Law covered in these questions
- Constitutional convention of individual ministerial responsibility
- Carltona Ltd v Commissioners of Works [1943] 2 All ER 560
- Crown Proceedings Act 1947, s 2
- Crown Proceedings Act 1947, s 21
- M v Home Office [1994] 1 AC 377
- Province of Bombay v Municipal Corporation of Bombay [1947] AC 58
- Lord Advocate v Dumbarton District Council [1990] 2 AC 580
- Crown Proceedings Act 1947, s 40
- Constitutional Reform and Governance Act 2010, ss 7 and 8
- Gouriet v Union of Post Office Workers [1978] AC 435
- Regency Act 1937, s 6
- Dissolution and Calling of Parliament Act 2022, s 2
- Cabinet Manual (2011), chapter 2 (conventions on government formation)
- Ministers of the Crown Act 1975, s 1
All 11 questions with answers
Try them above first, then read the worked answers below.
Question 1 · The Crown and the executiveDraft, pending solicitor review
A government minister makes a serious error in a department. Which statement best describes the principle of individual ministerial responsibility?
- The minister must always resign when any error occurs.
- The minister is accountable to Parliament for the department's actions and must answer for them, though resignation is not required in every case.Correct answer
- The minister is accountable only to the Prime Minister.
- The minister is accountable to the courts rather than to Parliament.
- The minister is legally liable personally for every civil servant's error.
Under the constitutional convention of ministerial responsibility, ministers answer to Parliament for the conduct of their departments. Resignation depends on the circumstances and political judgment.
Law basis: Constitutional convention of individual ministerial responsibilityQuestion 2 · The Crown and the executiveDraft, pending solicitor review
A statute confers on 'the Secretary of State' the power to requisition land. The requisition notice served on Oluwaseun's company was signed by an assistant secretary in the department, not by the minister personally. The company argues that the decision is invalid. Which of the following best describes the likely outcome?
- The decision is invalid, because powers given to a minister must be exercised by the minister personally.
- The decision is valid only if the minister gave a written delegation of the power to that particular named official.
- The decision is invalid, because delegation of statutory powers is only permitted to junior ministers.
- The decision is valid, as officials may act in the minister's name and the minister is accountable for them.Correct answer
- The decision is valid only if Parliament was informed of the identity of the official before it was made.
Under the Carltona principle, the functions given to ministers are normally exercised under their authority by responsible officials in their department. The decision of the official is constitutionally the decision of the minister, who remains answerable to Parliament for it. This is not true delegation, so the rule against delegation does not apply and no formal written delegation is required. The principle may be displaced by express statutory words or where the seriousness of the matter requires personal ministerial attention.
Law basis: Carltona Ltd v Commissioners of Works [1943] 2 All ER 560Question 3 · The Crown and the executiveDraft, pending solicitor review
Rhian is injured when a driver employed by the Ministry of Defence negligently crashes an army lorry into her car. She is told that she cannot sue 'the Crown'. Which of the following best describes the legal position?
- She cannot sue, because the Crown has immunity from liability in tort and the King can do no wrong in law.
- She can sue, because the Crown is liable in tort for its servants as if it were a private person.Correct answer
- She can sue the driver personally, but the Crown itself cannot be made vicariously liable.
- She can sue the Crown only if the Secretary of State grants a fiat permitting the claim to proceed.
- She can claim only under an ex gratia compensation scheme, not by bringing proceedings in the courts.
Section 2(1) of the Crown Proceedings Act 1947 provides that the Crown is subject to all those liabilities in tort to which it would be subject if it were a private person of full age and capacity, including liability for torts committed by its servants or agents. Proceedings are brought against the relevant authorised government department or the Attorney General. The old rule that the Crown could not be sued in tort, and the need for a fiat for claims against it, were abolished by the 1947 Act.
Law basis: Crown Proceedings Act 1947, s 2Question 4 · The Crown and the executiveDraft, pending solicitor review
A charity brings civil proceedings, not judicial review, against a government department to stop it disposing of land in alleged breach of contract. It seeks an injunction. Which of the following best describes the remedy the court may grant against the Crown in these proceedings?
- An injunction, because the Crown is treated in all respects as a private litigant.
- An order for specific performance, because the claim is founded on a contract.
- No remedy, because a government department cannot be made a defendant to civil proceedings.
- An injunction, but only if the Attorney General has consented to the proceedings beforehand.
- A declaration of the parties' rights in place of an injunction.Correct answer
Under section 21(1) of the Crown Proceedings Act 1947, in civil proceedings against the Crown the court cannot grant an injunction or order specific performance, but may instead make an order declaratory of the rights of the parties. In practice the Crown complies with declarations. M v Home Office held that this restriction does not prevent injunctions against ministers or officers in judicial review proceedings, but the charity here has brought ordinary civil proceedings against the department, so a declaration is the appropriate remedy.
Law basis: Crown Proceedings Act 1947, s 21; M v Home Office [1994] 1 AC 377Question 5 · The Crown and the executiveDraft, pending solicitor review
A government department proposes to build an office in a conservation area without applying for consent under a statute which requires 'any person' to obtain consent. The statute does not mention the Crown. Which of the following best describes the general approach to whether the statute binds the Crown?
- The Crown is bound by every statute, because it is subject to the rule of law like any other person.
- The Crown is bound by every statute passed after the Crown Proceedings Act 1947.
- The Crown is not bound by a statute unless it is named expressly or bound by necessary implication.Correct answer
- The Crown is bound unless the minister certifies that compliance would harm the public interest.
- The Crown is bound by statutes that regulate land, but not by those which impose criminal penalties.
There is a long-standing presumption that the Crown is not bound by a statute unless it is named expressly or bound by necessary implication, meaning that the purpose of the statute would be wholly frustrated if the Crown were not bound (Province of Bombay v Municipal Corporation of Bombay; Lord Advocate v Dumbarton DC). Many modern statutes, including planning legislation, now contain express provisions dealing with Crown application. The Crown Proceedings Act 1947 did not reverse the presumption, and there is no ministerial certificate exception.
Law basis: Province of Bombay v Municipal Corporation of Bombay [1947] AC 58; Lord Advocate v Dumbarton District Council [1990] 2 AC 580Question 6 · The Crown and the executiveDraft, pending solicitor review
Elif wishes to bring civil proceedings for damages against the King personally in respect of a dispute about a private estate. Which of the following best describes the position?
- Special advisers need not be impartial or objective, but permanent civil servants must be.Correct answer
- She may sue the King personally in the High Court, since the 1947 Act abolished Crown immunity.
- Neither is bound by the Civil Service Code, because both of them are appointed personally by the minister.
- She may sue the King, but only through the Attorney General as nominal defendant.
- She may sue the King personally only if the claim is in contract and not in tort.
Section 40(1) of the Crown Proceedings Act 1947 provides that nothing in the Act authorises proceedings in tort against His Majesty in his private capacity. The personal immunity of the monarch from suit in the courts therefore survives. The 1947 Act allows claims against the Crown in its public capacity, brought against government departments or the Attorney General, but these are claims against the state, not against the monarch personally. There is no consent procedure enabling personal claims to proceed.
Law basis: Crown Proceedings Act 1947, s 40Question 7 · The Crown and the executiveDraft, pending solicitor review
Ola, a special adviser to the Chancellor of the Exchequer, writes party political material for a ministerial speech. A permanent civil servant in the same department is asked to do the same. Which of the following best describes the difference in their positions?
- Both must act with political impartiality, so neither may write party political material.
- Neither is bound by the Civil Service Code, because both are appointed by the minister.
- Special advisers are not civil servants, so they are not bound by any statutory code of conduct.
- Permanent civil servants may write party material if the minister instructs them in writing.
- Special advisers need not be impartial or objective, but permanent civil servants must be.Correct answer
Part 1 of the Constitutional Reform and Governance Act 2010 places the civil service on a statutory footing. Under section 7 the Civil Service Code must require civil servants to carry out their duties with integrity and honesty, and with objectivity and impartiality. Special advisers are temporary civil servants appointed by ministers, and under sections 7(5) and 8 the Code need not require them to be objective or impartial; they are governed by a separate Code for Special Advisers. A ministerial instruction cannot require a permanent civil servant to act party-politically.
Law basis: Constitutional Reform and Governance Act 2010, ss 7 and 8 ↗Question 8 · The Crown and the executiveDraft, pending solicitor review
Pressure group members ask the Attorney General to lend his name to a relator action seeking an injunction against a trade union which is planning to break the criminal law. He refuses. They seek judicial review of the refusal. Which statement best describes the likely outcome?
- The refusal is reviewable on Wednesbury grounds, because the Attorney General is a government minister.
- The refusal is unlawful, because the Attorney General must consent where a criminal offence is threatened.
- The refusal is not reviewable, because the Attorney General's discretion in relator actions is for him alone.Correct answer
- The refusal is reviewable only if the group can show that the Attorney General acted for party political reasons.
- The refusal is irrelevant, because any member of the public may sue for an injunction to enforce public rights.
In Gouriet v Union of Post Office Workers the House of Lords held that only the Attorney General can sue on behalf of the public to enforce public rights, and a private individual cannot obtain an injunction to restrain a threatened criminal offence unless they will suffer special damage. The Attorney General's decision whether to consent to a relator action was held not to be reviewable by the courts; he is answerable to Parliament instead. This reflects the Attorney General's distinct constitutional role in protecting the public interest independently of government policy.
Law basis: Gouriet v Union of Post Office Workers [1978] AC 435Question 9 · The Crown and the executiveDraft, pending solicitor review
While the King is on a state visit abroad, the Prime Minister asks the Counsellors of State to dissolve Parliament so that an early general election can be held. The King has given no instructions about dissolution. Which of the following best describes the position?
- The Counsellors may not dissolve Parliament unless the King has expressly instructed them to do so.Correct answer
- The Counsellors may dissolve Parliament, because they may exercise all the royal functions in the King's absence.
- The Counsellors may dissolve Parliament only with the consent of the Leader of the Opposition.
- The Counsellors may not dissolve Parliament because dissolution now occurs only automatically after five years.
- The Counsellors may dissolve Parliament if the Lord Chancellor certifies that it is urgent.
Under section 6 of the Regency Act 1937, Counsellors of State may be delegated royal functions during the Sovereign's absence or illness, but they may not dissolve Parliament otherwise than on the express instructions of the Sovereign, nor grant any rank, title or dignity of the peerage. The power to dissolve Parliament was revived as a prerogative by the Dissolution and Calling of Parliament Act 2022, so early dissolution is possible, but here it would require the King's express instructions.
Law basis: Regency Act 1937, s 6; Dissolution and Calling of Parliament Act 2022, s 2Question 10 · The Crown and the executiveDraft, pending solicitor review
A general election produces a hung Parliament. The incumbent Prime Minister's party has the most seats but no majority, and talks are taking place between parties. Kemi asks whether the Prime Minister must resign immediately. Which of the following best describes the position?
- By law the Prime Minister must resign within 24 hours if no party has an overall majority.
- By convention the monarch must immediately appoint the leader of the party with the most seats.
- By law the House of Commons must elect a new Prime Minister by secret ballot at its first sitting after the election.
- By convention the incumbent may stay in office while it is unclear who can command the confidence of the Commons.Correct answer
- By convention the Prime Minister must resign and a caretaker is appointed by the Cabinet Secretary.
The appointment of the Prime Minister is a prerogative act of the monarch, governed by convention: the monarch appoints the person most likely to command the confidence of the House of Commons. The Cabinet Manual explains that where an election does not produce an overall majority, the incumbent government remains in office unless and until the Prime Minister tenders resignation, and should observe restrictions on new policy while the position is unclear. There is no statutory 24-hour rule and no election of the Prime Minister by the Commons.
Law basis: Cabinet Manual (2011), chapter 2 (conventions on government formation)Question 11 · The Crown and the executiveDraft, pending solicitor review
The Prime Minister decides that responsibility for prisons should move from the Ministry of Justice to the Home Office, which requires statutory functions vested in the Lord Chancellor to be transferred to the Home Secretary. Which of the following best describes how this can be done?
- Only by a new Act of Parliament, because statutory functions can never be transferred by delegated legislation.
- By Order in Council under the Ministers of the Crown Act 1975, without a new Act of Parliament.Correct answer
- By a letter from the Prime Minister to both ministers, because departmental organisation is a matter of convention.
- By resolution of the House of Commons, because Parliament conferred the original statutory functions.
- By the Cabinet Secretary issuing a direction under the Constitutional Reform and Governance Act 2010.
Section 1 of the Ministers of the Crown Act 1975 allows His Majesty by Order in Council to transfer functions from one minister to another, or to dissolve a government department and transfer its functions. Such Orders are delegated legislation laid before Parliament. This enables machinery of government changes without primary legislation. A Prime Minister's letter cannot transfer statutory functions, a Commons resolution alone has no such effect, and the Constitutional Reform and Governance Act 2010 does not confer this power on the Cabinet Secretary.
Law basis: Ministers of the Crown Act 1975, s 1 ↗More Constitutional and Administrative Law and EU Law topics
Back to all Constitutional and Administrative Law and EU Law questions, or sit a timed mock.