Law covered in these questions
- R v Church [1966] 1 QB 59
- DPP v Newbury and Jones [1977] AC 500
- R v Watson [1989] 1 WLR 684
- R v Dawson (1985) 81 Cr App R 150
- R v Lamb [1967] 2 QB 981
- R v Lowe [1973] QB 702
- R v Adomako [1995] 1 AC 171
- R v Misra and Srivastava [2004] EWCA Crim 2375
- R v Rose [2017] EWCA Crim 1168
- R v Sellu [2016] EWCA Crim 1716
- R v Mitchell [1983] QB 741
- A-G's Reference (No 3 of 1994) [1998] AC 245
- R v Cato [1976] 1 WLR 110
- R v Kennedy (No 2) [2007] UKHL 38
All 12 questions with answers
Try them above first, then read the worked answers below.
Question 1 · Involuntary manslaughterDraft, pending solicitor review
During an argument outside a pub, Jim shoves Lee hard in the chest. Lee falls backwards, hits his head on the kerb and dies. Jim did not intend or foresee any serious harm. Which of the following best describes Jim's liability for Lee's death?
- He is guilty of gross negligence manslaughter, because he breached a duty of care owed to Lee.
- He is not guilty, because he did not foresee any risk of serious harm to Lee from the shove.
- He is guilty of unlawful act manslaughter, as his battery was a dangerous act causing death.Correct answer
- He is guilty of murder, because he intended to apply unlawful force that resulted in death.
- He is not guilty, because Lee's death resulted from the kerb rather than from Jim's own act.
Unlawful act manslaughter requires an unlawful act that is a crime in itself, that is objectively dangerous in the sense that all sober and reasonable people would recognise it must subject the victim to the risk of some harm, albeit not serious harm (R v Church), and that causes death. The defendant need not foresee any harm (DPP v Newbury and Jones). Jim's shove is a battery, a reasonable person would see the risk of some harm, and Lee's fall caused death. Jim lacks intent to kill or cause serious harm, so it is not murder. Gross negligence applies to breaches of duty, not to deliberate assaults like this.
Law basis: R v Church [1966] 1 QB 59; DPP v Newbury and Jones [1977] AC 500Question 2 · Involuntary manslaughterDraft, pending solicitor review
Ian and a friend break into a house at night. Inside they find the occupier, a frail 87-year-old man, who is obviously distressed. They shout at him and leave. Shortly afterwards he suffers a heart attack and dies. Which of the following best describes whether the burglary was a dangerous act?
- It was dangerous only if Ian knew about the occupier's heart condition before entering the house.
- It was dangerous only if Ian personally foresaw a risk that the occupier might suffer harm.
- It was not dangerous, because burglary is a property offence that does not involve violence.
- It became dangerous once his frailty would have been obvious to a sober and reasonable person.Correct answer
- It was not dangerous, because a heart attack is not harm that a reasonable person would foresee.
The dangerousness test is objective: would a sober and reasonable person, present at the scene and with the knowledge the defendant had or would have gained, recognise the risk of some physical harm? In R v Watson the court held that the unlawful act comprised the whole burglary, and the reasonable person would have become aware of the victim's age and frailty during it. Once the old man's frailty was apparent, continuing to confront him was dangerous. Ian's own foresight is irrelevant (DPP v Newbury and Jones), and he need not have known of the heart condition. A property offence can still be dangerous on its facts.
Law basis: R v Watson [1989] 1 WLR 684; R v Church [1966] 1 QB 59Question 3 · Involuntary manslaughterDraft, pending solicitor review
Pat and Ray, wearing masks, rob a petrol station. They point a replica gun at the attendant, who appears to be a healthy middle-aged man, and he hands over cash through a glass screen. Unknown to them, he has a serious heart condition and dies of a heart attack minutes later. Which of the following best describes their liability for manslaughter?
- They are not liable unless a reasonable person would see a risk of physical harm to him.Correct answer
- They are liable, because pointing a gun at someone is always a dangerous unlawful act.
- They are liable, because the thin skull rule makes them responsible for his heart condition.
- They are not liable, because emotional shock can never amount to physical harm in law.
- They are liable, because robbery is an unlawful act and the attendant died as a result.
In R v Dawson, on similar facts, convictions were quashed because the jury had not been directed that the reasonable person has only the knowledge the defendant had or would have gained. A sober and reasonable person would not know of the attendant's heart condition, so the question is whether such a person would have recognised a risk of physical harm, which includes shock producing physical injury. The thin skull rule applies to causation once dangerousness is established, but it cannot make the act dangerous in the first place. Shock can be physical harm if it causes physical injury, so that option overstates the position, and there is no rule that pointing a gun is always dangerous.
Law basis: R v Dawson (1985) 81 Cr App R 150Question 4 · Involuntary manslaughterDraft, pending solicitor review
Nico and his best friend are playing with a revolver. Nico points it at his friend as a joke. Both believe it will not fire because neither bullet is opposite the barrel, and the friend is not alarmed. Nico pulls the trigger, the cylinder rotates and the friend is killed. Which of the following best describes Nico's liability for unlawful act manslaughter?
- He is liable for it, because the death of his friend was a natural consequence of his act.
- He is not liable for it, because he did not foresee any risk of harm to his friend at the time.
- He is liable for it, because pointing a gun at someone is a dangerous act in any circumstances.
- He is not liable, because there was no unlawful act as his friend did not fear violence.Correct answer
- He is liable for it, because firing a revolver at another person is a criminal act in itself.
Unlawful act manslaughter requires an act that is a crime in itself. In R v Lamb the defendant pointed a revolver at a friend as a joke; neither thought it would fire. There was no assault because the friend did not apprehend unlawful violence, and no battery because Lamb lacked the mens rea, so there was no unlawful act and the manslaughter conviction was quashed. The same reasoning applies to Nico. He may instead be considered for gross negligence manslaughter. The option based on dangerousness puts the cart before the horse: an act must be unlawful before its dangerousness matters. Lack of foresight is not the basis, as foresight is not required.
Law basis: R v Lamb [1967] 2 QB 981Question 5 · Involuntary manslaughterDraft, pending solicitor review
Two teenagers, Jay and Kit, drop a paving slab from a bridge onto the roof of an approaching train. It smashes through a window and kills the guard. They say they never thought anyone would be hurt and only wanted to see it smash. Which of the following best describes their liability for manslaughter?
- They are liable, as the act was dangerous by an objective standard, whatever they foresaw.Correct answer
- They are not liable, because they did not foresee that anyone might be harmed by the slab.
- They are liable only if they intended to cause at least some harm to a person on the train.
- They are liable only if a reasonable person of their age would have foreseen serious harm.
- They are not liable, because criminal damage cannot be the unlawful act for manslaughter.
In DPP v Newbury and Jones the House of Lords held that, for unlawful act manslaughter, the defendant need not have foreseen that his act might cause harm. It is enough that he intentionally did an act that was unlawful and that a sober and reasonable person would recognise as dangerous, in the sense of carrying the risk of some harm. Dropping a slab onto a train plainly meets this test. Criminal damage, or endangering safety on the railway, can be the unlawful act, so that option is wrong. The test is the sober and reasonable adult, and the harm foreseen by that person need only be some harm, not serious harm.
Law basis: DPP v Newbury and Jones [1977] AC 500; R v Church [1966] 1 QB 59Question 6 · Involuntary manslaughterDraft, pending solicitor review
Rob, the father of a baby, fails to take her to a doctor despite her obvious illness over several days, because he does not want social services involved. She dies. The prosecution wishes to charge unlawful act manslaughter based on the offence of wilful child neglect. Which of the following best describes the difficulty with that charge?
- Rob lacked any intention to harm his daughter, so no form of manslaughter is possible.
- The baby's death was caused by her illness, so there can be no liability for any homicide.
- Child neglect is a summary offence and so cannot found any form of manslaughter at all.
- Unlawful act manslaughter requires proof that Rob foresaw a risk of death to his baby.
- An omission, even a criminal one, cannot be the unlawful act for this manslaughter.Correct answer
In R v Lowe the Court of Appeal held that a failure to act, even where it constitutes the offence of wilful neglect, cannot be the unlawful act for unlawful act (constructive) manslaughter; that form of manslaughter requires a positive act. Rob's failure to seek medical help is an omission. He may instead be liable for gross negligence manslaughter, as a parent owes a duty of care to his child, if the breach was gross and caused death, and a reasonably prudent person would have foreseen an obvious and serious risk of death. Lack of intent does not prevent gross negligence manslaughter. Foresight of death by the defendant is not required for either form.
Law basis: R v Lowe [1973] QB 702; R v Adomako [1995] 1 AC 171Question 7 · Involuntary manslaughterDraft, pending solicitor review
During an operation, Dr Ash, an anaesthetist, fails for six minutes to notice that the tube supplying oxygen to the patient has become disconnected, despite alarms sounding. The patient suffers a cardiac arrest and dies. Which of the following best describes what the prosecution must prove for gross negligence manslaughter?
- That Dr Ash's conduct fell below that of a reasonably competent anaesthetist and so caused the death.
- A duty and a breach, plus Dr Ash's own awareness at the time of a risk of death to the patient.
- A duty, a breach causing death, an obvious risk of death, and negligence bad enough to be a crime.Correct answer
- That Dr Ash committed an unlawful act which a reasonable person would see as dangerous.
- A duty, a breach causing death, and an obvious risk of serious injury to the patient.
R v Adomako sets out the elements of gross negligence manslaughter: the defendant owed a duty of care to the victim, he breached it, the breach caused death, and the negligence was so bad that, in the jury's view, it should be judged criminal. Later cases, including R v Misra and R v Rose, add that there must have been a serious and obvious risk of death that a reasonable person would have foreseen. Mere civil negligence below the standard of a competent anaesthetist is not enough. A risk of serious injury, rather than death, is insufficient. The defendant's own awareness is not required, and the 'unlawful and dangerous act' test belongs to unlawful act manslaughter.
Law basis: R v Adomako [1995] 1 AC 171; R v Misra and Srivastava [2004] EWCA Crim 2375Question 8 · Involuntary manslaughterDraft, pending solicitor review
Honey, an optometrist, carries out a routine eye test on a boy but fails to examine the back of his eyes as she should have done. Had she done so, she would have seen swelling that indicated a life-threatening condition. The boy dies months later. Nothing in the information she actually had suggested any risk to his life. Which of the following best describes her liability?
- She is liable, because she failed to discover a risk that she was under a duty to look for.
- She is not liable, because an optometrist does not owe a duty of care to a patient's life.
- She is liable, because a reasonable optometrist would have carried out the full examination.
- She is not liable, because the risk of death was not obvious from what she knew at the time.Correct answer
- She is liable, because she breached her duty and a proper examination would have revealed the risk.
In R v Rose, on these facts, the Court of Appeal quashed a conviction for gross negligence manslaughter. The question of whether there was a serious and obvious risk of death must be assessed by reference to the information available to the defendant at the time of the breach. A reasonably prudent professional may have foreseen a risk if an examination had been done, but a risk that would only have been revealed by the examination that was not carried out is not an obvious risk. Honey's breach of duty is clear, and she did owe a duty, but without an obvious risk of death the offence is not made out.
Law basis: R v Rose [2017] EWCA Crim 1168Question 9 · Involuntary manslaughterDraft, pending solicitor review
Two junior doctors fail to diagnose and treat a patient's infection after surgery despite clear signs. He dies of toxic shock. The judge directs the jury that they may convict if the doctors' negligence created an obvious risk of serious injury to the patient. Which of the following best describes this direction?
- It is correct, because the test is the same as for unlawful act manslaughter in this respect.
- It is wrong, because doctors can be liable only for reckless conduct, not for gross negligence.
- It is wrong, because the prosecution must prove the doctors foresaw that the patient might die.
- It is correct, because gross negligence manslaughter requires only a risk of serious harm.
- It is wrong, because the obvious risk must be a risk of death rather than of serious injury.Correct answer
In R v Misra and Srivastava, on facts like these, the Court of Appeal confirmed that the offence of gross negligence manslaughter requires a serious and obvious risk of death, not merely of serious injury or of injury to health. The test is objective, so the doctors' own foresight of death is not required. The direction was therefore incomplete. Unlawful act manslaughter needs only an objective risk of some harm, but gross negligence manslaughter is narrower in this respect because the fault lies in the gross breach of duty itself. Doctors can be liable for gross negligence, as Adomako shows.
Law basis: R v Misra and Srivastava [2004] EWCA Crim 2375Question 10 · Involuntary manslaughterDraft, pending solicitor review
Mr Fry, a consultant surgeon, delays arranging further surgery for a patient whose condition deteriorates after an operation. The patient dies. At his trial for gross negligence manslaughter, the judge is asked how to direct the jury on whether the negligence was 'gross'. Which of the following best describes the correct approach?
- The judge should decide if his conduct was gross, leaving only causation to the jury.
- The jury should decide if his conduct was truly exceptionally bad, so as to amount to a crime.Correct answer
- The jury should decide if his conduct would justify an award of substantial civil damages.
- The jury should decide whether he was aware of the risk and chose to ignore it.
- The jury should decide if his conduct fell below the standard of a reasonably competent surgeon.
Whether negligence is gross is a question for the jury. Following R v Adomako, the jury must consider whether the breach of duty was so bad, in all the circumstances, that it ought to be judged criminal. In R v Sellu the Court of Appeal emphasised that juries must be helped to understand that this means conduct that was truly, exceptionally bad, going far beyond ordinary professional negligence. Mere failure to meet the standard of a competent surgeon is the civil test for breach, not the criminal threshold. Awareness of the risk is not required, as the test is objective. The judge cannot remove the issue from the jury.
Law basis: R v Adomako [1995] 1 AC 171; R v Sellu [2016] EWCA Crim 1716Question 11 · Involuntary manslaughterDraft, pending solicitor review
Outside a crowded post office, Fred gets into a row with Glen, who has pushed into the queue. Fred hits Glen, who staggers back into Hilda, an 89-year-old woman. She falls, breaks her leg and dies from complications. Fred argues that his unlawful act was aimed at Glen, not Hilda. Which of the following best describes his liability for Hilda's death?
- He cannot be guilty of manslaughter, because Glen's fall was an intervening act breaking the chain.
- He can be guilty only of a non-fatal offence against Glen, because Hilda's death was unforeseeable.
- He can be guilty of manslaughter only if he foresaw that Glen might fall onto another person.
- He cannot be guilty of manslaughter, because his unlawful act was directed only at Glen.
- He can be guilty of unlawful act manslaughter, as the act need not be aimed at the victim.Correct answer
For unlawful act manslaughter, the unlawful and dangerous act need not be directed at the person who dies. In R v Mitchell the defendant hit a man in a post office queue, who fell onto an elderly woman; she died and the manslaughter conviction was upheld (approved in A-G's Reference (No 3 of 1994)). Fred's battery on Glen was objectively dangerous and caused Hilda's death through a foreseeable sequence of events, so the chain of causation is unbroken. Glen's involuntary stagger is not a free and deliberate act. Fred's own foresight is irrelevant to dangerousness, which is assessed by the sober and reasonable person.
Law basis: R v Mitchell [1983] QB 741; A-G's Reference (No 3 of 1994) [1998] AC 245Question 12 · Involuntary manslaughterDraft, pending solicitor review
Cy and his friend Dom both use heroin. At Dom's request, Cy prepares a syringe and injects the heroin into Dom's arm himself. Dom dies of an overdose. Cy is charged with unlawful act manslaughter. Which of the following best describes the likely outcome?
- Cy can be convicted only if he foresaw that the injection might cause Dom serious harm.
- Cy cannot be convicted, because Dom consented to the injection and so there was no unlawful act.
- Cy can be convicted only if he had also supplied the heroin to Dom for payment beforehand.
- Cy can be convicted, because he himself administered a noxious thing that caused death.Correct answer
- Cy cannot be convicted, because Dom's free and informed request broke the chain of causation.
Where the defendant himself injects the drug, he commits the unlawful act of administering a noxious thing so as to endanger life or inflict grievous bodily harm under s 23 of the Offences Against the Person Act 1861. In R v Cato the defendant injected his friend with heroin at his request and was convicted of manslaughter. Kennedy (No 2) is distinguished because there the victim injected himself, so the free act was his. Here the act of administration is Cy's own, so there is no intervening act. Consent is no defence to administering a noxious thing in this way. Cy's subjective foresight of harm is not required for dangerousness.
Law basis: R v Cato [1976] 1 WLR 110; R v Kennedy (No 2) [2007] UKHL 38; Offences Against the Person Act 1861, s 23More Criminal Law and Practice topics
Back to all Criminal Law and Practice questions, or sit a timed mock.