Law covered in these questions
- R (Anderson) v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2002] UKHL 46
- R v Secretary of State for the Home Department, ex p Fire Brigades Union [1995] 2 AC 513
- House of Commons Disqualification Act 1975, s 1
- Senior Courts Act 1981, s 11(3)
- Constitutional Reform Act 2005, s 3
- Duport Steels Ltd v Sirs [1980] 1 WLR 142
- Constitutional Reform Act 2005, s 7
- Constitutional Reform Act 2005, Part 4, Chapter 2
- House of Commons Disqualification Act 1975, s 2
- Senior Courts Act 1981, s 12
- Constitutional Reform Act 2005, s 137
- R (UNISON) v Lord Chancellor [2017] UKSC 51
All 12 questions with answers
Try them above first, then read the worked answers below.
Question 1 · Separation of powersDraft, pending solicitor review
The Home Secretary has statutory power to set the minimum term ('tariff') which a prisoner serving a mandatory life sentence must serve before release can be considered. Ryan, a life prisoner, argues that this power breaches his rights. Which of the following best describes the likely outcome?
- A declaration of incompatibility, because setting the tariff is a sentencing function for an independent tribunal.Correct answer
- The power is lawful, because sentencing is an executive function in respect of mandatory life sentences.
- The power is quashed, because the separation of powers prevents ministers from exercising any function of a judicial kind.
- The power is lawful, because the Home Secretary is accountable to Parliament for each tariff decision.
- A declaration that the Home Secretary must consult the trial judge but may then set the tariff himself.
In R (Anderson) v Secretary of State for the Home Department the House of Lords held that the fixing of the tariff is in substance a sentencing exercise, which under Article 6 must be carried out by an independent and impartial tribunal, not a government minister. As the statute clearly gave the power to the Home Secretary, a declaration of incompatibility was made under section 4 HRA; it could not be quashed. Parliament then transferred tariff-setting to the judiciary. Ministerial accountability to Parliament does not satisfy Article 6.
Law basis: R (Anderson) v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2002] UKHL 46Question 2 · Separation of powersDraft, pending solicitor review
Statute provides that a new criminal injuries compensation scheme 'shall come into force on such day as the Secretary of State may appoint'. The Secretary of State decides never to bring it into force and instead introduces a cheaper non-statutory scheme under the prerogative. Which of the following best describes the likely outcome of a challenge?
- The decision is lawful, because the minister has an unfettered discretion over when commencement occurs.
- The decision is lawful, because the prerogative continues to exist alongside any statutory scheme.
- The decision is unlawful, because the minister must bring every provision of an Act into force within a reasonable time.
- The decision is unenforceable, because commencement decisions are matters for Parliament, not the courts.
- The decision is unlawful, as the prerogative cannot be used to frustrate the will of Parliament in the Act.Correct answer
In R v Secretary of State for the Home Department, ex p Fire Brigades Union the House of Lords held that, while the minister was under no legal duty to bring the statutory scheme into force at any particular time, he was under a duty to keep that question under review. He could not use the prerogative to introduce a scheme inconsistent with the statutory one and so render the commencement power redundant. This would frustrate Parliament's will and offend the separation of powers. There is no general duty to commence Acts within a reasonable time.
Law basis: R v Secretary of State for the Home Department, ex p Fire Brigades Union [1995] 2 AC 513Question 3 · Separation of powersDraft, pending solicitor review
A senior civil servant in the Ministry of Justice is invited to stand as a candidate at a general election. She asks whether she can remain in her post if elected as an MP. Which of the following best describes the legal position?
- She can remain a civil servant while sitting as an MP, provided she does not hold ministerial office.
- She can remain a civil servant if the Prime Minister certifies that there is no conflict of interest.
- She cannot sit while holding the post, because civil servants are disqualified from the Commons.Correct answer
- She can sit as an MP but must take unpaid leave from the civil service for the whole duration of the Parliament.
- She is disqualified only if her post involves advising a minister who sits in the House of Commons.
The House of Commons Disqualification Act 1975, section 1 and Schedule 1, disqualifies certain office-holders from membership of the House of Commons, including members of the civil service, judges, members of the armed forces and police forces. This reflects the separation of powers by keeping the permanent executive and judiciary out of the legislature. A civil servant who wishes to sit must resign. There is no exemption based on certification, unpaid leave or the particular minister she advises.
Law basis: House of Commons Disqualification Act 1975, s 1 ↗Question 4 · Separation of powersDraft, pending solicitor review
A High Court judge gives a series of judgments criticised by the government. A minister suggests that the judge should be dismissed. Which of the following best describes how a High Court judge may be removed from office?
- By the Crown on an address presented by both Houses of Parliament, as judges hold office during good behaviour.Correct answer
- By the Lord Chancellor acting alone, after consulting the Lord Chief Justice and the Judicial Appointments Commission.
- By the Prime Minister on the advice of the Cabinet, where the judge has lost the confidence of the government.
- By the Supreme Court on an application by the Attorney General alleging misconduct in office.
- By a resolution of the House of Commons alone, because the Commons has primacy over the House of Lords.
Under section 11(3) of the Senior Courts Act 1981, reflecting the Act of Settlement 1701, a High Court or Court of Appeal judge holds office during good behaviour, subject to a power of removal by His Majesty on an address presented by both Houses of Parliament. Security of tenure protects judicial independence, which ministers must uphold under section 3 of the Constitutional Reform Act 2005. Neither the Lord Chancellor nor the government can dismiss a senior judge, and one House alone is not enough.
Law basis: Senior Courts Act 1981, s 11(3); Constitutional Reform Act 2005, s 3 ↗Question 5 · Separation of powersDraft, pending solicitor review
Following an unpopular judgment, a government minister phones the judge to express concern about the reasoning and to ask how the judge intends to decide a related case still pending. Which provision is most directly engaged by the minister's conduct?
- The convention that ministers must resign if a court rules against their department in a politically important case.
- The statutory requirement that the Lord Chief Justice approves all communications between ministers and judges.
- The rule that judges must disclose any contact with ministers to the Judicial Appointments Commission.
- The statutory duty of ministers to uphold judicial independence and not to seek to influence particular decisions.Correct answer
- The parliamentary privilege that prevents ministers commenting on court cases in Parliament.
Section 3 of the Constitutional Reform Act 2005 requires the Lord Chancellor, other ministers and all with responsibility for matters relating to the judiciary to uphold the continued independence of the judiciary. Section 3(5) provides that the Lord Chancellor and other ministers must not seek to influence particular judicial decisions through any special access to the judiciary. The minister's call is a clear breach. There is no convention requiring resignation after losing a case, and the other options describe non-existent rules.
Law basis: Constitutional Reform Act 2005, s 3 ↗Question 6 · Separation of powersDraft, pending solicitor review
A trade union argues that a statutory provision on lawful industrial action produces an unfair result, and asks the Court of Appeal to read it narrowly so as to achieve what the judges think is a fairer outcome, contrary to the clear words. Which statement best reflects the proper judicial approach?
- Judges may depart from clear words whenever they consider that Parliament would have wanted a fairer or more just result.
- Where the words are clear, judges must apply them even if the result seems unjust; policy is for Parliament.Correct answer
- Judges may refuse to apply a provision they consider unjust, provided they give reasons in their judgment.
- Judges may read clear words narrowly only if the Attorney General consents to that interpretation.
- Judges may rewrite the provision but must refer the issue to Parliament for confirmation within six months.
In Duport Steels Ltd v Sirs the House of Lords stressed that the British constitution is firmly based on the separation of powers: Parliament makes the laws and the judiciary interprets them. Where the meaning of a statute is clear, judges must not invent fancied ambiguities to substitute their own views of what is fair or expedient. The Court of Appeal was criticised for doing so. No consent from the Attorney General or confirmation procedure exists, and section 3 HRA did not apply in that pre-HRA context.
Law basis: Duport Steels Ltd v Sirs [1980] 1 WLR 142Question 7 · Separation of powersDraft, pending solicitor review
Ella is writing about the reforms made to the office of Lord Chancellor in 2005. She wants to identify the change that most strengthened the separation between the executive and the judiciary. Which of the following best describes it?
- The Lord Chief Justice replaced the Lord Chancellor as head of the judiciary of England and Wales.Correct answer
- The Lord Chancellor became an elected office, chosen by the House of Commons at the start of each Parliament.
- The Lord Chancellor was given a seat on the Supreme Court so that the government's view could be represented.
- The office of Lord Chancellor was abolished and its functions were transferred to the Speaker of the Commons.
- The Lord Chancellor gained power to dismiss judges who failed to uphold the rule of law in their decisions.
Before the Constitutional Reform Act 2005, the Lord Chancellor was simultaneously a Cabinet minister, Speaker of the House of Lords and head of the judiciary who could sit as a judge. Section 7 of the 2005 Act made the Lord Chief Justice President of the Courts of England and Wales and head of the judiciary, and the Lord Chancellor no longer sits judicially. The office was not abolished, it is not elected, and it gained no power to dismiss judges; senior judges can be removed only on an address of both Houses.
Law basis: Constitutional Reform Act 2005, s 7 ↗Question 8 · Separation of powersDraft, pending solicitor review
A vacancy arises in the High Court. The Judicial Appointments Commission selects Marcus. The Lord Chancellor would prefer to appoint Fatima, who applied but was not selected. Which of the following best describes the Lord Chancellor's powers?
- He may appoint Fatima instead, provided he gives written reasons to the Lord Chief Justice and to Parliament.
- He has no role at all, because the Commission's selection takes effect without any ministerial involvement.
- He may appoint Fatima if the Prime Minister agrees, because senior judicial appointments are prerogative acts.
- He may reject the selection or ask the Commission to reconsider it, but cannot simply appoint Fatima.Correct answer
- He must accept Marcus, but may ask the Supreme Court to review the selection if he thinks it irrational.
Under Part 4 of the Constitutional Reform Act 2005 the Judicial Appointments Commission runs the selection process for judicial appointments in England and Wales. The Lord Chancellor's role is limited: having received a selection, he may accept it, reject it, or require the Commission to reconsider, and he must give reasons. He cannot substitute his own preferred candidate who was not selected. This limits executive influence over appointments while retaining some ministerial accountability. Formal appointment of High Court judges is by the King on the Lord Chancellor's recommendation.
Law basis: Constitutional Reform Act 2005, Part 4, Chapter 2Question 9 · Separation of powersDraft, pending solicitor review
After a landslide general election, the new Prime Minister wishes to appoint 110 ministers, all of whom are MPs, so that every government department is led by elected members. Which of the following best describes the legal limit?
- There is no legal limit on the number of ministers who are MPs, only a convention that the number should be reasonable.
- No more than 95 ministers may sit and vote in the Commons; those in excess may not sit or vote until the number falls.Correct answer
- No more than 95 ministers may be appointed in total, whichever House they sit in.
- No more than half of the members of the Cabinet may be drawn from the House of Commons.
- The limit may be exceeded with the approval of the House of Commons by simple resolution.
Section 2(1) of the House of Commons Disqualification Act 1975 provides that not more than 95 persons holding ministerial offices listed in Schedule 2 may sit and vote in the House of Commons at any one time. If the limit is exceeded, those appointed after it was reached may not sit or vote until the number is reduced. The limit restricts executive dominance of the legislature. It applies to ministers in the Commons only, so further ministers can be appointed from the House of Lords.
Law basis: House of Commons Disqualification Act 1975, s 2 ↗Question 10 · Separation of powersDraft, pending solicitor review
Following a period of austerity, ministers propose that the salaries of High Court judges be reduced by 10% to match cuts in public sector pay. Ruth, a policy adviser, is asked whether this can be done by ministerial determination. Which statement best describes the position?
- A determination may reduce judicial salaries provided the Lord Chief Justice is consulted first.
- A determination may reduce judicial salaries if both Houses of Parliament approve the change by resolution.
- Judicial salaries are set by the judges themselves, so ministers have no role in fixing them.
- Judicial salaries are fixed by the Act of Settlement 1701 and cannot be changed by anyone.
- A determination may increase judicial salaries but not reduce them, which protects judicial independence.Correct answer
Financial security is an aspect of judicial independence. Under section 12 of the Senior Courts Act 1981, the salaries of senior judges are determined by the Lord Chancellor with the agreement of the Treasury, and any salary may be increased but not reduced by a determination. Salaries are charged on the Consolidated Fund, so they are not voted on annually by Parliament. Ministers therefore cannot cut existing salaries by determination; doing so would require primary legislation. The judges do not set their own pay.
Law basis: Senior Courts Act 1981, s 12Question 11 · Separation of powersDraft, pending solicitor review
Lord Ahmed is a life peer who is appointed as a Justice of the Supreme Court. He wishes to continue speaking and voting in debates in the House of Lords on criminal justice reform. Which of the following best describes the position?
- He may sit and vote on any matter, because life peers cannot be excluded from the House of Lords.
- He may sit and vote only on matters not likely to come before the Supreme Court.
- He is disqualified from sitting or voting in the Lords while he holds high judicial office.Correct answer
- He may speak in debates but may not vote, under a convention agreed by the senior judiciary.
- He must resign his peerage before taking up his appointment to the Supreme Court.
Section 137 of the Constitutional Reform Act 2005 provides that a person is disqualified from sitting or voting in the House of Lords, or its committees, while holding any high judicial office, which includes a Justice of the Supreme Court. The peerage is not lost, so the person may return to the House after leaving judicial office. This ended the former position where the Law Lords sat both as the final court of appeal and as members of the legislature, strengthening the separation of powers.
Law basis: Constitutional Reform Act 2005, s 137 ↗Question 12 · Separation of powersDraft, pending solicitor review
A minister uses a power in an Act to make secondary legislation which contradicts the Act itself and removes a person's right of access to a court. Which statement best describes the court's position?
- The court must apply the regulations, because ministers are accountable only to Parliament.
- The court cannot review delegated legislation made by a minister.
- The court can quash the regulations as ultra vires, because a minister cannot use delegated powers to undermine a statutory right unless the Act clearly authorises it.Correct answer
- The court can amend the Act to resolve the conflict.
- The court can strike down the Act itself for failing to respect the rule of law.
Delegated legislation can be challenged on judicial review if it exceeds the powers given by the parent Act. Rights of access to the courts can be removed only by clear and express words in primary legislation.
Law basis: R (UNISON) v Lord Chancellor [2017] UKSC 51More Constitutional and Administrative Law and EU Law topics
Back to all Constitutional and Administrative Law and EU Law questions, or sit a timed mock.