Law covered in these questions
- R (Miller) v Secretary of State for Exiting the EU [2017] UKSC 5, paras 136-151
- Ministerial Code
- Attorney-General v Jonathan Cape Ltd [1976] QB 752
- Carltona Ltd v Commissioners of Works [1943] 2 All ER 560
- Joint Committee on Conventions, Conventions of the UK Parliament (HL 265, HC 1212, 2006)
- Reference re Amendment of the Constitution of Canada [1981] 1 SCR 753
- R (Miller) v Secretary of State for Exiting the European Union [2017] UKSC 5
- Peerage Act 1963, s 1
- Life Peerages Act 1958
- Cabinet Manual (2011), para 5.38
- Council of Civil Service Unions v Minister for the Civil Service [1985] AC 374
- Cabinet Manual (2011), chapter 2 (elections and government formation)
- Dissolution and Calling of Parliament Act 2022, ss 2 and 3
- Government of Wales Act 2006, s 107(5)-(6)
All 12 questions with answers
Try them above first, then read the worked answers below.
Question 1 · Constitutional conventionsDraft, pending solicitor review
A convention says the monarch gives royal assent to bills passed by both Houses. Suppose that the monarch refused assent. Which statement best describes the court's position on conventions?
- Conventions are statutes and can be repealed only by Parliament.
- Conventions are enforceable only through the criminal courts.
- Conventions are legally binding and enforced by injunction.
- Conventions are enforceable only by the House of Lords.
- Conventions are not legally enforceable, though courts may recognise them and use them in deciding the law.Correct answer
Conventions are rules of political practice which are not law and not enforced by the courts, although the courts may recognise their existence. They are not laid down in statute.
Law basis: R (Miller) v Secretary of State for Exiting the EU [2017] UKSC 5, paras 136-151Question 2 · Constitutional conventionsDraft, pending solicitor review
Jasmine, a Cabinet minister, gives a television interview in which she says that she strongly opposes the government's new policy on welfare reform, which was agreed in Cabinet. There has been no agreement to suspend collective responsibility. Which of the following best describes her position?
- By convention she should resign or expect dismissal, because ministers must publicly support agreed policy.Correct answer
- She may be prosecuted for breaching the Official Secrets Act by revealing that Cabinet disagreed on the policy.
- She is protected, because Article 10 ECHR prevents any sanction for political speech by a government minister.
- She must resign by law, because the Ministerial Code is given statutory force by the Constitutional Reform Act 2005.
- She may remain in office, because collective responsibility only applies to decisions announced in Parliament.
The convention of collective ministerial responsibility requires ministers to maintain a united public front once a decision has been taken; Cabinet discussions are confidential, and a minister who cannot support government policy is expected to resign or face dismissal. The convention can be suspended by agreement, as for the 1975 and 2016 European referendums. It is reflected in the Ministerial Code, which is not legally enforceable. No criminal liability arises merely from disagreeing publicly, and the convention is not confined to decisions announced in Parliament.
Law basis: Ministerial Code; Attorney-General v Jonathan Cape Ltd [1976] QB 752Question 3 · Constitutional conventionsDraft, pending solicitor review
A report finds serious operational failures by staff at an executive agency of the Home Office, leading to the wrongful detention of several people. The Home Secretary was not personally involved. Opposition MPs say the Home Secretary is legally obliged to resign. Which statement best describes the position?
- The Home Secretary must resign by law, because ministers are vicariously liable for their officials.
- The Home Secretary has no responsibility, because executive agencies are independent of their departments.
- The Home Secretary may be removed by a court order if the failures amount to maladministration.
- The Home Secretary is accountable to Parliament by convention, but no legal rule requires resignation.Correct answer
- The Home Secretary must resign if a majority of the House of Commons passes a motion criticising them.
Individual ministerial responsibility is a convention under which ministers are answerable to Parliament for the conduct of their departments, including executive agencies, and must give accurate information to Parliament. Resignation is expected for personal misconduct or misleading Parliament, but in practice ministers often distinguish policy from operational matters and do not resign for failings of officials of which they were unaware. The convention is political, not legal, so courts cannot order resignation, and a critical Commons motion does not legally compel it.
Law basis: Ministerial Code; Carltona Ltd v Commissioners of Works [1943] 2 All ER 560Question 4 · Constitutional conventionsDraft, pending solicitor review
A government elected with a commitment in its manifesto to nationalise the railways introduces a Bill to do so. Several peers wish to vote against the Bill at second reading in the House of Lords. Which convention is most relevant?
- The Sewel convention, under which the Lords should not oppose Bills affecting devolved matters.
- The Salisbury convention: the Lords do not oppose manifesto Bills at second reading.Correct answer
- The convention of collective responsibility, which binds all members of the House of Lords.
- The Ponsonby convention, under which Bills must be laid before the Lords for 21 sitting days.
- The convention that the Lords never vote against any Bill passed by the House of Commons.
The Salisbury (or Salisbury-Addison) convention provides that the House of Lords should not reject at second reading, or wreck through amendments, a government Bill which seeks to implement a commitment in the governing party's election manifesto. It reflects the primacy of the elected House. It does not prevent the Lords from proposing amendments, and it does not apply to all Bills. Sewel concerns Westminster legislating on devolved matters, Ponsonby concerns treaties, and collective responsibility binds ministers rather than peers generally.
Law basis: Joint Committee on Conventions, Conventions of the UK Parliament (HL 265, HC 1212, 2006)Question 5 · Constitutional conventionsDraft, pending solicitor review
A Canadian province asks its court whether there is a constitutional convention requiring substantial provincial consent before the federal government asks the UK Parliament to amend the Canadian constitution. The court finds that such a convention exists but has been breached. Which of the following best describes what the court can do?
- Grant an injunction preventing the federal government from making the request.
- Declare the federal government's request void because it breaches a binding convention.
- Refuse to consider the question at all, because conventions are matters for politicians.
- Award damages to the provinces whose consent was not obtained under the convention.
- Recognise that the convention exists and was breached, but not enforce it as law.Correct answer
In Reference re Amendment of the Constitution of Canada the Supreme Court of Canada held that it could answer a question about whether a convention existed, and found that one did, but that conventions are not enforced by the courts because they are not law; their sanction is political. The UK courts take the same approach, as shown in Miller (2017) regarding the Sewel convention. Courts may recognise and refer to conventions, for example as background, but will not grant injunctions, declare acts void or award damages for their breach.
Law basis: Reference re Amendment of the Constitution of Canada [1981] 1 SCR 753; R (Miller) v Secretary of State for Exiting the European Union [2017] UKSC 5Question 6 · Constitutional conventionsDraft, pending solicitor review
After a Prime Minister resigns, the governing party elects as its new leader Lord Grey, who sits in the House of Lords. Advisers debate whether he can become Prime Minister. Which of the following best reflects modern constitutional practice?
- There is a statutory rule that the Prime Minister must be an elected member of the House of Commons.
- There is no expectation either way, because the Prime Minister may sit in either House equally.
- By convention the Prime Minister sits in the Commons, so he would be expected to seek a seat there.Correct answer
- Lord Grey can become Prime Minister only if the House of Lords elects him by a majority vote.
- Lord Grey would need the consent of the Lord Speaker before the King could appoint him.
There is no statute requiring the Prime Minister to be an MP, but a strong modern convention requires the Prime Minister to sit in, and be accountable to, the elected House of Commons. When Lord Home became Prime Minister in 1963 he disclaimed his peerage under the Peerage Act 1963 and won a seat in the Commons. By contrast, other ministers, including senior ones such as the Foreign Secretary, may sit in the House of Lords. No election by the Lords or consent of the Lord Speaker is involved.
Law basis: Peerage Act 1963, s 1Question 7 · Constitutional conventionsDraft, pending solicitor review
The Prime Minister wants to appoint Daniel, a former Prime Minister who is no longer an MP, as Foreign Secretary. Daniel does not wish to stand for election. Which of the following best describes how this is usually achieved consistently with constitutional convention?
- He may be appointed without any seat in Parliament, because there is no rule linking ministers to Parliament.
- He is made a life peer, because ministers are expected to sit in one of the Houses of Parliament.Correct answer
- He must win a by-election within three months, because senior ministers must sit in the Commons by law.
- He may be appointed only as a temporary civil servant, because non-parliamentarians cannot be ministers.
- He must be approved by a vote of the House of Commons, which then grants him speaking rights.
By convention ministers must be members of either the House of Commons or the House of Lords, so they can be accountable to Parliament. Where a Prime Minister wishes to appoint someone who is not a parliamentarian, the usual course is to have them created a life peer, as happened when David Cameron was appointed Foreign Secretary in 2023. There is no statutory requirement that the Foreign Secretary sit in the Commons, and no by-election, Commons approval vote or civil service route is required.
Law basis: Life Peerages Act 1958; Ministerial CodeQuestion 8 · Constitutional conventionsDraft, pending solicitor review
The Prime Minister decides to commit UK armed forces to air strikes overseas in a non-emergency situation. Several MPs argue that the deployment is unlawful because the House of Commons has not voted to approve it. Which of the following best describes the position?
- Deployment is unlawful without a Commons vote, because statute requires prior approval of both Houses for any overseas action.
- Deployment is lawful only if both Houses approve it within 21 sitting days of the start of action.
- Deployment is unlawful because the prerogative to wage war was abolished by the Bill of Rights 1689.
- Deployment is lawful only if the Attorney General has certified it to the Speaker before action begins.
- Deployment is a prerogative power; a convention of prior Commons debate exists but is not legally binding.Correct answer
The deployment of the armed forces is an exercise of the royal prerogative. Since the Iraq vote in 2003 and the defeat of the government's motion on Syria in 2013, a convention has developed that the House of Commons should have an opportunity to debate military action before troops are committed, except in an emergency. The Cabinet Manual acknowledges this. However, it is a convention, not a legal requirement, and there is no UK War Powers Act. Courts have treated the decision to deploy forces as non-justiciable.
Law basis: Cabinet Manual (2011), para 5.38; Council of Civil Service Unions v Minister for the Civil Service [1985] AC 374Question 9 · Constitutional conventionsDraft, pending solicitor review
A general election has been called. During the campaign, a minister wants to announce a major new long-term contract for a defence procurement project. A civil servant warns that this may be inappropriate. Which of the following best describes the governing principle?
- By law, ministers lose all their powers during the period between dissolution and polling day.
- By law, the Civil Service Code forbids the government from entering into any contracts after dissolution.
- By convention, government continues but avoids major new initiatives during an election period.Correct answer
- By convention, ministers must obtain the consent of the Leader of the Opposition for all decisions.
- By law, the Electoral Commission must approve government announcements made during the campaign.
Ministers remain in office after dissolution and government must continue. However, by convention, reflected in the Cabinet Manual and pre-election guidance, during an election period the government should avoid taking or announcing decisions on new policies or entering large or contentious long-term commitments that could bind a future government, unless urgent. Ministers do not lose their legal powers, and the Civil Service Code does not ban contracts. There is no requirement for the Opposition's consent or Electoral Commission approval of announcements.
Law basis: Cabinet Manual (2011), chapter 2 (elections and government formation)Question 10 · Constitutional conventionsDraft, pending solicitor review
Following the Dissolution and Calling of Parliament Act 2022, the Prime Minister asks the King to dissolve Parliament only months after a general election, although another party leader appears able to form a government with a working majority. Which of the following best describes the King's position?
- The King normally acts on advice, but it is accepted that he may in exceptional circumstances refuse a dissolution.Correct answer
- The King must dissolve Parliament, because the 2022 Act imposes a statutory duty to act on the Prime Minister's request.
- The King may refuse only if the House of Commons has passed a motion opposing an early election.
- The King has no role, because under the 2022 Act Parliament is dissolved by the Speaker's certificate.
- The King must refer the request to the Supreme Court for a ruling on whether dissolution is justified.
Section 2 of the Dissolution and Calling of Parliament Act 2022 revived the prerogative power to dissolve Parliament as if the Fixed-term Parliaments Act 2011 had never been enacted. By convention the monarch acts on the Prime Minister's advice, but the government's published dissolution principles and the Lascelles principles accept that the monarch may refuse in exceptional circumstances, for example where an alternative government could be formed. Section 3 makes the exercise of the power non-justiciable, so no reference to the Supreme Court is possible.
Law basis: Dissolution and Calling of Parliament Act 2022, ss 2 and 3 ↗Question 11 · Constitutional conventionsDraft, pending solicitor review
A Bill passed by the Westminster Parliament alters the powers of the Welsh Ministers. The Senedd votes to withhold legislative consent, but the Bill proceeds and receives Royal Assent. Owain argues that the resulting Act is invalid in Wales. Which of the following best describes the position?
- The Act is invalid, because the Government of Wales Act 2006 makes Senedd consent a legal requirement.
- The Act is valid only to the extent that it applies in England, and must be read down for Wales.
- The Act is invalid, because the Senedd has a power of veto over Acts on devolved matters since 2017.
- The Act is valid, as the consent convention, though recognised in statute, is not legally enforceable.Correct answer
- The Act is valid only if the Secretary of State for Wales certifies that consent was unreasonably withheld.
Section 107(6) of the Government of Wales Act 2006, inserted by the Wales Act 2017, recognises that the UK Parliament will not normally legislate with regard to devolved matters without the Senedd's consent. Section 107(5) preserves Westminster's power to make laws for Wales. Following Miller (2017), statutory recognition of the Sewel convention does not convert it into a legally enforceable rule; its operation is a political matter. The Act is therefore valid throughout its territorial extent. There is no Senedd veto or certification process.
Law basis: Government of Wales Act 2006, s 107(5)-(6); R (Miller) v Secretary of State for Exiting the European Union [2017] UKSC 5 ↗Question 12 · Constitutional conventionsDraft, pending solicitor review
Sophie argues in an essay that a constitutional convention becomes binding only when it is written down in an official document such as the Cabinet Manual. Her tutor suggests a different test for identifying conventions, derived from Sir Ivor Jennings. Which of the following best describes that test?
- Whether the rule has been followed without exception for at least a century and has been recorded by Parliament.
- Whether the courts have recognised the rule in a reported case and given it legal effect.
- Whether there are precedents, whether the actors felt bound, and whether there is a reason for the rule.Correct answer
- Whether the rule has been approved by resolution of both Houses of Parliament.
- Whether the rule is set out in the Cabinet Manual or the Ministerial Code.
Jennings proposed three questions for identifying a convention: what are the precedents; did the actors in the precedents believe that they were bound by a rule; and is there a reason for the rule? A single precedent with a good reason may suffice. Writing a convention down in documents such as the Cabinet Manual or Ministerial Code may describe it but does not create it or give it legal force, and judicial recognition does not make it enforceable. There is no fixed period of observance or requirement of parliamentary approval.
Law basis: Reference re Amendment of the Constitution of Canada [1981] 1 SCR 753 (applying Jennings' test)More Constitutional and Administrative Law and EU Law topics
Back to all Constitutional and Administrative Law and EU Law questions, or sit a timed mock.