Key rules
Theft – Theft Act 1968, s 1: dishonestly appropriating property belonging to another with the intention of permanently depriving the other of it. Max 7 years; either way (shoplifting of goods worth £200 or less is treated as summary only, Magistrates' Courts Act 1980, s 22A, although D may elect Crown Court trial).
| Element |
Section |
Key points / cases |
| Appropriation |
s 3(1) |
Any assumption of the rights of an owner (R v Morris (1984): label swap); consent of owner irrelevant (R v Gomez (1993)); a valid gift can be appropriated (R v Hinks (2001)); later assumption by keeping or dealing as owner counts |
| Property |
s 4 |
Money, real and personal property, things in action. Confidential information is not property (Oxford v Moss (1979)). Wild mushrooms, flowers, fruit, foliage not theft unless picked for reward, sale or commercial purpose (s 4(3)) |
| Belonging to another |
s 5 |
Possession or control suffices – even an owner can steal his own car from a garage (R v Turner (No 2) (1971)); obligation to deal with property in a particular way (s 5(3), R v Wain (1995)); property got by mistake with obligation to restore (s 5(4), A-G's Ref (No 1 of 1983) (1985)) |
| Dishonesty |
s 2 + common law |
Not dishonest if D believes in legal right (s 2(1)(a)), owner's consent (s 2(1)(b)), owner cannot be found by reasonable steps (s 2(1)(c)). Willingness to pay does not prevent dishonesty (s 2(2)). Otherwise Ivey v Genting Casinos (2017), applied in R v Barton and Booth (2020) |
| Intention to permanently deprive |
s 6 |
Includes treating the thing as one's own to dispose of regardless of the owner's rights; borrowing counts only if the "goodness, virtue and practical value" is exhausted (R v Lloyd (1985)); intending to replace money with equivalent notes is still IPD (R v Velumyl (1989)) |
Dishonesty (Ivey test): (1) ascertain D's actual state of knowledge or belief as to the facts (the reasonableness of the belief is evidence only); (2) decide whether D's conduct was dishonest by the standards of ordinary decent people. There is no requirement that D realised it was dishonest.
Robbery – Theft Act 1968, s 8: stealing, and immediately before or at the time of doing so, and in order to do so, using force on any person or putting or seeking to put any person in fear of being then and there subjected to force. Max life; indictable only.
- Requires a completed theft: a claim of right negating dishonesty negates robbery – R v Robinson (1977).
- Force can be minimal and on property held by V – R v Clouden (1987) (wrenching a bag).
- Appropriation is continuing: force used while making off may still be "at the time of" stealing – R v Hale (1978).
- Force must be used in order to steal – violence for another reason followed by an opportunistic taking is theft plus assault, not robbery.
How it is tested
- Debt collector: D takes money by force believing he is owed it. No dishonesty under s 2(1)(a), so no theft and no robbery (Robinson), though assault may remain.
- Overpaid salary: employer pays by mistake and D keeps it – s 5(4) obligation to restore, so property "belongs to another".
- Borrowing a season ticket and returning it once used up – IPD under s 6 (Lloyd).
- Tie-up after taking: D takes jewellery, then ties V up while still in the house – Hale continuing appropriation makes it robbery.
Exam traps
- Asking whether D thought he was dishonest – the Ghosh second limb was abolished.
- Thinking an owner's consent prevents appropriation (Gomez).
- Treating information as property.
- Saying robbery requires significant force – minimal force on a bag suffices.
- Forgetting that the force must be used "in order to" steal.
Quick check
Remember: no theft means no robbery – if D has a genuine belief in a legal right (s 2(1)(a)), both fail, however much force is used.