Law covered in these questions
- R (Miller) v Secretary of State for Exiting the European Union [2017] UKSC 5
- Thoburn v Sunderland City Council [2002] EWHC 195 (Admin)
- R (HS2 Action Alliance Ltd) v Secretary of State for Transport [2014] UKSC 3
- Madzimbamuto v Lardner-Burke [1969] 1 AC 645
- Attorney-General v Jonathan Cape Ltd [1976] QB 752
- Council of Civil Service Unions v Minister for the Civil Service [1985] AC 374
- R v Secretary of State for the Home Department, ex p Simms [2000] 2 AC 115
- R (UNISON) v Lord Chancellor [2017] UKSC 51
- Constitutional Reform Act 2005, s 23
- Constitutional Reform and Governance Act 2010, s 20
- MacCormick v Lord Advocate 1953 SC 396
- R (Jackson) v Attorney General [2005] UKHL 56
All 9 questions with answers
Try them above first, then read the worked answers below.
Question 1 · Sources of the constitutionDraft, pending solicitor review
Priya, a law student, argues that the UK has no constitution because there is no single document called 'the Constitution'. Her tutor disagrees. Which of the following best describes the sources of the UK constitution?
- It draws on several sources: statutes, case law, conventions, the prerogative and authoritative works.Correct answer
- It is found mainly in the Bill of Rights 1689, which Parliament cannot amend by ordinary statute.
- It consists only of rules enforceable in the courts, so conventions and parliamentary practices form no part of it.
- It is found in the Human Rights Act 1998, which consolidated all earlier constitutional statutes.
- It is set out in the Cabinet Manual, which has the force of law once laid before Parliament.
The UK constitution is uncodified: its rules are found in statutes (for example the Bill of Rights 1689, Parliament Acts, Human Rights Act 1998, Constitutional Reform Act 2005), common law, the royal prerogative, constitutional conventions, the law and custom of Parliament and authoritative writers such as Dicey. Conventions are part of the constitution even though the courts do not enforce them. The Cabinet Manual is a guide to practice with no legal force, and no single statute, including the Bill of Rights 1689, is entrenched against ordinary amendment.
Law basis: R (Miller) v Secretary of State for Exiting the European Union [2017] UKSC 5Question 2 · Sources of the constitutionDraft, pending solicitor review
A new Act contains a provision that is inconsistent with a surviving clause of Magna Carta 1297, but the new Act does not mention Magna Carta at all. Daniel asks whether the courts will treat that clause of Magna Carta as impliedly repealed. Which statement best reflects the courts' approach?
- Any earlier statute is impliedly repealed to the extent of inconsistency, whatever its subject matter.
- Constitutional statutes can never be repealed by Parliament, whether expressly or impliedly.
- Constitutional statutes may be repealed only by an Act passed with the consent of both Houses under the Parliament Acts.
- A constitutional statute is not impliedly repealed; express words or unavoidable implication are needed.Correct answer
- A court will disapply the later Act and give priority to the older constitutional statute in every case.
In Thoburn v Sunderland City Council Laws LJ recognised a category of 'constitutional statutes' which are not subject to the doctrine of implied repeal. They may be repealed only by express words or words so specific that the inference of actual intention to repeal is irresistible. This qualifies, but does not displace, parliamentary sovereignty: Parliament can still repeal such statutes expressly. The ordinary implied repeal rule from Ellen Street Estates applies to ordinary statutes only, and nothing requires the Parliament Acts procedure for constitutional change.
Law basis: Thoburn v Sunderland City Council [2002] EWHC 195 (Admin); R (HS2 Action Alliance Ltd) v Secretary of State for Transport [2014] UKSC 3Question 3 · Sources of the constitutionDraft, pending solicitor review
The Prime Minister refuses to resign after losing a vote of no confidence in the House of Commons. Megan, a constituent, asks whether she can obtain a court order compelling him to resign. Which of the following best describes the legal position?
- A court can order resignation because the Dissolution and Calling of Parliament Act 2022 requires it within fourteen days.
- No court will order it, because the duty to resign or seek dissolution after losing confidence is a convention.Correct answer
- A court can grant a declaration that the Prime Minister has acted unlawfully but cannot order him to resign.
- The Speaker may apply to the Supreme Court for a mandatory order requiring the Prime Minister's resignation.
- A court can order resignation because conventions crystallise into law once they have been followed for long enough.
Conventions are non-legal rules of political obligation. The courts may recognise them but will not enforce them: in Miller (2017) the Supreme Court held that even the Sewel convention, though mentioned in statute, was a political matter beyond the courts' competence. The obligation on a government that loses the confidence of the Commons is conventional. The Dissolution and Calling of Parliament Act 2022 repealed the statutory confidence mechanism in the Fixed-term Parliaments Act 2011 and contains no such duty, and long usage does not turn a convention into law.
Law basis: R (Miller) v Secretary of State for Exiting the European Union [2017] UKSC 5; Madzimbamuto v Lardner-Burke [1969] 1 AC 645Question 4 · Sources of the constitutionDraft, pending solicitor review
A newspaper wishes to publish the diaries of a former Cabinet minister which record Cabinet discussions held eight years ago. The Attorney General seeks an injunction on the basis that publication would breach the convention of collective Cabinet responsibility. Which of the following best describes how the court will approach the claim?
- It will enforce the convention directly, because collective responsibility is a binding rule of constitutional law.
- It will refuse relief, because the government can never rely on confidentiality in relation to Cabinet papers.
- It will grant relief automatically, because Cabinet discussions remain confidential for thirty years under statute.
- It will refuse relief, because conventions can only be enforced by the House of Commons and not by the courts.
- It will not enforce the convention as such, but may restrain publication if confidentiality is still needed.Correct answer
In Attorney-General v Jonathan Cape Ltd (the Crossman diaries case) the court did not enforce the convention of collective responsibility as such. It held that Cabinet confidences could be restrained under the equitable doctrine of breach of confidence where the public interest required it, but confidentiality lapses with time. On the facts, about ten years later, an injunction was refused. So the court looks at whether continuing confidentiality is needed, not at the convention directly, and there is no automatic thirty-year statutory bar.
Law basis: Attorney-General v Jonathan Cape Ltd [1976] QB 752Question 5 · Sources of the constitutionDraft, pending solicitor review
Owen, a trainee, is asked which of the following is a source of the UK constitution that operates as law but derives from neither statute nor judicial decision-making about legislation. His supervisor mentions powers such as the issue of passports and the conduct of foreign affairs. Which source is being described?
- Constitutional conventions, being rules of political practice which the courts will enforce.
- The law and custom of Parliament, being the rules which govern how ministers deal with foreign states.
- The royal prerogative, being the residue of discretionary legal powers left with the Crown.Correct answer
- Authoritative works, being the writings of jurists which bind the courts on questions of power.
- Delegated legislation, being rules made by ministers without any parent Act of Parliament.
Dicey described the royal prerogative as 'the residue of discretionary or arbitrary authority which at any given time is legally left in the hands of the Crown'. Its existence and extent are recognised by the common law, and it covers matters such as foreign affairs, treaties and the issue of passports. Conventions are not legal rules and are not enforced by the courts. Authoritative works are persuasive only, and delegated legislation always needs a parent Act, so neither fits the description.
Law basis: R (Miller) v Secretary of State for Exiting the European Union [2017] UKSC 5; Council of Civil Service Unions v Minister for the Civil Service [1985] AC 374Question 6 · Sources of the constitutionDraft, pending solicitor review
Sana is advising a pressure group that wants to argue that a statute should be read restrictively because it affects a fundamental right of access to the courts. She relies on the idea that the common law itself protects certain constitutional rights. Which statement best describes this source of constitutional protection?
- The courts may strike down any statute which infringes a fundamental common law right recognised in earlier case law.
- The courts presume that Parliament does not mean to override basic rights without express words or clear inference.Correct answer
- Common law rights apply only where the Human Rights Act 1998 provides no Convention right.
- Common law rights are protected only if listed in Magna Carta or the Bill of Rights 1689.
- Common law rights may be restricted by delegated legislation without any express authority in the parent Act.
Under the principle of legality the courts presume that general words in a statute are not intended to override fundamental rights; Parliament must 'squarely confront what it is doing' by express language or necessary implication (R v SSHD ex p Simms). In R (UNISON) v Lord Chancellor the Supreme Court held that employment tribunal fees made under a general power were unlawful because they effectively prevented access to justice. The courts cannot strike down primary legislation, and common law rights exist alongside, not merely in default of, the Human Rights Act 1998.
Law basis: R v Secretary of State for the Home Department, ex p Simms [2000] 2 AC 115; R (UNISON) v Lord Chancellor [2017] UKSC 51Question 7 · Sources of the constitutionDraft, pending solicitor review
A Bill proposes to abolish the Supreme Court and transfer its jurisdiction to a committee of the House of Lords. Hamid asks whether any legal rule prevents Parliament doing this by ordinary Act. Which of the following is the best answer?
- Yes; the Constitutional Reform Act 2005 can be amended only with a two-thirds majority in the House of Commons.
- Yes; the Supreme Court is established by the royal prerogative and so cannot be abolished or altered by statute.
- Yes; the Act of Settlement 1701 forbids Parliament from altering the structure of the senior courts.
- No; but such a Bill would need the consent of the Lord Chief Justice before receiving Royal Assent.
- No; the court was created by the Constitutional Reform Act 2005, which Parliament can amend like any Act.Correct answer
The Supreme Court was established by Part 3 of the Constitutional Reform Act 2005, beginning with section 23, and began work in 2009. Because Parliament is sovereign and no Parliament can bind its successors, the 2005 Act can be amended or repealed by an ordinary Act passed in the usual way. The UK has no special majority or entrenchment rules for constitutional legislation. The court is a statutory creation, not a prerogative one, and neither the Act of Settlement nor any requirement for judicial consent restricts Parliament here.
Law basis: Constitutional Reform Act 2005, s 23 ↗Question 8 · Sources of the constitutionDraft, pending solicitor review
Lucy is preparing a seminar paper on the treaty-making process. She notes that the Ponsonby Rule once required treaties to be laid before Parliament for 21 sitting days before ratification. Which of the following best describes the current position?
- The requirement remains a convention only and cannot be relied on in any legal proceedings.
- The requirement was abolished when the royal prerogative to make treaties was transferred to Parliament.
- It is now largely set out in statute in Part 2 of the Constitutional Reform and Governance Act 2010.Correct answer
- The requirement now means that a treaty cannot be ratified unless both Houses approve it by resolution.
- The requirement now applies only to treaties which would change domestic law without an Act.
The Ponsonby Rule was a convention, but section 20 of the Constitutional Reform and Governance Act 2010 now provides that a treaty is not to be ratified unless it has been laid before Parliament with an explanatory memorandum and 21 sitting days have passed without either House resolving against ratification. This is a statutory example of a convention being turned into law. Positive approval is not required, and the treaty-making power itself remains a prerogative power exercised by ministers.
Law basis: Constitutional Reform and Governance Act 2010, s 20 ↗Question 9 · Sources of the constitutionDraft, pending solicitor review
Imogen notes that Parliament's legislative power was used in the Acts of Union 1706 and 1707, and that some writers say certain terms of the Union were meant to be permanent. A client asks whether the Union legislation is a higher form of law which the English courts will enforce against a later Act of Parliament. Which statement best reflects the orthodox position?
- It is an important constitutional source, but the courts do not treat it as entrenched higher law.Correct answer
- The Union legislation is a fundamental law, so any inconsistent later Act is void and unenforceable in every UK court.
- The Union legislation is binding only in Scotland and has no effect as part of English law.
- The Union legislation may be amended only by a referendum of voters in both England and Scotland.
- The Union legislation is a convention which the courts will note but treat as having no legal effect.
The Acts of Union created the Parliament of Great Britain and are a key constitutional source. Some Scottish judges, in MacCormick v Lord Advocate, doubted whether the new Parliament inherited the English doctrine of unlimited sovereignty. However, the orthodox view, reflected in the practice of the UK courts, is that the Union legislation is not enforced as an entrenched higher law against later Acts, many of its provisions having been amended. It is statute, not a convention, and there is no legal referendum requirement.
Law basis: MacCormick v Lord Advocate 1953 SC 396; R (Jackson) v Attorney General [2005] UKHL 56More Constitutional and Administrative Law and EU Law topics
Back to all Constitutional and Administrative Law and EU Law questions, or sit a timed mock.