argues that a 'reasonable period' means no more than two years. Which of the following best describes the court's approach?
- The starting point is the full remaining term of the mortgage.Correct answer
- The reasonable period is normally limited to two years.
- The reasonable period is fixed by statute at five years.
- The court must order immediate possession if the arrears exceed six months.
- The court may consider only the lender's proposed period.
In Cheltenham & Gloucester Building Society v Norgan the Court of Appeal held that, in exercising its discretion under the Administration of Justice Act 1970 s 36, the court should take as its starting point the full remaining term of the mortgage, and ask whether the mortgagor can pay off the arrears within that period. The court should consider factors such as the borrower's budget, the reasons for the arrears and the adequacy of the security. Xena's proposal is within the remaining 18 years, so a suspended order may be appropriate. There is no statutory fixed period.
Law basis: Cheltenham & Gloucester Building Society v Norgan [1996] 1 WLR 343; Administration of Justice Act 1970 s 36Question 12 · MortgagesDraft, pending solicitor review
Yuri's house is mortgaged to Zen Bank. He is in arrears and has moved out temporarily to stay with relatives while renovations are done. Zen Bank enters the empty house peaceably and changes the locks without any court proceedings. Yuri argues the bank had to apply to court so he could seek protection. Which of the following best describes the legal position?
- The statutory protection does not apply where the mortgagee takes possession without proceedings.Correct answer
- The bank acted unlawfully, because a court order is always required for possession.
- The bank acted unlawfully, because Yuri is a residential occupier.
- The bank must now apply to court within 28 days.
- The bank must return the keys if Yuri pays any part of the arrears.
In Ropaigealach v Barclays Bank plc the Court of Appeal held that the Administration of Justice Act 1970 s 36 applies only where the mortgagee brings an action in which it claims possession. It does not prevent a mortgagee from taking possession peaceably without court proceedings, where the property is empty. Mortgagees nevertheless usually go to court, as entering occupied premises risks criminal liability, regulated lenders are bound by conduct rules, and a court order assists a sale. Yuri was not in occupation at the time of entry.
Law basis: Ropaigealach v Barclays Bank plc [2000] QB 263; Administration of Justice Act 1970 s 36Question 13 · MortgagesDraft, pending solicitor review
Abe's legal charge by deed provides that the mortgage money is due one month after the date of the charge, and is silent on the power of sale. Two years later Abe is three months in arrears with interest. The lender sells the house to Bree without serving any notice on Abe. Abe argues the sale is void. Which of the following best describes Bree's position?
- Bree's title is void, because no notice requiring payment was served.
- Bree obtains good title, because the power of sale had arisen and she need not check if it was exercisable.Correct answer
- Bree obtains good title only if Abe consents.
- Bree's title is void, because the charge did not expressly confer a power of sale.
- Bree obtains good title only if she paid the full market value.
Under LPA 1925 s 101, the power of sale arises when the mortgage is made by deed and the mortgage money has become due, which here happened one month after the charge. Under s 103 it becomes exercisable if, among other things, interest is two months in arrears, which is satisfied anyway. More importantly, s 104(2) protects a purchaser: once the power has arisen, the buyer's title cannot be impeached on the ground that the power was not exercisable or was improperly exercised. Abe's remedy is damages against the lender. No express power is needed.
Law basis: Law of Property Act 1925 ss 101, 103, 104Question 14 · MortgagesDraft, pending solicitor review
Cora's lender took possession of her land and sold it at auction. It failed to mention in the particulars that the land had valuable planning permission for 100 flats, which would have attracted far higher bids. Cora sues the lender. Which of the following best describes the lender's duty?
- It owes no duty, as it may sell in its own interests.
- It owes a duty only if it sold to an associate.
- It must obtain the best possible price, whatever the cost.
- It must delay the sale until the market is favourable.
- It must take reasonable care to obtain the true market value.Correct answer
A mortgagee exercising its power of sale may choose when to sell, but must take reasonable care to obtain the true market value of the property at the time of sale. In Cuckmere Brick Co Ltd v Mutual Finance Ltd, the mortgagee was held liable for failing to advertise the existence of a valuable planning permission, which depressed the price. The duty is not to obtain the best possible price regardless of cost, nor to wait for a better market. A sale to an associate attracts stricter scrutiny of the price, but the duty of care applies generally.
Law basis: Cuckmere Brick Co Ltd v Mutual Finance Ltd [1971] Ch 949Question 15 · MortgagesDraft, pending solicitor review
Dev's lender is selling his commercial property under its power of sale. The property's value could be substantially increased if planning permission were obtained, which would take about a year. Dev demands that the lender apply for permission before selling. Which of the following best describes the lender's obligations?
- It must apply for planning permission, because this would increase the price.
- It must wait until the market improves before selling.
- It need not apply for planning permission, and may sell now.Correct answer
- It must offer Dev the chance to sell the property himself first.
- It may sell now only if Dev consents.
In Silven Properties Ltd v Royal Bank of Scotland plc the Court of Appeal held that a mortgagee is entitled to sell the property in its existing condition, and is not obliged to take steps to improve or increase its value, such as applying for planning permission, before selling. The mortgagee may also choose the timing of the sale, even if the market is depressed. Once it decides to sell, it must take reasonable care to obtain the true market value at that time (Cuckmere Brick). Dev's consent is not required.
Law basis: Silven Properties Ltd v Royal Bank of Scotland plc [2003] EWCA Civ 1409Question 16 · MortgagesDraft, pending solicitor review
Elia's house was subject to a first charge to Fern Bank and a second charge to Gale Ltd. Fern Bank sells the house for £400,000. Its costs of sale are £10,000, the debt owed to it is £300,000, and Gale Ltd is owed £60,000. Which of the following best describes how the £90,000 left after Fern Bank's costs and debt should be applied?
- All of it to Elia, as the mortgagor.
- £45,000 each to Gale Ltd and Elia.
- All of it paid into court for the parties.
- All of it kept by Fern Bank for future costs.
- £60,000 to Gale Ltd and £30,000 to Elia.Correct answer
LPA 1925 s 105 provides that the selling mortgagee holds the proceeds on trust, first to pay any prior encumbrances, then the costs of sale, then the money due under its own mortgage, with the residue paid to the person entitled to the mortgaged property. That person includes subsequent mortgagees in order of priority before the mortgagor. After the £10,000 costs and £300,000 debt, £90,000 remains; £60,000 goes to Gale Ltd and only the £30,000 balance to Elia. Paying the whole surplus to the mortgagor is the common error.
Law basis: Law of Property Act 1925 s 105Question 17 · MortgagesDraft, pending solicitor review
Hana's house is in negative equity: she owes £400,000 but it is worth £300,000. Interest is accruing faster than any rent the lender could obtain. The lender wants to take possession and let the house until the market recovers, while Hana wants it sold now to limit her losses. Which of the following best describes Hana's position?
- She cannot force a sale, because only the lender has a power of sale.
- She may apply for a court order for sale even though the lender objects.Correct answer
- She can force a sale only if she pays the shortfall first.
- She can force a sale only if the property is unoccupied.
- She must accept the lender's choice of letting.
Under LPA 1925 s 91(2), the court may, on the request of the mortgagor or any other interested person, direct a sale of the mortgaged property on such terms as it thinks fit, even against the mortgagee's wishes. In Palk v Mortgage Services Funding plc, the Court of Appeal ordered a sale on the mortgagor's application where the lender's plan to let the property and wait for a rise in prices would cause the mortgagor's debt to grow unfairly. Hana does not need to pay the shortfall before applying, though she remains liable for it after sale.
Law basis: Palk v Mortgage Services Funding plc [1993] Ch 330; Law of Property Act 1925 s 91Question 18 · MortgagesDraft, pending solicitor review
Ian owns a registered house. On 1 March he charges it to Jay Ltd, which applies for registration on 20 March. On 10 March he charges it to Kay Bank, which applies for registration on 15 March. Both charges are now registered. Which of the following best describes the priority between the charges?
- Jay Ltd has priority because its charge was created first.
- Priority depends on which lender advanced more money.
- They rank equally because both are registered.
- Jay Ltd has priority because Kay Bank had notice of it.
- Kay Bank has priority because its charge was entered on the register first.Correct answer
Under LRA 2002 s 48(1), registered charges on the same registered estate are to be taken to rank as between themselves in the order shown in the register. Registration takes effect from the time the application is made (s 74). Kay Bank applied on 15 March and Jay Ltd on 20 March, so Kay Bank's charge is entered first and ranks ahead, even though Jay Ltd's charge was created earlier. Jay Ltd could have protected itself with an official search with priority. Notice is irrelevant to priority between registered charges.
Law basis: Land Registration Act 2002 ss 48, 74 ↗Question 19 · MortgagesDraft, pending solicitor review
Lark Bank holds a legal charge over an office block let to several tenants. The borrower has defaulted. Lark Bank appoints a receiver under its statutory power to collect the rents. The receiver negligently fails to collect rent, and a tenant leaves owing money. The borrower blames Lark Bank. Which of the following best describes the receiver's position?
- The receiver is deemed to be the borrower's agent.Correct answer
- The receiver is the bank's agent, so the bank is liable for his acts.
- The receiver is an officer of the court, accountable only to the court.
- The receiver is the tenants' agent.
- The receiver acts for both bank and borrower equally.
Under LPA 1925 s 109(2), a receiver appointed under the statutory power is deemed to be the agent of the mortgagor, who is solely responsible for the receiver's acts and defaults unless the mortgage deed provides otherwise. This is a major reason why lenders prefer to appoint receivers instead of taking possession themselves, since a mortgagee in possession is strictly accountable for the income it ought to have received. The receiver may still owe duties to the borrower, but the bank is not generally liable for his defaults.
Law basis: Law of Property Act 1925 s 109More Land Law topics
Back to all Land Law questions, or sit a timed mock.