Law covered in these questions
- Law of Property (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 1989 s 2
- Firstpost Homes Ltd v Johnson [1995] 1 WLR 1567
- Law of Property (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 1989 s 2(1), (3)
- Spiro v Glencore International AG [1991] Ch 537
- McCausland v Duncan Lawrie Ltd [1997] 1 WLR 38
- Law of Property (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 1989 s 1(2), (3)
- Law of Property Act 1925 s 53(1)(b), (2)
- Law of Property Act 1925 s 53(1)(c)
- Law of Property Act 1925 ss 52, 54(2)
- Walsh v Lonsdale (1882) 21 Ch D 9
- Yaxley v Gotts [2000] Ch 162
- Law of Property (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 1989 s 2(5)
- Neocleous v Rees [2019] EWHC 2462 (Ch)
- Law of Property (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 1989 s 2(1), (4)
All 12 questions with answers
Try them above first, then read the worked answers below.
Question 1 · Contract and deed formalitiesDraft, pending solicitor review
Nadia agrees to sell her registered house to Oscar. Nadia's solicitor sends Oscar a letter setting out all the terms of the sale, which Oscar signs and returns. Nadia never signs any document, although her name is typed at the top of the letter as the seller. Oscar now seeks to enforce the sale. Which of the following best describes the position?
- There is a valid contract, because Oscar as buyer signed a document containing all the terms.
- There is a valid contract, because the typed name of the seller counts as her signature.
- There is no valid contract, because a contract for land must be made by deed.
- There is a valid contract, because the letter came from Nadia's own solicitor.
- There is no valid contract, because the document was not signed by or on behalf of Nadia.Correct answer
A contract for the sale of an interest in land must be in writing, incorporate all the expressly agreed terms and be signed by or on behalf of each party (LP(MP)A 1989 s 2(1), (3)). In Firstpost Homes Ltd v Johnson the Court of Appeal held that a party's name typed into a letter as addressee was not a signature for this purpose. Nadia has not signed, and nothing shows the solicitor signed on her behalf, so there is no contract. A signature by the buyer alone is insufficient, and no deed is needed for the contract itself.
Law basis: Law of Property (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 1989 s 2; Firstpost Homes Ltd v Johnson [1995] 1 WLR 1567 ↗Question 2 · Contract and deed formalitiesDraft, pending solicitor review
Ceri and Dafydd agree to the sale of Ceri's house for £400,000. Each signs a separate copy of the contract and the copies are exchanged. Ceri's copy includes a strip of garden at the side, but Dafydd's copy omits it. Neither notices before exchange. Which of the following best describes the position?
- There is a valid contract on the terms in the buyer's copy.
- There is a valid contract on the terms in the seller's copy.
- There is no valid contract, because the exchanged documents are not identical.Correct answer
- There is a valid contract because both parties signed a document.
- There is a valid contract which must be rectified to include the strip.
Under LP(MP)A 1989 s 2(3), where contracts are exchanged, the documents incorporating the terms must be signed by each party, and each party signs one of the documents. The exchange route assumes the parts are identical, recording a single set of agreed terms. Where the parts differ on a material term such as the land included, there is no exchange of contracts satisfying s 2 and so no contract. Rectification under s 2(4) is available only where a written document fails to record what the parties actually agreed, which needs proof of a common agreement.
Law basis: Law of Property (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 1989 s 2(1), (3) ↗Question 3 · Contract and deed formalitiesDraft, pending solicitor review
Ebony grants Fred an option to buy her warehouse in a document signed by both of them that satisfies the formality rules. A year later Fred serves a notice exercising the option. The notice is signed by Fred alone. Ebony argues that no binding sale has arisen. Which of the following best describes the position?
- The exercise is ineffective because Ebony did not sign the notice.
- The exercise is effective because the option itself is the contract.Correct answer
- The exercise is effective only if Ebony countersigns within 14 days.
- The exercise is ineffective because options must be registered first.
- The exercise is ineffective because it must be made by deed.
The grant of an option is the contract for the sale of land and must satisfy LP(MP)A 1989 s 2. In Spiro v Glencore International AG, Hoffmann J held that the exercise of the option is a unilateral act by the grantee, not the making of a new contract. The notice of exercise therefore need not be signed by both parties. Fred's signed notice is effective, and Ebony is bound to complete. Protection of the option on the register matters for priority against third parties, not for validity between the parties.
Law basis: Spiro v Glencore International AG [1991] Ch 537; Law of Property (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 1989 s 2 ↗Question 4 · Contract and deed formalitiesDraft, pending solicitor review
Gwen and Huw exchange valid contracts for the sale of Gwen's cottage. A week later, over the phone, they agree that completion will be moved forward by a month. Huw confirms this in an email signed by him, but Gwen never signs anything. Gwen then refuses to complete on the earlier date. Which of the following best describes the variation?
- It is binding because it relates only to the completion date.
- It is binding because Huw confirmed it in writing.
- It is binding because the original contract already satisfied the rules.
- It is binding because a variation of a valid contract needs no formality.
- It is not binding as a variation because it does not comply with the formality rules.Correct answer
A variation of a material term of a contract for the sale of land must itself satisfy LP(MP)A 1989 s 2: it must be in writing, incorporate the terms and be signed by or on behalf of both parties. In McCausland v Duncan Lawrie Ltd the Court of Appeal held that the completion date is a material term, so an informal variation of it is ineffective. The original contract stands with its original completion date. Huw's signature alone does not satisfy s 2, and the validity of the original contract does not carry over to an informal variation.
Law basis: McCausland v Duncan Lawrie Ltd [1997] 1 WLR 38; Law of Property (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 1989 s 2 ↗Question 5 · Contract and deed formalitiesDraft, pending solicitor review
Ian executes a transfer of his registered house to his son Jac. Ian signs the transfer at home alone. The next day his neighbour, who did not see him sign, adds her signature as a witness. The transfer states on its face that it is a deed. Which of the following best describes the transfer?
- It is a valid deed, because it states that it is a deed and was signed.
- It is a valid deed, because the witness signed within a reasonable time.
- It is not a valid deed, because Ian did not sign in the presence of the witness.Correct answer
- It is not a valid deed, because a transfer must be witnessed by a solicitor.
- It is a valid deed once it has been registered at HM Land Registry.
Under LP(MP)A 1989 s 1(2) and (3), an instrument executed by an individual is a deed only if it makes clear on its face that it is intended to be a deed, it is signed by him in the presence of a witness who attests the signature, and it is delivered as a deed. Ian signed alone and the neighbour did not witness his signature, so the attestation requirement fails. There is no requirement that the witness be a solicitor. Registration cannot cure a defective deed, as HM Land Registry would not accept the document.
Law basis: Law of Property (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 1989 s 1(2), (3) ↗Question 6 · Contract and deed formalitiesDraft, pending solicitor review
Kezia orally declares to her partner Liam that she holds her registered flat on trust for them both equally. Nothing is written down and Liam makes no contribution. When the relationship ends, Kezia denies the trust. Which of the following best describes Liam's claim to a half share?
- The declaration is valid, because a trust of land can be declared orally.
- The declaration is unenforceable, because it was not evidenced in signed writing.Correct answer
- The declaration is valid, because Liam lived in the flat with Kezia.
- The declaration is void, because only a deed can create a trust of land.
- The declaration is valid as a resulting trust in Liam's favour.
Under LPA 1925 s 53(1)(b), a declaration of trust respecting land must be manifested and proved by some writing signed by the person able to declare the trust. Kezia's oral declaration is therefore unenforceable. Section 53(2) preserves implied, resulting and constructive trusts, but Liam made no financial contribution, so no resulting trust arises, and a common intention constructive trust would need detrimental reliance, which the facts do not show. Living in the flat is not by itself detrimental reliance. No deed is required, only signed writing.
Law basis: Law of Property Act 1925 s 53(1)(b), (2)Question 7 · Contract and deed formalitiesDraft, pending solicitor review
Mali holds an equitable half share in a house under a trust. She sends her brother Nye an unsigned typed note saying she gives him her share. The trustees ask whether Nye is now entitled. Which of the following best describes the effect of the note?
- It is ineffective, because it was not signed by Mali.Correct answer
- It is effective, because equitable interests can pass informally.
- It is effective once the trustees are told about it.
- It is effective, because it was in writing.
- It is ineffective, because only a deed can transfer an equitable interest.
LPA 1925 s 53(1)(c) provides that a disposition of a subsisting equitable interest must be in writing signed by the person disposing of it or by her agent authorised in writing. Mali's note is in writing but unsigned, so the disposition is void and she keeps her share. A deed is not required, so the last option overstates the rule. Notice to the trustees affects priority between competing assignees but cannot cure a failure of formality. The rule applies to all subsisting equitable interests, not only those in land.
Law basis: Law of Property Act 1925 s 53(1)(c)Question 8 · Contract and deed formalitiesDraft, pending solicitor review
Owain agrees orally to grant Pia a two-year lease of his flat in return for a premium of £10,000 and a monthly rent. She pays the premium and moves in. Nothing is in writing. Which of the following best describes Pia's position?
- She has a legal two-year lease under the short lease exception.
- She has a legal lease because the term is under seven years.
- She has a legal lease because she has moved into possession.
- She has an equitable two-year lease under the principle in Walsh v Lonsdale.
- She does not have a legal two-year lease, because a premium was paid.Correct answer
LPA 1925 s 54(2) allows a lease of up to three years to be legal without a deed only if it takes effect in possession at the best rent reasonably obtainable without taking a fine. A premium is a fine, so the exception does not apply and a deed was required under s 52. There is no signed written contract, so Walsh v Lonsdale cannot give an equitable lease. Pia's possession and payment of rent may, however, give rise to a periodic tenancy at law. The seven-year figure relates to registration, not formality.
Law basis: Law of Property Act 1925 ss 52, 54(2); Walsh v Lonsdale (1882) 21 Ch D 9Question 9 · Contract and deed formalitiesDraft, pending solicitor review
Quinn, a builder, orally agrees with Ross that if Quinn converts Ross's house into flats free of charge, Ross will give him the ground-floor flat. Quinn does all the work. Ross then refuses to transfer the flat, pointing out that nothing was signed. Which of the following best describes Quinn's position?
- He has no claim, because the agreement does not comply with the formality rules.
- He can sue on the oral contract, because he has performed his side fully.
- He has a claim only in restitution for the value of his work.
- He may be entitled under a constructive trust despite the lack of formality.Correct answer
- He is entitled to the flat by implied easement.
An oral agreement for the sale or disposition of an interest in land is void under LP(MP)A 1989 s 2(1). However, s 2(5) preserves the creation and operation of resulting, implied or constructive trusts. In Yaxley v Gotts, on similar facts, the Court of Appeal held that a builder who carried out work in reliance on an oral promise of a flat was entitled to it under a constructive trust, the facts also giving rise to proprietary estoppel. Part performance no longer exists as a doctrine, so suing on the oral contract fails.
Law basis: Yaxley v Gotts [2000] Ch 162; Law of Property (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 1989 s 2(5) ↗Question 10 · Contract and deed formalitiesDraft, pending solicitor review
Saira and Theo negotiate the sale of Saira's land by email. Saira's final email agreeing all the terms ends with her name and contact details, inserted automatically by her email software. Theo replies accepting and types his name at the end. Saira later claims there is no contract. Which of the following best describes the position?
- There is no contract, because emails can never satisfy the formality rules.
- There is no contract, because only a handwritten signature is valid.
- There may be a contract, because an email signature can amount to signing.Correct answer
- There is no contract, because the email must be printed and signed.
- There may be a contract, but only if a deed is later executed.
LP(MP)A 1989 s 2 requires a document containing all the terms signed by each party, but it does not require a handwritten signature. In Neocleous v Rees the court held that an email ending with the sender's name and details, even though added automatically, could amount to a signature because it was intended to authenticate the email. Whether a contract exists depends on whether the exchange contains all agreed terms and shows an intention to be bound. A deed is never needed for the contract itself, and a printed copy adds nothing.
Law basis: Neocleous v Rees [2019] EWHC 2462 (Ch); Law of Property (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 1989 s 2 ↗Question 11 · Contract and deed formalitiesDraft, pending solicitor review
Ulla contracts in writing, signed by both parties, to buy Vince's house. They also agreed orally that Vince would remove a derelict shed before completion, but this term was left out of the written contract by mistake. Vince now argues the whole contract is void. Which of the following best describes the most likely outcome?
- The court may rectify the document, making the contract valid from the start.Correct answer
- The contract is valid and the shed term is simply unenforceable.
- The contract is void and cannot be saved by any means.
- The contract becomes valid only if the parties sign a fresh deed.
- The contract is valid because terms about structures are not land terms.
LP(MP)A 1989 s 2(1) requires the written contract to incorporate all expressly agreed terms, so the omission of an agreed term would normally invalidate it. However, s 2(4) provides that where the court orders rectification, the contract comes into being at the time specified in the order. If Ulla shows the parties' common agreement and a mistaken failure to record it, the court can rectify. An alternative route, where appropriate, is treating the term as a separate collateral contract (Record v Bell). A term about a shed on the land is plainly part of the land bargain.
Law basis: Law of Property (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 1989 s 2(1), (4); Record v Bell [1991] 1 WLR 853 ↗Question 12 · Contract and deed formalitiesDraft, pending solicitor review
Ash Ltd is transferring its registered warehouse to a buyer. The transfer, which states that it is executed as a deed, is signed by one director of Ash Ltd. No one else signs it and there is no witness. The company has no common seal. Which of the following best describes whether the transfer has been validly executed?
- It is valid, because a single director may always sign on behalf of a company.
- It is not valid, because a company may only execute a deed under its common seal.
- It is not valid, because a lone director's signature must be witnessed.Correct answer
- It is valid, because the transfer states on its face that it is a deed.
- It is valid once the buyer accepts delivery of the transfer.
Under the Companies Act 2006 s 44(2), a company without a seal executes a document by the signature of two authorised signatories (directors or the company secretary) or by a single director signing in the presence of a witness who attests the signature. A single unwitnessed director's signature does not meet either route. A company need not have a common seal (s 45), so that option is wrong. Stating that the document is a deed and delivering it are further requirements, but they cannot cure defective execution.
Law basis: Companies Act 2006 ss 44, 46 ↗More Land Law topics
Back to all Land Law questions, or sit a timed mock.