Law covered in these questions
- Sentencing Act 2020 s 73
- Sentencing Council guideline on reduction in sentence for a guilty plea
- Sentencing Act 2020, s 73
- Sentencing Council Reduction in Sentence for a Guilty Plea guideline
- R v Newton (1982) 77 Cr App R 13
- R v Goodyear [2005] EWCA Crim 888
- Sentencing Act 2020, s 63
- Sentencing Act 2020, s 64
- Sentencing Act 2020, s 65
- Sentencing Act 2020, ss 277 and 288
- Sentencing Act 2020, s 230
- Sentencing Act 2020, s 59
- Sentencing Council Totality guideline
- Sentencing Act 2020, s 14
All 13 questions with answers
Try them above first, then read the worked answers below.
Question 1 · SentencingDraft, pending solicitor review
A defendant pleads guilty at the first stage of proceedings in the Crown Court. Which statement best describes the effect on the sentence?
- The court gives no reduction for a plea to an indictable offence.
- The court must take the plea into account and normally gives a reduction of up to one third, which reduces as the proceedings progress.Correct answer
- The court must halve the sentence in every case.
- The court cannot reduce the sentence, whatever the stage.
- The court must reduce the sentence to the statutory minimum.
Question 2 · SentencingDraft, pending solicitor review
Lena is charged with an either-way offence of assault occasioning actual bodily harm. She indicates not guilty in the magistrates' court and the case is sent to the Crown Court. On the first day of her trial, before the jury is sworn, she pleads guilty. Which of the following best describes the reduction in sentence she should normally receive?
- A reduction of one-quarter, because she pleaded at her first Crown Court hearing.
- A reduction of one-fifth, because she pleaded after her case had been sent.
- A reduction of one-tenth, because she pleaded on the first day of trial.Correct answer
- No reduction, because she indicated a not guilty plea in the magistrates' court.
- A reduction of one-third, because she pleaded before the jury was sworn.
Section 73 of the Sentencing Act 2020 requires the court to take into account the stage at which, and the circumstances in which, a guilty plea was indicated, and to follow the Sentencing Council's Reduction in Sentence for a Guilty Plea guideline. The maximum reduction of one-third is available where the plea is indicated at the first stage of proceedings, normally the first hearing in the magistrates' court. After that the maximum is one-quarter, reducing on a sliding scale to one-tenth on the first day of trial, with a further reduction possible even during the trial. Lena pleaded on the first day of trial, so a one-tenth reduction is normal.
Law basis: Sentencing Act 2020, s 73; Sentencing Council Reduction in Sentence for a Guilty Plea guideline ↗Question 3 · SentencingDraft, pending solicitor review
Mal is charged with burglary of commercial premises, an either-way offence. At the magistrates' court he gives no indication of plea, and the case is sent to the Crown Court. At the plea and trial preparation hearing, he pleads guilty. Which of the following best describes his likely reduction in sentence?
- Up to one-quarter, because he did not indicate guilt at the first stage.Correct answer
- A reduction of one-tenth, because his case had already been sent for trial.
- No reduction, because a guilty plea must be indicated in the magistrates' court.
- A reduction of one-third, because he pleaded guilty before any trial date was fixed.
- A reduction of one-third, because the PTPH is his first hearing in the Crown Court.
Under the Sentencing Council's guilty plea guideline, applied through s 73 of the Sentencing Act 2020, the first stage of proceedings is normally the first hearing at which a plea or indication of plea is sought and recorded, which for an either-way offence is the hearing in the magistrates' court. A plea indicated after that stage attracts a maximum reduction of one-quarter. Mal gave no indication in the magistrates' court, so his plea at the PTPH attracts up to one-quarter. The one-third reduction is reserved for those who indicate guilt at the first opportunity. Pleading before a trial date is set does not alter this.
Law basis: Sentencing Act 2020, s 73; Sentencing Council Reduction in Sentence for a Guilty Plea guideline ↗Question 4 · SentencingDraft, pending solicitor review
Nora pleads guilty to wounding. The prosecution says she attacked the victim with a broken bottle. Nora says she only pushed him and he fell onto glass. The difference would significantly affect the sentence. The prosecution will not accept her account. Which of the following best describes what the judge should do?
- Hold a Newton hearing, hearing evidence and finding the facts to the criminal standard.Correct answer
- Empanel a jury to decide which version of events is correct before sentence.
- Vacate the guilty plea and order a trial, because the facts are in dispute.
- Sentence on the prosecution's version, because Nora has accepted her guilt by pleading.
- Sentence on Nora's version, because she is entitled to the benefit of any doubt about the facts.
Where a defendant pleads guilty on a basis that differs from the prosecution case, and the difference would materially affect sentence, the judge must either sentence on the defence basis or hold a hearing to determine the facts (R v Newton). At a Newton hearing the judge hears evidence and must be sure of the prosecution version before sentencing on it. No jury is involved. If Nora's account is rejected, the credit for her plea will usually be reduced, often by half. The judge is not obliged to accept the defence version simply because of the plea, but nor may he simply adopt the prosecution version without a hearing.
Law basis: R v Newton (1982) 77 Cr App R 13Question 5 · SentencingDraft, pending solicitor review
Owen, charged in the Crown Court with fraud, is considering pleading guilty but wants to know what sentence he would face. His counsel asks the judge, in open court and with the prosecution present, for an indication of the maximum sentence if Owen pleads guilty now. Which of the following best describes the position?
- The judge may indicate the maximum sentence on a plea, which then binds him.Correct answer
- The judge may give an indication, but it does not bind him if Owen then pleads guilty.
- The judge may not give any indication, because this would put pressure on Owen to plead.
- The judge must give an indication, because a defendant is entitled to know his sentence.
- The judge may indicate the likely sentence after trial and on a plea for comparison.
Under R v Goodyear, a defendant may, through counsel, request an indication of the maximum sentence that would be imposed if he were to plead guilty at that stage. The request must come from the defendant, in open court with both parties present. The judge has a discretion whether to give an indication and may decline. If given, the indication binds the judge and any other judge dealing with the case, provided the plea follows within a reasonable time. The judge must not indicate what the sentence would be after a trial, as that would put improper pressure on the defendant. An indication is not a right.
Law basis: R v Goodyear [2005] EWCA Crim 888Question 6 · SentencingDraft, pending solicitor review
Pia is convicted of an assault. The sentencing judge is applying the Sentencing Council guideline for the offence. Pia's solicitor asks how the court assesses how serious the offence is. Which of the following best describes the statutory approach?
- It considers only the harm actually caused to the victim by her assault.
- It considers her culpability and the harm caused, intended or foreseeable.Correct answer
- It considers only her culpability, as harm depends on chance and is irrelevant.
- It considers the victim's personal statement as determining the seriousness.
- It considers her previous convictions first, as they are the main factor.
Section 63 of the Sentencing Act 2020 provides that, where a court is considering the seriousness of an offence, it must consider the offender's culpability in committing the offence and any harm which the offence caused, was intended to cause, or might foreseeably have caused. Sentencing Council guidelines reflect this by placing offences into culpability and harm categories. Previous convictions are a statutory aggravating factor under s 65, but they are considered after the initial assessment of culpability and harm. A victim personal statement may inform harm but does not determine seriousness. Both culpability and harm are relevant.
Law basis: Sentencing Act 2020, s 63 ↗Question 7 · SentencingDraft, pending solicitor review
Raj is convicted of theft. At the time he committed it, he was on bail awaiting trial for an unrelated burglary. Which of the following best describes how the court must treat the fact that the theft was committed while on bail?
- As a factor the court may consider only if the prosecution has proved it to a jury.
- As a separate offence of breaching bail, to be sentenced in addition to the theft.
- As a reason to impose a sentence equal to the maximum available for theft.
- As irrelevant until he has been convicted of the burglary for which he was bailed.
- As an aggravating factor, which the court must state in open court.Correct answer
Under s 64 of the Sentencing Act 2020, where an offence is committed while the offender was on bail, the court must treat that fact as an aggravating factor and must state in open court that the offence is so aggravated. This is a statutory aggravating factor, so it applies regardless of the outcome of the proceedings for which bail was granted. Committing an offence on bail is not itself a separate offence; failing to surrender is the offence under the Bail Act. Aggravation increases the sentence within the guideline range but does not require the statutory maximum. No jury finding is required.
Law basis: Sentencing Act 2020, s 64 ↗Question 8 · SentencingDraft, pending solicitor review
Sam, aged 35, is convicted of shoplifting goods worth £150. He has 20 previous convictions for shoplifting over the last three years. His solicitor argues that the court should sentence only for the current offence. Which of the following best describes the relevance of the previous convictions?
- The court may consider them only when deciding whether to make a community order.
- The court may take them into account only if Sam agrees that they are relevant.
- The court must ignore them, because Sam has already been punished for them.
- The court must treat each relevant recent conviction as an aggravating factor.Correct answer
- The court must treat them as aggravating only if they are for the same offence.
Under s 65 of the Sentencing Act 2020, in considering the seriousness of an offence committed by an offender with one or more previous convictions, the court must treat as an aggravating factor each previous conviction that it considers can reasonably be so treated, having regard in particular to the nature of the offence to which the conviction relates and its relevance to the current offence, and the time that has elapsed since the conviction. Sam's many recent shoplifting convictions plainly aggravate. This does not mean he is punished twice. The convictions need not be for identical offences, and his agreement is not needed.
Law basis: Sentencing Act 2020, s 65 ↗Question 9 · SentencingDraft, pending solicitor review
Tina is convicted of a burglary of commercial premises. The judge decides the offence passes the custody threshold and is considering a sentence of 18 months' imprisonment. Tina has strong mitigation and a good prospect of rehabilitation. Which of the following best describes whether the sentence may be suspended?
- It may be suspended only for a period equal to the length of the custodial term.
- It may be suspended, as terms from 14 days to two years can be suspended.Correct answer
- It may be suspended, but only if Tina consents to unpaid work as a requirement.
- It may not be suspended, because burglary is excluded from suspended sentences.
- It may not be suspended, because only terms of 12 months or less can be suspended.
Under s 277 of the Sentencing Act 2020, a court that passes a sentence of imprisonment of at least 14 days but not more than two years on an offender aged 21 or over may make a suspended sentence order, so that the sentence does not take effect unless the offender commits a further offence or breaches a requirement. The operational period must be between six months and two years (s 288). Requirements, such as unpaid work, may be imposed but are not mandatory. The Sentencing Council's Imposition guideline sets out factors such as realistic prospect of rehabilitation and strong personal mitigation. An 18-month term can therefore be suspended.
Law basis: Sentencing Act 2020, ss 277 and 288 ↗Question 10 · SentencingDraft, pending solicitor review
Una is convicted of a minor theft. The magistrates are considering a short custodial sentence because she has several previous convictions. Her solicitor argues that custody is not permitted. Which of the following best describes the test the court must apply before imposing custody?
- Whether the court is sure that Una would breach a community order if one were imposed.
- Whether a custodial sentence would protect the public from serious harm from Una.
- Whether Una has previously received a community sentence for any offence.
- Whether the offence is so serious that only custody can be justified for it.Correct answer
- Whether the offence carries a maximum sentence of more than six months' custody.
Section 230(2) of the Sentencing Act 2020 provides that the court must not pass a custodial sentence unless it is of the opinion that the offence, or the combination of the offence and one or more associated offences, was so serious that neither a fine alone nor a community sentence can be justified for the offence. Previous convictions may aggravate seriousness, but the threshold must still be crossed. There are limited exceptions, such as where the offender refuses to consent to a community requirement that needs consent. Public protection from serious harm is the test for extended sentences for dangerous offenders, not for the custody threshold.
Law basis: Sentencing Act 2020, s 230 ↗Question 11 · SentencingDraft, pending solicitor review
Vic is convicted of three separate thefts from different victims on different days. The judge is considering whether to make the sentences concurrent or consecutive. Which of the following best describes the principle the judge must apply?
- Concurrent sentences must be imposed, because all the offences are thefts.
- The overall sentence must be just and proportionate to the total offending.Correct answer
- The sentence must equal the longest single sentence that could have been imposed.
- Consecutive sentences must be imposed, because the offences were separate.
- Each sentence must be calculated separately and added up without adjustment.
The Sentencing Council's Totality guideline, which courts must follow under s 59 of the Sentencing Act 2020, requires that when sentencing for more than one offence the overall sentence should reflect all the offending behaviour and be just and proportionate. Consecutive sentences are generally appropriate for offences arising out of unrelated facts or incidents, and concurrent sentences for offences arising out of the same incident, but in either case the court must step back and consider whether the aggregate is just and proportionate, adjusting the sentences if necessary. Simply adding up individual sentences without review is wrong.
Law basis: Sentencing Act 2020, s 59; Sentencing Council Totality guideline ↗Question 12 · SentencingDraft, pending solicitor review
Wes, aged 30, pleads guilty in the magistrates' court to an either-way offence of fraud. After hearing the facts, the magistrates consider that, given the large sums and his long record, the appropriate sentence exceeds their powers. Which of the following best describes their options?
- They must sentence him within their powers, as he has already pleaded guilty before them.
- They may commit him for sentence only if he consents to the committal.
- They may adjourn and ask the Crown Court to give them additional sentencing powers.
- They must vacate the plea and send the case to the Crown Court for trial instead.
- They may commit him to the Crown Court for sentence, as their powers are inadequate.Correct answer
Under s 14 of the Sentencing Act 2020, where an adult is convicted by a magistrates' court of an offence triable either way, and the court is of the opinion that the offence, or the combination of the offence and associated offences, is so serious that the Crown Court should have the power to deal with the offender as if he had been convicted on indictment, the court may commit him in custody or on bail to the Crown Court for sentence. His consent is not required. The plea stands, and the Crown Court then has its full sentencing powers. Wes will retain credit for his early guilty plea.
Law basis: Sentencing Act 2020, s 14 ↗Question 13 · SentencingDraft, pending solicitor review
Xan, aged 28, is convicted of a domestic burglary. He has two previous convictions for domestic burglary, each committed after the previous conviction, both after 1999. He pleaded guilty at the first opportunity. Which of the following best describes the sentencing position?
- No minimum applies, because the burglary did not involve any violence.
- A three-year minimum applies unless unjust; a plea may cut it to 80% of that.Correct answer
- A minimum of three years applies, and the plea may reduce it by up to one-third.
- A minimum of three years applies, and no reduction may be given for a guilty plea.
- A minimum of seven years applies, because this is his third domestic burglary.
Under s 314 of the Sentencing Act 2020, where an offender aged 18 or over is convicted of a domestic burglary and has two previous convictions for domestic burglary meeting the statutory conditions, the court must impose a custodial sentence of at least three years unless there are particular circumstances relating to the offences or the offender which would make that unjust. Under s 73, a guilty plea reduction may be applied, but the sentence must not be less than 80% of the minimum. So Xan's guilty plea cannot reduce the term below about 2 years 5 months. The seven-year minimum applies to third Class A drug trafficking offences.
Law basis: Sentencing Act 2020, ss 73 and 314 ↗More Criminal Law and Practice topics
Back to all Criminal Law and Practice questions, or sit a timed mock.