Law covered in these questions
- Re Ellenborough Park [1956] Ch 131
- Prescription Act 1832 s 2
- Tehidy Minerals Ltd v Norman [1971] 2 QB 528
- Regency Villas Title Ltd v Diamond Resorts (Europe) Ltd [2018] UKSC 57
- Hill v Tupper (1863) 2 H & C 121
- Moncrieff v Jamieson [2007] UKHL 42
- Batchelor v Marlow [2001] EWCA Civ 1051
- Copeland v Greenhalf [1952] Ch 488
- Aldred's Case (1610) 9 Co Rep 57b
- Harris v De Pinna (1886) 33 Ch D 238
- Regis Property Co Ltd v Redman [1956] 2 QB 612
- Crow v Wood [1971] 1 QB 77
- MRA Engineering Ltd v Trimster Co Ltd (1987) 56 P & CR 1
- Nickerson v Barraclough [1981] Ch 426
All 22 questions with answers
Try them above first, then read the worked answers below.
Question 1 · EasementsDraft, pending solicitor review
Jo owns a house with a garden next to a field owned by Ken. For many years Jo has crossed the field to reach a footpath. Which is NOT a requirement for a right to be an easement?
- That the easement accommodates the dominant tenement.
- That the right is exercisable only by the owner of the dominant land personally and not by their successors.Correct answer
- That there is a dominant and a servient tenement.
- That the dominant and servient tenements are not both owned and occupied by the same person.
- That the right is capable of forming the subject matter of a grant.
The four requirements are a dominant and servient tenement, accommodation of the dominant tenement, separate ownership or occupation, and capability of forming the subject matter of a grant. An easement must be capable of passing to successors.
Law basis: Re Ellenborough Park [1956] Ch 131Question 2 · EasementsDraft, pending solicitor review
Lara has crossed her neighbour's field to reach the road for 22 years, openly, without force and without ever asking permission. The use has never been interrupted. Which statement best describes her position?
- She cannot claim, because easements cannot be acquired by long use.
- She can claim only if she used the path secretly, to avoid objection.
- She can claim only if the neighbour gave her permission at the start.
- She can claim a right of way by prescription, because 20 years' continuous use as of right, which means without force, secrecy or permission, is enough.Correct answer
- She cannot claim, because prescription needs at least 100 years' use.
An easement can be acquired by prescription through 20 years' continuous use as of right: nec vi, nec clam, nec precario. Use with permission, by force or in secret does not count.
Law basis: Prescription Act 1832 s 2; Tehidy Minerals Ltd v Norman [1971] 2 QB 528Question 3 · EasementsDraft, pending solicitor review
A developer laid out a square of houses around a private garden. Each conveyance granted the buyer the right to use the garden for recreation and enjoyment, in common with the other owners. A later owner of the garden argues that a right of mere recreation cannot be an easement. Which of the following best describes the position?
- It cannot be an easement, because recreation confers no benefit on land.
- It cannot be an easement, because it is too vague.
- It can be an easement only if the garden is also used as a path.
- It is a licence, because it is shared with many people.
- It can be an easement, because it accommodates the houses as a communal garden.Correct answer
In Re Ellenborough Park the Court of Appeal held that a right to use a communal garden was a valid easement. There was a dominant and servient tenement, the right accommodated the houses as it was connected with their normal enjoyment as residences, the tenements were owned by different persons, and the right was capable of forming the subject matter of a grant, being sufficiently definite. In Regency Villas v Diamond Resorts the Supreme Court confirmed that purely recreational and sporting rights can be easements. Sharing with others does not prevent an easement.
Law basis: Re Ellenborough Park [1956] Ch 131; Regency Villas Title Ltd v Diamond Resorts (Europe) Ltd [2018] UKSC 57Question 4 · EasementsDraft, pending solicitor review
Paul leases land beside a canal and runs a boat-hire business. The canal company grants him, by deed, the exclusive right to put pleasure boats on the canal for hire. A rival business puts boats on the canal, and Paul sues the rival, claiming an easement. Which of the following best describes Paul's right?
- It is an easement, because it was granted by deed.
- It is not an easement, as it does not accommodate land.Correct answer
- It is an easement, because Paul's land adjoins the canal.
- It is a profit à prendre, because it involves the use of water.
- It is an easement, because it is exclusive.
An easement must accommodate the dominant tenement, meaning it must benefit the land itself, not merely the owner's personal or business interests. In Hill v Tupper, on these facts, the court held that an exclusive right to put pleasure boats on a canal was not an easement but a personal licence, enforceable only against the grantor. It was a commercial monopoly rather than a right benefiting the land, so Paul cannot sue the rival. A deed and adjoining land are insufficient on their own. A profit involves taking something from the land, which is not this case.
Law basis: Hill v Tupper (1863) 2 H & C 121; Re Ellenborough Park [1956] Ch 131Question 5 · EasementsDraft, pending solicitor review
Quinn owns a house next to a large private car park owned by Rae. Quinn's deed of grant gives him the right to park one car anywhere in the car park, which has 80 spaces, in common with others. Rae argues that a parking right can never be an easement. Which of the following best describes the position?
- It cannot be an easement, because parking always excludes the owner.
- It is a licence, because parking is a personal right.
- It cannot be an easement, because it is not attached to a fixed space.
- It can be an easement, because Rae keeps reasonable use of her land.Correct answer
- It can be an easement only if Quinn pays an annual fee.
A right to park can be an easement provided it does not deprive the servient owner of the reasonable use of the land, or under the earlier test, of possession and control. In Moncrieff v Jamieson the House of Lords accepted that a right to park could exist as an easement, and suggested the test is whether the servient owner retains possession and control. A right to park one car anywhere among 80 spaces leaves Rae with ample use, unlike Batchelor v Marlow, where the right to park six cars on a small area for most of the working day was an ouster. Payment is not required.
Law basis: Moncrieff v Jamieson [2007] UKHL 42; Batchelor v Marlow [2001] EWCA Civ 1051Question 6 · EasementsDraft, pending solicitor review
For many years Sian, a wheelwright, has stored customers' vehicles awaiting repair on a narrow strip of her neighbour Tom's land, using the whole strip and occasionally leaving some there for weeks. She claims an easement of storage. Which of the following best describes the likely outcome?
- She has an easement, because storage rights can exist as easements.
- She has no easement, because storage benefits her business only.
- She has an easement, because her use was long and continuous.
- She has no easement, because her use ousts Tom.Correct answer
- She has an easement only if the strip is fenced.
In Copeland v Greenhalf, on similar facts, the court held that a claim to store an unlimited number of vehicles on a strip of land amounted to a claim to the whole beneficial user of the strip, effectively joint occupation, and could not be an easement. An easement cannot exclude the servient owner from the land (the 'ouster' principle). Storage rights limited in extent can be easements, as in Wright v Macadam, so the issue is degree. Length of use cannot convert a possessory claim into an easement, although it might support a claim in adverse possession.
Law basis: Copeland v Greenhalf [1952] Ch 488; Moncrieff v Jamieson [2007] UKHL 42Question 7 · EasementsDraft, pending solicitor review
Uma's house has enjoyed an uninterrupted view of the sea for 40 years. Her neighbour Vic obtains planning permission to build an extension that will block the view. Uma claims an easement of view by long use. Which of the following best describes her claim?
- She has an easement of view by prescription after 20 years.
- She has an easement of view under the Prescription Act 1832.
- She has no easement only because she never paid for the view.
- She has an easement, because Vic's extension needs planning permission.
- She has no easement, because a right to a view cannot exist as an easement.Correct answer
A right to a view, or to a general flow of air, cannot exist as an easement because it is too vague and would unduly restrict the use of neighbouring land (Aldred's Case; see also Harris v De Pinna). Long enjoyment cannot therefore create such a right by prescription. Uma could protect a view only through a restrictive covenant, such as a covenant against building. By contrast, a right to light through a defined window can be an easement. Planning permission does not affect private property rights in either direction.
Law basis: Aldred's Case (1610) 9 Co Rep 57b; Harris v De Pinna (1886) 33 Ch D 238Question 8 · EasementsDraft, pending solicitor review
Wyn's deed grants him a right of way over his neighbour Xena's drive and also states that Xena 'will keep the drive in good repair at her own expense'. The drive deteriorates, and Wyn sues Xena for failing to repair it as part of his easement. Which of the following best describes the position?
- Xena must repair, because the repair obligation is part of the easement.
- The easement imposes no duty to repair, but Wyn may repair it.Correct answer
- Xena must repair, because a servient owner must maintain an easement.
- Wyn's easement fails because it contains a positive obligation.
- Xena must repair only if Wyn contributes half the cost.
An easement generally cannot require the servient owner to spend money or do anything positive (Regis Property Co v Redman). The obligation to repair the drive is therefore not part of the easement, although it may be enforceable as a contractual covenant between the original parties. The easement itself remains valid; the dominant owner has an ancillary right to enter the servient land to carry out repairs needed to exercise the right of way. The recognised anomaly is the obligation to fence (Crow v Wood), which does not apply here.
Law basis: Regis Property Co Ltd v Redman [1956] 2 QB 612; Crow v Wood [1971] 1 QB 77Question 9 · EasementsDraft, pending solicitor review
Yara sells part of her land to Zack. The part sold has its own access to a public road, but it is a steep, narrow lane that is difficult for large vehicles. A more convenient route lies over Yara's retained land. The transfer is silent about access. Zack claims an easement of necessity over the convenient route. Which of the following best describes his claim?
- He has no easement of necessity, because the land is not landlocked.Correct answer
- He has an easement of necessity, because the existing access is inconvenient.
- He has an easement of necessity, because it is needed for reasonable enjoyment.
- He has an easement of necessity, but must pay Yara for it.
- He has no easement, because easements cannot be implied on a sale of part.
An easement of necessity arises only where, without it, the land cannot be used at all, typically where land is landlocked. Inconvenience is not enough (MRA Engineering Ltd v Trimster Co Ltd). The implication is based on the presumed intention of the parties (Nickerson v Barraclough). Zack's land has its own access to a public road, so no easement of necessity arises. The 'reasonable enjoyment' test belongs to Wheeldon v Burrows, which requires prior use of the route by the common owner. Easements can be implied on a sale of part.
Law basis: MRA Engineering Ltd v Trimster Co Ltd (1987) 56 P & CR 1; Nickerson v Barraclough [1981] Ch 426Question 10 · EasementsDraft, pending solicitor review
Ali takes a lease of a cellar from Bea, who owns the building, for use as a restaurant, as both parties know. Public health regulations require a ventilation duct for a restaurant, which can only be installed on Bea's retained part of the building. The lease is silent. Bea refuses to allow it. Which of the following best describes Ali's position?
- He has an implied easement based on the common intention of the parties.Correct answer
- He has no right, because the lease does not mention a duct.
- He has an easement of necessity, because the cellar is landlocked.
- He must apply for planning permission before claiming any right.
- He may terminate the lease but has no easement.
An easement may be implied where it is necessary to give effect to the common intention of the parties as to the use of the land (Pwllbach Colliery v Woodman). In Wong v Beaumont Property Trust Ltd, a lease of a cellar for use as a restaurant gave rise to an implied easement to install a ventilation duct over the landlord's property, because the parties intended the premises to be used as a restaurant and that use was impossible without it. This is distinct from necessity, which concerns land that cannot be used at all, such as landlocked land.
Law basis: Wong v Beaumont Property Trust Ltd [1965] 1 QB 173; Pwllbach Colliery Co Ltd v Woodman [1915] AC 634Question 11 · EasementsDraft, pending solicitor review
Cara owned two adjoining plots. She regularly drove across Plot 1 along a visible, made-up track to reach a garage on Plot 2. She sold Plot 2 to Dan, and the transfer says nothing about access. The track is the only convenient way to the garage. Which of the following best describes Dan's position?
- He has no right, because Cara could not have an easement over her own land.
- He has an easement of necessity, because the garage is otherwise unusable.
- He is likely to acquire an easement under the rule in Wheeldon v Burrows.Correct answer
- He has a licence only, revocable by Cara.
- He must wait 20 years to acquire an easement by prescription.
Under Wheeldon v Burrows, on a sale of part, the buyer acquires as easements those quasi-easements over the retained land which were continuous and apparent, necessary for the reasonable enjoyment of the land sold, and used by the common owner at the time of the grant for the benefit of the part sold. A visible made-up track used by Cara to reach the garage satisfies these conditions. It does not matter that Cara could not have an easement over her own land; the rule converts quasi-easements into easements on the sale. Strict necessity is not required.
Law basis: Wheeldon v Burrows (1879) 12 Ch D 31Question 12 · EasementsDraft, pending solicitor review
Eli owned a house and a field. He used a path across the field to reach the house's back gate. He sold the field to Fay, keeping the house, and the transfer did not reserve any right of way. The house also has front access to the road. Eli now claims a right of way over the field. Which of the following best describes his claim?
- He has an implied easement under the rule in Wheeldon v Burrows.
- He has an easement, because he used the path before the sale.
- He has an easement under section 62 of the Law of Property Act 1925.
- He has an easement of necessity, because he used the path.
- He is unlikely to have a right, as a seller must expressly reserve easements.Correct answer
A grantor may not derogate from his grant, so the courts are reluctant to imply reservations in the seller's favour. The rule in Wheeldon v Burrows applies to grants to the buyer, not to reservations for the seller, and LPA 1925 s 62 operates only in favour of the land conveyed. An implied reservation may arise only by necessity or common intention. The house has front access, so there is no necessity, and nothing suggests a common intention. A seller who wants rights over the land sold must reserve them expressly.
Law basis: Wheeldon v Burrows (1879) 12 Ch D 31; Law of Property Act 1925 s 62Question 13 · EasementsDraft, pending solicitor review
Gil rented a flat from Hal, who owned the whole building and garden. During the tenancy Hal allowed Gil, as a favour, to store coal in a shed in the garden. Hal later granted Gil a new lease of the flat by deed, which said nothing about the shed. Hal now wants Gil to stop using the shed. Which of the following best describes the position?
- The new lease converted the permission into an easement under section 62.Correct answer
- Gil's permission was a licence and can be revoked at any time.
- Gil has an easement only if the new lease expressly mentions the shed.
- Gil has an easement by prescription.
- Gil has an easement of necessity to store coal.
LPA 1925 s 62 implies into a conveyance of land, including a lease by deed, all liberties, privileges, easements, rights and advantages appertaining to or enjoyed with the land at the time of the conveyance, unless excluded. In Wright v Macadam, on similar facts, a permission to store coal in a shed, enjoyed by the tenant at the time of a new lease, was converted into an easement by s 62. The right must be capable of being an easement. Express exclusion of s 62 in the new lease would have prevented this.
Law basis: Wright v Macadam [1949] 2 KB 744; Law of Property Act 1925 s 62Question 14 · EasementsDraft, pending solicitor review
Ivo's house has the benefit of a legal right of way over his neighbour Jo's field. Ivo buys Jo's field and occupies both properties for several years. He then sells the field to Kai, and the transfer says nothing about any right of way. Ivo claims the old easement still exists. Which of the following best describes the position?
- The easement continues, because it was a legal easement granted by deed.
- The easement was extinguished when the field and house came into common ownership and possession.Correct answer
- The easement was suspended and revived automatically on the sale.
- The easement continues, because it is registered against the field.
- The easement was abandoned, because Ivo stopped using it.
An easement requires the dominant and servient tenements to be owned or occupied by different persons. Where both come into the same ownership and possession, the easement is extinguished by unity of seisin, as one cannot have an easement over one's own land. It does not revive automatically when the land is sold again. Ivo would need an express reservation in the transfer to Kai, or would have to rely on an implied reservation, which is difficult for a seller. Abandonment requires a clear intention never to use the right again, which is not the basis here.
Law basis: Re Ellenborough Park [1956] Ch 131Question 15 · EasementsDraft, pending solicitor review
Lily owned a farmhouse and an adjoining cottage, and occupied both. She regularly used a visible gravel track across the farmhouse land to reach the cottage. She sold the cottage to Matt by a conveyance that did not exclude section 62 of the Law of Property Act 1925 and did not mention the track. Before the sale, the cottage had never been occupied separately. Which of the following best describes Matt's position?
- He cannot rely on section 62, because there was no prior diversity of occupation.
- He has an easement only if the track is strictly necessary.
- He may acquire an easement under section 62, because the use was continuous and apparent.Correct answer
- He has no easement, because Lily could not have one over her own land.
- He must rely on prescription, because the conveyance was silent.
LPA 1925 s 62 implies into a conveyance the rights enjoyed with the land conveyed. Traditionally it required prior diversity of occupation, but in Platt v Crouch and Wood v Waddington the Court of Appeal held that s 62 can operate without prior diversity where the right was continuous and apparent, such as a visible made-up track used for the benefit of the land sold. Matt may therefore acquire an easement. The conveyance did not exclude s 62. Wheeldon v Burrows might also apply, but strict necessity is not required for either route.
Law basis: Platt v Crouch [2003] EWCA Civ 1110; Wood v Waddington [2015] EWCA Civ 538; Law of Property Act 1925 s 62Question 16 · EasementsDraft, pending solicitor review
From 1980 until 2005, Nell openly drove across her neighbour's field to reach her barn, without permission and without objection. She then stopped for several years because she stopped farming. She resumed use in 2022, and her neighbour now objects. Which of the following best describes the most suitable basis for Nell's claim to an easement?
- Lost modern grant, based on 20 years' use as of right at any time.Correct answer
- The Prescription Act 1832, as she has 20 years' use next before the action.
- Common law prescription, because her use dates back to time immemorial.
- Necessity, because the barn has no other access.
- No claim is possible, because her use was interrupted.
Under the doctrine of lost modern grant, the court presumes that a grant was made and lost where there has been 20 years' use as of right. The 20 years can be any period; they need not be immediately before the claim (Tehidy Minerals v Norman). Nell used the track as of right from 1980 to 2005, so she can rely on lost modern grant. The Prescription Act 1832 requires 20 years' use 'next before' the action, which she lacks because of the gap. Common law prescription is defeated by showing the right could not have existed since 1189.
Law basis: Dalton v Angus & Co (1881) 6 App Cas 740; Tehidy Minerals Ltd v Norman [1971] 2 QB 528Question 17 · EasementsDraft, pending solicitor review
For 25 years Ola has used a path across her neighbour Pat's garden. Every January, Ola pays Pat £20 and Pat sends her a letter saying she may use the path for another year. Ola now claims an easement by prescription. Which of the following best describes her claim?
- She has an easement, because she has used the path for over 20 years.
- She has an easement, because her payments show a contractual right.
- She has no easement, because her use was with permission and not as of right.Correct answer
- She has an easement under the Prescription Act 1832.
- She has no easement, because she paid only a nominal sum.
Prescription requires use 'as of right', meaning without force, without secrecy and without permission (nec vi, nec clam, nec precario). Use by permission, renewed each year in return for payment, is precario and cannot found a prescriptive easement (Gardner v Hodgson's Kingston Brewery Co Ltd). It does not matter how long the use continued. Ola may have a contractual licence, but that is personal and does not create an easement. The size of the payment is irrelevant; the issue is that her use was permitted.
Law basis: Gardner v Hodgson's Kingston Brewery Co Ltd [1903] AC 229Question 18 · EasementsDraft, pending solicitor review
Rex owns a car park and has displayed prominent signs for over 20 years stating 'Private car park. For customers only'. Sam, who is not a customer, has parked there daily throughout, ignoring the signs. Rex never physically stopped him. Sam claims a prescriptive easement to park. Which of the following best describes his claim?
- He fails, because his use contrary to the signs was not as of right.Correct answer
- He succeeds, because his use was open and continuous for 20 years.
- He succeeds, because Rex never physically prevented him.
- He fails, because parking can never be an easement.
- He succeeds, because signs alone cannot prevent prescription.
Use must be without force (nec vi) to be as of right. In Winterburn v Bennett the Court of Appeal held that use in the face of clear and continuous signs prohibiting it is contentious and therefore not as of right, even though the owner took no physical steps. The landowner need not resort to physical obstruction or litigation; displaying appropriate signs is sufficient to show the use is not acquiesced in. Sam's claim therefore fails. Parking can be an easement in principle (Moncrieff v Jamieson), so the problem is the nature of his use.
Law basis: Winterburn v Bennett [2016] EWCA Civ 482Question 19 · EasementsDraft, pending solicitor review
Tia has rented a cottage from Uri for 30 years under a series of leases. Throughout, she has walked across a field that Uri also owns to reach the village shop. Uri now plans to fence the field. Tia claims a prescriptive easement over it. Which of the following best describes her claim?
- She succeeds, because her use was open and without permission for 30 years.
- She fails, because easements cannot benefit leasehold land.
- She succeeds under the Prescription Act 1832.
- She fails, because a tenant cannot prescribe against her landlord.Correct answer
- She succeeds, but only for the remainder of her lease.
Prescription is based on the presumed grant of an easement by a fee simple owner to another fee simple owner. A tenant cannot acquire an easement by prescription over other land belonging to her own landlord, because any use is referable to the landlord-tenant relationship and the tenant cannot presume a grant against her own landlord (Gayford v Moffatt). Easements can benefit leasehold land if expressly or impliedly granted, so that option is wrong. Tia could claim an implied grant if one arose under her lease, but not prescription.
Law basis: Gayford v Moffatt (1868) LR 4 Ch App 133Question 20 · EasementsDraft, pending solicitor review
Vince's kitchen window has received light across his neighbour Will's land, without interruption, for 25 years. Some years ago Will orally told Vince he did not mind the window. Will now plans an extension that will substantially block the light. Which of the following best describes Vince's position?
- He has no easement, because Will gave oral permission.
- He has an easement only if the window was built with planning permission.
- He has no easement, because light cannot be the subject of an easement.
- He has an easement only if he can show 40 years' use.
- He has an easement of light, as the consent was only oral.Correct answer
Under the Prescription Act 1832 s 3, where access of light to a building has been actually enjoyed without interruption for 20 years, the right becomes absolute and indefeasible unless it was enjoyed by consent or agreement expressly made or given for that purpose by deed or writing. Unlike other easements, oral permission does not defeat a claim to light. Vince has 25 years' uninterrupted enjoyment and only oral consent, so he has a right to light and may seek an injunction or damages if the extension causes an actionable obstruction.
Law basis: Prescription Act 1832 s 3Question 21 · EasementsDraft, pending solicitor review
Xia has a right of way over Yan's drive to reach her house. She demolishes the house and builds a block of 30 flats, whose residents and visitors now use the drive constantly. Yan seeks an injunction. Which of the following best describes the likely outcome?
- Xia's use is permitted, because an easement can be used with any intensity.
- Xia's easement is extinguished entirely by the redevelopment.
- Xia's use is permitted, because the dominant land is the same land.
- Xia's use is likely to be excessive and restrainable.Correct answer
- Xia's use is excessive only if the easement was granted by deed.
For an easement acquired by prescription or implication, the question is whether there has been a radical change in the character or identity of the dominant land, as opposed to a mere change or intensification in use, and whether the change will result in a substantial increase in the burden on the servient land (McAdams Homes Ltd v Robinson). Replacing a single house with 30 flats is likely to satisfy both limbs, so Yan may obtain an injunction or damages. The easement is not extinguished; the excessive use is restrained. For express grants, the scope depends on construing the grant.
Law basis: McAdams Homes Ltd v Robinson [2004] EWCA Civ 214Question 22 · EasementsDraft, pending solicitor review
Zoe has a right of way over Amy's track to reach Field A. Zoe buys Field B, which adjoins Field A, and starts using the track to reach Field A and then drive on across it to Field B, where she has built a workshop. Amy objects. Which of the following best describes the position?
- Zoe may use the track, because she passes through Field A.
- Zoe may not use the easement to benefit Field B.Correct answer
- Zoe may use the track, because the burden is the same.
- Zoe's easement now benefits both fields automatically.
- Zoe may use it for Field B only if she pays Amy compensation.
An easement may be used only for the benefit of the dominant tenement. In Harris v Flower, the court held that a right of way to one plot could not be used to gain access to additional land beyond it, even if the route crossed the dominant land. Zoe's use for the benefit of Field B, which is not part of the dominant tenement, is outside the easement. It does not matter that the additional burden may be small. Zoe would need an express grant of a right of way for Field B.
Law basis: Harris v Flower (1904) 74 LJ Ch 127More Land Law topics
Back to all Land Law questions, or sit a timed mock.