Law covered in these questions
- Crime and Disorder Act 1998, s 51(1)
- Magistrates' Courts Act 1980, s 17A
- Sentencing Act 2020, s 14
- Magistrates' Courts Act 1980, s 19
- Sentencing Council Allocation Guideline
- Bail Act 1976, s 4 and Sch 1
- Bail Act 1976, Sch 1, Pt 1, paras 2 and 9
- Bail Act 1976, Sch 1, Pt 1, para 9
- Bail Act 1976, Sch 1, Pt 1, para 1A
- Bail Act 1976, Sch 1, Pt 1, para 2A
- Criminal Justice and Public Order Act 1994, s 25
- Coroners and Justice Act 2009, ss 114 and 115
- Bail Act 1976, s 3(6)
- Bail Act 1976, Sch 1, Pt IIA, paras 1 to 3
All 16 questions with answers
Try them above first, then read the worked answers below.
Question 1 · First hearings, allocation and bailDraft, pending solicitor review
Dee, aged 30, is charged with robbery, an indictable-only offence, and appears before the magistrates' court the next morning. Her solicitor asks the court to deal with the case summarily, as she intends to plead guilty and has no previous convictions. Which of the following best describes what the magistrates must do?
- Send her case to the Crown Court forthwith, without taking a plea.Correct answer
- Adjourn for a pre-sentence report before deciding where she should be dealt with.
- Take her guilty plea and then commit her to the Crown Court for sentence.
- Hold an allocation hearing to decide whether summary trial is more suitable.
- Take her plea and sentence her, as she has no previous convictions.
Under s 51(1) of the Crime and Disorder Act 1998, where an adult appears or is brought before a magistrates' court charged with an offence triable only on indictment, the court must send her forthwith to the Crown Court for trial. The magistrates have no jurisdiction to try or sentence robbery, so they cannot take a plea or hold an allocation hearing. Dee's intended guilty plea will be entered at the plea and trial preparation hearing in the Crown Court, and early indication may attract the maximum credit under the guilty plea guideline. The magistrates will deal with bail and may give directions.
Law basis: Crime and Disorder Act 1998, s 51(1) ↗Question 2 · First hearings, allocation and bailDraft, pending solicitor review
Eli is charged with theft from his employer of £12,000, an either-way offence. At his first appearance before the magistrates, he is asked to indicate his plea and says he will plead guilty. Which of the following best describes what happens next?
- The court may sentence him, but cannot commit him to the Crown Court once he has pleaded.
- He may withdraw his indication at any time before sentence without permission.
- He is treated as pleading guilty, but must be sent to the Crown Court for trial.
- The court must hold an allocation hearing before taking any plea from him.
- He is treated as pleading guilty; the court may sentence him or commit him for sentence.Correct answer
Under s 17A of the Magistrates' Courts Act 1980 (plea before venue), the court asks an adult charged with an either-way offence to indicate a plea. If he indicates guilty, the court proceeds as if he had pleaded guilty at a summary trial, so he is convicted. The court may then sentence him or, if it considers its powers inadequate, commit him to the Crown Court for sentence under s 14 of the Sentencing Act 2020. Allocation under s 19 only takes place if he indicates not guilty or gives no indication. A guilty plea may be withdrawn only with the court's leave, before sentence.
Law basis: Magistrates' Courts Act 1980, s 17A; Sentencing Act 2020, s 14 ↗Question 3 · First hearings, allocation and bailDraft, pending solicitor review
Fay, aged 35, indicates a not guilty plea to an either-way offence of fraud. At the allocation hearing the prosecution says the case involves several victims but is straightforward and that the likely sentence, even after trial, is well within the magistrates' powers. Which of the following best describes how the court should approach allocation?
- It should accept jurisdiction only if both prosecution and defence agree that it is appropriate.
- It should generally keep the case for summary trial, as the sentence is likely to be within its powers.Correct answer
- It should accept jurisdiction only if Fay consents and also has no previous convictions.
- It should send the case to the Crown Court, because fraud cases are presumed unsuitable for summary trial.
- It should send the case to the Crown Court, because any fraud involving several victims is serious.
Under s 19 of the Magistrates' Courts Act 1980, the court decides whether an either-way offence is more suitable for summary trial or trial on indictment, considering representations and any previous convictions, and applying the Sentencing Council's allocation guideline. The guideline states that, in general, either-way offences should be tried summarily unless the outcome would clearly be a sentence in excess of the court's powers, or the case involves unusual legal, procedural or factual complexity. Fay's case is straightforward and within the magistrates' powers, so summary trial is appropriate. There is no presumption that fraud must be sent to the Crown Court, and the parties' agreement is not required.
Law basis: Magistrates' Courts Act 1980, s 19; Sentencing Council Allocation Guideline ↗Question 4 · First hearings, allocation and bailDraft, pending solicitor review
Gus, aged 40, is charged with an either-way offence of theft and appears before the magistrates for the first time. He has a settled address, a job and no previous convictions. The prosecution does not object to bail but the clerk asks whether Gus has to show why he should be granted bail. Which of the following best describes the position?
- Gus has a right to bail only if the prosecution consents to him being granted it.
- Gus has a right to bail only because the offence is triable either way, not indictable.
- Gus has no right to bail until the court has decided where his case will be tried.
- Gus must show that he will surrender to custody before he can be granted bail.
- Gus has a general right to bail, unless one of the statutory exceptions applies.Correct answer
Section 4 of the Bail Act 1976 gives a general right to bail to a defendant accused of an offence who appears before a court, subject to the exceptions in Schedule 1. The burden is not on the defendant to justify bail; rather, bail may be refused only if the court is satisfied that an exception applies, such as substantial grounds for believing he would fail to surrender, commit further offences or interfere with witnesses. The prosecution's consent is not required, although its position is relevant. The right applies to indictable offences too, subject to specific restrictions such as those for murder and for certain repeat offences.
Law basis: Bail Act 1976, s 4 and Sch 1 ↗Question 5 · First hearings, allocation and bailDraft, pending solicitor review
Hal is charged with burglary of a dwelling. He has five previous convictions for failing to surrender and two for burglary committed while on bail. The prosecution opposes bail. Which of the following best describes the test the magistrates must apply?
- Whether the prosecution can prove beyond reasonable doubt that he would abscond.
- Whether it is more likely than not that he would commit an offence while on bail.
- Whether he would be likely to receive a custodial sentence if he were convicted.
- Whether there are substantial grounds to believe he would abscond or reoffend.Correct answer
- Whether there is any risk at all that he would fail to surrender if granted bail.
Under Schedule 1, Part 1, para 2 of the Bail Act 1976, a defendant charged with an imprisonable offence need not be granted bail if the court is satisfied that there are substantial grounds for believing that, if released on bail, he would fail to surrender to custody, commit an offence while on bail, or interfere with witnesses or otherwise obstruct the course of justice. Hal's record of failing to surrender and offending on bail will be highly relevant under para 9. The standard is 'substantial grounds for believing', not proof beyond reasonable doubt or a mere possibility. The likely sentence is a factor but not the test itself.
Law basis: Bail Act 1976, Sch 1, Pt 1, paras 2 and 9Question 6 · First hearings, allocation and bailDraft, pending solicitor review
Ivy is charged with assault occasioning actual bodily harm on a neighbour. The prosecution objects to bail on the ground that she may interfere with the neighbour, who is the main witness. In deciding whether there are substantial grounds for that belief, which of the following best describes the matters the court must consider?
- Only Ivy's previous convictions and whether she has ever failed to surrender before.
- Only whether Ivy lives close enough to the neighbour to make contact with her likely.
- The offence, her character and ties, her bail record and the strength of the evidence.Correct answer
- Only the seriousness of the offence charged and the likely sentence on conviction.
- Only the views of the neighbour and the strength of the prosecution evidence against Ivy.
Schedule 1, Part 1, para 9 of the Bail Act 1976 requires the court, when deciding whether an exception applies, to have regard to such of the following as appear relevant: the nature and seriousness of the offence and the probable method of dealing with it; the defendant's character, antecedents, associations and community ties; her record of complying with previous grants of bail; the strength of the evidence; and, where relevant, risk of physical or mental injury to others. The court must consider all relevant factors, not just one. Ivy's proximity to the neighbour is relevant, but only as part of this wider assessment.
Law basis: Bail Act 1976, Sch 1, Pt 1, para 9Question 7 · First hearings, allocation and bailDraft, pending solicitor review
Jo, aged 22, is charged with a minor theft from a shop worth £60. She has two previous convictions for similar thefts, both dealt with by fines. The prosecution objects to bail, saying she will commit further offences. The court considers there is no real prospect of a custodial sentence. Which of the following best describes the court's position?
- It may refuse bail, because she has previous convictions for similar offences.
- It cannot refuse bail, because theft is never an imprisonable offence for an adult.
- It may refuse bail, because she is likely to commit further offences while on bail.
- It cannot refuse bail on that ground, as there is no real prospect of custody.Correct answer
- It may refuse bail, but only if she has failed to surrender in previous proceedings.
Schedule 1, Part 1, para 1A of the Bail Act 1976 provides that the general grounds in para 2 (fail to surrender, commit offences, interfere with witnesses) do not apply where the defendant is 18 or over, has not been convicted in the proceedings, and it appears to the court that there is no real prospect that she will be sentenced to a custodial sentence. This 'no real prospect of custody' restriction means that the prosecution's fear of reoffending cannot justify refusal. Other exceptions, for example for her own protection or for risk of domestic violence, are not engaged. Theft is imprisonable in principle, so that option is wrong.
Law basis: Bail Act 1976, Sch 1, Pt 1, para 1AQuestion 8 · First hearings, allocation and bailDraft, pending solicitor review
Kev, aged 30, is charged with burglary, an either-way offence. At the time of the alleged burglary he was on bail for an unrelated theft charge. The prosecution opposes bail. Which of the following best describes the effect of his being on bail at the time?
- The court must refuse bail, because offending on bail creates an absolute bar.
- The court may take it into account only after he has been convicted of the burglary.
- The court need not grant bail, but only if he also has previous convictions for burglary.
- The court must grant bail, because he has not yet been convicted of the earlier theft.
- The court need not grant bail, as the offence is alleged to have been committed on bail.Correct answer
Schedule 1, Part 1, para 2A of the Bail Act 1976 provides that a defendant need not be granted bail if the offence is indictable or triable either way and it appears to the court that he was on bail in criminal proceedings on the date of the offence. This is a free-standing exception, so Kev's bail status alone can justify refusal, though it is not mandatory. It does not depend on his conviction for the earlier matter. The court will still consider all the circumstances under para 9. There is no absolute bar to bail, so the 'must refuse' option overstates the rule.
Law basis: Bail Act 1976, Sch 1, Pt 1, para 2AQuestion 9 · First hearings, allocation and bailDraft, pending solicitor review
Lex is charged with rape. He has a previous conviction for rape from twelve years ago, for which he served a custodial sentence. His solicitor applies to the magistrates for bail, stressing that he has strong family ties and has complied with all bail conditions so far. Which of the following best describes the test for bail?
- Bail must be refused, because a previous rape conviction means bail is never available.
- Bail may be granted only if the court finds exceptional circumstances justify it.Correct answer
- Bail must be granted unless there are substantial grounds to believe he would reoffend.
- Bail may be granted only by a High Court judge, because the charge is one of rape.
- Bail may be granted only if his previous conviction was within the last ten years.
Section 25 of the Criminal Justice and Public Order Act 1994 provides that a person charged with or convicted of murder, attempted murder, manslaughter, rape, attempted rape or certain other serious sexual offences, who has a previous conviction for any such offence, shall be granted bail only if the court is satisfied that there are exceptional circumstances which justify it. Lex's previous rape conviction triggers this restriction, however long ago it was (a previous manslaughter conviction counts only if it led to custody). Bail is not absolutely prohibited, so the 'never' option is wrong, but the ordinary presumption is reversed. Family ties and good compliance may contribute to exceptional circumstances.
Law basis: Criminal Justice and Public Order Act 1994, s 25 ↗Question 10 · First hearings, allocation and bailDraft, pending solicitor review
Mo, aged 25, is charged with murder and appears before the magistrates' court the morning after charge. His solicitor wants to make a full bail application at that hearing, arguing that Mo has strong community ties and a weak case against him. Which of the following best describes the magistrates' power?
- They may grant bail if satisfied there is no significant risk he would commit an offence.
- They may grant bail, but only with conditions including a substantial surety.
- They cannot hear the application, because bail is never available for a charge of murder.
- They may grant bail if the prosecution does not object and Mo has no convictions.
- They cannot grant bail, as bail for murder can only be decided by a Crown Court judge.Correct answer
Section 115 of the Coroners and Justice Act 2009 provides that a person charged with murder may not be granted bail except by order of a judge of the Crown Court. The magistrates must send the case to the Crown Court under s 51 of the Crime and Disorder Act 1998 and remand Mo in custody; the Crown Court must then decide bail as soon as reasonably practicable, usually within 48 hours. Bail for murder is available in principle, but under s 114 it requires the court to be of the opinion that there is no significant risk of the defendant committing an offence likely to cause physical or mental injury. That test is for the Crown Court judge, not the magistrates.
Law basis: Coroners and Justice Act 2009, ss 114 and 115 ↗Question 11 · First hearings, allocation and bailDraft, pending solicitor review
Nia is charged with a serious fraud. The court has substantial grounds for believing she might fail to surrender, because she has a home in Spain and a lot of money abroad. Her solicitor argues that conditions could address the risk. Which of the following best describes the court's approach?
- It may grant bail with conditions, such as passport surrender, if they meet the risk.Correct answer
- It must refuse bail, because conditions cannot address a risk of failing to surrender.
- It may grant bail with conditions, but only if Nia agrees to wear an electronic tag.
- It may grant conditional bail only if Nia pleads guilty to the fraud at the hearing.
- It must refuse bail, because a defendant with assets abroad is always a flight risk.
Section 3(6) of the Bail Act 1976 allows the court to impose conditions that appear necessary to secure that the defendant surrenders to custody, does not commit offences on bail, does not interfere with witnesses, or is available for reports. Before refusing bail, the court should consider whether conditions would sufficiently address the risk identified. For a flight risk, typical conditions include surrendering a passport, residence, reporting to a police station, a surety or security, and electronic monitoring where appropriate. Conditions are not dependent on a guilty plea, and tagging is only one option. If no conditions would suffice, bail may be refused.
Law basis: Bail Act 1976, s 3(6) ↗Question 12 · First hearings, allocation and bailDraft, pending solicitor review
Ola is refused bail at her first appearance after her solicitor makes a full application. At the next hearing a week later, her solicitor wants to make another full application, repeating the same arguments as before. Nothing has changed. Which of the following best describes Ola's entitlement?
- She may make further applications on the same arguments at every hearing.
- She may make one further application using any argument, even ones already made.Correct answer
- She may make another application only with the consent of the prosecution.
- She may not make another application, because she must now appeal to the Crown Court.
- She may not make another application unless there has been a change in circumstances.
Schedule 1, Part IIA of the Bail Act 1976 provides that, if the court decides not to grant bail, it must consider bail at each subsequent hearing while the defendant is in custody. At the first hearing after the one at which bail was refused, the defendant may support an application with any argument as to fact or law, whether or not it has been advanced before. At subsequent hearings the court need not hear arguments it has heard previously. So Ola is entitled to one further full application, after which a change of circumstances or new argument will be needed. She may also apply to the Crown Court, but is not obliged to.
Law basis: Bail Act 1976, Sch 1, Pt IIA, paras 1 to 3Question 13 · First hearings, allocation and bailDraft, pending solicitor review
Pip, charged with an either-way offence, is refused bail by the magistrates after a fully argued application. His solicitor wants a different court to consider bail as soon as possible. Which of the following best describes the route available?
- An application for judicial review, which is the only route to challenge a bail refusal.
- An application to the Court of Appeal, as the refusal involves a point of law.
- An application to the Crown Court, supported by a certificate of full argument.Correct answer
- An appeal to the High Court by way of case stated against the refusal of bail.
- An application to a different bench of magistrates, which must rehear it in full.
Where magistrates refuse bail after hearing full argument, they must issue a certificate confirming this under s 5(6A) of the Bail Act 1976. The defendant may then apply to the Crown Court for bail under s 81 of the Senior Courts Act 1981. The Crown Court hears the application afresh. The High Court's former inherent jurisdiction to hear bail applications where the Crown Court has refused was largely removed by s 17 of the Criminal Justice Act 2003, and judicial review is available only in exceptional circumstances. Case stated and the Court of Appeal are not routes for magistrates' bail decisions.
Law basis: Bail Act 1976, s 5(6A); Senior Courts Act 1981, s 81 ↗Question 14 · First hearings, allocation and bailDraft, pending solicitor review
Rex is charged with wounding with intent. The magistrates grant him conditional bail. The prosecutor opposes this strongly and wishes to appeal. Which of the following best describes what the prosecution must do?
- Apply to the High Court for judicial review within 24 hours of the bail decision.
- Give oral notice at any time before Rex leaves the court building on that day.
- Give oral notice at the end of the hearing, then written notice within two hours.Correct answer
- Give written notice within seven days, during which Rex must remain in custody.
- Lodge written notice of appeal with the Crown Court within 48 hours of the bail decision.
Under s 1 of the Bail (Amendment) Act 1993, the prosecution may appeal to the Crown Court against a grant of bail for an imprisonable offence. Oral notice of appeal must be given at the conclusion of the proceedings in which bail was granted and before the defendant is released, and written notice must be served within two hours of the conclusion of the proceedings. The defendant then remains in custody until the appeal is heard, which must be within 48 hours, excluding weekends and public holidays. If the written notice is not served in time, the appeal is treated as abandoned. Judicial review is not the route.
Law basis: Bail (Amendment) Act 1993, s 1 ↗Question 15 · First hearings, allocation and bailDraft, pending solicitor review
Sal is granted bail to attend the magistrates' court on 3 March. She does not attend, explaining later that she had written the wrong date in her diary. She is brought to court on a warrant. Which of the following best describes her liability for failing to surrender?
- She commits no offence, because her failure to attend was a genuine mistake about the date.
- She commits an offence only if the court had warned her of the consequences in writing.
- She commits an offence, but the prosecution must prove she had no reasonable cause.
- She commits an offence unless she proves reasonable cause, which this is unlikely to be.Correct answer
- She commits no offence, because she surrendered once she realised her mistake.
Under s 6(1) of the Bail Act 1976, a person released on bail who fails without reasonable cause to surrender to custody commits an offence. Under s 6(3), the burden of proving reasonable cause is on the defendant, on the balance of probabilities. A mistake about the date, caused by her own carelessness, is unlikely to amount to reasonable cause; the courts take the view that defendants must take responsibility for knowing their court dates. Even if she has reasonable cause, she must surrender as soon as reasonably practicable afterwards (s 6(2)). There is no requirement of a written warning, and the burden is not on the prosecution.
Law basis: Bail Act 1976, s 6(1) to (3) ↗Question 16 · First hearings, allocation and bailDraft, pending solicitor review
Tia is charged with criminal damage after kicking a car door in anger. The repair cost is £900. She tells her solicitor she wants a jury trial in the Crown Court because she distrusts the magistrates. Which of the following best describes where the case will be tried?
- In the magistrates' court, as low-value damage is tried as if summary only.Correct answer
- In the Crown Court, because criminal damage is an either-way offence.
- In the Crown Court, but only if the magistrates decline jurisdiction.
- Wherever Tia chooses, because she has a right to elect trial by jury.
- In the magistrates' court, unless the prosecution asks for Crown Court trial.
Criminal damage is generally triable either way, but under s 22 of the Magistrates' Courts Act 1980 and Schedule 2, where the value involved does not exceed £5,000, the court must proceed as if the offence were triable only summarily. The defendant therefore has no right to elect Crown Court trial, and the maximum sentence is reduced accordingly. The value here is £900, so the case stays in the magistrates' court whatever Tia wishes. This rule does not apply to arson or aggravated criminal damage, which remain triable either way or on indictment regardless of value.
Law basis: Magistrates' Courts Act 1980, s 22 and Sch 2 ↗More Criminal Law and Practice topics
Back to all Criminal Law and Practice questions, or sit a timed mock.