Abi, a self-employed decorator, emails a company an invoice for work she knows she never did, hoping it will be paid. The company's finance officer spots the fake invoice immediately and pays nothing. Abi is charged with fraud by false representation. Which of the following best describes her liability?
- She is not guilty, because the company was not deceived by her false representation.
- She is guilty, as the offence is complete once she dishonestly makes the representation.Correct answer
- She is guilty only of attempted fraud, because her representation did not succeed.
- She is not guilty, because a representation made by email cannot be a false representation.
- She is not guilty, because she made no gain and the company suffered no actual financial loss.
Under s 2 of the Fraud Act 2006, the offence is committed where a person dishonestly makes a false representation, knowing it is or might be untrue or misleading, intending to make a gain for herself or another, or to cause loss or expose another to a risk of loss. The offence is complete when the representation is made with the required mens rea; it is not necessary that anyone is deceived, or that any gain or loss actually results. Abi's invoice falsely represented that work had been done, and she intended a gain. So she commits the full offence, not merely an attempt. Representations can be made in any form, including by email.
Law basis: Fraud Act 2006, ss 1 and 2 ↗