Law covered in these questions
- PACE Code C, paras 11.1 and 11.1A
- Police and Criminal Evidence Act 1984, s 78
- PACE Code C, paras 1.7 and 11.15, Note 1F
- PACE Code C, para 1.7 and Note for Guidance 1B
- PACE Code C, paras 6.9 and 6.10 and Note for Guidance 6D
- Criminal Justice and Public Order Act 1994, s 36(4)
- PACE Code C, para 10.11
- PACE Code D, para 3.12
- PACE Code D, para 3.14
- PACE Code D, paras 3.17 and 3.21
- PACE Code D, paras 3.2 and 3.4
- Police and Criminal Evidence Act 1984, ss 62 and 63
All 10 questions with answers
Try them above first, then read the worked answers below.
Question 1 · Police interviews and identificationDraft, pending solicitor review
Officers arrest Tom for burglary in the street, and caution him. While waiting for a van, one officer asks Tom where he has hidden the stolen jewellery and why he did it. There is no risk to anyone and no evidence at risk. Tom makes admissions. Which of the following best describes the officers' conduct?
- It breached Code C only because Tom was not given a written notice of his rights first.
- It complied with Code C, because questions at the scene are not an 'interview' at all.
- It complied with Code C, because Tom had been cautioned before the questions were asked.
- It complied with Code C, because questions may be asked at any time after a lawful arrest.
- It breached Code C, as after arrest he should be interviewed only at a station.Correct answer
An interview is the questioning of a person regarding his involvement or suspected involvement in a criminal offence, which must be carried out under caution (PACE Code C, para 11.1A). Under para 11.1, following a decision to arrest, a suspect must not be interviewed about the offence except at a police station, unless the delay would be likely to lead to interference with evidence, harm to people, serious loss or damage to property, alerting other suspects or hindering the recovery of property. None of these applied. The caution does not cure the breach. The admissions may be challenged under ss 76 or 78, and lack of a solicitor will be relevant.
Law basis: PACE Code C, paras 11.1 and 11.1A; Police and Criminal Evidence Act 1984, s 78Question 2 · Police interviews and identificationDraft, pending solicitor review
Uri, aged 15, is arrested for robbery. His mother cannot attend for three hours. The investigating officer, keen to make progress, starts to interview Uri with only his solicitor present. There is no risk of harm or interference with evidence from waiting. Which of the following best describes the conduct of the interview?
- It complies with Code C, because an appropriate adult is only needed at the charge.
- It breaches Code C, as a juvenile must not be interviewed without an appropriate adult.Correct answer
- It complies with Code C, because Uri's solicitor is able to act as his appropriate adult.
- It complies with Code C, because Uri is over 14 and may waive the right to an adult.
- It breaches Code C only if Uri asks for his mother to be present before the interview.
PACE Code C, para 11.15, provides that a juvenile or vulnerable person must not be interviewed regarding their involvement in an offence in the absence of the appropriate adult, unless an urgent interview is authorised under paras 11.1 and 11.18 because delay would lead to harm, interference with evidence or similar consequences. There is no urgency here. A solicitor acting in a professional capacity cannot act as the appropriate adult (Code C, Note for Guidance 1F). Uri is under 18, so he is a juvenile, and he cannot waive the requirement. The appropriate adult should also be present when he is informed of his rights and when charged. The interview is in breach.
Law basis: PACE Code C, paras 1.7 and 11.15, Note 1FQuestion 3 · Police interviews and identificationDraft, pending solicitor review
Vic, aged 16, is arrested for assaulting his mother at home. The custody officer proposes that his mother should act as his appropriate adult, as she is at the station giving a statement and is willing to do so. Which of the following best describes whether she may act?
- She may act, because she is willing and is already at the police station.
- She may act, because a parent is the first person to be considered as appropriate adult.
- She should not act, because she is not trained or experienced in dealing with juveniles.
- She should not act, as she is the alleged victim of the offence being investigated.Correct answer
- She may act, provided that Vic himself agrees to her acting as his appropriate adult.
PACE Code C, para 1.7, lists who may act as appropriate adult for a juvenile: a parent or guardian, a social worker, or failing these another responsible adult aged 18 or over who is not a police officer or employed by the police. Note for Guidance 1B states that a person, including a parent, should not be the appropriate adult if they are suspected of involvement in the offence, are the victim, are a witness, are involved in the investigation, or have received admissions before attending to act. Vic's mother is the alleged victim, so she should not act. A social worker or other responsible adult should be found instead. His agreement does not change this.
Law basis: PACE Code C, para 1.7 and Note for Guidance 1BQuestion 4 · Police interviews and identificationDraft, pending solicitor review
Wes's solicitor attends his police interview for theft. When an officer asks a question based on a misstatement of the evidence, the solicitor interrupts, challenges the question and advises Wes not to answer it. The officer wants to have the solicitor removed. Which of the following best describes whether removal is justified?
- It is justified, because the solicitor interrupted the officer during the interview.
- It is justified, because the solicitor advised Wes not to answer a question put to him.
- It is not justified, as challenging improper questions is part of a solicitor's role.Correct answer
- It is justified, because a solicitor's role in interview is limited to that of an observer.
- It is not justified, because a solicitor may never be removed from a police interview.
PACE Code C, Note for Guidance 6D, explains that the solicitor's only role in the police station is to protect and advance the legal rights of the client. The solicitor may intervene to seek clarification, challenge an improper question or the manner in which it is put, advise the client not to reply to particular questions, or give further legal advice. Under paras 6.9 and 6.10, a solicitor may be required to leave only if their conduct prevents or unreasonably obstructs proper questions being put to the suspect, such as answering on the client's behalf or writing answers for them. Challenging a question based on a misstatement is proper. Removal is possible in principle, but not on these facts.
Law basis: PACE Code C, paras 6.9 and 6.10 and Note for Guidance 6DQuestion 5 · Police interviews and identificationDraft, pending solicitor review
Xan is arrested near a burgled house. Officers find fresh glass fragments on his jacket. In interview, they ask him to account for the glass, but do not tell him what offence they are investigating, what they believe the glass shows, or what may happen if he does not answer. He says nothing. Which of the following best describes whether an inference may be drawn at trial?
- An inference may be drawn, because he was cautioned on arrest before interview.
- No inference may be drawn, as he was not given a proper special warning.Correct answer
- An inference may be drawn, but only if he later gives evidence explaining the glass.
- No inference may be drawn, because silence in interview can never found an inference.
- An inference may be drawn, because the glass fragments called for an explanation.
Section 36 of the Criminal Justice and Public Order Act 1994 allows an inference where an arrested person fails or refuses to account for any object, substance or mark on his person or clothing. However, under s 36(4) and PACE Code C, para 10.11, the suspect must first be told in ordinary language the offence being investigated, the fact he is being asked to account for, that the officer believes this may be due to his taking part in the offence, that a court may draw a proper inference if he fails to account for it, and that a record is being made. Xan was not given this special warning, so no s 36 inference may be drawn.
Law basis: Criminal Justice and Public Order Act 1994, s 36(4); PACE Code C, para 10.11 ↗Question 6 · Police interviews and identificationDraft, pending solicitor review
A witness to a street robbery tells police that the robber was a man she had never seen before, whom she saw for about ten seconds. Police arrest Yan, who denies being the robber. The officer in charge decides that no identification procedure is needed because other evidence points to Yan. Which of the following best describes the requirements of Code D?
- A procedure should be held only if the witness has already picked Yan out in the street.
- No procedure is needed, because the witness only saw the robber for about ten seconds.
- A procedure should be held only if Yan's solicitor requests one in writing.
- No procedure is needed, because there is other evidence implicating Yan in the robbery.
- An identification procedure should be held, because identification is disputed.Correct answer
PACE Code D, para 3.12, provides that whenever an eye-witness has identified, or may be able to identify, a suspect, and the suspect disputes being the person seen, an identification procedure shall be held unless it is not practicable or it would serve no useful purpose in proving or disproving whether the suspect was involved. Examples of no useful purpose include where the suspect is already well known to the witness. The witness here saw a stranger and may be able to identify him, and Yan disputes identification. The existence of other evidence does not remove the duty. A short sighting goes to the quality of any identification, not to whether a procedure is needed.
Law basis: PACE Code D, para 3.12Question 7 · Police interviews and identificationDraft, pending solicitor review
Police need to hold an identification procedure for Zak, who disputes being the man who committed an assault. The identification officer is deciding between a video identification and an identification parade. Both are practicable. Which of the following best describes the procedure that should normally be offered first?
- A group identification, because it most closely resembles the circumstances of the crime.
- Video identification, unless a parade is more suitable and practicable.Correct answer
- Whichever procedure Zak or his solicitor chooses to request.
- An identification parade, unless Zak is willing to have his image recorded on video.
- An identification parade, because it allows the witness to see the suspect in person.
Under PACE Code D, para 3.14, the suspect shall initially be offered a video identification unless it is not practicable, or an identification parade is both practicable and more suitable than a video identification, or the officer in charge considers a group identification more suitable. Video identification is therefore the default. The suspect may make representations about which procedure should be used, but the choice is not his. A group identification is an alternative only where it is more suitable than both of the others. A video identification uses moving images of the suspect and at least eight other people resembling him.
Law basis: PACE Code D, para 3.14Question 8 · Police interviews and identificationDraft, pending solicitor review
Abi is suspected of a robbery and identification is disputed. She refuses to take part in a video identification, saying she does not trust the police. The identification officer wants to proceed nevertheless. Which of the following best describes the options available under Code D?
- Abi must be compelled to take part in a video identification under a court order.
- No identification procedure may take place, because Abi has refused her consent.
- The officer may use a covert video identification using existing images of Abi.Correct answer
- No procedure may take place, but Abi's refusal cannot be given in evidence at trial.
- The witness must instead be taken to see Abi directly in a confrontation at once.
Under PACE Code D, if the suspect refuses to cooperate with an identification procedure, the identification officer may arrange a covert video identification using any suitable images, or a covert group identification, if practicable (para 3.21). Before refusing, the suspect must be told that if she does not consent, her refusal may be given in evidence and the police may proceed covertly (para 3.17). A confrontation is a last resort, used only if no other procedure is practicable. The police do not need a court order to proceed covertly, and the refusal can be given in evidence.
Law basis: PACE Code D, paras 3.17 and 3.21Question 9 · Police interviews and identificationDraft, pending solicitor review
Minutes after a mugging, police arrive and the victim gives a description of the attacker. There is not yet any particular suspect. Officers drive the victim around nearby streets to see whether she can spot the man. She points to Ben, who is then arrested. Which of the following best describes the lawfulness of this procedure?
- It is not permitted, because Ben had not consented to being identified in the street.
- It is not permitted, because street identifications can only take place with a solicitor present.
- It is permitted, as a witness may be taken around the area when there is no known suspect.Correct answer
- It is not permitted, because a formal identification procedure must always be used first.
- It is permitted, but the victim's identification is inadmissible in evidence at trial.
PACE Code D, para 3.2, allows a witness to be taken to a particular neighbourhood or place to see whether she can identify the person she saw, where the identity of the suspect is not known. This is commonly done immediately after the offence. The officers must take care not to direct the witness's attention to any individual, and must record the witness's first description and the circumstances. Once a suspect is known and available, formal procedures under paras 3.4 onwards must be used, and an identification procedure may still be required if Ben disputes the identification. The street identification is admissible, subject to s 78 and a Turnbull direction.
Law basis: PACE Code D, paras 3.2 and 3.4Question 10 · Police interviews and identificationDraft, pending solicitor review
Cal is arrested for a sexual assault. Police want a blood sample to compare with blood found at the scene. Cal refuses to give one. The investigating officer wants to take it by force, or alternatively to rely on the refusal at trial. Which of the following best describes the position?
- The sample may be taken without consent if a superintendent authorises it in writing.
- The sample may be taken without consent because Cal has been arrested for an offence.
- The sample cannot be taken without consent, and no inference may be drawn from refusal.
- The sample may be taken without consent if a doctor considers it medically safe.
- It cannot be taken without consent, but a court may draw inferences from refusal.Correct answer
A blood sample is an intimate sample. Under s 62 of the Police and Criminal Evidence Act 1984, an intimate sample may be taken from a person in police detention only if authorised by an inspector and with the person's written consent. It can never be taken by force. Under s 62(10), where a person refuses without good cause to give an intimate sample, the court or jury may draw such inferences from the refusal as appear proper, and the refusal may be treated as corroboration of other evidence. Cal must be warned of this consequence. Non-intimate samples, such as mouth swabs, may in contrast be taken without consent under s 63 in specified circumstances.
Law basis: Police and Criminal Evidence Act 1984, ss 62 and 63 ↗More Criminal Law and Practice topics
Back to all Criminal Law and Practice questions, or sit a timed mock.