Law covered in these questions
- Landlord and Tenant (Covenants) Act 1995 s 17
- Landlord and Tenant (Covenants) Act 1995 ss 1, 5
- Landlord and Tenant (Covenants) Act 1995 ss 16, 25
- Landlord and Tenant (Covenants) Act 1995 s 17(2)
- Spencer's Case (1583) 5 Co Rep 16a
- Law of Property Act 1925 ss 141, 142
- Landlord and Tenant (Covenants) Act 1995 s 3(6)
- Landlord and Tenant (Covenants) Act 1995 ss 6, 8
- Landlord and Tenant (Covenants) Act 1995 s 23
- Landlord and Tenant (Covenants) Act 1995 s 3(5)
- Tulk v Moxhay (1848) 2 Ph 774
- Landlord and Tenant Act 1927 s 19(1)(a)
- International Drilling Fluids Ltd v Louisville Investments (Uxbridge) Ltd [1986] Ch 513
- Landlord and Tenant Act 1988 ss 1, 4
All 18 questions with answers
Try them above first, then read the worked answers below.
Question 1 · Enforceability of leasehold covenantsDraft, pending solicitor review
In 1990, Nell took a 40-year lease of an office from Owen. In 2010 Nell assigned the lease to Pace Ltd, which has now stopped paying rent. Owen wants to recover the arrears from Nell, who has had nothing to do with the property for 16 years. Which of the following best describes Nell's liability?
- Nell is not liable, because she was released when she assigned the lease.
- Nell is not liable, because Owen must pursue Pace Ltd first.
- Nell is liable only if she gave an authorised guarantee agreement.
- Nell is liable, but only if Owen serves a notice on her within six months of the rent falling due.Correct answer
- Nell is liable, but only for arrears that accrued before 1996.
The lease was granted before 1 January 1996, so it is an 'old' lease and the original tenant remains liable on her covenants for the whole term through privity of contract, even after assignment. However, LT(C)A 1995 s 17 applies to old and new leases: a landlord cannot recover a fixed charge, such as rent, from a former tenant unless, within six months of the charge becoming due, he serves notice on her in the prescribed form. Automatic release on assignment applies only to new leases, and AGAs apply only to new leases.
Law basis: Landlord and Tenant (Covenants) Act 1995 s 17 ↗Question 2 · Enforceability of leasehold covenantsDraft, pending solicitor review
In 2005, Quinn took a 20-year lease of a shop. In 2015, with the landlord's consent, Quinn assigned the lease to Ruby. No authorised guarantee agreement was required. Ruby has now failed to pay rent. The landlord seeks the arrears from Quinn. Which of the following best describes Quinn's liability?
- Quinn is liable, because he is the original tenant.
- Quinn is liable until the lease is registered in Ruby's name.
- Quinn is liable if the landlord serves a notice within six months.
- Quinn is liable for half the arrears with Ruby.
- Quinn is not liable, because he was released from the tenant covenants on assignment.Correct answer
The lease was granted after 31 December 1995, so it is a 'new' lease under the Landlord and Tenant (Covenants) Act 1995. Under s 5, a tenant who assigns the whole of the premises demised is released from the tenant covenants from the assignment, provided it is not an excluded assignment, for example one in breach of covenant. Quinn assigned with consent and gave no authorised guarantee agreement, so he has no liability for Ruby's arrears. Continuing liability of an original tenant through privity of contract is a feature of old leases.
Law basis: Landlord and Tenant (Covenants) Act 1995 ss 1, 5 ↗Question 3 · Enforceability of leasehold covenantsDraft, pending solicitor review
Sam holds a 2012 lease of a warehouse containing a qualified covenant against assignment. He asks for consent to assign to Tara. The landlord gives consent on condition that Sam enters into an authorised guarantee agreement. Tara later defaults. Which of the following best describes Sam's liability?
- Sam is liable as guarantor of Tara's obligations under the AGA.Correct answer
- Sam is not liable, because AGAs are void under the 1995 Act.
- Sam is liable as guarantor of Tara and of every later assignee.
- Sam is liable as if he were still the tenant, without limit of time.
- Sam is not liable, because the landlord's condition was unreasonable.
Under LT(C)A 1995 s 16, where a tenant is released on assignment but the landlord's consent is required, the tenant may enter into an authorised guarantee agreement guaranteeing performance by the immediate assignee. It is lawful for the landlord to require an AGA as a condition of consent (s 16(3)). The guarantee extends only to the immediate assignee, Tara, and ends when she lawfully assigns. An attempt to make Sam guarantee later assignees would be void under s 25. Requiring an AGA is commonly a reasonable condition, especially where the lease specifies it.
Law basis: Landlord and Tenant (Covenants) Act 1995 ss 16, 25 ↗Question 4 · Enforceability of leasehold covenantsDraft, pending solicitor review
Uri is the original tenant under a 1985 lease, which he assigned in 2000. The current tenant fell into arrears in January. In October the landlord wrote to Uri for the first time, demanding payment of the January arrears. Which of the following best describes Uri's position?
- He is liable, because original tenants of old leases are liable for the whole term.
- He is not liable, because the landlord did not serve notice within six months.Correct answer
- He is liable, because the landlord wrote to him within the same year.
- He is not liable, because old leases release tenants on assignment.
- He is liable for the rent, but not for interest on it.
An original tenant under an old lease remains liable through privity of contract. However, under LT(C)A 1995 s 17(2), the former tenant is not liable for a fixed charge unless, within six months beginning with the date when the charge becomes due, the landlord serves on him a notice informing him that the charge is due and that the landlord intends to recover it. The January arrears were not notified until October, outside the six-month window, so Uri is not liable for them. Section 17 applies to both old and new leases.
Law basis: Landlord and Tenant (Covenants) Act 1995 s 17(2) ↗Question 5 · Enforceability of leasehold covenantsDraft, pending solicitor review
Val took an old lease in 1980 and assigned it to Wes in 1990. Wes assigned it to Xu in 2000. Xu is now in breach of the repairing covenant, and the landlord sues Wes. Which of the following best describes Wes's liability?
- Wes is liable, because he took the lease while it was still an old lease.
- Wes is not liable for breaches occurring after he assigned the lease to Xu.Correct answer
- Wes is liable jointly with Xu as a prior assignee.
- Wes is liable unless he gave a direct covenant to the landlord.
- Wes is liable because repairing covenants run with the land.
Under an old lease, an assignee is bound by covenants which touch and concern the land through privity of estate (Spencer's Case; LPA 1925 s 142). Privity of estate exists only while the assignee holds the lease, so Wes is liable only for breaches committed during his tenure and not for those after he assigned to Xu. The original tenant, Val, remains liable through privity of contract. The position would be different if Wes had entered into a direct covenant with the landlord to observe the covenants for the rest of the term, which the facts do not show.
Law basis: Spencer's Case (1583) 5 Co Rep 16a; Law of Property Act 1925 ss 141, 142Question 6 · Enforceability of leasehold covenantsDraft, pending solicitor review
Yuki took a new lease of a restaurant in 2018. The lease contains a covenant by the landlord to provide Yuki personally with two free parking spaces, expressed to be 'personal to Yuki Tanaka'. Yuki assigns the lease to Zane, who claims the parking spaces. Which of the following best describes Zane's position?
- Zane is not entitled, because the covenant is expressed to be personal.Correct answer
- Zane is entitled, because the parking benefits the restaurant.
- Zane is entitled, because all landlord covenants pass under the 1995 Act.
- Zane is entitled only if he gives the landlord a direct covenant.
- Zane is not entitled, because covenants must touch and concern land.
Under LT(C)A 1995 s 3, the benefit and burden of all landlord and tenant covenants of a new lease pass on assignment, whether or not they touch and concern the land. However, s 3(6)(a) provides that this does not operate to make a covenant enforceable by or against an assignee if it is, in whatever terms, expressed to be personal to any person. The parking covenant is expressly personal to Yuki, so its benefit does not pass to Zane. The touching and concerning test applies to old leases, not new ones.
Law basis: Landlord and Tenant (Covenants) Act 1995 s 3(6) ↗Question 7 · Enforceability of leasehold covenantsDraft, pending solicitor review
Ada granted a new lease of a shop in 2016. In 2026 she sells the freehold reversion to Bex. Ada wants to be free from her landlord covenants, including a covenant to repair the structure. Which of the following best describes how Ada may be released?
- She is released automatically on the sale of the reversion.
- She can never be released, as she is the original landlord.
- She may apply for release by serving notice on the tenant.Correct answer
- She is released only if the tenant enters into a new lease with Bex.
- She is released only if Bex enters into an authorised guarantee agreement.
Unlike tenants, landlords of new leases are not released automatically on assigning the reversion. Under LT(C)A 1995 ss 6 and 8, the landlord may apply to be released by serving a notice on the tenant before or within four weeks after the assignment. If the tenant does not object within four weeks, the release takes effect; if the tenant objects, the landlord may apply to the county court, which may declare it reasonable for the landlord to be released. AGAs are a tenant mechanism only.
Law basis: Landlord and Tenant (Covenants) Act 1995 ss 6, 8 ↗Question 8 · Enforceability of leasehold covenantsDraft, pending solicitor review
Cole is the landlord of a shop under a lease granted in 2010. The tenant owes £12,000 of rent that fell due before Cole sold the reversion to Dina. The sale contract says nothing about the arrears. Dina sues the tenant for the £12,000. Which of the following best describes the position?
- Dina can recover, because rights under the lease pass with the reversion.
- Dina cannot recover, because pre-sale rights stay with Cole.Correct answer
- Dina can recover, but only if she gives notice to the tenant within six months.
- Dina can recover half, sharing it with Cole.
- Dina can recover, because the arrears are a charge on the land.
For new leases, LT(C)A 1995 s 23(1) provides that a person who becomes entitled to the benefit of a covenant on an assignment does not by virtue of the assignment have any rights in relation to any time falling before the assignment. Under s 23(2), the right to sue for earlier breaches can be expressly assigned. The contract is silent, so the right to the £12,000 remains with Cole. This differs from old leases, where LPA 1925 s 141 allowed a new landlord to sue for arrears accrued before the transfer (Arlesford Trading Co v Servansingh).
Law basis: Landlord and Tenant (Covenants) Act 1995 s 23 ↗Question 9 · Enforceability of leasehold covenantsDraft, pending solicitor review
Eli holds a new lease of a shop containing a covenant not to use the premises for the sale of hot food. Eli sublets the shop to Fay, who opens a takeaway. The sublease contains no similar covenant. The head landlord wants to stop Fay. Which of the following best describes the head landlord's position?
- It cannot act against Fay, as there is no privity of contract or estate.
- It may act against Fay only if she had actual notice of the covenant.
- It may sue Fay for damages under the head lease.
- It may enforce the covenant only by forfeiting Fay's sublease.
- It may enforce the restrictive covenant directly against Fay as occupier.Correct answer
There is no privity of contract or estate between a head landlord and a subtenant, so positive covenants are not directly enforceable. However, restrictive covenants can be enforced against a subtenant. For new leases, LT(C)A 1995 s 3(5) provides that a restrictive covenant is capable of being enforced against any other person who is the owner or occupier of any demised premises to which it relates. The head landlord may therefore seek an injunction against Fay directly. It may also be able to forfeit the head lease, which would end the sublease, subject to relief.
Law basis: Landlord and Tenant (Covenants) Act 1995 s 3(5); Tulk v Moxhay (1848) 2 Ph 774 ↗Question 10 · Enforceability of leasehold covenantsDraft, pending solicitor review
Gil holds a lease of offices containing a covenant not to assign without the landlord's consent. Gil asks for consent to assign to a sound company that will use the offices for the same purpose. The landlord refuses, explaining that it wants Gil to surrender the lease so it can re-let at a higher rent. Which of the following best describes the landlord's refusal?
- It is unreasonable, because it is for a purpose collateral to the landlord-tenant relationship.Correct answer
- It is reasonable, because a landlord may protect its financial interests.
- It is reasonable, because the covenant gives the landlord an absolute discretion.
- It is unreasonable only if the lease is a new lease.
- It is reasonable unless Gil offers a rent deposit.
Under LTA 1927 s 19(1)(a), a qualified covenant against assignment is subject to a proviso that consent is not to be unreasonably withheld. In International Drilling Fluids Ltd v Louisville Investments the Court of Appeal held that a landlord is not entitled to refuse consent on grounds that have nothing to do with the relationship of landlord and tenant in regard to the subject matter of the lease. Refusing in order to recover the premises for re-letting at a higher rent is a collateral purpose and is unreasonable. The rule applies to old and new leases.
Law basis: Landlord and Tenant Act 1927 s 19(1)(a); International Drilling Fluids Ltd v Louisville Investments (Uxbridge) Ltd [1986] Ch 513Question 11 · Enforceability of leasehold covenantsDraft, pending solicitor review
Hal's lease contains a qualified covenant against assignment. He sends the landlord a written request for consent with full information about the proposed assignee. Three months later, despite chasing, he has heard nothing, and the assignee has withdrawn. Which of the following best describes Hal's position?
- He has no remedy, because the landlord has an unlimited time to decide.
- He may assign anyway, because consent is deemed given after 28 days.
- He may treat the lease as terminated.
- He may claim only if the landlord eventually refuses.
- He may claim damages for breach of statutory duty.Correct answer
Under the Landlord and Tenant Act 1988 s 1, where a tenant serves a written application for consent under a qualified covenant, the landlord owes a duty, within a reasonable time, to give consent unless it is reasonable not to, and to serve written notice of his decision with reasons for any refusal or conditions. The burden of proving reasonableness is on the landlord (s 1(6)). Breach of the duty is actionable in tort for damages (s 4). There is no deemed consent after a fixed period; Hal's remedy is damages for the lost assignment.
Law basis: Landlord and Tenant Act 1988 ss 1, 4 ↗Question 12 · Enforceability of leasehold covenantsDraft, pending solicitor review
Ivo is the tenant of a new lease and his obligations are guaranteed by his parent company, Jet plc. Ivo wishes to assign to Kel. The landlord agrees, but requires Jet plc to guarantee Kel's obligations directly. Which of the following best describes the validity of Jet plc's guarantee of Kel?
- It is valid, because the landlord may impose any reasonable condition.
- It is valid, because guarantors are outside the 1995 Act.
- It is valid only for the first five years of Kel's tenure.
- It is void, because the guarantor of the assignor cannot guarantee the assignee.Correct answer
- It is void, because guarantees of commercial leases are prohibited.
Question 13 · Enforceability of leasehold covenantsDraft, pending solicitor review
Lia holds a lease containing an absolute covenant not to assign. In breach of the covenant, she executes a deed assigning the lease to Max. The landlord had refused consent. Which of the following best describes the effect of the assignment?
- It is void, so the lease remains vested in Lia.
- It vests the lease in Max, subject to forfeiture.Correct answer
- It is void unless the landlord later accepts rent from Max.
- It is effective, and the landlord has no remedy.
- It is effective only as an equitable assignment.
An assignment made in breach of a covenant against assignment is nevertheless effective to vest the lease in the assignee (Old Grovebury Manor Farm Ltd v W Seymour Plant Sales & Hire Ltd (No 2)). The breach gives the landlord a right to forfeit if the lease contains a forfeiture clause, and Max takes subject to that right. In a new lease the assignment would also be an excluded assignment under LT(C)A 1995 s 11, so Lia would not be released. The assignment is not void, so the option suggesting the lease stays with Lia is wrong.
Law basis: Old Grovebury Manor Farm Ltd v W Seymour Plant Sales & Hire Ltd (No 2) [1979] 1 WLR 1397; Landlord and Tenant (Covenants) Act 1995 s 11Question 14 · Enforceability of leasehold covenantsDraft, pending solicitor review
Nia holds a 2020 lease of a retail unit. The lease states that the landlord may withhold consent to assignment unless the proposed assignee has net profits of at least three times the annual rent. Nia proposes an assignee whose profits are twice the rent, and the landlord refuses consent. Which of the following best describes the refusal?
- It is not unreasonable, because the agreed condition is not met.Correct answer
- It is unreasonable, because the assignee is otherwise respectable.
- It is unreasonable, because conditions cannot be fixed in advance.
- It is valid only if the landlord proves financial loss.
- It is unreasonable, because the 1927 Act overrides lease terms.
For qualifying new leases of non-residential premises, LTA 1927 s 19(1A), inserted by the 1995 Act, allows the landlord and tenant to agree in advance the circumstances in which the landlord may withhold consent, and conditions subject to which it may be granted. If the landlord withholds consent because such a pre-agreed circumstance exists, it is not unreasonably withholding consent. The lease specified profits of three times the rent; the assignee has only twice, so the refusal is not unreasonable. The landlord need not show loss.
Law basis: Landlord and Tenant Act 1927 s 19(1A)Question 15 · Enforceability of leasehold covenantsDraft, pending solicitor review
Oli has rented a flat on a monthly periodic tenancy since 2024. The roof begins to leak into his bedroom. He has not told the landlord, who has no other way of knowing. Oli now sues for damages for the damage caused before he complains. Which of the following best describes the landlord's position?
- The landlord is liable from when the leak began, under the implied repairing covenant.
- The landlord is not liable, because the tenancy is shorter than seven years.
- The landlord is not liable, because tenants must repair the roof.
- The landlord is liable only if the lease expressly covers the roof.
- The landlord is not liable until he has notice of the disrepair.Correct answer
Under the Landlord and Tenant Act 1985 s 11, in a lease of a dwelling-house for a term of less than seven years, the landlord covenants to keep in repair the structure and exterior, including the roof, and certain installations. The covenant cannot be excluded by the lease. However, in O'Brien v Robinson the House of Lords held that the landlord's liability arises only when he has notice of the want of repair. As the landlord had no notice, he is not liable for damage before Oli complains. A periodic tenancy is treated as a lease for less than seven years, so s 11 applies.
Law basis: Landlord and Tenant Act 1985 s 11; O'Brien v Robinson [1973] AC 912 ↗Question 16 · Enforceability of leasehold covenantsDraft, pending solicitor review
Pat rents a flat in a converted Victorian block. Because of the poor sound insulation that existed when the building was converted, Pat can hear her neighbours' ordinary daily activities. She sues the landlord for breach of the covenant for quiet enjoyment. Which of the following best describes the likely outcome?
- She succeeds, because the noise substantially interferes with her enjoyment.
- She succeeds, because the landlord must keep the flat fit for habitation.
- She fails, because the covenant does not apply to defects existing at the grant.Correct answer
- She fails, because quiet enjoyment concerns only physical eviction.
- She succeeds only if the neighbours are also the landlord's tenants.
The covenant for quiet enjoyment protects the tenant against substantial interference with possession by the landlord or those claiming under him, but it is prospective. In Southwark LBC v Mills the House of Lords held that tenants could not complain under the covenant about noise caused by poor sound insulation that existed when the lease was granted, as the tenant takes the property as she finds it, and the neighbours' ordinary use was not a breach. The covenant is not limited to physical eviction, but it does not impose an obligation to improve the premises.
Law basis: Southwark LBC v Mills [2001] 1 AC 1Question 17 · Enforceability of leasehold covenantsDraft, pending solicitor review
Ross owns the freehold of a shop let on a 2015 lease, under which the landlord covenants to repair the structure. Ross sells the freehold to Sky. The structure then falls into disrepair. Sky claims she is not bound by Ross's repairing covenant because she never agreed to it. Which of the following best describes the position?
- Sky is not bound, because the covenant was personal to Ross.
- Sky is bound only if she expressly accepted the covenant on purchase.
- Sky is bound, because the burden of the landlord covenants passes to her.Correct answer
- Sky is not bound, because only Ross can be sued for the repairs.
- Sky is bound only if the tenant served a notice on her within six months.
Under LT(C)A 1995 s 3(3), on an assignment of the reversion of a new lease, the assignee becomes bound by the landlord covenants of the tenancy except to the extent that they did not bind the assignor immediately before the assignment, or relate to premises not comprised in the assignment. Sky therefore becomes bound by the repairing covenant for breaches occurring after the sale. Nothing suggests the covenant was expressed to be personal, and no express acceptance is needed. Ross may also remain liable unless released under ss 6 to 8.
Law basis: Landlord and Tenant (Covenants) Act 1995 s 3(3) ↗Question 18 · Enforceability of leasehold covenantsDraft, pending solicitor review
In 1993, Tom took a 30-year lease of a shop. In 2000, Tom entered into a signed written contract to assign the lease to Uma, but no deed of assignment was ever executed. Uma took possession and later stopped paying rent. The landlord sues Uma for the rent. Which of the following best describes Uma's liability?
- Uma is liable, because she is in possession and benefits from the lease.
- Uma is liable, because the contract satisfied the formality rules.
- Uma is liable under the Landlord and Tenant (Covenants) Act 1995.
- Uma is not directly liable, as an equitable assignee has no privity of estate with the landlord.Correct answer
- Uma is not liable, because the assignment was void.
For old leases, enforcement against an assignee depends on privity of estate, which requires a legal assignment by deed (LPA 1925 s 52). In Purchase v Lichfield Brewery Co, an equitable assignee under a contract to assign was held not liable to the landlord for rent, because there was no privity of estate. Tom remains liable through privity of contract. The 1995 Act would treat an equitable assignment as an assignment for new leases, but this is an old lease granted in 1993. The assignment is not void; it takes effect in equity.
Law basis: Purchase v Lichfield Brewery Co [1915] 1 KB 184; Law of Property Act 1925 s 52More Land Law topics
Back to all Land Law questions, or sit a timed mock.