Law covered in these questions
- City of London Building Society v Flegg [1988] AC 54
- Law of Property Act 1925 ss 2, 27
- State Bank of India v Sood [1997] Ch 276
- Law of Property Act 1925 s 2(1)(ii)
- Law of Property Act 1925 ss 2(1)(ii), 27(2)
- Law of Property Act 1925 s 2
- Land Registration Act 2002 s 29
- Law of Property Act 1925 s 27(2)
- Trustee Act 1925 s 36
- Land Registration Act 2002 s 40
- Ahmed v Kendrick (1988) 56 P & CR 120
- Administration of Estates Act 1925 s 39
- Williams & Glyn's Bank Ltd v Boland [1981] AC 487
All 10 questions with answers
Try them above first, then read the worked answers below.
Question 1 · OverreachingDraft, pending solicitor review
Leo and Mia, a married couple, are the registered proprietors of a house bought largely with money from Mia's parents, who live there and have a beneficial interest. Without telling the parents, Leo and Mia mortgage the house to Nova Bank and the advance is paid to them both. They default. Which of the following best describes the parents' position against Nova Bank?
- Their interest has been overreached, so the bank takes free of it.Correct answer
- Their interest binds the bank, because they were in actual occupation.
- Their interest binds the bank, because they were not consulted.
- Their interest binds the bank unless it made inquiries of them.
- Their interest ranks equally with the bank's charge.
Under LPA 1925 ss 2(1)(ii) and 27(2), a disposition by trustees of land where the capital money is paid to at least two trustees overreaches the beneficial interests, which then attach to the money. In City of London Building Society v Flegg, on similar facts, the House of Lords held that the beneficial interests of parents in actual occupation were overreached by a mortgage granted by two trustees, so they could not claim an overriding interest. Overreaching takes effect before the question of overriding interests arises. Failure to consult does not affect the mortgagee.
Law basis: City of London Building Society v Flegg [1988] AC 54; Law of Property Act 1925 ss 2, 27Question 2 · OverreachingDraft, pending solicitor review
Ola and Pip, the two registered proprietors of a house, charge it to Quay Bank to secure Ola's future business borrowing. No money is advanced at the time the charge is created. Pip's brother, who has a beneficial interest and lives there, argues that overreaching cannot occur because no capital money arose. Which of the following best describes the position?
- He is right, because overreaching requires payment of capital money.
- He is right, because the charge secures only future debts.
- His interest binds the bank, because he lives there.
- His interest is overreached even though no capital money arose at the time.Correct answer
- His interest is overreached only once money is later advanced.
In State Bank of India v Sood the Court of Appeal held that a charge granted by two trustees to secure existing and future liabilities overreached the beneficial interests of occupiers, even though no capital money arose on the creation of the charge. LPA 1925 s 2(1)(ii) requires compliance with s 27 as to capital money only so far as such money arises. Overreaching therefore operated immediately on the grant of the charge, defeating the brother's argument that his occupation gave him an overriding interest.
Law basis: State Bank of India v Sood [1997] Ch 276; Law of Property Act 1925 s 2(1)(ii)Question 3 · OverreachingDraft, pending solicitor review
A registered house is held on trust by Rook Trust Corporation Ltd as the sole trustee for several beneficiaries, one of whom lives there. The trust corporation sells the house to Sue, who pays the whole price to it. Which of the following best describes the effect on the occupying beneficiary's interest?
- It binds Sue, because the money was paid to only one trustee.
- It binds Sue, because the beneficiary was in actual occupation.
- It is overreached, because a trust corporation can give a valid receipt alone.Correct answer
- It is overreached only if a second trustee countersigns.
- It binds Sue unless she obtained the beneficiary's consent.
LPA 1925 s 27(2) requires capital money to be paid to or by the direction of not less than two trustees, except where the trustee is a trust corporation. A trust corporation can therefore give a valid receipt on its own, and the beneficial interests are overreached on payment to it. The occupying beneficiary's interest attaches to the proceeds, and actual occupation cannot help, because overreached interests do not override. The general two-trustee rule is the tempting trap here, but it does not apply to trust corporations.
Law basis: Law of Property Act 1925 ss 2(1)(ii), 27(2)Question 4 · OverreachingDraft, pending solicitor review
Tia and Ugo, as trustees, own a registered field. They previously granted their neighbour Vin an option to buy part of it, protected by a notice. They now sell the field to Wes, who pays the price to both of them. Wes argues that the option was overreached. Which of the following best describes the position?
- The option was overreached because the price was paid to two trustees.
- The option was overreached because it is an equitable interest.
- The option binds Wes, because options cannot be overreached.Correct answer
- The option binds Wes only if Vin is in actual occupation.
- The option is converted into a claim against the sale proceeds.
Overreaching under LPA 1925 s 2 applies to equitable interests under the trust of land, which are capable of being converted into money and transferred to the proceeds. Commercial equitable interests such as estate contracts, options, equitable easements and restrictive covenants are not overreachable, as they cannot sensibly be satisfied out of the proceeds. Vin's option was protected by a notice, so it binds Wes under LRA 2002 s 29. Actual occupation is not needed where an interest is protected on the register.
Law basis: Law of Property Act 1925 s 2; Land Registration Act 2002 s 29Question 5 · OverreachingDraft, pending solicitor review
Xena is the sole surviving registered proprietor of a house held on trust for herself and her late brother's estate as tenants in common. A Form A restriction is on the title. She wishes to sell to Yves, who is concerned about the brother's estate's interest. Which of the following best describes how overreaching can be achieved?
- Xena should appoint a second trustee so that the price is paid to two trustees.Correct answer
- Xena can give a valid receipt alone as surviving legal owner.
- Yves must obtain the written consent of the brother's executors.
- Yves must pay the brother's share directly to the executors.
- Overreaching is impossible because one owner has died.
Overreaching requires capital money to be paid to at least two trustees or a trust corporation (LPA 1925 s 27(2)). Xena, as sole trustee, cannot give a valid receipt, and the Form A restriction prevents registration of a disposition by her alone. The solution is for Xena to appoint a second trustee, under the Trustee Act 1925 s 36, so that the purchase money is paid to two trustees, satisfying the restriction and overreaching the estate's interest. Consent of the executors is unnecessary, and paying them directly would not satisfy s 27.
Law basis: Law of Property Act 1925 s 27(2); Trustee Act 1925 s 36; Land Registration Act 2002 s 40Question 6 · OverreachingDraft, pending solicitor review
Zac and Ama, trustees of a registered house, sold it to a buyer for £400,000, paid to them both. Their sister Bel, a beneficiary with a one-third share who lived there, was not consulted. Zac and Ama have spent all the money. Bel asks what claim she has. Which of the following best describes her position?
- She can claim against Zac and Ama for breach of trust, as her interest attached to the proceeds.Correct answer
- She has a claim against the buyer for one third of the price.
- She can recover the house from the buyer, because she was not consulted.
- She has an overriding interest against the buyer because she lived there.
- She has no claim, because overreaching extinguishes the beneficial interest.
Because the price was paid to two trustees, Bel's interest was overreached under LPA 1925 ss 2 and 27 and detached from the land, attaching instead to the proceeds of sale. The buyer takes free of it, even though Bel was in occupation (City of London Building Society v Flegg), and the trustees' failure to consult under TOLATA s 11 does not invalidate the sale. Overreaching does not extinguish Bel's interest: she has a personal claim against Zac and Ama for breach of trust and may trace into any identifiable proceeds.
Law basis: Law of Property Act 1925 ss 2, 27; City of London Building Society v Flegg [1988] AC 54Question 7 · OverreachingDraft, pending solicitor review
Cal and Dot are joint registered proprietors and beneficial joint tenants of a house. Cal forges Dot's signature on a transfer of the house to Eli, who pays the price to Cal. Dot, who lives there, discovers the transfer. Which of the following best describes the effect of the transfer?
- It overreaches Dot's interest, because both names appear on the transfer.
- It overreaches Dot's interest because Eli paid full value.
- It passes the whole beneficial interest to Eli, who bought in good faith.
- It is wholly void, and Eli acquires nothing.
- It is effective against Cal's beneficial share but does not overreach Dot's interest.Correct answer
Overreaching requires a genuine disposition by at least two trustees. Where one co-owner forges the other's signature, there is no valid disposition by both trustees and no overreaching. In Ahmed v Kendrick, a husband forged his wife's signature on a transfer; it was held effective to pass his own beneficial share, severing the joint tenancy, but did not affect her interest. Eli's good faith and payment cannot overcome the forgery. Dot can seek alteration of the register, while Eli may claim against Cal or seek indemnity.
Law basis: Ahmed v Kendrick (1988) 56 P & CR 120; Law of Property Act 1925 s 2Question 8 · OverreachingDraft, pending solicitor review
Fin and Gia, trustees of a registered house, agree to sell to Hui. Both trustees sign a written direction instructing Hui to pay the entire price into Fin's solicitor's client account. A beneficiary living in the house argues that overreaching failed because the money did not go to both trustees. Which of the following best describes the position?
- Overreaching failed, because only one trustee received the money.
- Overreaching failed, because payment to a solicitor is not payment to trustees.
- Overreaching occurred, because the money was paid by the direction of both trustees.Correct answer
- Overreaching occurred only if the solicitor holds the money for both.
- Overreaching failed, because the beneficiary was in occupation.
LPA 1925 s 27(2) provides that the proceeds of sale must be paid to or applied by the direction of not less than two persons as trustees, unless the trustee is a trust corporation. Payment made in accordance with a direction signed by both trustees satisfies the section, even if the money is received by one trustee or his solicitor. Overreaching therefore occurred and the beneficiary's occupation cannot defeat it (City of London Building Society v Flegg). Any misapplication by Fin is a matter between the trustees and the beneficiaries.
Law basis: Law of Property Act 1925 s 27(2); City of London Building Society v Flegg [1988] AC 54Question 9 · OverreachingDraft, pending solicitor review
Ida died, and her son Jay was appointed as her sole executor. Ida's registered house is held for the benefit of her three children under her will. Jay sells the house to Kip, who pays the whole price to Jay. One of Jay's sisters, who lives in the house, argues that her interest binds Kip. Which of the following best describes the position?
- Her interest binds Kip, because the price was paid to only one person.
- Her interest binds Kip, because she was in actual occupation.
- Her interest binds Kip unless a second executor is appointed.
- Kip takes free only if all three children consented.
- Kip takes free, because a sole personal representative can give a valid receipt.Correct answer
LPA 1925 s 27(2) requires capital money to be paid to at least two trustees, but expressly excepts a sole personal representative acting as such, as well as a trust corporation. Jay, as sole executor, can therefore give a valid receipt for the purchase money, and Kip takes free of the beneficiaries' interests. The general two-trustee rule is the trap. The sister's occupation does not help, because her interest under the will is satisfied out of the proceeds in the administration of the estate, and the beneficiaries' consent is not required.
Law basis: Law of Property Act 1925 s 27(2); Administration of Estates Act 1925 s 39Question 10 · OverreachingDraft, pending solicitor review
Leon is the sole registered proprietor of a house in which his wife Mira has a beneficial interest and lives. He applies to Pine Bank for a loan secured on the house. The bank's solicitor is concerned that Mira's interest may bind the bank. Which of the following steps would best protect the bank against Mira's interest?
- Requiring Leon to confirm in writing that no one else has an interest.
- Registering the charge within the priority period of its search.
- Inspecting the house and noting that Mira lives there.
- Requiring Leon to appoint a second trustee and paying the advance to both trustees.Correct answer
- Obtaining a statutory declaration from Leon about his marital status.
A mortgage by a sole trustee cannot overreach beneficial interests, which is why Mira's interest coupled with actual occupation would bind the bank (Williams & Glyn's Bank v Boland). If Leon appoints a second trustee and the advance is paid to both, the mortgage overreaches Mira's interest under LPA 1925 ss 2 and 27, as in City of London Building Society v Flegg. An alternative is to obtain Mira's informed written consent to the charge. Leon's own assurances and simple inspection do not defeat her interest, and prompt registration does not affect overriding interests.
Law basis: Law of Property Act 1925 ss 2, 27; Williams & Glyn's Bank Ltd v Boland [1981] AC 487; City of London Building Society v Flegg [1988] AC 54More Land Law topics
Back to all Land Law questions, or sit a timed mock.