Law covered in these questions
- Criminal Justice Act 2003 s 116
- Criminal Justice Act 2003, s 116(1) and (2)(a)
- Criminal Justice Act 2003, s 116(2)(e), (3) and (4)
- Criminal Justice Act 2003, ss 117 and 121
- Criminal Justice Act 2003, s 118(1)
- R v Andrews [1987] AC 281
- Criminal Justice Act 2003, s 114(1)(d) and (2)
- Criminal Justice Act 2003, s 115(3)
- R v Twist [2011] EWCA Crim 1143
- Criminal Justice Act 2003, ss 101(1)(d) and 103
- R v Hanson [2005] EWCA Crim 824
- Criminal Justice Act 2003, s 101(3) and (4)
- Criminal Justice Act 2003, ss 101(1)(g) and 106
- Criminal Justice Act 2003, ss 101(1)(f) and 105
All 15 questions with answers
Try them above first, then read the worked answers below.
Question 1 · Hearsay, bad character and identification evidenceDraft, pending solicitor review
At a criminal trial the prosecution wants to read out a statement of a witness who has died, which describes the defendant's actions. Which statement best describes the admissibility of the statement?
- It can be admitted only if it was sworn before a judge.
- It can be admitted only if the defendant agrees.
- It cannot be admitted, because hearsay is never admissible.
- It can be admitted only after a retrial.
- It may be admitted as hearsay under the Criminal Justice Act 2003, because the maker is dead and the statement was made in a document and relevant.Correct answer
Hearsay is generally inadmissible, but section 116 of the Criminal Justice Act 2003 admits a statement if the maker is dead, subject to the conditions, and the court can exclude it where it is unfair.
Law basis: Criminal Justice Act 2003 s 116 ↗Question 2 · Hearsay, bad character and identification evidenceDraft, pending solicitor review
Wyn witnessed a robbery and gave police a signed witness statement describing the robber's distinctive tattoo. Before trial Wyn dies of natural causes. The prosecution wishes to read his statement to the jury. Which of the following best describes its admissibility?
- It may be admitted only if the jury is told that it carries no weight at all.
- It may be admitted only if the defence agrees that the statement can be read.
- It is inadmissible, because hearsay is only admissible if it is a business document.
- It is inadmissible, because the defence cannot cross-examine the witness about it.
- It may be admitted, as the maker is dead and his oral evidence would be admissible.Correct answer
Under s 116 of the Criminal Justice Act 2003, a statement made by a person not giving oral evidence is admissible as evidence of any matter stated if oral evidence by that person of the matter would be admissible, the person is identified to the court's satisfaction, and one of the conditions in s 116(2) is met, which include that the person is dead. Wyn's statement therefore satisfies the conditions. The court retains power to exclude it under s 78 PACE or s 126, and may consider s 124 evidence challenging Wyn's credibility. The judge must direct the jury about the limitations of untested evidence, but it is not without weight. Defence consent is not required.
Law basis: Criminal Justice Act 2003, s 116(1) and (2)(a) ↗Question 3 · Hearsay, bad character and identification evidenceDraft, pending solicitor review
Xena saw an attack outside a nightclub and gave a statement to police. She now refuses to attend court, saying the defendant's associates have threatened to harm her family if she testifies. The prosecution applies to admit her statement. Which of the following best describes the requirements?
- It may be admitted only if she agrees to attend court to confirm the statement.
- It may be admitted with leave if in the interests of justice, as she is in fear.Correct answer
- It may be admitted only if the prosecution proves that the defendant made the threats.
- It is automatically admissible, because she is unavailable to give evidence.
- It is inadmissible, because fear is not a ground for admitting hearsay statements.
Section 116(2)(e) of the Criminal Justice Act 2003 provides that a statement is admissible where, through fear, the relevant person does not give oral evidence, and the court gives leave. 'Fear' is to be widely construed and includes fear of the death or injury of another person or financial loss (s 116(3)). Under s 116(4), leave may be given only if the court considers that the statement ought to be admitted in the interests of justice, having regard to its contents, the risk of unfairness, the availability of special measures and other relevant circumstances. The prosecution need not prove the defendant made the threats. Unlike death, fear requires leave.
Law basis: Criminal Justice Act 2003, s 116(2)(e), (3) and (4) ↗Question 4 · Hearsay, bad character and identification evidenceDraft, pending solicitor review
In an assault trial, the prosecution wants to adduce hospital records made by a triage nurse, recording the victim's injuries and noting that he said he had been 'kicked by a man in a red jacket'. The nurse cannot now remember the patient. Which of the following best describes the admissibility of the records?
- They are admissible only as to the injuries, never as to what the victim said.
- They may be admissible only if the nurse gives evidence and adopts the records.
- They may be admissible as documents made in the course of a profession.Correct answer
- They are inadmissible, because the records contain a second layer of hearsay.
- They are inadmissible, because the nurse cannot remember making the records.
Under s 117 of the Criminal Justice Act 2003, a statement in a document is admissible as evidence of any matter stated if the document was created or received by a person in the course of a trade, business, profession or other occupation, and the person who supplied the information had, or may reasonably be supposed to have had, personal knowledge of the matters dealt with. The victim had personal knowledge of how he was injured and the nurse received it in the course of her profession. Multiple hearsay is permitted for business documents under s 121(1)(a). The nurse need not remember or attend; s 117(4) and (5) impose extra conditions only for documents prepared for criminal proceedings.
Law basis: Criminal Justice Act 2003, ss 117 and 121 ↗Question 5 · Hearsay, bad character and identification evidenceDraft, pending solicitor review
Yusuf is stabbed in his flat. Within minutes, while bleeding heavily and in great distress, he tells a neighbour who rushes in, 'Kev did this to me.' Yusuf dies before trial. The prosecution wishes to call the neighbour to repeat his words. Which of the following best describes the most suitable basis for admission?
- As res gestae, as he was so overpowered by the event that concoction can be ruled out.Correct answer
- As evidence of bad character, because it shows Kev's propensity to commit violence.
- As a confession, because the statement identifies the person who committed the offence.
- As a business document, because the neighbour recorded the words immediately in writing.
- As a previous consistent statement, because Yusuf would have said the same in court.
Section 118(1) of the Criminal Justice Act 2003 preserves the common law res gestae rule, under which a statement is admissible if it was made by a person so emotionally overpowered by an event that the possibility of concoction or distortion can be disregarded. In R v Andrews, a victim's identification of his attackers, made minutes after being stabbed, was admitted on this basis. Yusuf's words were spontaneous and made while he was dominated by the event. Alternatively s 116 could apply, as he is dead. It is not a confession, which must be made by the defendant, and nothing indicates a written business record.
Law basis: Criminal Justice Act 2003, s 118(1); R v Andrews [1987] AC 281 ↗Question 6 · Hearsay, bad character and identification evidenceDraft, pending solicitor review
In Zed's trial for theft, the defence wants to adduce a statement made by a person who told an investigator that he, not Zed, took the money. The maker is alive and in the country but refuses to attend court, and none of the specific statutory hearsay exceptions applies. Which of the following best describes the court's power to admit the statement?
- It must admit it, because hearsay adduced by the defence is subject to no restrictions.
- It cannot admit it, because none of the specific statutory hearsay exceptions applies.
- It cannot admit it, because the maker is available and could be compelled to attend court.
- It must admit it, because the statement was made by a third party and assists the defence.
- It may admit it if satisfied it is in the interests of justice, applying set factors.Correct answer
Section 114(1)(d) of the Criminal Justice Act 2003 allows a hearsay statement to be admitted if the court is satisfied that it is in the interests of justice for it to be admissible. Under s 114(2), the court must have regard to factors including the probative value of the statement, its importance in the context of the case, the circumstances in which it was made, the reliability of the maker and of the evidence of the statement, whether oral evidence can be given and if not why not, the difficulty of challenging it, and the prejudice to the opposing party. The defence may use this safety valve, though the court will consider why a witness summons was not used.
Law basis: Criminal Justice Act 2003, s 114(1)(d) and (2) ↗Question 7 · Hearsay, bad character and identification evidenceDraft, pending solicitor review
Police raid Abe's flat on suspicion of drug dealing. While they are there, his mobile phone receives several text messages from unknown numbers saying things like 'Can I get a 20 bag tonight?'. The prosecution wishes to rely on the messages to show Abe is a dealer. The defence objects that they are hearsay. Which of the following best describes the position?
- They are hearsay, because they are out-of-court statements used to prove Abe is a dealer.
- They are not hearsay, because text messages are electronic records and not statements.
- They are not hearsay, as the senders did not intend anyone to believe Abe was a dealer.Correct answer
- They are hearsay, and can be admitted only under the interests of justice exception.
- They are hearsay, and are inadmissible because the senders cannot be identified.
Under s 115(3) of the Criminal Justice Act 2003, a statement is a 'matter stated' for the hearsay rules only if one of the purposes of the maker appears to have been to cause another person to believe the matter, or to act on the basis that it is as stated. In R v Twist the Court of Appeal held that text messages requesting drugs were not hearsay when relied on to show the recipient was a dealer, because the senders did not intend to cause anyone to believe that he was a dealer; that was an implication, not the purpose of the message. The messages are admissible as direct evidence, subject to relevance and s 78.
Law basis: Criminal Justice Act 2003, s 115(3); R v Twist [2011] EWCA Crim 1143 ↗Question 8 · Hearsay, bad character and identification evidenceDraft, pending solicitor review
Bea is charged with a street robbery in which the robber threatened the victim with a knife. She has three convictions in the last four years for robberies committed in a similar way, using a knife to threaten lone women. The prosecution applies to adduce them to show propensity. Which of the following best describes the court's approach?
- They are inadmissible unless Bea gives evidence and denies the previous offences.
- They may be admitted through gateway (d) to show propensity, subject to fairness.Correct answer
- They must be admitted automatically once the prosecution shows they are similar.
- They are inadmissible, because previous convictions can never prove the present offence.
- They are admissible only if Bea attacks the character of a prosecution witness.
Under s 101(1)(d) of the Criminal Justice Act 2003, evidence of a defendant's bad character is admissible if it is relevant to an important matter in issue between the defendant and the prosecution, which under s 103(1)(a) includes whether she has a propensity to commit offences of the kind charged. Previous convictions for offences of the same description or category can establish propensity (s 103(2)). R v Hanson gives guidance: the court considers the number, similarity, recency and strength of the convictions. Bea's three recent, similar knife robberies are strong propensity evidence. The court must still consider excluding them under s 101(3) if admission would be unfair.
Law basis: Criminal Justice Act 2003, ss 101(1)(d) and 103; R v Hanson [2005] EWCA Crim 824 ↗Question 9 · Hearsay, bad character and identification evidenceDraft, pending solicitor review
Cal is charged with a sophisticated fraud. The prosecution applies to adduce, under gateway (d), a single conviction from 15 years ago for shoplifting goods worth £20. The defence objects. Which of the following best describes the court's power?
- It may exclude the conviction only if Cal undertakes not to put his good character in issue.
- It must admit the conviction, because any previous dishonesty shows a propensity to be dishonest.
- It must exclude it if admission would be so unfair that it ought not to be admitted.Correct answer
- It may exclude the conviction only under s 78 PACE, as s 101 gives no power to exclude.
- It must admit the conviction, because the defence has no power to object under gateway (d).
Under s 101(3) of the Criminal Justice Act 2003, the court must not admit evidence under gateway (d) or (g) if, on an application by the defendant, it appears that its admission would have such an adverse effect on the fairness of the proceedings that the court ought not to admit it. Under s 101(4), it must have regard in particular to the length of time since the matters concerned. A single, old, minor shoplifting conviction has little probative value on a sophisticated fraud and is likely to be excluded. R v Hanson confirms that a single conviction will often not show propensity. Section 101(3) is the specific statutory power here.
Law basis: Criminal Justice Act 2003, s 101(3) and (4); R v Hanson [2005] EWCA Crim 824 ↗Question 10 · Hearsay, bad character and identification evidenceDraft, pending solicitor review
Dan is on trial for possession of drugs with intent to supply. He gives evidence that the arresting officer planted the drugs in his car because the officer has a grudge against him. Dan has several previous convictions for violence. The prosecution now applies to adduce them. Which of the following best describes the likely ruling?
- They may be admitted through gateway (g), as Dan has attacked another person's character.Correct answer
- They are admissible through gateway (f), because Dan has given a false impression of himself.
- They are inadmissible, because his convictions are for violence, not for drugs offences.
- They are inadmissible, because a defendant is entitled to put forward any defence he wishes.
- They are admissible through gateway (d), because they show a propensity to be untruthful.
Under s 101(1)(g) of the Criminal Justice Act 2003, evidence of a defendant's bad character is admissible if he has made an attack on another person's character. Under s 106, this includes giving evidence that the other person has committed an offence or behaved in a reprehensible way, such as alleging that an officer planted evidence. Dan's convictions may therefore be admitted, so the jury can assess his credibility in light of the attack. The court must consider excluding them under s 101(3) if admission would be unfair. Violent convictions do not show a propensity to be untruthful under gateway (d), and Dan has not given a false impression of himself.
Law basis: Criminal Justice Act 2003, ss 101(1)(g) and 106 ↗Question 11 · Hearsay, bad character and identification evidenceDraft, pending solicitor review
Eve is on trial for theft from her employer. In evidence-in-chief she says, 'I've never been in trouble with the police in my life.' In fact she has a caution for theft and a conviction for fraud. Which of the following best describes how the prosecution may respond?
- It may adduce her record via gateway (f) to correct the false impression given.Correct answer
- It may adduce her record only if it had already given notice under gateway (d).
- It cannot adduce her record, because a caution is not evidence of bad character.
- It cannot adduce her record, because she did not attack anyone else's character.
- It may cross-examine her about her record only with the agreement of the defence.
Under s 101(1)(f) of the Criminal Justice Act 2003, evidence of a defendant's bad character is admissible to correct a false impression given by the defendant. Under s 105, a defendant gives a false impression if she makes an express or implied assertion apt to give the court or jury a false or misleading impression about her. Eve's claim never to have been in trouble is plainly false given her caution and conviction. Under s 105(6), the evidence is admissible only if it goes no further than necessary to correct the false impression. A caution is evidence of misconduct within s 98. Section 101(3) does not apply to gateway (f), though s 78 PACE may.
Law basis: Criminal Justice Act 2003, ss 101(1)(f) and 105 ↗Question 12 · Hearsay, bad character and identification evidenceDraft, pending solicitor review
Fin is charged with assault. The main prosecution witness, Gil, has a conviction from two years ago for perverting the course of justice by giving a false alibi to police. The defence wants to cross-examine Gil about this conviction to undermine his credibility. Which of the following best describes the requirements?
- Leave is needed, and is given if it has substantial probative value on credibility.Correct answer
- No leave is needed, because the conviction relates to Gil's honesty rather than violence.
- Leave is needed, and will be given only if the prosecution consents to the questioning.
- No leave is needed, because a witness's previous convictions may always be put to him.
- Leave is not available, because only a defendant's bad character can be adduced.
Section 100 of the Criminal Justice Act 2003 governs the bad character of non-defendants. Unless all parties agree or the evidence is important explanatory evidence, the evidence is admissible only with the court's leave and only if it has substantial probative value in relation to a matter which is in issue in the proceedings and is of substantial importance in the context of the case as a whole (s 100(1)(b) and (4)). Gil's credibility as the main witness is of substantial importance, and a recent conviction for giving false information to police has substantial probative value on that issue, so leave is likely. Prosecution consent is not a precondition.
Law basis: Criminal Justice Act 2003, s 100 ↗Question 13 · Hearsay, bad character and identification evidenceDraft, pending solicitor review
Hal is charged with a street robbery. The only evidence against him is the victim's identification. She saw the robber's face for about five seconds under a street lamp, at night, while frightened, and later picked Hal out at a video identification. Hal denies being the robber. Which of the following best describes the judge's duty?
- To warn the jury of the special need for caution and to examine the circumstances.Correct answer
- To give a warning only if the defence asks the judge to do so before speeches begin.
- To tell the jury that a video identification removes any risk of mistaken identification by her.
- To direct the jury that identification evidence needs corroboration before they can convict.
- To withdraw the case from the jury, because the identification was made at night under a street lamp.
Under R v Turnbull, where the case against the defendant depends wholly or substantially on the correctness of disputed identification evidence, the judge must warn the jury of the special need for caution before convicting in reliance on it, explaining that a convincing witness can be mistaken. The judge should direct the jury to examine closely the circumstances of the identification, such as the length of observation, distance, lighting, obstructions, whether the witness had seen the accused before, and any discrepancies with the first description. The warning is mandatory, not dependent on a defence request. Corroboration is not required. Withdrawal is appropriate only where the quality is poor and unsupported.
Law basis: R v Turnbull [1977] QB 224Question 14 · Hearsay, bad character and identification evidenceDraft, pending solicitor review
Ivo is charged with burglary. The only evidence is from a neighbour who glimpsed a man running from the house for a second or two, from 40 metres away, in the dark, and later identified Ivo in a video identification. There is no other evidence linking him to the burglary. Which of the following best describes how the judge should deal with a defence submission at the close of the prosecution case?
- The judge should leave the case to the jury, because a formal identification was carried out.
- The judge should withdraw the case only if the neighbour admits that she might be mistaken.
- The judge should leave the case to the jury with a full Turnbull warning about the risks.
- The judge should leave the case to the jury, because reliability is a matter for the jury.
- The judge should withdraw the case, as the identification is poor and unsupported.Correct answer
R v Turnbull provides that where, in the judge's opinion, the quality of identifying evidence is poor, as for example where it depends solely on a fleeting glance or on a longer observation made in difficult conditions, the judge should withdraw the case from the jury and direct an acquittal unless there is other evidence which goes to support the correctness of the identification. The neighbour's sighting was fleeting, distant and in the dark, and there is no supporting evidence. A Turnbull warning is not enough in these circumstances. Although reliability is usually for the jury, Turnbull creates this specific exception, consistent with the second limb of R v Galbraith.
Law basis: R v Turnbull [1977] QB 224; R v Galbraith [1981] 1 WLR 1039Question 15 · Hearsay, bad character and identification evidenceDraft, pending solicitor review
Jen and Kit are jointly tried for a violent robbery. Each blames the other. In evidence, Jen says Kit planned the robbery and carried out the violence. Kit has three previous convictions for robbery involving violence. Jen's counsel wants to adduce them. Which of the following best describes the relevant gateway?
- Gateway (f), as Kit has given a false impression by denying the offence charged.
- Gateway (g), as Kit has attacked Jen's character by blaming her for the robbery.
- Gateway (e), as it has substantial probative value on an important issue between them.Correct answer
- No gateway, as one defendant may never adduce another's bad character.
- Gateway (d), as only the prosecution may adduce evidence of a co-defendant's bad character.
Section 101(1)(e) of the Criminal Justice Act 2003 makes a defendant's bad character admissible if it has substantial probative value in relation to an important matter in issue between the defendant and a co-defendant. Under s 104(1), evidence relevant to a defendant's propensity to be untruthful is admissible on this basis only if the nature or conduct of his defence undermines the co-defendant's defence. Where each blames the other, which of them used violence is an important matter in issue, and Kit's convictions for violent robbery have substantial probative value on that. Gateway (d) is for the prosecution only. Section 101(3) does not apply to gateway (e).
Law basis: Criminal Justice Act 2003, ss 101(1)(e) and 104 ↗More Criminal Law and Practice topics
Back to all Criminal Law and Practice questions, or sit a timed mock.