Law covered in these questions
- Osman v United Kingdom (1998) 29 EHRR 245
- Rabone v Pennine Care NHS Foundation Trust [2012] UKSC 2
- R (Middleton) v West Somerset Coroner [2004] UKHL 10
- McCann v United Kingdom (1995) 21 EHRR 97
- Chahal v United Kingdom (1996) 23 EHRR 413
- Soering v United Kingdom (1989) 11 EHRR 439
- Ireland v United Kingdom (1978) 2 EHRR 25
- Tyrer v United Kingdom (1978) 2 EHRR 1
- R (Limbuela) v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2005] UKHL 66
- Commissioner of Police of the Metropolis v DSD [2018] UKSC 11
- Austin v Commissioner of Police of the Metropolis [2009] UKHL 5
- Austin v United Kingdom (2012) 55 EHRR 14
- P v Cheshire West and Chester Council [2014] UKSC 19
- Brogan v United Kingdom (1988) 11 EHRR 117
All 15 questions with answers
Try them above first, then read the worked answers below.
Question 1 · Absolute and limited Convention rightsDraft, pending solicitor review
Police received reports that a teacher had become obsessed with a pupil and had made veiled threats. They took limited action. The teacher later shot and killed the pupil's father. The family argue that the police breached Article 2. Which of the following best describes the test for the positive operational duty?
- Whether the police could have prevented the death by any measure at all, however costly or burdensome it would be.
- Whether the police were grossly negligent, because Article 2 applies only to gross negligence.
- Whether police knew or ought to have known of a real and immediate risk to life and failed to act reasonably.Correct answer
- Whether the police intended the death, because Article 2 concerns only intentional killing by state agents.
- Whether the risk to life was certain to materialise, because a mere possibility of harm is never enough.
In Osman v United Kingdom the European Court of Human Rights held that Article 2 may imply a positive obligation on the authorities to take preventive operational measures to protect an individual whose life is at risk from the criminal acts of another. A breach requires that the authorities knew or ought to have known at the time of a real and immediate risk to the life of an identified individual, and failed to take measures within their powers which, judged reasonably, might have been expected to avoid that risk. The duty must not impose an impossible or disproportionate burden.
Law basis: Osman v United Kingdom (1998) 29 EHRR 245Question 2 · Absolute and limited Convention rightsDraft, pending solicitor review
Melanie, a voluntary psychiatric patient assessed as at high risk of suicide, was allowed home leave by an NHS trust and took her own life. Her parents argue that Article 2 applied even though she was not detained. Which of the following best describes the Supreme Court's view?
- The operational duty applied, as the trust assumed responsibility for a patient at real and immediate risk.Correct answer
- The operational duty did not apply, because it is limited to people detained by the state.
- The operational duty applied, but the claim failed because her parents could not be victims under section 7.
- The operational duty did not apply, because suicide is a voluntary act for which the state is never responsible.
- The operational duty applied only because the trust had been negligent in its general systems.
In Rabone v Pennine Care NHS Foundation Trust the Supreme Court held that the operational duty under Article 2 extended to a voluntary psychiatric patient who was at real and immediate risk of suicide. Relevant factors included the trust's assumption of responsibility, the patient's vulnerability, and the exceptional nature of the risk; the difference from a detained patient was one of form, not substance. The trust breached the duty by allowing home leave. Her parents were victims in their own right and their claim was not barred.
Law basis: Rabone v Pennine Care NHS Foundation Trust [2012] UKSC 2Question 3 · Absolute and limited Convention rightsDraft, pending solicitor review
A young prisoner, Liam, hangs himself in his cell. The coroner directs the jury that they may record only a brief verdict of the means of death, and may not comment on whether the prison failed to take precautions. Liam's family challenge this. Which of the following best describes the requirements of Article 2?
- An inquest is not required, because Article 2 is satisfied by any internal review carried out by the prison.
- An effective investigation is needed, but it may be carried out by the prison service itself.
- An inquest is required, but it may consider only the medical cause of death and not any failures.
- An effective investigation is needed, so the inquest must address the circumstances of death.Correct answer
- No investigation is needed, because Article 2 imposes only a negative duty not to take life.
Article 2 includes a procedural obligation to carry out an effective, independent official investigation where a person dies in state custody or the state may be implicated. In R (Middleton) v West Somerset Coroner the House of Lords held that, where the inquest is the means of discharging this duty, the statutory question 'how' the deceased came by his death must be read as 'by what means and in what circumstances', allowing the jury to express conclusions on central factual issues, including failures by the authorities. An internal prison review lacks the necessary independence.
Law basis: R (Middleton) v West Somerset Coroner [2004] UKHL 10Question 4 · Absolute and limited Convention rightsDraft, pending solicitor review
Soldiers shoot dead three suspected terrorists in a public street, believing they are about to detonate a car bomb. It later emerges that there was no bomb. The operation had been planned on the basis of untested assumptions. Which of the following best describes the test applied under Article 2?
- Use of force is lawful if the soldiers honestly believed that it was reasonable in all the circumstances.
- Use of force is lawful if it was proportionate to a legitimate aim of protecting national security.
- Force must be no more than absolutely necessary, judged also by how the operation was planned.Correct answer
- Use of force is unlawful only if the soldiers intended to kill rather than to incapacitate.
- Use of force is assessed solely by reference to the soldiers' state of mind when they fired.
Article 2(2) permits deprivation of life only where it results from the use of force which is no more than 'absolutely necessary' for a listed purpose, such as defence of any person from unlawful violence. In McCann v United Kingdom the European Court held that, while the soldiers honestly believed it was necessary to shoot, the UK breached Article 2 because the operation was planned and controlled in a way that failed to minimise recourse to lethal force. The test is stricter than ordinary proportionality and extends to planning, not just the soldiers' state of mind.
Law basis: McCann v United Kingdom (1995) 21 EHRR 97Question 5 · Absolute and limited Convention rightsDraft, pending solicitor review
The Home Secretary wishes to deport Karan, a foreign national suspected of supporting terrorism, to his home state. There are substantial grounds for believing he would face torture there. The government argues that the threat he poses to national security should be weighed against that risk. Which of the following best describes the legal position?
- Deportation is prohibited, as Article 3 is absolute and the risk cannot be balanced against security.Correct answer
- Deportation is lawful if the threat to national security clearly outweighs the risk of ill-treatment abroad.
- Deportation is lawful because Article 3 does not apply to acts of a foreign state outside the UK.
- Deportation is prohibited only if Karan proves that torture is more likely than not to occur.
- Deportation is lawful if the UK obtains any diplomatic assurance from the receiving state.
Article 3 is an absolute right; no derogation is permitted and no balancing exercise is allowed. In Chahal v United Kingdom the European Court held that where substantial grounds are shown for believing that a person faces a real risk of torture or inhuman or degrading treatment if deported, the state must not deport them, whatever their conduct or the threat to national security. Soering established that responsibility arises from the act of removal itself. Diplomatic assurances may be relevant but are not automatically sufficient, and the standard is 'real risk', not 'more likely than not'.
Law basis: Chahal v United Kingdom (1996) 23 EHRR 413; Soering v United Kingdom (1989) 11 EHRR 439Question 6 · Absolute and limited Convention rightsDraft, pending solicitor review
During internment, detainees were subjected to five interrogation techniques, including wall-standing, hooding, noise, and deprivation of sleep, food and drink. The European Court of Human Rights considered whether this amounted to torture. Which of the following best describes how it classified the treatment?
- As torture, because any deliberate ill-treatment by state agents during interrogation counts as torture.
- As lawful, because the UK had derogated from Article 3 during the emergency in Northern Ireland.
- As degrading punishment only, because the detainees had not been convicted of any offence.
- As inhuman and degrading treatment, not torture, lacking the special stigma of very cruel suffering.Correct answer
- As outside Article 3, because the techniques caused no lasting physical injury to the detainees.
In Ireland v United Kingdom the European Court held that the five techniques constituted inhuman and degrading treatment in breach of Article 3, but did not amount to torture, which attaches a special stigma to deliberate inhuman treatment causing very serious and cruel suffering. The Court declined to revise this judgment in 2018. Article 3 is non-derogable under Article 15(2), so derogation could not justify the treatment. Lasting physical injury is not required; intense physical and mental suffering suffices.
Law basis: Ireland v United Kingdom (1978) 2 EHRR 25Question 7 · Absolute and limited Convention rightsDraft, pending solicitor review
A 15-year-old boy on the Isle of Man was sentenced by a juvenile court to three strokes of the birch, administered by police officers. Local opinion supported the punishment as a deterrent. Which of the following best describes the European Court of Human Rights' view?
- The punishment was lawful, because local public opinion supported it as an effective deterrent.
- The punishment was degrading, as it treated him as an object in the power of the authorities.Correct answer
- The punishment was torture, because it involved the deliberate infliction of physical pain.
- The punishment was lawful, because Article 3 permits corporal punishment imposed by a court.
- The punishment was not covered by Article 3, because it caused no lasting physical injury.
In Tyrer v United Kingdom the European Court held that judicial birching was degrading punishment contrary to Article 3. Institutionalised violence, inflicted by strangers on behalf of the state, treated the boy as an object in the power of the authorities and assaulted his dignity and physical integrity. The Court stressed that the Convention is a living instrument, interpreted in light of present-day conditions, so local support for the punishment was irrelevant. It did not reach the severity of torture, and lasting injury was not required.
Law basis: Tyrer v United Kingdom (1978) 2 EHRR 1Question 8 · Absolute and limited Convention rightsDraft, pending solicitor review
Under a statutory scheme, asylum seekers who did not claim asylum as soon as reasonably practicable were refused all support and banned from working, so that several were left sleeping rough without food. They claim that the Home Secretary breached Article 3. Which of the following best describes the House of Lords' view?
- Article 3 could not apply, because it imposes only negative duties and the state had not acted against them.
- Article 3 could not apply, because the scheme was required by primary legislation.
- Article 3 applied only if the claimants could show that they had suffered physical injury.
- Article 3 was breached automatically whenever an asylum claimant was refused support.
- Withdrawing support could breach Article 3 once the treatment reached the minimum level of severity.Correct answer
In R (Limbuela) v Secretary of State for the Home Department the House of Lords held that denying support to asylum seekers who were also prohibited from working could amount to inhuman or degrading treatment under Article 3, for which the state was responsible because of its deliberate policy. The treatment must reach a minimum level of severity, which would be crossed where a person faced imminent prospect of serious suffering through lack of food, shelter or basic hygiene. The statute allowed support to avoid a breach, so section 6(2) did not apply. A breach was not automatic.
Law basis: R (Limbuela) v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2005] UKHL 66Question 9 · Absolute and limited Convention rightsDraft, pending solicitor review
Several women reported serious sexual assaults by a taxi driver over several years. Because of serious operational failures, the police failed to investigate properly and he committed further attacks. The women sue the police under the HRA. Which of the following best describes the Supreme Court's view?
- Article 3 applies only to ill-treatment by state agents, so the police owed no duty in respect of a private attacker.
- Article 3 is breached only if there was a systemic failure in the legal framework, not operational failings.
- Article 3 claims against the police are barred because the police have immunity from negligence claims.
- Article 3 imposes a duty to conduct an effective investigation, which serious operational failures can breach.Correct answer
- Article 3 applies, but only if the women can prove that further attacks were certain to occur.
In Commissioner of Police of the Metropolis v DSD the Supreme Court held that Article 3 imposes a positive obligation on the state to conduct an effective investigation into serious ill-treatment by private individuals. The duty is not limited to systemic failures in the legal framework; serious operational failures in the conduct of the investigation can amount to a breach. Common law immunity from negligence claims does not prevent an HRA claim. The claimants did not need to prove that further attacks were certain.
Law basis: Commissioner of Police of the Metropolis v DSD [2018] UKSC 11Question 10 · Absolute and limited Convention rightsDraft, pending solicitor review
During a large demonstration at Oxford Circus, police contained around 3,000 people, including passers-by, within a cordon for about seven hours to prevent serious violence. Lois, who was caught in the cordon, claims a breach of Article 5. Which of the following best describes the outcome?
- There was a deprivation of liberty, because any confinement for more than a few hours engages Article 5.
- Article 3 imposes a duty to investigate effectively, which serious operational failures can breach.Correct answer
- Article 3 is breached only if there was a systemic failure in the legal framework, and never by operational failings.
- There was no deprivation of liberty because Lois had chosen to attend a public demonstration.
- There was a deprivation of liberty, because people who were not protesters were caught in the cordon.
In Austin v Commissioner of Police of the Metropolis the House of Lords held, and the European Court in Austin v UK agreed, that the containment did not amount to a deprivation of liberty within Article 5. In deciding whether there is a deprivation, the purpose of crowd control measures is relevant: where they are resorted to in good faith, are proportionate to the situation, and are enforced for no longer than reasonably necessary, Article 5 is not engaged. The inclusion of passers-by did not alter this, and Lois need not have chosen to attend.
Law basis: Austin v Commissioner of Police of the Metropolis [2009] UKHL 5; Austin v United Kingdom (2012) 55 EHRR 14Question 11 · Absolute and limited Convention rightsDraft, pending solicitor review
Peter, who has severe learning disabilities, lives in a council-arranged care placement where staff supervise and control him continuously and would not let him leave to live elsewhere. He appears content and does not object. Which of the following best describes whether he is deprived of his liberty?
- He is not deprived of liberty, because he does not object and the placement is in his own best interests.
- He is not deprived of liberty, because the arrangements are comparable to those for any person with his disabilities.
- He is deprived of liberty only if he is kept under lock and key at all times.
- He is deprived of liberty only if a court has ordered the placement under the Mental Health Act 1983.
- He is, as the acid test is continuous supervision and control without freedom to leave; contentment is irrelevant.Correct answer
In P v Cheshire West and Chester Council the Supreme Court held that the 'acid test' for deprivation of liberty under Article 5 is whether the person is under continuous supervision and control and is not free to leave. The person's compliance or lack of objection, the relative normality of the placement, and the reason or purpose behind it are irrelevant. Human rights are universal, so a disabled person's liberty is assessed in the same way as anyone else's. Such deprivations must be authorised, for example under the Mental Capacity Act 2005.
Law basis: P v Cheshire West and Chester Council [2014] UKSC 19Question 12 · Absolute and limited Convention rightsDraft, pending solicitor review
Under anti-terrorism legislation, Aidan is arrested and held in police custody for four days and six hours before being released without charge. He was never brought before a judge. Which of the following best describes the position under Article 5?
- Article 5(3) was not breached, because terrorism cases permit detention without judicial control for up to 14 days.
- Article 5(3) was not breached, because he was released without charge and so suffered no detriment.
- Article 5(3) was breached, because he was not brought promptly before a judge or judicial officer.Correct answer
- Article 5(1) was breached, because arrest on suspicion of terrorism is never a permitted ground of detention.
- Article 5(3) was not breached, because a review by a senior police officer satisfies the requirement.
Article 5(3) requires that everyone arrested or detained on reasonable suspicion of having committed an offence be brought promptly before a judge or other officer authorised by law to exercise judicial power. In Brogan v United Kingdom the European Court held that detention for four days and six hours without judicial control breached Article 5(3), even in the context of terrorism. Release without charge does not cure the breach. A police review is not judicial control, and detention on reasonable suspicion is a permitted ground under Article 5(1)(c).
Law basis: Brogan v United Kingdom (1988) 11 EHRR 117Question 13 · Absolute and limited Convention rightsDraft, pending solicitor review
Three people are arrested under terrorism powers. They are told only that they are being arrested under the relevant section, but within a few hours they are questioned in detail about specific suspected criminal acts. They argue that Article 5(2) was breached. Which of the following best describes the test?
- Article 5(3) was breached, as he was not brought promptly before a judge or judicial officer.Correct answer
- Article 5(3) was not breached, as terrorism cases permit detention without judicial control for up to 14 days.
- Reasons need never be given where the arrest is made under anti-terrorism legislation.
- Reasons must be given only when the detained person is first brought before a court.
- Reasons must be given by a lawyer, because Article 5(2) is satisfied only by legal advice.
Article 5(2) requires that everyone arrested be informed promptly, in a language they understand, of the reasons for the arrest and of any charge. In Fox, Campbell and Hartley v United Kingdom the European Court held that merely citing the legal basis of the arrest was insufficient on its own, but the requirement was satisfied because the reasons became apparent during interviews conducted within a few hours, which was sufficiently prompt. Written reasons at the moment of arrest are not essential, and the requirement applies to terrorism arrests too.
Law basis: Fox, Campbell and Hartley v United Kingdom (1990) 13 EHRR 157Question 14 · Absolute and limited Convention rightsDraft, pending solicitor review
A soldier is sentenced by his commanding officer, under military disciplinary rules, to several months' committal to a military prison for an offence which domestic law classifies as purely disciplinary. He claims that he was entitled to the guarantees for criminal cases under Article 6. Which of the following best describes the approach?
- Reasons must be given in writing at the moment of arrest, or the arrest is automatically unlawful from the start.
- Article 6 applies only to proceedings in the ordinary criminal courts, not to military tribunals.
- Article 6 applies to disciplinary cases only if the penalty is a fine above a fixed financial limit.
- Article 6 applies to disciplinary cases only where the accused person has requested a lawyer.
- Reasons must be given promptly in simple language, which may happen during interviews.Correct answer
In Engel v Netherlands the European Court set out three criteria for deciding whether a matter involves a 'criminal charge' under Article 6: the domestic classification, which is a starting point only; the nature of the offence; and the nature and degree of severity of the penalty that the person risks incurring. A disciplinary matter carrying a significant deprivation of liberty will usually be criminal for Article 6 purposes, attracting the guarantees in Article 6(2) and (3). Domestic labels are not decisive, and military tribunals are not excluded.
Law basis: Engel v Netherlands (1976) 1 EHRR 647Question 15 · Absolute and limited Convention rightsDraft, pending solicitor review
The Secretary of State 'calls in' a major planning application and decides it himself, in line with government policy. The developer's neighbours argue that this breaches Article 6, because the minister is not an independent and impartial tribunal. Which of the following best describes the House of Lords' view?
- There is a breach, because planning decisions must be made at first instance by an independent judge.
- There is a breach, but the court can only make a declaration of incompatibility.
- There is no breach, because the availability of judicial review gives sufficient judicial control.Correct answer
- There is no breach, because Article 6 does not apply to planning decisions affecting property.
- There is no breach only because the Secretary of State is accountable to Parliament for the decision.
In R (Alconbury Developments Ltd) v Secretary of State for the Environment, Transport and the Regions the House of Lords accepted that the Secretary of State was not an independent and impartial tribunal when deciding called-in planning applications in line with his own policy. However, Article 6 is satisfied where the decision is subject to subsequent control by a judicial body with 'full jurisdiction'. Judicial review, which allows the court to examine legality, procedural fairness and rationality, provided sufficient control for such policy-based administrative decisions. Accountability to Parliament alone would not suffice.
Law basis: R (Alconbury Developments Ltd) v Secretary of State for the Environment, Transport and the Regions [2001] UKHL 23More Constitutional and Administrative Law and EU Law topics
Back to all Constitutional and Administrative Law and EU Law questions, or sit a timed mock.